Geothermobarometry Explained

Geothermobarometry is the methodology for estimating the pressure and temperature history of rocks (metamorphic, igneous or sedimentary). Geothermobarometry is a combination of geobarometry, where the pressure attained (and retained) by a mineral assemblage is estimated, and geothermometry where the temperature attained (and retained) by a mineral assemblage is estimated.

Methodology

Geothermobarometry relies upon understanding the temperature and pressure of the formation of minerals within rocks.^[1] There are several methods of measuring the temperature or pressure of mineral formation or re-equilibration relying for example on chemical equilibrium between minerals^[2] or by measuring the chemical composition^{[3] [4]} and/or the crystal-chemical state of order of individual minerals or by measuring the residual stresses on solid inclusions^[5] or densities in fluid inclusions.^[6]

"Classic" (thermodynamic) thermobarometry^[7] relies upon the attainment of thermodynamic equilibrium between mineral pairs/assemblages that vary their compositions as a function of temperature and pressure. The distribution of component elements between the mineral assemblages is then analysed using a variety of analytical techniques as for example electron microprobe (EM), scanning electron microscope (SEM), Mass Spectrometry (MS). There are numerous extra factors to consider such as oxygen fugacity and water activity (roughly, the same as concentration) that must be accounted for using the appropriate methodological and analytical approach (e.g. Mössbauer spectroscopy, micro-raman spectroscopy, infrared spectroscopy etc...)Geobarometers are typically net-transfer reactions, which are sensitive to pressure but have little change with temperature, such as garnet-plagioclase-muscovite-biotite reaction that involves a significant volume reduction upon high pressure:

$\backslash mathsf$

Since mineral assemblages at equilibrium are dependent on pressures and temperatures, by measuring the composition of the coexisting minerals, together with using suitable activity models, the P-T conditions experienced by the rock can be determined.

As different equilibrium constants of mineral assemblages would occur as lines with different slopes in the P-T diagram, therefore, by finding the intersection of at least two lines in the P-T diagram, the P-T condition of the specimen can be obtained.

Despite the usefulness of geothermobarometry, special attention should be paid to whether the mineral assemblages represent an equilibrium, any occurrence of retrograde equilibrium in the rock, and appropriateness of calibration of the results.

Elastic thermobarometry is a method of determining the equilibrium pressure and temperature attained by the host mineral and its inclusion on the rock history from the excess pressures exhibited by mineral inclusions trapped inside host minerals. Upon exhumation and cooling, contrasting compressibilities and thermal expansivities induce differential strains (volume mismatches) between a host crystal and its inclusions. These strains can be quantified in situ using Raman spectroscopy or X-ray diffraction. Knowing equations of state and elastic properties of minerals, elastic thermobarometry inverts measured strains to calculate the pressure-temperature conditions under which the stress state was uniform in the host and inclusion. These are commonly interpreted to represent the conditions of inclusion entrapment or the last elastic equilibration of the pair.

Data on the geothermometers and geobarometers is derived from both laboratory studies on synthetic (artificial) mineral assemblages and from natural systems for which other constraints are available.

For example, one of the best known and most widely applicable geothermometers is the garnet-biotite relationship where the relative proportions of Fe and Mg in garnet and biotite change with increasing temperature, so measurement of the compositions of these minerals to give the Fe-Mg distribution between them allows the temperature of crystallization to be calculated, given some assumptions.

Assumptions in thermodynamic thermobarometry

In natural systems, the chemical reactions occur in open systems with unknown geological and chemical histories, and application of geothermobarometers relies on several assumptions that must hold in order for the laboratory data and natural compositions to relate in a valid fashion:

• That the full mineralogical assemblage required for the thermobarometer is present. If not all of the minerals of the reaction are present, or did not equilibrate with each other simultaneously, then any pressures and temperatures calculated for the ideal reaction will deviate from those actually experienced by the rock.
• That chemical equilibrium was achieved to a satisfactory degree. This could be impossible to demonstrate definitively, if the minerals of the thermobarometer assemblage are not all observed in contact with each other.
• That any minerals in a two-mineral barometer or thermometer grew in equilibrium, which is assumed when the minerals are seen to be in contact.
• That the mineral assemblage has not been altered by retrograde metamorphism, which can be assessed using an optical microscope in most cases.
• That certain mineralogical assemblages are present. Without these, the accuracy of a reading may be altered from an ideal, and there may be more error inherent in the measurement.
• That minerals present in thin section are in the same solid solution state as in the model. Many minerals such as feldspars and augite have a range of solid solution variations. Each variation can effect the model and the way a rock is metamorphosed over time.

