Th-stopping explained

pronounced as /notice/Th-stopping is the realization of the dental fricatives pronounced as /[θ, ð]/ as stops - either dental or alveolar - which occurs in several dialects of English. In some accents, such as of Indian English and middle- or upper-class Irish English, they are realized as the dental stops pronounced as /[t̪, d̪]/ and as such do not merge with the alveolar stops pronounced as //t, d//; thus, for example, tin (pronounced as /[tʰɪn]/ in Ireland and pronounced as /[ʈɪn]/ in India) is not a homophone of thin pronounced as /[t̪ʰɪn]/.[1] In other accents, such as varieties of Caribbean English, Nigerian English, Liberian English, and older, rural, or working-class Irish English, such pairs are indeed merged.[1] Variation between both dental and alveolar forms exists in much of the working-class English speech of North America and sometimes southern England. It is also common for babies and toddlers, who are still learning to talk and/or haven't fully grown their front teeth capable of producing the Th sound. Th-stopping occurred in all continental Germanic languages, resulting in cognates such as German die for "the" and Bruder for "brother".

New York City English

For the working class of New York City and its surrounding region, the fricatives pronounced as //θ// and pronounced as //ð// are often pronounced as affricatives or stops, rather than as fricatives. Usually they remain dental, so that the oppositions pronounced as //t-θ// and pronounced as /[d-ð]/ are not lost. Thus thanks may be pronounced pronounced as /[θæŋks]/, pronounced as /[tθæŋks]/, or pronounced as /[t̪æŋks]/ in decreasing order of occurrence; all are distinct from tanks pronounced as /[tʰæŋks]/. The pronounced as /[t̪]/ variant has a weakish articulation. The pronounced as //t-θ// opposition may be lost, exceptionally in the environment of a following pronounced as //r// (making three homophonous with tree), and in the case of the word with, (so that with a may rhyme with the non-rhotic pronunciation of "bitter-bidder"; with you may be pronounced as /[wɪtʃu]/, following the same yod-coalescence rule as hit you. These pronunciations are all stigmatized.

The pronounced as /[d-ð]/ opposition seems to be lost more readily, though not as readily as the "Brooklynese" stereotype might lead one to believe. As in many other places, initial pronounced as /[ð]/ is subject to assimilation or deletion in a range of environments in relatively informal and/or popular speech, e.g. who's there pronounced as /[huz (z)ɛə]/; as in many other places, it is also subject to stopping there pronounced as //dɛə//. This option extends to one or two words in which the pronounced as //ð// is not initial, e.g. other, which can thus become a homonym of utter-udder. But it would not be usual for southern to be pronounced identically with sudden or breathe with breed.

African American Vernacular English

In African American Vernacular English, in the words with and nothing, pronounced as /[t]/ may occur corresponding to standard pronounced as /[θ]/, with the [t] itself being succeeded by the t-glottalization rule: thus pronounced as /[wɪʔ]/ for with and pronounced as /[ˈnʌʔɪn]/ for nothing.[2] Th-stopping is also reported for some other non-initial pronounced as /[θ]/s, apparently particularly when preceded by a nasal and followed by a plosive, as keep your mouth closed. In initial position, pronounced as /[θ]/ occurs in AAVE just as in standard accents: thin is pronounced as /[θɪn]/, without the stopping of West Indian accents.[3] Stopping of initial pronounced as /[ð]/, however, is frequent, making then pronounced as pronounced as /[d̪ɪ̃n]/ or sometimes homophonous with den.

Frequency in other accents

Th-stopping is also commonly heard, specifically from speakers of working-class origins, in the American English dialects of the Inland North (for example, in Milwaukee, Chicago, Cleveland, Buffalo, and Scranton), the Upper Midwest (for example in the especially Fennoscandian-descended locals of Minnesota's Iron Range and Michigan's Upper Peninsula), and the Mid-Atlantic region (for example, in Philadelphia and Baltimore),[4] It is also heard in a minority of speakers of England's Estuary dialect (for example, in London), but only in the case of word-initial pronounced as //ð//.[5] Many speakers of Philippine English and some speakers of other variants in Asia also have th-stopping.

The dialect of Sheffield in England is sometimes referred to as "dee-dar" because of the th-stopping to change initial pronounced as //ð// to pronounced as //d//. However, a 1997 study in Sheffield found this was then largely confined to older males.

