TUI Group explained

TUI AG
Type:Public (Aktiengesellschaft)
Traded As:
Trade Name:TUI Group
Former Name:Preussag AG (1923–2002)
Location:Hanover and Berlin, Germany
Industry:Hospitality, tourism
Products:Charter and scheduled passenger airlines, package holidays, cruise lines, hotels and resorts
Services:Travel agencies
Revenue: €20,665.9 million (2023)[1]
Operating Income: €997.2 million (2023)
Net Income: €455.7 million (2023)
Num Employees:58,342 (2023)

TUI AG (trading as TUI Group) is a German leisure, travel and tourism company; it is the largest such company in the world.[2] [3] TUI is an acronym for Touristik Union International ("Tourism Union International"). TUI AG was known as Preussag AG until 1997 when the company changed its activities from mining to tourism. It is headquartered in Hanover, Germany.[4]

It fully or partially owns several travel agencies, hotel chains, cruise lines and retail shops as well as five European airlines. These activities involve the operation of 353 hotels with 275,144 beds and it allows its brand to be used for another 65 hotels operated by third parties. These hotels accommodate 21 million guests a year.[5] It also operates 16 cruise ships under the TUI Cruises, Hapag-Lloyd Cruises and Marella Cruises brands, as well as a fleet of 134 aircraft.

It is trading as TUI AG on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange and Hanover Stock Exchange.

History

The origins of the company lie in the industrial and transportation company Preussag AG, which was originally formed as a German mining company. It was incorporated on 9 October 1923, as Preußische Bergwerks- und Hütten-Aktiengesellschaft (Prussian Mine and Foundry Company). In 1927 it was merged with the Ruhr coal company, Hibernia AG, and electricity utility to become the Vereinigte Elektrizitäts und Bergwerks AG (VEBA AG) (United Electrical and Mining Company).[6]

After the sale of Salzgitter AG and purchase of Hapag-Lloyd AG (the navigation and logistics company) in 1997, Preussag AG became a global enterprise in the service and leisure industry. At that time, Hapag-Lloyd held a 30% interest in the tourism conglomerate TUI (founded 1968), increased to 100% by 1999. In addition the company acquired 25% of Thomas Cook shares in 1997, which it doubled the following year. On 2 February 1999, the Carlson Leisure Group merged with Thomas Cook into a holding company owned by the German bank Westdeutsche Landesbank, Carlson Inc and Preussag.[7] However, in mid-2000 Preussag acquired Thomas Cook's rival Thomson Travel and was forced to sell its majority 50.1% stake in Thomas Cook by regulatory authorities.[8] In 2002, Preussag renamed itself TUI AG.[9]

TUI announced a merger of its travel division with the British tour operator First Choice in March 2007,[10] which was approved by the European Commission on 4 June 2007, on the condition that the merged company sell Budget Travel in Ireland.[11] TUI held a 55% stake in the new company, TUI Travel PLC, which began operations in September 2007.[12]

In April 2008, Alexey Mordashov, who purchased his first shares in TUI Travel in autumn 2007, purchased additional TUI Travel shares under S-Group in order to expand TUI Travel into Eastern Europe and Russia.[13] [14] [15]

Its logistics activities, concentrated in the shipping sector, were kept separate and bundled within Hapag-Lloyd AG. A majority stake in Hapag-Lloyd was sold to the Albert Ballin consortium of investors in March 2009[16] and a further stake was sold to Ballin in February 2012, as TUI worked to exit from the shipping business and to optimize its tourism business with expansion in Russia, China and India under Michael Frenzel.[15] [17] Prior to August 2010, John Fredriksen held the largest Norwegian privately held stake in TUI Travel and had a significant influence upon TUI Travel's direction and strategy.[18] As Alexey Mordashov through his S-Group Travel Holding increased his stake in TUI Travel to a stake larger than Fredriksen's stake, the shipping business had to be sold.[18]

In June 2014 the company announced it would fully merge with TUI Travel to create a united group with a value of $US9.7 billion.[19] The merger was completed on 17 December 2014 and the combined business began trading on the Frankfurt and London stock exchanges.[20] Prior to this merger, Alexey Mordashov, the largest private shareholder in TUI Travel, held a blocking stake in TUI Travel through his S-Group.[21] After the merger, Alexey Mordashov's stake was reduced to less than a blocking stake of 25%.[21]