Assumptions in elastic thermobarometry

In natural systems elastic behaviour of minerals can be easily perturbed by high temperature re-equilibration, plastic or brittle deformation, leading to an irreversible change beyond the elastic regime that will prevent reconstructing the "elastic history" of the pair.

• The major assumption behind elastic geobarometry is that the host and the inclusion have experience initially the same pressure and that deformation of the host-inclusion system is elastic, hence reversible, and can therefore be inverted to obtain the entrapment pressure of the inclusion.^[8]
• The shape of the inclusion is assumed to be spherical but calculations for non-spherical shapes are available^[9]
• For several host-inclusion pairs the elastic properties for the host and the inclusion are assumed to be isotropic. For some pairs anisotropic solutions are available (e.g. quartz in garnet, zircon in garnet)^{[10] [11]}
• Simple calculation methods assume linear elasticity

Techniques

Some techniques include:

Geothermometers

• Ti saturation content of biotite mica.^[12]
• Fe-Mg exchange between garnet-biotite and garnet-amphibole.
• Mg-Fe systematics in pigeonites and augites ^[13]
• Zr content of rutile, effective for higher temperatures than the Ti-in-biotite thermometer. Requires quartz, rutile, and zircon to be equilibrated.^[14]
• Ti-in-zircon crystallization thermometer

Note that the Fe-Mg exchange thermometers are empirical (laboratory tested and calibrated) as well as calculated based on a theoretical thermodynamic understanding of the components and phases involved. The Ti-in-biotite thermometer is solely empirical and not well understood thermodynamically.

Geobarometers

• GASP; an acronym for the assemblage garnet-(Al₂SiO₅)-silica(quartz)-plagioclase
• GPMB; an acronym for the assemblage garnet-plagioclase-muscovite-biotite
• Garnet-plagioclase-hornblende-quartz.^{[15] [16]}
• Hornblende ^{[17] [18] [19]}

Various mineral assemblages rely more upon pressure than temperature; for example reactions which involve a large volume change. At high pressure, specific minerals assume lower volumes (therefore density increases, as the mass does not change) - it is these minerals which are good indicators of paleo-pressure.

Software

Software for "classic" thermobarometry includes:

• THERMO-CALC softwarewas founded in 1997, but it all started much before that, as early as the mid-1970s, in fact. The place was the department for physical metallurgy at the Royal Institute of Technology (KTH) in Stockholm, Sweden, where Mats Hillert was a professor. Three of his graduate students at this time were, Bo Sundman, Bo Jansso and John Ågren. Thermo-calc is a software used by materials scientists and engineers to generate material properties data, gain insights about materials, understand a specific observation, and answer direct questions related to a specific material and/or its processing. Used in conjunction with suitable databases, Thermo-Calc can be used for a wide variety of applications.
• THERMOCALC^{[20] [21]} developed by Tim Holland and Roger Powell calculates model phase equilibria involving the HPx-eos and/or individual end-members from the Holland & Powell dataset.
• Perple_X,^{[22] [23] [24] [25] [26]} originally developed by James A.D. Connolly is a collection of fortran programs for calculating and displaying petrologic phase equilibria
• XMapTools^[27] orioginally developed by Pierre Lanari is an advanced analysis software for quantitative chemical analysis of solids in 1D, 2D and 3D. It provides numerical tools and packages implemented in a guided and versatile environment that allows you to explore and visualise data in your own way. For example, XMapTools includes a wide range of data processing options including routines for classification, segmentation, calibration and visualisation via single and multi-channel maps or via binary, ternary and spider diagrams. Now it includes Bingo Antidote.
• Bingo-Antidote is a petrological software originally developed by Pierre Lanari and Erik Duesterhoeft that offers an alternative modelling strategy based on iterative thermodynamic models integrated with quantitative compositional mapping. The latter is distributed as an XMapTools add-on and comes with a redesigned graphical user interface and improved features.

