The Twentieth Century Society Explained

The Twentieth Century Society
Abbreviation:C20
Formation:1979 (as The Thirties Society)
Headquarters:70 Cowcross Street, London
Leader Title:Director
Leader Name:Catherine Croft
Leader Title2:Chairman and Trustee
Leader Name2:Hugh Pearman
Leader Title3:President
Leader Name3:Catherine Slessor

The Twentieth Century Society (abbreviated to C20), founded in 1979 as The Thirties Society, is a British charity that campaigns for the preservation of architectural heritage from 1914 onwards. It is formally recognised as one of the National Amenity Societies,[1] and as such is a statutory consultee on alterations to listed buildings within its period of interest.

History

The catalyst to form the society was the proposal to replace Lloyd's of London's Classical-style 1920s headquarters with a new modernist Richard Rogers building. Marcus Binney (founder of Save Britain's Heritage), John Harris (director of the RIBA drawings collection) and Simon Jenkins (editor of London's Evening Standard) felt that the existing building "represented a whole body of important architecture of the period that deserved more sympathetic assessment".[2] Ultimately the façade of the 1920s building was retained and received a Grade II listing in 1977. It was incorporated into Rogers' 1986 design.[3]

Established in December 1979, the Thirties Society, as it was initially called, had offices at 21 Cambridge Street, London.[4] Its organisation was modelled on the Georgian Group and the Victorian Society, and its initial intention was to preserve architecture from the 1930s,[5] by calling for "statutory protection from the Department of the Environment for the protection of important buildings and interiors".[6] Speaking of the need for the society, Jenkins, the vice-chairman, said "It's easier to find examples of architecture from the 1890s than the 1930s, and although there are buildings which I find absolutely hideous, there are architectural reasons why they should be preserved."[7] In 1992, a spokesperson for English Heritage said, "We have found the Thirties Society proposals are usually well supported. It has been very influential in saving some of the best twentieth-century buildings."[8]

Founding members

Founding members included:

The society of "young fogeys" as they were called[8] invited Maxwell Fry, Jane Drew, Sir Sacheverell Sitwell, Lady Diana Cooper, Sir John Betjeman and Peter Fleetwood-Hesketh[10] to be patrons.[6] [11] They also considered Douglas Fairbanks and David Niven but "there was some concern that the stars of the Twenties and Thirties might not be around long enough to warrant putting their names on the letterhead."[6] Norman St John Stevas, Minister for the Arts, attended the launch party.[12]

Catherine Croft, the current director, took over the position from Kenneth Powell in 2002.[13]

Name

There was a debate over the society's name. The Inter-War Society was considered too martial and it was joked that The Twenties and Thirties Society sounded too much like a dating service.[6] The name The Thirties Society was eventually settled on. The name was changed to The Twentieth Century Society (abbreviated to C20) in 1992, about which Stamp said, "Much as I like the very English anomaly of a body called The Thirties Society defending buildings of the 1950s, the fact is that our name obscures our aims. We defend buildings put up as late as the 1970s."[14]

Manchester branch

In 1982, a Manchester branch of the society was formed, with a focus on the Grosvenor Picture Palace on All Saints Street, which was under threat of demolition.[15]

Other activities

The society held its first conference, on the Seventies, in 1999.[16]

The society published a journal between 1981 and 2018; initially entitled The Thirties Society Journal it became Twentieth Century Architecture from 1994.[17]

In 2019, to mark the society's 40th anniversary, they curated a list of 40 Buildings Saved, a collection of 40 "buildings which would not have survived without our intervention" including Jubilee Pool in Penzance, Plymouth's Civic Centre and St. Augustine in Manchester.[18]

The Risk List

In 1998, the society released a Buildings at Risk report, which included Pimlico School, Romney House and Simpson's Building. Of the report, Bronwen Edwards, a C20 caseworker, said, "What is indisputable is these buildings are a unique record of social, economic and architectural history – a vivid reminder of the way people lived, worked and played through the century."[19]

Starting in 2015, the society has published The Risk List (a play on the Rich List) [20] every two years, which highlights ten buildings that the society believes are "in danger of either substantial alteration or demolition".[21]

The bi-annual lists are as follows:

Year Building Location Status
2023Channel 4 headquarters London
2023Museum of LondonLondon
2023Jagonari CentreLondon
2023Bastion HouseLondon
2023Norco HouseAberdeen
2023Riviera HotelWeymouthCurrently listed
2023PointWeymouth
2023Ringway CentreBirmingham
2023County HallCardiff
2023Power station cooling towers West Burton
2023Scottish Widows buildingEdinburghCurrently listed
2021SwindonGranted Grade II listing[22]
2021City HallLondonCertificate of Immunity
2021SwanseaPlans to retain (as of 2023)
2021Assembly HallsDerbyPlans to retain (as of 2023)
2021Bull YardCoventry
2021The Lawns, Halls of ResidenceHullListed Grade II*
2021Cressingham Gardens' EstateLondonBid to be listed was rejected
2021Electricity Board HQLondonBid to be listed in 2017 was rejected
2021Swimming poolHalifax
2021ShirehallShrewsbury
2019Alton EstateRoehamptonNo longer threatened (as of 2023)
2019Fawley Power StationHampshireDemolished (2021)
2019Walton CourtSurreyDemolished
2019Richmond HouseLondonGrade II* listed
2019British Library Centre for ConservationLondon
2019BFI IMAX CinemaLondonCertificate of Immunity
2019Civic CentreSunderlandDemolished (2022)
2019Homebase SuperstoreBrentfordAt risk of demolishing for new housing (2022)
2019Ardudwy Theatre and Residential TowerMerionyddGrade II* listed. Up for sale.
2019All Saints' Pastoral Centre and ChapelHertfordshireOccupied by an international school
2017Dunelm HouseDurhamGranted Grade II listing (2021)
2017BHS muralsStockport and HullGranted Grade II listing (2019)
2017Reform Synagogue and Police StationManchester
2017Central HillLondonBid to be listed was rejected (2019)
2017The Elephant and Swimming BathsCoventryBaths are listed Grade II. Elephant was refused listing
2017High Cross HouseDevonAwaiting restoration
2017Cumberbatch North and South Buildings OxfordDemolished
2017St. Leonards ChurchSt. Leonards-on-SeaGrade II listed
201760 Hornton StreetWest KensingtonDemolished
2017Holborn LibraryHolbornBid to be listed was rejected (2010)
2015St Peter's SeminaryCardrossPositive solution found[23]
2015Western Morning News HQPlymouthPositive solution found
2015Hyde Park BarracksLondonBid to be listed was rejected (2015)
2015Robin Hood GardensLondonDemolished
2015New Congregation SynagogueLiverpoolGrade II* listed. Approval given to turn it into a series of apartments (2017)
2015Bernat Klein StudioEdinburghListed Category A. On Buildings At Risk register for Scotland.
2015Church of the Holy CrossMerseysideListed Grade II
2015Town HallHoveBid to be listed was rejected (2014)
2015Salvation Army hostelNewcastleGrade II listed. Put up for sale (2021)
2015Sainsbury'sGreenwichDemolished
2015Civic OfficesDurhamDemolished

Cases and campaigns

1979
- The Oxo Tower, designed by Albert Moore in 1929 was threatened with redevelopment, but was subsequently designated part of a conservation area.[24] [25]