Homophonous pairs

pronounced as //t, d//pronounced as //θ, ð//IPANotes
ate eighth pronounced as /ˈeɪt/ Some accents pronounce ate as pronounced as //ɛt//
Bart bath pronounced as /ˈbɑːt/ Non-rhotic accents with trapbath split.
bat bath pronounced as /ˈbæt/ Without trapbath split.
bayed bathe pronounced as /ˈbeɪd/
bet Beth pronounced as /ˈbɛt/
bladder blather pronounced as /ˈblædə(ɹ)/
blight Blythe pronounced as /ˈblaɪt/
blitter blither pronounced as /ˈblɪɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
boat both pronounced as /ˈboʊt/
body bothy pronounced as /ˈbɒɾi/ Without lotcloth split and with intervocalic alveolar flapping.
boot booth pronounced as /ˈbuːt/
breed breathe pronounced as /ˈbɹiːd/
breath pronounced as /ˈbɹɛt/
brought broth pronounced as /ˈbrɔːt/ With lotcloth split. Also pronounced as //ˈbrɒt// in some accents.
cedar seether pronounced as /ˈsiːdə(ɹ)/
cent synth pronounced as /ˈsɪnt/ With pinpen merger.
cite scythe pronounced as /ˈsaɪt/
clot cloth pronounced as /ˈklɒt/ Without cotcaught merger.
coot couth pronounced as /ˈkuːt/
D; dee the pronounced as /ˈdiː/ The before vowels and silent H.
D; dee thee pronounced as /ˈdiː/
Dan than pronounced as /ˈdæn/
dare their pronounced as /ˈdeə(ɹ)/
dare there pronounced as /ˈdeə(ɹ)/
dare they're pronounced as /ˈdeə(ɹ)/
the rude pronounced as /dəˈruːd/
day they pronounced as /ˈdeɪ/
debt death pronounced as /ˈdɛt/
Dee the pronounced as /ˈdiː/ The before vowels and silent H.
Dee thee pronounced as /ˈdiː/
den then pronounced as /ˈdɛn/
dense thence pronounced as /ˈdɛns/
dents thence pronounced as /ˈdɛn(t)s/
dhow thou pronounced as /ˈdaʊ/
die thy pronounced as /ˈdaɪ/
dine thine pronounced as /ˈdaɪn/
dirt dearth pronounced as /ˈdɜː(ɹ)t/ with fernfirfur merger.
dis this pronounced as /ˈdɪs/
doe though pronounced as /ˈdoʊ/
does those pronounced as /ˈdoʊz/
dough though pronounced as /ˈdoʊ/
dow thou pronounced as /ˈdaʊ/
dow though pronounced as /ˈdoʊ/
drought drouth pronounced as /ˈdɹaʊt/
dye thy pronounced as /ˈdaɪ/
eater either pronounced as /ˈiːɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
eater ether pronounced as /ˈiːtə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
eight eighth pronounced as /ˈeɪt/
nth pronounced as /ˈɛnt/
fate faith pronounced as /ˈfeɪt/
fetter feather pronounced as /ˈfɛɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
fit fifth pronounced as /ˈfɪt/ Some accents pronounce fifth as pronounced as //ˈfɪft//.
fodder father pronounced as /ˈfɑːdə(ɹ)/ With fatherbother merger.
fort forth pronounced as /ˈfɔː(ɹ)t/
fort fourth pronounced as /ˈfɔː(ɹ)t/
fraught froth pronounced as /ˈfɹɔːt/ With lotcloth split.
frot froth pronounced as /ˈfɹɒt/ Without lotcloth split.
got pronounced as /ˈɡɒt/
groat growth pronounced as /ˈɡɹoʊt/
hart hearth pronounced as /ˈhɑː(ɹ)t/
hat hath pronounced as /ˈhæt/
header heather pronounced as /ˈhɛdə(ɹ)/
heart hearth pronounced as /ˈhɑː(ɹ)t/
heat heath pronounced as /ˈhiːt/
hitter hither pronounced as /ˈhɪɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
hurt earth pronounced as /ˈɜː(ɹ)t/ With H-dropping and fernfirfur merger.
Ida either pronounced as /ˈaɪdə/ Non-rhotic accents.
knead neath pronounced as /ˈniːd/