Software for elastic thermobarometry includes:

• EntraPT^[28] originally developed by Mattia L. Mazzucchelli, Ross J. Angel and Matteo Alvaro is a web application for elastic geobarometry. It is designed to make elastic thermobarometry easier. You can graphically analyze the residual strains of your inclusions and estimate their entrapment conditions, all in one place. It makes also easy to export, reuse, share and compare your data.
• Strainman^[29] originally developed by Ross J. Angel, Mara Murri, Boriana Mihailova and Matteo Alvaro is computer program for Windows for calculating strains from changes in Raman (or other phonon) mode wavenumbers, and vice-versa.
• EosFit^[30] is a software suite for calculations involving both thermal expansion and equations of state which now includes five major components to perform EoS calculations both with (EosFit7GUI)^[31] and without (EosFit7c) graphic user interface and perform host-inclusion calculations (Eosfit7-Pinc^[32]) with non-linear elasticity. Eosfit uses cfml_eos a validated set of Fortran modules that can be ‘used’ (in the Fortran sense) to easily write programs that can read, manipulate and fit EoS data, and perform related calculations for EoS.

Clinopyroxene thermobarometry

See main article: Clinopyroxene thermobarometry. The mineral clinopyroxene is used for temperature and pressure calculations of the magma that produced igneous rock containing this mineral.

References

• Winter, D.John.Thermodynamics of metamorphic reactions: Geothermobarometry, 543-556
• Henry, D. J., Guidotti, C. V. and Thomson, J. A. (2005) The Ti-saturation surface for low-to-medium pressure metapelitic biotite: Implications for Geothermometry and Ti-substitution Mechanisms. American Mineralogist, 90, 316-328.
• Guidotti, C. V., Cheney, J. T. and Henry, D. J. (1988) Compositional variation of biotite as a function of metamorphic reactions and mineral assemblage in the pelitic schists of western Maine: American Journal of Science-Wones Memorial Volume, v. 288A, 270-292.

External links

• Thermo-Calc Software - this can be purchased online with a range of databases however there is also a free Educational Package on their website https://thermocalc.com/academia/free-educational-package/
• THERMOCALC (Holland & Powell) - currently free to download online for everyone with a range of databases available. See the download guide at: https://hpxeosandthermocalc.org/the-thermocalc-software/thermocalc-get-started/thermocalc-download-guide/