On 12 December 2016, Alexey Mordashov increased his stake in TUI Group from 18% to more than 20%.[21] [22] In October 2018, his 24.9% stake was the largest privately held stake in TUI Group.[23] In June 2019 Mordashov transferred 65% of his stake to the KN-Holding, owned by his sons Kirill Mordashov and Nikita Mordashov. TUI says in a statement that they ”welcome the second generation of the family amongst its shareholders”.[24]

Berge & Meer and Boomerang Reisen as well as Atraveo were sold to the holding company GENUI in 2019.[25]

At the end of 2019, the holiday home provider Wolters Reisen GmbH and the round trip specialist Wolters Rundreisen GmbH, of which TUI Group owned 100% of the shares via an investment company, were sold to the Frankfurt-based company e-domizil.[26]

In August 2020, the company reported a net loss of €2.3 billion (from October 2019 to June 2020) as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Out of the sum, €1.5 billion loss related to the period from April to June 2020, while the revenue for the same period was €75 million, 98% less than the same period in 2019. TUI's chief executive officer, Fritz Joussen announced that the firm was considering selling the Marella cruise line.[27]

In March 2022, the company's largest single shareholder, Alexey Mordashov, a Russian oligarch and confidante of Vladimir Putin, was placed under sanctions due to the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine.[28] [29] [30] [31]

In March 2023 it was announced that TUI would seek to raise $1.8 billion by selling shares at a discount to existing investors, excluding Mordashov as a result of sanctions under German securities law.[32] [33]

Governance

The following people have served in key roles:

!Time period!Chief Executive Officer (CEO)!Time period!Chairman of the Supervisory Board
2022-Sebastian Ebel2019-Dieter Zetsche[34]
2013-2022Friedrich Joussen2011-2019Klaus Mangold
2014-2016Peter Long (Co-CEO)[35] 2010-2011Dietmar Kuhnt[36]
2004-2010Jürgen Krumnow

Stock exchange and shareholders

The company's shares are listed on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange, the London Stock Exchange, as well as the Hanover Stock Exchange.[37]

In spring 2007, the Norwegian shipowner and financial investor John Fredriksen acquired a 15.01% stake in TUI. At TUI's AGM in May 2008, Fredriksen demanded a split-up of the group and the dismissal of TUI CEO Michael Frenzel.[38] At the AGM on 13 May 2009, Fredriksen demanded that Supervisory Board Chairman Jürgen Krumnow be voted out of office so that he could then join the Supervisory Board himself. However, these attempts were unsuccessful.[39] On 28 February 2014, Monteray Enterprises Ltd (John Fredriksen) notified TUI that its share of voting rights in TUI had fallen below the 3% thresholds on 24 February 2014.[40]

Russian oligarch Alexey Mordashov joined TUI at the beginning of 2008. By July 2008, he had increased his stake to 15.03% and in March 2012 to 25.29%, and later to 34%.[41] He was thus the largest single shareholder.[42] Alexey Mordashov has been on the EU sanctions list since 28 February 2022 and, according to a corresponding voting rights notification, transferred control of most of his indirectly held shares to the Virgin Islands-based company Ondero Limited, controlled by Marina Mordashova, on that date. Due to an investigation by the Federal Ministry of Economics and Climate Protection regarding the transfer of the shares to Ondero Limited, the transfer is suspended.[43] The shareholding in TUI AG therefore continues to be held (indirectly) by Alexey Mordashov. Due to the capital increase in spring 2023, in which Alexey Mordashov was not allowed to participate due to his sanction,[44] his shareholding has meanwhile decreased significantly. According to the voting rights notifications of the German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority of 16 May 2023, 10.87% shares in TUI AG have been indirectly attributable to Alexey Mordashov since 19 April 2023, while Marina Mordashowa holds 0% in TUI AG.[45]

Shareholder structure (July 2023)!Shareholder!Share
Institutional investors57.8 %
Alexei Mordaschow10.9 %
Private investors30.2 %
RIU S.A. (Familie Riu Güell)1.1 %

In February 2024, the company decided to leave the London Stock Exchange retaining its listings on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange and the Hanover Stock Exchange.[46]

Group structure

TUI Hotels & Resorts

In the 2022 financial year, the Hotels & Resorts segment comprised a total of 353 hotels with 275,144 beds. With 322 properties, the majority are four- or five-star hotels. 53% were operated under management contracts, 38% were owned by the respective hotel company, 8% were leased and 1% of the facilities were operated under franchise agreements. In addition, 65 hotels were operated by third-party hoteliers under TUI's international concept brands as at 30 September 2022, bringing the total number including third-party hotels to 418.