1980s

1980
- The society's first high-profile case was the Art Deco Firestone Tyre Factory (built 1928) in West London. In anticipation of it being listed, the building was demolished by its owners over a bank holiday weekend.[26]
1982
- The society protested the proposal to develop Memorial Court, designed by Sir Giles Gilbert Scott at Clare College, Cambridge,[27] saying the new building would "destroy the vista which gives coherence to Scott's design".[28]
1983
- Arthur Scargill "incurred the formidable wrath" of the society, when the National Union of Mineworkers moved headquarters, leaving its 1950s 222 Euston Road location open to threat of demolition. The building was saved.[29]
1984
- Terence Conran's application to change the windows of 1930's Heal's on Tottenham Court Road was opposed by the society. Of Conran, Stamp said "He has turned out to be rather a crude shopkeeper."[30] Their objection ultimately failed.[31]
1985
- The society spoke out against British Telecom's (BT) attempt to remove the traditional Giles Gilbert Scott-designed red phone boxes.[32] They campaigned for as many as possible to be saved, by contacting every local authority in Britain. A spokesman for the society said, "They fit extraordinarily into their surroundings, whether urban or rural, and they are the most satisfactory neighbours to historic buildings."[33] Ultimately 500 boxes were saved, under a 1987 agreement between the British government, BT and English Heritage.[34] By 1992, 1,200 of the early designed boxes were listed, with a further 18,000 kept in use by BT.[35]
- The society's objection to the alteration to Hoover's cafeteria was unsuccessful, with permission to renovate granted by Ealing Council.[36]
1986
- A fundraising campaign, in conjunction with Save Britain's Heritage, was launched to save Monkton House in Sussex, a surrealist mansion. Stamp said "I cannot think of another 20th century house with its contents intact which is so worth keeping."[37]
- Sudbury Town tube station, (rebuilt 1930), was updated in consultation with the society, amongst others.[38]
- Together with Save Britain's Heritage, the society proposed that Brynmawr rubber factory designed by Architects' Co-Partnership in Gwent, Wales (built 1946-1952), was repurposed as a re-training centre.[39] The building was given a Grade II* listing, the first post-war building in the UK to receive such a listed status but remained empty.[40] The building was ultimately demolished in 2001.
1987
- The society joined several groups in opposing British Coal's plans to demolish the Grade II listed Frizzell baths at Lynemouth Colliery in Northumberland (built 1938).[41] The campaign was successful, with the Secretary of State for the Environment rejecting British Coal's proposal.[42]
- After publishing a report The End of the Tunnel, in conjunction with The Victorian Society, the society held "top level talks" regarding concerns over "widespread destruction" of older underground stations.[43]
- Together with Save Britain's Heritage, the society opposed the demolition of Bracken House (built 1959) in the City, London, with Stamp describing it as "the one thing that isn't rubbish."[44] It was listed in August 1987, becoming "the first major post-war building to be listed".[45]
- After pressure from the society, the British government changed its stance on listing post-war buildings, allowing "buildings of special architectural or historical importance" to be listed if they were minimum 30 years old, or in exceptional circumstances 10.[46]
1988
- The society joined the Urban Design Group's list of signatories in support of the Prince of Wales' "role as scourge of glass stumps and carbuncles".[47]
1989
- The society urged Wandsworth Council and English Heritage to save Battersea Power Station from "demolition by demoralisation".[48]

1990s

1991
- Concern was expressed about the future of London Zoo, which needed £13 million worth of repairs to 70 buildings.[49]
- The society backed CAMRA's campaign to save historic pubs from "bogus 'period' facelifts".[50] One success was Prospect Inn in Thanet, Kent, designed by Oliver Hill (built 1937), which was listed as Grade II.[51]
- The society called for the preservation of the Cheltenham Estate in North Kensington (built 1968–1975), designed by Ernö Goldfinger.[52] The society called for the Nottingham Playhouse (built 1964) to be declared architecturally significant.[53]
- The "Lido campaign" called for the preservation of outdoor pools, including the Jubilee Pool (built 1935) in Penzance.[35]
- Odeon House, designed by C Edmund Wilford (built 1930s) was to be saved from demolition in Sutton Coldfield. It received Grade II listing in 1998.[54]
- The society objected to a proposed 25-foot-tall fountain to commemorate the Queen's 40 years as monarch, planned for Parliament Square, London. The fountain was not built.[55]
1994
- The society suggested ten concrete bridges spanning the M1 to be listed as historic monuments.[56]
- The society successfully encouraged the National Trust to add Erno Goldfinger's home, 2 Willow Road, (built 1939) to its portfolio. It was opened to the public in 1995.[57]
- The society successfully prevented the demolition of Tunstall's Barber's Palace cinema frontage (built 1920) citing it as an "interesting example of 1920s Modernist Movement architecture".[58]
1995
- The society protested a glass lift being installed in Liverpool Cathedral, saying it would "reduce the awe and majesty of this fine building".[59]
- The society joined English Heritage in successfully protesting the modernisation of Totnes' post office on Fore Street.[60] [61]
1996
- The society backed Humberston Fitties residents' appeal to become a conservation area.[62] The appeal was successful, followed by an Article 4 direction in 1998, which ensured the area's character was preserved.[63]
- The society saved a 1960s concrete frieze in Coventry city centre from being removed, stating it was "one of only two examples of Mexican-style public art on pub fronts in the country".[64]
- The society objected to the demolishing of the Dunlop Semtex Factory, Gwent (built 1945). It was the focus of "many students of architecture, including Frank Lloyd Wright" for the dome structure of its roof and concrete contours. It was authorised for demolition in the same year.[65]
- The society objected to the demolishing of the Empire Pool in Cardiff. It was authorised for demolition in 1999 to make way for the Millennium Stadium.[66]
- The society called for the preservation of Uxbridge's Lido, calling for it to be listed.[67] It was granted Grade II listing in 1998.[68]
1997
- Together with English Heritage, the society proposed Derby bus station, the UK's first purpose-built bus station (built 1933), be granted listed status.[69] It closed in 2005 and was demolished the following year.[70]