kneader neither pronounced as /ˈniːdə(ɹ)/
kneed neath pronounced as /ˈniːd/
ladder lather pronounced as /ˈlædə(ɹ)/
lade lathe pronounced as /ˈleɪd/
laid lathe pronounced as /ˈleɪd/
latter lather pronounced as /ˈlæɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
letter leather pronounced as /ˈlɛɾə(ɹ)/
lied lithe pronounced as /ˈlaɪd/
load loathe pronounced as /ˈloʊd/
lode loathe pronounced as /ˈloʊd/
loud Louth pronounced as /ˈlaʊd/
martyr Martha pronounced as /ˈmɑːtə/ Non-rhotic accents.
mat math pronounced as /ˈmæt/
matte math pronounced as /ˈmæt/
mead Meath pronounced as /ˈmiːd/
meat Meath pronounced as /ˈmiːt/
meet Meath pronounced as /ˈmiːt/
met meth pronounced as /ˈmɛt/
mete Meath pronounced as /ˈmiːt/
mitt myth pronounced as /ˈmɪt/
motte moth pronounced as /ˈmɑt/
mutter mother pronounced as /ˈmʌɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
naught north pronounced as /ˈnɔːt/ Non-rhotic accents.
neater neither pronounced as /ˈniːɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
Some accents pronounce neither as pronounced as //ˈnaɪtə(ɹ)//.
neat neath pronounced as /ˈniːt/
need neath pronounced as /ˈniːd/
oat oath pronounced as /ˈoʊt/
oats oaths pronounced as /ˈoʊts/
odes oaths pronounced as /ˈoʊdz/
pads paths pronounced as /ˈpædz/ Without trapbath split.
paid pathe pronounced as /ˈpeɪd/
part path pronounced as /ˈpɑːt/ Non-rhotic accents with trapbath split.
parts paths pronounced as /ˈpɑːts/
pat path pronounced as /ˈpæt/ Without trapbath split.
pats paths pronounced as /ˈpæts/
pit pith pronounced as /ˈpɪt/
pity pithy pronounced as /ˈpɪti/
rat wrath pronounced as /ˈɹæt/ Without trapbath split.
rate wraith pronounced as /ˈɹeɪt/
read wreathe pronounced as /ˈɹiːd/
reads wreathes pronounced as /ˈɹiːdz/
reads wreaths pronounced as /ˈɹiːdz/
reed wreathe pronounced as /ˈɹiːd/
reeds wreathes pronounced as /ˈɹiːdz/
reeds wreaths pronounced as /ˈɹiːdz/
ride writhe pronounced as /ˈɹaɪd/
rot Roth pronounced as /ˈɹɒt/ Without lotcloth split.
root ruth, Ruth pronounced as /ˈɹuːt/ With yod-dropping.
Some accents pronounce root as pronounced as //ˈɹʊt//.
route ruth, Ruth pronounced as /ˈɹuːt/ With yod-dropping.
Some accents pronounce route as pronounced as //ˈɹaʊt//.
scent synth pronounced as /ˈsɪnt/ With penpin merger.
seed seethe pronounced as /ˈsiːd/
seeder seether pronounced as /ˈsiːdə(ɹ)/
sent synth pronounced as /ˈsɪnt/ With penpin merger.
set saith pronounced as /ˈsɛt/
set pronounced as /ˈsɛt/
she'd sheathe pronounced as /ˈʃiːd/
sheet sheath pronounced as /ˈʃiːt/
side scythe pronounced as /ˈsaɪd/
sight scythe pronounced as /ˈsaɪt/
sit pronounced as /ˈsɪt/
site scythe pronounced as /ˈsaɪt/
smit smith pronounced as /ˈsmɪt/
smite pronounced as /ˈsmaɪt/
spilt spilth pronounced as /ˈspɪlt/
soot sooth pronounced as /ˈsuːt/ Some accents pronounce soot as pronounced as //ˈsʊt//.
sudden southern pronounced as /ˈsʌdən/ Non-rhotic accents.
sued soothe pronounced as /ˈsuːd/ With yod-dropping.
suede swathe pronounced as /ˈsweɪd/ Some accents pronounce swathe as pronounced as //ˈswɒd//.
suit sooth pronounced as /ˈsuːt/ With yod-dropping.
swat swath pronounced as /ˈswɒt/ Without lotcloth split.
swayed swathe pronounced as /ˈsweɪd/ Some accents pronounce swathe as pronounced as //ˈswɒd//.