Cruises

TUI's cruise segment operates a total of 16 cruise ships under three brands:

TUI Multinational Airlines

TUI owns several airlines operating under the brands TUI fly and TUI Airlines. They are managed by TUI Airline Management.

AirlineCountryDescription
TUI AirwaysTUI Airways is the largest of the TUI airlines. It has 70 aircraft and flies from 26 British airports to 109 destinations worldwide. It was formed by the merger of Thomsonfly (formerly Britannia Airways) and First Choice Airways (formerly Air 2000). The airline was the last TUI airline to be rebranded.
TUI fly Belgium BelgiumTUI fly Belgium has operated since March 2004 to more than 105 destinations around Europe, the Red Sea, Caribbean, Canary Islands, US and Africa. Since 2012 it has operated scheduled flights as well as charter services. It was formerly known as Jetairfly, rebranded to TUI fly Belgium in late 2016.
GermanyTUI fly Deutschland has operated since 1972, under the name Hapag-Lloyd Flug, and rebranded to TUIfly in 2007. It has yet again rebranded as TUI fly Deutschland. It has 40 aircraft, flying to 39 destinations.
TUI fly Netherlands NetherlandsSince 2005, TUI fly Netherlands has operated charter flights from Amsterdam Schiphol Airport to destinations in Southern Europe, North Africa, the Caribbean, and Latin America. It was formerly known as Arkefly, rebranded to Arke in 2013, and rebranded again to its current name in 2015.
TUI fly Nordic Ireland
Denmark
Finland
Norway
Sweden
TUI fly Nordic flies from Ireland, Sweden, Denmark, Finland, and Norway. They fly holidaymakers travelling with the following tour operators; TUI Sverige (Sweden), TUI Finland (Finland), TUI Norge (Norway), and TUI Danmark (Denmark). There was a slight name change, from TUIfly Nordic to TUI fly Nordic.

, TUI Group operates the following aircraft:[51]

TUI Group fleet
AircraftIn ServiceOrders PassengersNotes
PETotal
Boeing 737-7004 - - 148148To be phased out by 2027.[52]
Boeing 737-800551 - 189189
Boeing 737 MAX 83917[53]  - 189189
- 18[54] TBA
Boeing 767-300ER1 - - 328328Set to be phased out by 2025.[55]
Boeing 787-813 - 25280305
47253300
- 325325
Boeing 787-9663282345
Embraer E195-E23 - 136136
Total12136

Corporate affairs

The key indicators of the TUI Group are (as at the financial year ending 30 September):[56] [57]

TUI Group Financial Information!Year!Revenue (€bn)!Net Profit (€m)!Number of employees
201617.191066,779
201718.564566,577
201819.573369,546
201918.941671,473
20207.9–3,14848,330
20214.7–2,46750,584
202216.5–27761,091
202320.630665,413

Controversies

On 16 April 2009, TUI Travel and S-Group Travel Holding of the Russian shareholder Mordashov declared the formation of a joint venture in Russia with investments of 30 million euros to develop tourism activities in Russia and Ukraine. The intention was to take over the tour operators VKO Group and Mostravel in Russia and Voyage Kiev in Ukraine, which had over 160 travel agencies and over half a million customers.[58] In March 2022, TUI AG terminated the brand use agreement with TUI Russia; TUI Russia is no longer a TUI Group company. The last shares in TUI Russia were sold in 2021.[59]

A 2018 study in the UK found that Tui had the largest gender pay gap reported to date by a major UK company, with its male employees paid more than twice what female employees are paid.[60]

In August 2018, some air passengers questioned the distribution of gendered stickers to children on a flight: "future pilot" for boys, "future cabin crew" for girls.[61]