21st century

2002
- The society joined the Ancient Monuments Society in trying to save the grade II listed private home Greenside in Virginia Water (built 1937) designed by Connell, Ward and Lucas, from demolition. The following year the owners demolished it without consent, "arguing that the Human Rights Act justified his actions".[71]
2005
- The society submitted an application for Sheffield's Crucible Theatre to be listed. The application was successful, with Grade II listing status given in 2007.[72]
2013
- The society's appeal for Swindon's Renault Distribution Centre (built 1982), designed by Norman Foster to be listed was successful.[73]
- After many years of campaigning for the listing of Building Design Partnership's 1969 Preston bus station, it was granted listed status.[74]
2015
- The society called to save parts of the Eduardo Paolozzi mosaic, installed at the Tottenham Court Road station (created 1984). Threatened with permanent removal as part of the station's overhaul, the Society arranged for the decorative arch designs to be restored at the University of Edinburgh, where Paolozzi studied.[75]
2022
- The society called for the Trinity Laban Conservatoire of Music and Dance in Deptford to be listed. If successful, it would become "the youngest building on the list – and the first 21st Century building to make the cut".[76]
2023
- The society campaigned to save Bristol's NCP Rupert Street Car Park, (built 1959-60). The car park, which was built in 1959–1960 was set to be replaced with a 21-storey apartment building, but the Twentieth Century Society argued that the car park should be preserved because it was "a good example of an absolutely pivotal building type from the 20th century".[77]

The Twentieth Century Society's successes

The following are some of the buildings and objects that the society has successfully campaigned to save:

Publications

Journal

The society published a journal between 1981 and 2018; initially entitled The Thirties Society Journal[78] it became Twentieth Century Architecture from 1994.[79]

Books

The following books were published by C20, unless otherwise stated:

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Amenity Societies and other Voluntary bodies . . historicengland.org.uk . 20 May 2023.
  2. Powers . Alan . Stamp . Gavin . 2004 . The Twentieth Century Society: A brief history . No. 7 . Twentieth Century Architecture. 7 . 158–160 . 41859680.
  3. Web site: Lloyd's Building . . historicengland.org.uk . 6 June 2023.
  4. News: 18 December 1979 . The Daily Telegraph . Grigsby . John . Fight to save OXO Tower . 10 . London.
  5. News: 30 November 1979 . The Guardian . Crawford . David . A great time for houses . 10 . Manchester.
  6. News: 14 December 1979 . The Guardian . Games . Stephen . 30s is a dangerous age . 9 . Manchester.
  7. News: 14 December 1979 . The Guardian . Chesshyre . Robert . Daytrip to the Thirties . 44 . London.
  8. News: 26 July 1992 . The Observer . Martin . Bailey . Apostles of Art Deco to wage a modern war . 6 . London.
  9. News: 19 December 1979 . The Guardian . Stephen . Games . A cartoon that paints too unfair a picture . 12 . Manchester.
  10. News: 12 February 1985 . The Daily Telegraph . . P. Fleetwood-Hesketh . 12 . London.
  11. News: 14 December 1979 . Evening Standard . . Londoner's Diary . 24 . London.
  12. News: 15 December 1979 . The Daily Telegraph . . London Day by Day . 14 . London.
  13. News: 22 August 2002 . The Stage . . Catherine Croft . 2 . London.
  14. News: 16 May 1992 . The Daily Telegraph . . Falling in . 15 . London.
  15. News: 2 July 1982 . Manchester Evening News . . Saving the Thirties . 38 . Manchester.
  16. 2012 . Harwood . Elain . Powers . Alan . From downturn to diversity, revisiting the 1970s . Twentieth Century Architecture . London . No. 10 . The Twentieth Century Society . 9.
  17. Web site: The Twentieth Century Society . [JSTOR]] . 17 September 2022.
  18. Web site: 40 buildings saved . . c20society.org.uk . 20 May 2023.
  19. News: 26 November 1998 . Marylebone Mercury . Van Mead . Nick . Modern Classics . 7 . London.
  20. Web site: C20 launches 2023 "risk list" campaign . . c20society.org.uk . 20 May 2023.
  21. Web site: Richard Rogers' Channel 4 headquarters . Carlson . Cajsa . dezeen.com . 8 March 2023 . 20 May 2023.
  22. Web site: Bradford's Richard Dunn Sports Centre gets listed status . . bbc.co.uk . 6 July 2023.
  23. Web site: Top 10 C20 buildings at Risk 2017 . . c20society.org.uk . 20 May 2023.
  24. News: 1 April 1983 . Belfast Telegraph . . OXO tower is reprieved . 2 . Belfast.
  25. News: 15 December 1979 . The Daily Telegraph . . London Day by Day . 14 . London.
  26. News: 28 August 1980 . The Daily Telegraph . Grigsby . John . Protection Plea for best buildings of 20th Century . 15 . London.
  27. News: 10 September 1982 . Cambridge Evening News . . Architecture society attacks library scheme . 11 . Cambridge.
  28. News: 13 October 1982 . The Guardian . Games . Stephen . Rival verdicts on a valued varsity vista . 3 . Manchester.
  29. News: 3 January 1983 . The Daily Telegraph . . London Day by Day . 8 . London.
  30. News: 5 December 1984 . Evening Standard . . Windows of Opportunity . 6 . London.
  31. News: 21 October 1985 . The Guardian . Hearst . David . Conran rejects Heal's plea . 5 . Manchester.
  32. News: 6 February 1985 . The Daily Telegraph . . Telephone vandals . 16 . London.
  33. News: 25 March 1985 . Birmingham Evening Mail . . Council Set to engage in red phone box fight . 29 . Birmingham.
  34. News: 18 May 1987 . Evening Standard . Stringer . Robin . Heritage on the line . 5 . London.
  35. News: 26 July 1992 . The Observer . Bailey . Martin . Apostles of Art Deco to wage a modern war . 6 . London.
  36. News: 4 October 1985 . Southall Gazette . . Hoover changes . 8 . London.
  37. News: 17 January 1986 . The Daily Telegraph . . Race is on to save surrealist mansion . 18 . London.
  38. News: 8 May 1986 . Wembley Observer . . Historic tube gets an update . 19 . London.
  39. News: 22 October 1986 . The Daily Telegraph . . Threat to "masterpiece" . 18 . London.
  40. Web site: Lost Modern: Brynmawr Rubber Factory, Gwent, Wales. 29 March 2020 . Twentieth Century Society .
  41. News: 18 March 1987 . The Journal . . Plans to demolish baths is attacked . 16 . London.
  42. News: 29 July 1987 . Evening Chronicle . . Listed pithead baths to stay . 11 . Newcastle upon Tyne.