tank thank pronounced as /ˈtæŋk/
tater theta pronounced as /ˈteɪtə/ Non-rhotic accents.
Some accents pronounce theta as pronounced as //ˈtiːtə//.
taught thought pronounced as /ˈtɔːt/
team theme pronounced as /ˈtiːm/
teary theory pronounced as /ˈtɪəɹi/
teat teeth pronounced as /ˈtiːt/
teed teethe pronounced as /ˈtiːd/
teeter theta pronounced as /ˈtiːtə/ Non-rhotic accents.
Some accents pronounce theta as pronounced as //ˈteɪtə//.
tent tenth pronounced as /ˈtɛnt/
Thai thigh pronounced as /ˈtaɪ/
tic thick pronounced as /ˈtɪk/
tick thick pronounced as /ˈtɪk/
ticket thicket pronounced as /ˈtɪkət/
tide tithe pronounced as /ˈtaɪd/
tie thigh pronounced as /ˈtaɪ/
tied tithe pronounced as /ˈtaɪd/
tin thin pronounced as /ˈtɪn/
tinker thinker pronounced as /ˈtɪnkə(ɹ)/
toot tooth pronounced as /ˈtuːt/
tor thaw pronounced as /ˈtɔː/ Non-rhotic accents.
tor pronounced as /ˈtɔː(ɹ)/
tore thaw pronounced as /ˈtɔː/ Non-rhotic accents with horsehoarse merger.
tore pronounced as /ˈtɔː(ɹ)/ With horsehoarse merger.
torn thorn pronounced as /ˈtɔː(ɹ)n/ With horsehoarse merger.
tort thought pronounced as /ˈtɔː(ɹ)t/ Non-rhotic accents.
tote pronounced as /ˈtoʊt/
trash thrash pronounced as /ˈtɹæʃ/
trawl thrall pronounced as /ˈtɹɔːl/
tread thread pronounced as /ˈtɹɛd/
tree three pronounced as /ˈtɹiː/
trill thrill pronounced as /ˈtɹɪl/
true threw pronounced as /ˈtɹuː, ˈtɹɪu/
true through pronounced as /ˈtɹuː/ With yod-dropping.
trust thrust pronounced as /ˈtɹʌst/
tum thumb pronounced as /ˈtʌm/
tump thump pronounced as /ˈtʌmp/
turd third pronounced as /ˈtɜː(ɹ)d/ With fernfirfur merger.
udder other pronounced as /ˈʌdə(ɹ)/
utter other pronounced as /ˈʌɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
Utes youths pronounced as /ˈjuːts/
welt wealth pronounced as /ˈwɛlt/
wetter weather pronounced as /ˈwɛɾə(ɹ)/ With intervocalic alveolar flapping.
wit width pronounced as /ˈwɪt/
wit with pronounced as /ˈwɪt/
wordy worthy pronounced as /ˈwɜː(ɹ)di, ˈwʌɹdi/
wort worth pronounced as /ˈwɜː(ɹ)t, ˈwʌɹt/ Some accents pronounce wort as pronounced as //ˈwɔː(ɹ)t//.
wrought Roth pronounced as /ˈɹɔːt/ With lotcloth split.
wrought wroth pronounced as /ˈɹɔːt/ With lotcloth split.

See also

References

pronounced as /navigation/

Notes and References

  1. Book: Wells, J.C.. The British Isles. Accents of English. 1989. University Press. Cambridge. 9780521285407. 2. 565–66, 635.
  2. 10.2307/412325 . 0097-8507 . 46 . 3 . 764 . Wolfram, Walter A. . A Sociolinguistic Description of Detroit Negro Speech . Language . September 1970 . 412325.
  3. Wolfram 1969, p. 130, does however mention the use of 'a lenis pronounced as /[t]/' as a rare variant.
  4. Book: van den Doel, Rias. How Friendly Are the Natives? An Evaluation of Native-Speaker Judgements of Foreign-Accented British and American English. 2006. Landelijke onderzoekschool taalwetenschap (Netherlands Graduate School of Linguistics). 268.
  5. Book: van den Doel, Rias. How Friendly Are the Natives? An Evaluation of Native-Speaker Judgements of Foreign-Accented British and American English. 2006. Landelijke onderzoekschool taalwetenschap (Netherlands Graduate School of Linguistics). 251.