TUI has become the main airline carrying out charter deportation flights for the UK Home Office.[62] It is estimated that in November and December 2020 TUI carried out the deportation of more than 150 people in 13 flights to 23 destinations for the Home Office.[63]

On 20 May 2022, the German TV Programme ZDF-Magazin Royale dedicated an episode to the history of TUI. It reported that Preussag was active in World War II producing bombs for the Nazi Party. Later Preussag also provided chemicals to Saddam Hussein's in Iraq, so facilitating the development of chemical weapons.[64] [65] The company were also supportive of the regime of Muammar Gaddafi in Libya and helped to build a factory for the production of chemical bombs.[64] The management responded to a request for information, by saying that they were not aware of the company's history.[66]

In May 2022, it was reported that the Russian oligarch Alexei Mordashov had made a transfer of a holding of 29.9% of the company: TUI failed to follow the rules and verify the new owner of the shares. In addition, the transfer was a violation of the sanctions against Russia by the European Union, which sanctioned Mordashov personally.[67]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Annual Report 2023. TUI . 13 February 2024.
  2. http://www.dw.de/tui-forges-worlds-biggest-tourism-operator/a-17921804 TUI forges World's biggest tourism operator
  3. News: Die 10 Grossten Reiseveranstalter der welt. Ten of the Day. 15 December 2023.
  4. "Contact TUI Group." TUI AG. Retrieved on 29 May 2009.
  5. Web site: About TUI Group . 2023-10-10 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  6. Web site: History . Preussen Elektra . 14 April 2017.
  7. Web site: WESTDEUTSCHE LANDESBANK / CARLSON / THOMAS COOK (Merger) [1999] ECComm 26 (8 March 1999) ]. www.worldlii.org . 2015-12-02.
  8. Web site: German firm buys Thomas Cook . 7 December 2000 . BBC . 14 April 2017.
  9. News: Goodbye Thomson, hello TUI – how Germany beat Britain in the battle of the sunlounge . https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20220112/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/comment/farewell-thomson-hello-tui/ . 2022-01-12 . subscription . live . The Telegraph . 18 October 2017 . 11 March 2019. Leadbeater . Chris .
  10. News: First Choice to tie up with TUI . BBC News . 19 March 2007 . 24 June 2013.
  11. News: First Choice-TUI merger cleared . BBC News . 4 June 2007 . 24 June 2013.
  12. Web site: Thomson and First Choice to merge. 19 March 2007. The Guardian.
  13. News: TUI gründet mit Mordaschow Reisetochter in Russland Touristikkonzern und Oligarch vertiefen Partnerschaft . de. TUI establishes a subsidiary in Russia with Mordashov. Touristkonzern and Oligarch deepen partnership. . 11 April 2008 . Financial Times Deutschland. 22 October 2018.
  14. News: Alexej Mordaschow baut Einfluss bei TUI aus . de. Alexei Mordashov is extending his influence at TUI . 30 August 2010 . . Heitmann . Jens. 22 October 2018.
  15. News: Russischer Investor baut Einfluss bei TUI aus . de. Russian investor is extending his influence at TUI . 31 January 2011 . . 22 October 2018.
  16. News: Kuehnen . Eva . TUI AG completes sale of Hapag-Lloyd unit . 8 August 2010 . 23 March 2009 . Reuters.
  17. Web site: TUI AG set to agree Hapag-Lloyd deal this week . . 12 February 2012.
  18. News: Tui-Großaktionär stockt Anteil auf . de. Tui major shareholder increases stake . 30 August 2010 . . Wnuck . Corinna. 22 October 2018.
  19. Web site: Tui Travel agrees to merger with German majority stakeholder . International Travel News . 17 December 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20141006110023/http://www.internationaltravelnews.com/index.php/sid/223325423/scat/26e7946dced8f2bc/ht/Tui-Travel-agrees-to-merger-with-German-majority-stakeholder . 2014-10-06 . dead .
  20. News: Young . Sarah . TUI Travel, TUI AG merger completes . 17 December 2014 . Reuters . 17 December 2014.
  21. News: Roundup: Tui-Großaktionär Mordaschow nähert sich der Sperrminorität . de. Roundup: Tui major shareholder Mordashov approaches the blocking minority . 1 September 2017 . Bild. 22 October 2018.
