| Genre: | Reality Game show |
| Creator: | 3Ball Productions |
| Starring: | Mystery (Erik von Markovik) James Matador (Stan Tayi) J-Dog (Justin Marks) Tara Ferguson |
| Country: | United States |
| Language: | English |
| Num Seasons: | 2 |
| Num Episodes: | 16 |
| Executive Producer: | J. D. Roth Todd A. Nelson Adam Greener Doug Wilson Clair McCabe Michael Hirschorn Jeff Olde Suzanne Murch |
| Producer: | Angela Malloy |
| Company: | 3Ball Productions |
| Editor: | Taatshing Hui Tim Preston |
| Camera: | Multi-camera |
| Runtime: | 43 mins. |
| Network: | VH1 |
The Pickup Artist is an American reality television dating themed game show that aired on VH1.[1] The show was hosted by pickup artist Mystery (Erik von Markovik) and his wings J-Dog (Justin Marks) and James Matador, with Tara Ferguson replacing J-Dog in season 2. The first season featured eight male contestants that had previously been unsuccessful in love and relationships. Throughout the show the contestants are tutored in the art of the "pickup" as taught by Mystery and his wings. In each episode the men were given challenges that involved picking women up in different situations, such as on a bridge during the day or in a nightclub. As the show progressed the men were instructed to pick up women of varying levels of difficulty, such as in the second to last challenge of the first season where the men had to pick up a stripper, described by Mystery as "the ultimate challenge."[2] The winner of the first season was Alvaro "Kosmo" Orlando.
The second season featured nine contestants and aired in October 2008,[3] with the second season's winner being 27-year-old Simeon Moses.
| Season | Premiere Date | Finale Date | Winner | Runner-up | Location | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | August 6, 2007 | September 24, 2007 | Alvaro "Kosmo" Orlando | Brady Sprunger | Austin, Texas | |
| 2 | October 12, 2008 | November 30, 2008 | Simeon Moses | Matt Radmanovich | Phoenix, Arizona |
| Name | Age | Status/Reason on Show | Eliminated | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kosmo (Alvaro Orlando) | 23 | Freezes up around women | Winner | |
| Brady | 25 | Lacking in self-confidence | 7th | |
| Joe D. | 25 | The "friend" to girls | 6th | |
| Pradeep | 22 | Overanalyzes and talks too much | 5th | |
| Joe W. | 24 | Starts off strong but often fails fast | 4th | |
| Scott | 26 | Gets very nervous and stutters around women | 3rd | |
| Fred | 45 | 40-year-old virgin, plus 5 | 2nd | |
| Spoon (Steven Poon) | 27 | Does not know how to approach women | 1st |
| Episode | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | |
| 1 | Kosmo | Joe D. | Joe W. | Kosmo | Pradeep | Kosmo | Brady | Kosmo |
| 2 | Brady | Brady | Kosmo | Joe D. | Kosmo | Brady | Kosmo | Brady |
| 3 | Fred | Kosmo | Pradeep | Joe W. | Joe D. | Joe D. | Joe D. | |
| 4 | Joe D. | Joe W. | Joe D. | Brady | Brady | Pradeep | ||
| 5 | Joe W. | Scott | Scott | Pradeep | Joe W. | |||
| 6 | Pradeep | Pradeep | Brady | Scott | ||||
| 7 | Scott | Fred | Fred | |||||
| 8 | Spoon | Spoon | ||||||
The contestant won immunity.
The contestant was chosen as a wingman and had immunity.
The contestant was eliminated.
The contestant quit the competition.
The contestant won the title of the Pickup Artist.
| Name | Age | Also Known As | Status/Reason for coming on the show | Episode Eliminated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simeon Moses | 27 | The High-Pitched Hottie | Cried when his girlfriend dumped him | Winner |
| Matt Radmanovich | 26 | The guy with foot in his mouth | Flew across the country and his girlfriend dumped him upon arrival | Episode 8 |
| Greg Fellows | 26 | The Loner | Has not had a date in 5 years | Episode 7 |
| Rian Turner | 28 | Patron Saint of the Overlooked | A virgin who has not even had a girlfriend | Episode 6 |
| Brian Ly | 21 | The guy who kissed a girl | Kissed a girl | Episode 5 |
| Todd Pabst | 26 | The Girl's Best Friend | Has had sex | Episode 4 |
| Karl Meyer | 21 | The Brokenhearted Kid | His only girlfriend broke up with him and broke his heart | Episode 3 |
| Kevin Feng | 21 | Strike-out King | The only girlfriend he has ever had cheated on him | Episode 2 |
| Alex William Shelley | 22 | Women think he's gay | Virgin, lives with his parents | Episode 1 |
| Episode | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | |
| 1 | Brian | Brian | Greg | Rian | Simeon | Matt | Simeon | Simeon |
| 2 | Greg | Greg | Matt | Brian | Matt | Simeon | Matt | Matt |
| 3 | Karl | Todd | Brian | Matt | Greg | Greg | Greg | |
| 4 | Kevin | Rian | Todd | Simeon | Rian | Rian | ||
| 5 | Matt | Matt | Simeon | Greg | Brian | |||
| 6 | Rian | Simeon | Rian | Todd | ||||
| 7 | Simeon | Karl | Karl | |||||
| 8 | Todd | Kevin | ||||||
| 9 | Alex | |||||||
The contestant won immunity.
The contestant was chosen as a wingman and had immunity.
The contestant was eliminated.
The contestant won the title of the Pickup Artist.
The initial viewer ratings were disappointing, debuting with only 673,000 viewers.[4] [5] Viewer ratings picked up by the season's end, resulting in the series being picked up for a second season.
Critical reception for the series was mixed, with The A.V. Club panning the second season's opening episode.[6]
Controversy began to cloud The Pickup Artist after revelations that some of the contestants' livelihoods were not as they were listed on the VH1 show profiles.[7] Alvaro "Kosmo" Orlando had been referred to as a game programmer, but he actually had been an aspiring actor for the previous four years - working out of Miami, New York, and Los Angeles.[8] Runner-up contestant Brady Sprunger was characterized as a shy photographer, but he had been working for a modeling agency, the Los Angeles-based Action Agency, for five full years prior to the show's taping.
According to Psychology Today, the empirical feeling "that some teachings of pick-up artists are grounded in theory does not negate the callous and objectionable nature of the field.",[9] so that it belongs to pseudoscience[10] without empirical evidence of truth.[11]