Notes and References

1. Powell . R. . Holland . T. J. B. . February 2008 . On thermobarometry . Journal of Metamorphic Geology . en . 26 . 2 . 155–179 . 10.1111/j.1525-1314.2007.00756.x . 2008JMetG..26..155P . 0263-4929.
2. Wood . B.J. . Holland . T.J.B. . Newton . R.C. . Kleppa . O.J. . September 1980 . Thermochemistry of jadeite—diopside pyroxenes . Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta . en . 44 . 9 . 1363–1371 . 10.1016/0016-7037(80)90095-2. 1980GeCoA..44.1363W .
3. Book: Holland . Heinrich D. . Treatise on geochemistry . Turekian . Karl K. . 2004 . Elsevier/Pergamon . 978-0-08-043751-4 . 1st . Amsterdam Boston.
4. Book: Treatise on Geochemistry . 2003-12-04 . 978-0-08-043751-4 . en-US.
5. Kohn . Matthew J. . Mazzucchelli . Mattia L. . Alvaro . Matteo . 2023-05-30 . Elastic Thermobarometry . Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences . en . 51 . 1 . 331–366 . 10.1146/annurev-earth-031621-112720 . 2023AREPS..51..331K . 256443282 . 0084-6597.
6. Levresse . Gilles . Cervantes-de la Cruz . Karina Elizabeth . Aranda-Gómez . José Jorge . Dávalos-Elizondo . María Guadalupe . Jiménez-Sandoval . Sergio . Rodríguez-Melgarejo . Francisco . Alba-Aldave . Leticia Araceli . January 2016 . CO2 fluid inclusion barometry in mantle xenoliths from central Mexico: A detailed record of magma ascent . Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research . en . 310 . 72–88 . 10.1016/j.jvolgeores.2015.11.012.
7. Powell . Roger . Holland . Tim . 1994 . Optimal geothermometry and geobarometry . American Mineralogist . 79 . 120–133.
8. Moulas . Evangelos . Kostopoulos . Dimitrios . Podladchikov . Yury . Chatzitheodoridis . Elias . Schenker . Filippo L. . Zingerman . Konstantin M. . Pomonis . Panagiotis . Tajčmanová . Lucie . 2020-12-15 . Calculating pressure with elastic geobarometry: A comparison of different elastic solutions with application to a calc-silicate gneiss from the Rhodope Metamorphic Province . Lithos . en . 378-379 . 105803 . 10.1016/j.lithos.2020.105803 . 2020Litho.37805803M . 224846463 . 0024-4937.
9. Elastic geothermobarometry: Corrections for the geometry of the host-inclusion system . 2023-08-01 . Geology . 2018 . 10.1130/g39807.1 . Mazzucchelli . M.L. . Burnley . P. . Angel . R.J. . Morganti . S. . Domeneghetti . M.C. . Nestola . F. . Alvaro . M. . 46 . 3 . 231–234 . 2018Geo....46..231M . free .
10. Mazzucchelli . M. L. . Reali . A. . Morganti . S. . Angel . R. J. . Alvaro . M. . 2019-12-15 . Elastic geobarometry for anisotropic inclusions in cubic hosts . Lithos . en . 350-351 . 105218 . 10.1016/j.lithos.2019.105218 . 0024-4937. free . 2019Litho.35005218M .
11. Murri . Mara . Mazzucchelli . Mattia L. . Campomenosi . Nicola . Korsakov . Andrey V. . Prencipe . Mauro . Mihailova . Boriana D. . Scambelluri . Marco . Angel . Ross J. . Alvaro . Matteo . 2018-11-01 . Raman elastic geobarometry for anisotropic mineral inclusions . American Mineralogist . en . 103 . 11 . 1869–1872 . 10.2138/am-2018-6625CCBY . 1945-3027. 11567/919890 . free .
12. http://www.geol.lsu.edu/henry/Research/biotite/TiInBiotiteGeothermometer.htm Ti-in biotite geothermometer, Henry et al. 2005
13. Lindsley & Andersen 1983 - A Two-pyroxene Thermometer; Journal of Geophysical Research, vol. 88
14. http://www.rpi.edu/~watsoe/research/Watson_etal_CMP06.pdf Crystallization thermometers for zircon and rutile, Watson et al. 2006; Contributions to mineralogy and petrology v. 151
15. Kohn, M.J. and Spear, F.S. (1989): Am. Min. 74:77-84. (Pargasite component)
16. Kohn, M.J. and Spear, F.S. (1990): Am. Min. 75:89-96. (Tschermakite component)
17. Hammerstrom, J.M. and Zen, E.-an. (1986): Am. Min. 71:1297-1313.
18. Hollister, L.S., Grissom, G.C., Peters, E.K., Stowell, H.H. and Sisson, V.B.(1987): Am. Mineral. 72:231-239.