  22. News: Алексей Мордашов приблизил свою долю в TUI к блокирующему пакету . ru. Alexey Mordashov brought his stake in TUI closer to the blocking stake . 10 January 2017 . RBC. 22 October 2018.
  23. Web site: Shareholder structure . TUI Group. 22 October 2018.
  24. Web site: Change in the shareholder structure of TUI AG. www.tuigroup.com. en. 2019-12-05.
  25. Web site: TUI Group to sell German specialist tour operators "Berge & Meer" and "Boomerang Reisen" / Group sharpens its profile . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  26. Web site: TUI Group sells German holiday home provider Wolters Reisen . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  27. News: Tour operator Tui considers disposals after racking up €2.3bn loss. Financial Times. Hancock. Alice. 13 August 2020. 13 August 2020.
  28. Web site: 2022-03-02 . Alexei Mordashov: Russia's richest man is now an EU sanctions target . 2022-03-05 . The Guardian . en.
  29. Web site: Welle . Deutsche . The Russian oligarchs of the FinCEN Files DW 26.09.2020 . 2022-03-05 . DW.COM . en-GB.
  30. News: Джонс . Пит (Jones, Pete) . Стэк . Грэм (Stack, Graham) . Кипрский филиал аудиторского гиганта PwC, вероятно, нарушил санкции при работе на российского олигарха: Утечка документов показала, что PwC Cyprus поспешила реструктурировать компании российских олигархов, когда возникла угроза санкций. Власти Кипра заверяют, что расследуют эпизод, когда PwC предположительно завершила сделку по продаже акций россиянина через несколько дней после того, как он попал в санкционный список ЕС. . Cyprus Wing of Auditing Giant PwC May Have Breached Sanctions in Work for Oligarch: Leaked documents show staff at PwC Cyprus hurried to restructure companies belonging to Russian oligarchs as the prospect of sanctions loomed. Now Cyprus says it is investigating one case in which PwC staff appeared to work on the transfer of an oligarch’s assets in the days after he was sanctioned by the EU. . ru . . 14 November 2023 . 16 November 2023 . 17 November 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20231117033844/https://www.occrp.org/en/cyprus-confidential/cyprus-wing-of-auditing-giant-pwc-may-have-breached-sanctions-in-work-for-oligarch. Alternate archive
  31. News: Розэ . Анна (Rose, Anna) . Журналист для Путина. Как Хуберт Зайпель за деньги хвалил Кремль: Немецкий телеканал ARD и его дочерняя телерадиовещательная компания NDR годами, уже после аннексии Крыма, внимали байкам о России от проплаченного Кремлем журналиста. По данным только что вышедшего в свет расследования, видный немецкий тележурналист Хуберт Зайпель получал из Москвы сотни тысяч евро за книги о Путине. Тем самым Зайпель стал первым западным журналистом, тайное финансирование которого Кремлем было документально доказано. . Journalist for Putin. How Hubert Seipel praised the Kremlin for money: For years, after the annexation of Crimea, the German television channel ARD and its subsidiary broadcasting company NDR listened to stories about Russia from a journalist paid by the Kremlin. According to a just-published investigation, prominent German television journalist Hubert Seipel received hundreds of thousands of euros from Moscow for books about Putin. Thus, Seipel became the first Western journalist whose secret financing by the Kremlin was documented. . ru . . 15 November 2023 . 16 November 2023 . 17 November 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20231117033149/https://www.svoboda.org/a/zhurnalist-dlya-putina-kak-hubert-zaypelj-za-denjgi-hvalil-kremlj/32685573.html. Alternate archive
  32. Web site: TUI open to new majority shareholder following resignation of sanctioned Russian billionaire. City A.M. . 2023-08-15 . 2023-03-24 .
  33. Web site: TUI launches €1.8bn share sale, but Russian owner is banned . Travel Gossip . 2023-03-24 . 2023-08-15.
