The TV Guide Award was an annual award created by the editors of TV Guide magazine, as a readers poll to honor outstanding programs and performers in the American television industry. The awards were presented until 1964. The TV Guide Award was revived 1999–2001.
Ellery Queen won a TV Guide Award in 1950 for Best Mystery Show on Television.[1] The Lucky Strike ads of the early 1950s won the first TV Guide award as commercial of the year.The trophy was a bronze statuette of a heroic figure holding a filigree globe.[2] The 1952 TV Guide Magazine award was given to Zoo Parade, which also won the 1950 George Foster Peabody Award and the 1951 Look TV Award.[3] American Bandstand was featured on its second anniversary in the Philadelphia issue of TV Guide, which said it was "the people's choice" for a 1954 TV Guide award. The magazine had been founded the year before by Walter Annenberg, owner of American Bandstand.[4]
In 1961 the TV Guide Award was cited by the Associated Press as one of the three important entertainment awards, together with the Academy Awards and the Emmy Awards.[5] Ballots were printed in a single issue of the magazine. Completed ballots were submitted by U.S. Mail and tabulated by direct-mail specialists Cassidy-Richlar, Inc.[5]
The TV Guide Award Show was broadcast in color on March 25, 1960, on NBC. Robert Young hosted a series of skits featuring Fred MacMurray and Nanette Fabray. Seven awards were presented in the final ten minutes of the show.[6] Recipients were chosen based on 289,000 ballots submitted by readers of TV Guide.[7]
| Category | Recipient | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favorite Series of One Hour or Longer | Perry Mason | ||
| Favorite Half-Hour Series | Father Knows Best | ||
| Best Single Musical or Variety Program | Another Evening with Fred Astaire | [8] | |
| Most Popular Male Personality | Raymond Burr | Perry Mason | |
| Most Popular Female Personality | Loretta Young | The Loretta Young Show | |
| Best News or Information Program | The Huntley-Brinkley Report | ||
| Best Single Dramatic Program | "The Turn of the Screw" | Startime[9] |
Broadcast on NBC, the second annual TV Guide Award Show was presented June 13, 1961. The hour-long program was hosted by Efrem Zimbalist, Jr., with comedy sketches featuring Jackie Cooper and Nanette Fabray. NBC-TV was recognized for its 1960 election night coverage, and the following awards were presented.[10]
| Category | Recipient | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favorite Series | Perry Mason | [11] | |
| Favorite New Series | The Andy Griffith Show | ||
| Best Single Musical or Variety Program | Sing Along with Mitch | ||
| Favorite Male Performer | Raymond Burr | Perry Mason | |
| Favorite Female Performer | Carol Burnett | The Garry Moore Show | |
| Best News or Information Program | The Huntley-Brinkley Report | ||
| Best Single Dramatic Program | "Macbeth" | Hallmark Hall of Fame |
The third annual TV Guide Award Show was broadcast June 24, 1962, on NBC. Hosted by Dave Garroway,[12] the program included sketches featuring Art Carney and special guest Judy Holliday.[13] In a brief concluding segment, awards in eight categories were presented.[12]
| Category | Recipient | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favorite Series | Bonanza | ||
| Favorite New Series | Ben Casey | ||
| Best Single Musical or Variety Program | The Bob Hope Christmas Show | ||
| Favorite Male Performer | Vince Edwards | Ben Casey | |
| Favorite Female Performer | Carol Burnett | The Garry Moore Show | |
| Best News or Information Program | The Huntley-Brinkley Report | [14] | |
| Best Single News or Information Program | NBC-TV coverage of John Glenn's orbital space flight | ||
| Best Single Dramatic Program | "The Prince and the Pauper" | Walt Disney's Wonderful World of Color |
The fourth TV Guide Award presentation was made during the NBC special, The Bob Hope Show Presenting the TV Guide Awards, broadcast April 14, 1963. The 45-minute comedy and variety portion of the show featured Dean Martin and Martha Raye. Eight awards were presented in the concluding segment of the show, with live pickups in New York and Hollywood.[15]
| Category | Recipient | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favorite Series | Bonanza | ||
| Favorite New Series | The Beverly Hillbillies | ||
| Best Single Musical or Variety Program | The Bob Hope Christmas Show | ||
| Favorite Male Performer | Richard Chamberlain | Dr. Kildare | |
| Favorite Female Performer | Carol Burnett | ||
| Best News or Information Program | The Huntley-Brinkley Report | ||
| Best Single News or Information Program | "The Tunnel" | ||
| Best Children's Series | Walt Disney's Wonderful World of Color |
The fifth TV Guide Award presentation was made on a special presentation of Bob Hope's NBC-TV show on April 17, 1964.[16] [17]
| Category | Recipient | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favorite Series | Dr. Kildare | ||
| Favorite New Series | The Fugitive | [18] | |
| Best Single Dramatic, Musical or Variety Program | "Tyger, Tyger" (two-part episode) | Dr. Kildare | |
| Favorite Male Performer | David Janssen | The Fugitive | |
| Favorite Female Performer | Inger Stevens | The Farmer's Daughter | |
| Best News or Information Program | The Huntley-Brinkley Report | ||
| Best Single News or Information Program | ABC 1964 Winter Olympics coverage |
The TV Guide Award was revived in 1999. Categories included traditional awards like Favorite Actor in a Comedy, Favorite Actor in a Drama Series, Favorite Star in a New Series, Favorite Drama Series, and Favorite Comedy Series, to more off-beat categories which differed by year and are listed below. The winners were voted on by readers via magazine ballots and on-line voting. Each of these three award ceremonies were broadcast on Fox. The first award ceremony was televised on February 24, 1999 with 1.2 million fans voting. The second ceremony was aired on March 6, 2000, with 1.6 million fans voting. The third and final ceremony was aired on February 24, 2001, with 1.5 million fans voting, at which point the award was discontinued.[19]
Among the winners were David Duchovny, Tim Allen, Roma Downey, Jenna Elfman, David James Elliott, Martin Sheen, Bette Midler, Regis Philbin, Sean Hayes, and Noah Wyle.