Taylor v Beere explained

Taylor v Beere
Court:Court of Appeal of New Zealand
Date Decided:19 March 1982
Full Name:Alister Taylor v Margaret Lorraine Beere
Citations:[1982] 1 NZLR 81
Judges:Cooke P, Richardson J, Somers J
Transcripts:High Court judgment
Keywords:negligence, defamation, exemplary damages

Taylor v Beere [1982] 1 NZLR 81 is a cited case in New Zealand regarding exemplary damages in tort [1]

Background

Mrs Beere had one of her friends who was an amateur photographer take a photograph of her and her granddaughter in their home.

In 1972, Beere discovered that another friend, controversial publisher Alister Taylor, had obtained the negative, and was planning to print a guidebook for teenagers called "Down under the Plum Trees" about sex, alcohol and drug use featuring this photo.

Beere wrote to Taylor, demanding that her photo not be used in his book, but Taylor included this photo in the first 10,000 books.

Her photo featuring in such a book caused Beere embarrassment, as people thought she had agreed to be in the book.

As a result, Beere sued for defamation.

Held

Beere was awarded $12,500 in damages, which included an award for exemplary damages.

Notes and References

  1. Book: Butterworths Student Companion Torts . 4th . McLay . Geoff . LexisNexis . 0-408-71686-X. 2003 .