  34. Web site: Dr Dieter Zetsche to succeed Professor Klaus Mangold as Chairman of the Supervisory Board of TUI AG in 2018 . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  35. Web site: Change at the helm of TUI Group: Fritz Joussen becomes sole CEO of TUI Group / Peter Long, Joint CEO up to the AGM, becomes Supervisory Board member . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  36. Web site: 2009-10-28 . EANS-Adhoc: TUI AG / Change at the helm of the Supervisory Board . 2023-10-02 . presseportal.de . de.
  37. Web site: TUI Group listed in the Open Market of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange as of 1 April . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  38. News: 2008-03-14 . TUI shares soar on breakup news . en . Reuters . 2023-10-02.
  39. Web site: Activist investor fails to oust Tui chairman Financial Times . 2023-10-02 . www.ft.com.
  40. Web site: Financial Statements TUI AG . tuigroup.com.
  41. Web site: TUI AG has been informed about changes in ownership of shareholder Unifirm Limited / Change in TUI's shareholder structure . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  42. Web site: 2022-03-01 . TUI Group's Largest Shareholder Hit With European Union Sanctions . 2023-10-02 . Yahoo Finance . en-US.
  43. Web site: TUI AG receives information about the owner of its shareholder Unifirm . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  44. Web site: Capital Increase . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  45. Web site: Shareholder structure . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  46. News: Tui investors vote to leave London Stock Exchange amid record results. 13 February 2024. The Guardian. 31 May 2024.
  47. Web site: Our business . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  48. Web site: TUI Group: Sale of Hapag-Lloyd Cruises to TUI Cruises completed . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  49. Web site: Imprint - Hapag-Lloyd Cruises . 2023-10-02 . www.hl-cruises.com . en.
  50. Web site: Our Ships - Hapag-Lloyd Cruises . 2023-10-02 . www.hl-cruises.com . en.
  51. Web site: TUI Group Fleet . 17 July 2023 . Planespotters.net.
  52. Web site: TUI Group set to end B737-700 ops by 2027 . 2024-04-13 . ch-aviation . en.
  53. Web site: 21 November 2017 . TUI fly krijgt naast B737 MAX8 ook vier MAX10's in de vloot (Dutch) . 21 November 2017 . flightlevel.be.
  54. Web site: 21 November 2017 . TUI fly krijgt naast B737 MAX8 ook vier MAX10's in de vloot . 21 November 2017 . flightlevel.be.
  55. Web site: Cathy . Buyck . TUI Trains Eye on Transition to Boeing 737 Max and 787 Fleets AIN . 2024-03-02 . Aviation International News.
  56. Web site: All TUI Annual Reports . 18 February 2023 . www.tuigroup.com.
  57. Web site: TUI Fundamentalanalyse KGV Kennzahlen . 2024-03-02 . boerse.de . de.
  58. Web site: TUI Travel launches Russian joint venture . 2023-10-02 . www.travelweekly.com . en.
  59. Web site: TUI terminates agreement: TUI brand name may no longer be used by TUI Russia . 2023-10-02 . www.tuigroup.com . en.
  60. News: Tui's male employees paid more than double female staff – report . Sarah . Butler . Caelainn . Barr . The Guardian . 16 February 2018 . 22 January 2019 . www.theguardian.com.
  61. News: 'Sexist' Tui Airways crew gave different badges to girls and boys . Nadia . Khomami . The Guardian . 22 August 2018 . 22 January 2019 . www.theguardian.com.
  62. Web site: The two sides of TUI: crisis-hit holiday giant turned deportation specialist – Corporate Watch. corporatewatch.org. 27 January 2021.
  63. Web site: The Home Office deportation drive against Channel-crossing migrants: a balance sheet – Corporate Watch. corporatewatch.org. 29 April 2021.
  64. Kelly . Michael J. . 2013 . """Never Again""? German Chemical Corporation Complicity in the Kurdish Genocide" . Berkeley Journal of International Law . 10.15779/Z38594T. 145705967 .
  65. Adib-Moghaddam . Arshin . 2006-07-01 . The Whole Range of Saddam Hussein's War Crimes . Middle East Report . 239 . 30–35 . 10.2307/25164729 . 25164729 . 0899-2851.
  66. Web site: ZDF Magazin Royale vom 20. Mai 2022 . 2022-05-20 . www.zdf.de . de.
  67. Web site: Ltd . Jacobs Media Group . Scrutiny grows on Mordashov Tui stake . 2022-05-20 . Travel Weekly . en.