  43. News: 8 April 1987 . Evening Standard . . LRT 'killing history' . 4 . Newcastle upon Tyne.
  44. News: 11 August 1987 . The Guardian . Rose . David . 'Classic' City post-war building faces threat of demolition . 2 . London.
  45. News: 14 August 1987 . The Daily Telegraph . Bedlow . Robert . Bracken House given listed status . 14 . London.
  46. News: 26 July 1992 . The Observer . Bailey . Martin . Apostles of Art Deco to wage a modern war . 6 . London.
  47. News: 11 May 1988 . The Guardian . Ardill . John . Urban designers vow to promote Prince's quest for better cities . 7 . London.
  48. News: 4 December 1989 . Evening Standard . Bar-Hillel . Mira . Chilling warning over Battersea . 85 . London.
  49. News: 9 April 1991 . The Daily Telegraph . O'Brien . R Barry . London's £13 million appeal to 'save our zoo' . 2 . London.
  50. News: 10 April 1991 . Burton Mail . Small . Peter . Pubs 'ruined' by fake looks . 5 . Burton on Trent.
  51. News: 21 September 1991 . The Guardian . Smithers . Rebecca . Thirties thing . 56 . London.
  52. News: 13 July 1991 . The Daily Telegraph . Powell . Kenneth . Palumbo calls to protect council flats . 16 . London.
  53. News: 2 August 1991 . Evening Post . Curry . Lynne . Playhouse set for accolade . 12 . Nottingham.
  54. News: 9 September 1991 . Evening Mail . . Fight is on for "Odeon House" . 7 . West Bromwich.
  55. News: 12 September 1991 . Westminster and Pimlico News . Power . Lynn . A right royal dispute . 1 . London.
  56. News: 25 July 1994 . The Daily Telegraph . . Motorway bridge is history in the making . 30 . London.
  57. News: 14 July 1994 . The Guardian . Brown . Paul . Ezard. John . National Trust gives hard-edged 1960s terrace house the seal of heritage approval . 3 . London.
  58. News: 22 June 1994 . Staffordshire Sentinel . Holmes . Peter . Eyesore rap over cinema . 18 . Stafford.
  59. News: 17 March 1995 . Liverpool Echo . Todd . Ann . A big ding dong verily on high . 5 . Liverpool.
  60. News: 17 February 1995 . Torbay Express and South Devon Echo . . Heritage group lick Ex-PO bid . 3 . Torbay.
  61. News: 17 April 1995 . Torbay Express and South Devon Echo . . Pane in the glass cured by planners . 15 . Torbay.
  62. News: 8 January 1996 . Grimbsy Daily Telegraph . . Over 800 signed petition . 12 . Grimsby.
  63. Web site: Humberston Fitties . . humberstonfitties.com . 9 May 2023.
  64. News: 29 March 1996 . Coventry Evening Telegraph . Murray . Eddy . Pub art is saved from scrapheap . 10 . Coventry.
  65. News: 25 February 1999 . Gwent Gazette . Meek . Julian . History on your doorstep . 10 . Gwent.
  66. News: 30 September 1999 . South Wales Echo . Griffiths . Glanmor . From dream . 4 . Cardiff.
  67. News: 21 August 1999 . Harefield Gazette . . Swimming pool is an asset to us all . 19 . Harefield.
  68. Book: Sherwood, Philip . 2007 . Around Uxbridge Past and Present . Sutton Publishing . Stroud . 72 . 978-0-7509-4794-7.
  69. News: 24 September 1997 . Derby Daily Telegraph . Smith . Caroline . Bid to save station may halt big plans . 3 . Derby.
  70. Web site: Caravan for bus depot protestor who hit roof . Britten . Nick . telegraph.co.uk . 20 May 2023.
  71. News: Antistescu . Roxana . 7 May 2018 . Demolishing modernism: Britain's lost post-war gems . The Guardian . 6 July 2023.
  72. Web site: The Crucible Theatre . historicengland.org.uk. 5 July 2023.
  73. Web site: Swindon's 'View To A Kill' warehouse given listed status. BBC News. 5 June 2023. 10 September 2013.
  74. Waite. Richard. 10 January 2013. New bid to list Preston's Brutalist bus station. Architects' Journal.
  75. News: Khomami . Nadia . 31 July 2015 . Eduardo Paolozzi Tottenham Court Road mosaics to go to Edinburgh . The Guardian . 6 July 2023.
  76. Web site: Campaigners call for storm-damaged Trinity Laban centre to be listed . Ing . Will . architectsjournal.co.uk . 20 May 2023.
  77. News: Grierson . Jamie . 24 February 2023 . 'A lovely building': charity launches plan to save Bristol's Rupert Street car park . The Guardian . 26 February 2023 . 0261-3077.
  78. Web site: the Thirties Society Journal . . jstor.org . 20 May 2023.
  79. Web site: Twentieth Century Architecture . . jstor.org . 20 May 2023.