19. Johnson, and Rutherford (1989): Geology 17: 837-841.
20. Holland . T. J. B. . Powell . R. . 2004-10-08 . An internally consistent thermodynamic data set for phases of petrological interest: AN INTERNALLY CONSISTENT THERMODYNAMIC DATA SET . Journal of Metamorphic Geology . en . 16 . 3 . 309–343 . 10.1111/j.1525-1314.1998.00140.x.
21. Powell . R . Holland . T. . Worley . B. . June 1998 . Calculating phase diagrams involving solid solutions via non-linear equations, with examples using THERMOCALC . Journal of Metamorphic Geology . en . 16 . 4 . 577–588 . 10.1111/j.1525-1314.1998.00157.x . 1998JMetG..16..577P . 129301254 . 0263-4929.
22. Connolly . J. a. D. . 1990-06-01 . Multivariable phase diagrams; an algorithm based on generalized thermodynamics . American Journal of Science . en . 290 . 6 . 666–718 . 10.2475/ajs.290.6.666. 1990AmJS..290..666C .
23. Connolly . J.A.D. . July 2005 . Computation of phase equilibria by linear programming: A tool for geodynamic modeling and its application to subduction zone decarbonation . Earth and Planetary Science Letters . en . 236 . 1–2 . 524–541 . 10.1016/j.epsl.2005.04.033. 2005E&PSL.236..524C .
24. Connolly . James A. D. . Galvez . Matthieu E. . 2018-11-01 . Electrolytic fluid speciation by Gibbs energy minimization and implications for subduction zone mass transfer . Earth and Planetary Science Letters . en . 501 . 90–102 . 10.1016/j.epsl.2018.08.024 . 2018E&PSL.501...90C . 134999977 . 0012-821X.
25. Connolly . J. A. D. . Petrini . K. . September 2002 . An automated strategy for calculation of phase diagram sections and retrieval of rock properties as a function of physical conditions . Journal of Metamorphic Geology . en . 20 . 7 . 697–708 . 10.1046/j.1525-1314.2002.00398.x . 2002JMetG..20..697C . 73603565 . 0263-4929.
26. Connolly . J. A. D. . Kerrick . D. M. . 1987-01-01 . An algorithm and computer program for calculating composition phase diagrams . Calphad . en . 11 . 1 . 1–55 . 10.1016/0364-5916(87)90018-6 . 0364-5916.
27. Lanari . Pierre . Vidal . Olivier . De Andrade . Vincent . Dubacq . Benoît . Lewin . Eric . Grosch . Eugene G. . Schwartz . Stéphane . 2014-01-01 . XMapTools: A MATLAB©-based program for electron microprobe X-ray image processing and geothermobarometry . Computers & Geosciences . en . 62 . 227–240 . 10.1016/j.cageo.2013.08.010 . 0098-3004.
28. EntraPT: An online platform for elastic geothermobarometry . 2023-08-01 . American Mineralogist . 2021 . 10.2138/am-2021-7693ccbyncnd . Mazzucchelli . Mattia Luca . Angel . Ross John . Alvaro . Matteo . 106 . 5 . 830–837 . 2021AmMin.106..830M . free .
29. Angel . Ross J. . Murri . Mara . Mihailova . Boriana . Alvaro . Matteo . 2019-02-01 . Stress, strain and Raman shifts . Zeitschrift für Kristallographie - Crystalline Materials . en . 234 . 2 . 129–140 . 10.1515/zkri-2018-2112 . 105926659 . 2196-7105.
30. Angel . Ross J. . Alvaro . Matteo . Gonzalez-Platas . Javier . 2014-05-01 . EosFit7c and a Fortran module (library) for equation of state calculations . Zeitschrift für Kristallographie - Crystalline Materials . de . 229 . 5 . 405–419 . 10.1515/zkri-2013-1711 . 56434995 . 2196-7105.
31. Gonzalez-Platas . J. . Alvaro . M. . Nestola . F. . Angel . R. . 2016-08-01 . EosFit7-GUI: a new graphical user interface for equation of state calculations, analyses and teaching . Journal of Applied Crystallography . en . 49 . 4 . 1377–1382 . 10.1107/S1600576716008050 . 1600-5767.
32. Angel . Ross J. . Mazzucchelli . Mattia L. . Alvaro . Matteo . Nestola . Fabrizio . 2017-09-01 . EosFit-Pinc: A simple GUI for host-inclusion elastic thermobarometry . American Mineralogist . en . 102 . 9 . 1957–1960 . 10.2138/am-2017-6190 . 2017AmMin.102.1957A . 1945-3027.