Symphony No. 5 (Prokofiev) Explained

Symphony No. 5
Composer:Sergei Prokofiev
Image Upright:1.2
Key:B-flat major
Opus:100
Duration:40 min
Movements:Four
Premiere Conductor:Prokofiev
Premiere Performers:USSR State Symphony Orchestra
Premiere Location:Moscow Conservatory

Sergei Prokofiev wrote his Symphony No. 5 in B-flat major, Op. 100, in the Soviet Union in the summer of 1944.[1]

Background

From 1925 onward, Prokofiev’s status as a composer grew, with his 1942Piano Sonata No. 7 receiving the Stalin Prize (Second Class). Prior to composing his Fifth Symphony, Prokofiev relocated to Moscow as a result of his increasing reliance on financial support from the Soviet Union and their threat of revoking their contributions.[2]

The creation of the Fifth Symphony can be traced to musical ideas explored during the composition of Prokofiev's earlier work, particularly the Symphony No. 4 in C major composed fourteen years prior.[3] Prokofiev incorporated these musical motifs into a piano score over less than a month during his stay at The Composers' House in Ivanovo, under the background of the Soviet Union’s involvement in World War II.

He gave out in a statement at the time of the work's premiere that he intended it as "a hymn to free and happy Man, to his mighty powers, his pure and noble spirit."[4] He added, "I cannot say that I deliberately chose this theme. It was born in me and clamoured for expression. The music matured within me. It filled my soul."[5]

Movements

The piece is in four movements, lasting 40–45 minutes:

  1. Andante (in B-flat major)
  2. Allegro marcato (in D minor)
  3. Adagio (in F major)
  4. Allegro giocoso (in B-flat major)

Movement I

The first movement is in a tightly argued sonata form: its exposition presents two themes, one calm and sustained, the other soaring with tremolo accompaniment from strings, which are then involved in an elaborate and climactic development section. The movement is wrapped up with an electrifying coda punctuated by a roaring tam-tam and low piano tremolos.

1st theme, mm. 1–7
  • \relative c'
    mm. 8–10
  • \relative c'
    mm. 29–30
  • \relative c
    2nd theme, mm. 54–64
  • \relative c
    mm. 74–77
  • \relative c
    Closing theme, mm. 83–86
  • \relative c

    Movement II

    The second movement is an insistent scherzo in Prokofiev's typical toccata mode, framing a central theme in triple time.

    mm. 3–10
  • \relative c
    mm. 56–58
  • \relative c
  • mm. 112–115
  • \relative c
    mm. 120–127
  • \relative c'
    mm. 154–157
  • Movement III

    The third movement is a dreamy slow movement, full of nostalgia, which nevertheless builds up to a tortured climax before receding to a quiet end.

    mm. 4–8
  • \relative c
    mm. 55–62
  • \relative c
    mm. 82–84
  • \relative c
    "tortured climax" mm. 125–131
  • Movement IV

    The finale starts with a cello choir playing a slow introduction recalling the first theme of the first movement, which then launches into the movement proper, a rondo. The playful ("giocoso") main theme is contrasted with two calmer episodes, one introduced by the flute, the other a chorale in the strings. Just as the movement is striving to end with a victorious tone, the music degenerates into a frenzy (rehearsal mark 111), which is stripped down to a string quartet playing staccato "wrong notes" (rehearsal mark 113) with rude interjections from low trumpets, making the ultimate orchestral unison on B-flat sound all the more ironic.

    mm. 3–6
  • \relative c
    Theme from first movement, mm. 15–22
  • mm. 29–36
  • \relative c
    mm. 37–38
  • \relative c
    mm. 54–55
  • \relative c
    mm. 83–90
  • \relative c
    mm. 164–172
  • \relative c

    Instrumentation

    The work is scored for the following:

    valign=topWoodwind valign=topBrass valign=topPercussion valign=top width=25%Keyboard

    Strings

    Premiere

    The symphony was premiered on January 13, 1945, in the Great Hall of Moscow Conservatory by the USSR State Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Prokofiev himself.[6]

    As he took the stage, artillery fired. He paused until it finished. This left a great impression upon the audience, who upon leaving the Great Hall learned the gunfire marked the Red Army's crossing of the Vistula into Germany.[6] The premiere was very well-received, and the symphony has remained one of the composer's most popular works.

    Then, in November of that year, Serge Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony Orchestra introduced the score to America and recorded it in Boston's Symphony Hall on February 6 and 7, 1946, for RCA Victor, using an optical sound film process introduced by RCA in 1941; it was initially issued on 78-rpm discs and later on LP and CD. The symphony's rapid insertion into the repertoire was referenced by Dennis Dobson in his review of the 1951 Edinburgh Festival for Music Survey, where he panned the work as "noisy, uncouth" and a "falling off in maturity" from works such as Chout and the Piano Concerto No. 3 and went on to say, "that this work is well thought of and much played in both America and the Soviet Union speaks sociological and cultural volumes".[7]

    Notable recordings

    OrchestraConductorRecord companyYear of recordingFormat
    Philharmonic Symphony Orchestra of New YorkArtur RodzińskiColumbia Records1946LP/CD
    Boston Symphony OrchestraSergei KoussevitzkyRCA, Dutton1946LP/CD
    Danish Radio Symphony OrchestraErik TuxenDecca1952LP/CD
    Philadelphia OrchestraEugene OrmandyColumbia1958LP
    Philharmonia OrchestraThomas SchippersAngel, Medici Masters1957LP/CD
    Orchestre de la Société des Concerts du ConservatoireJean MartinonRCA1959LP
    Cleveland OrchestraGeorge SzellSony1959LP/CD
    Boston Symphony OrchestraErich LeinsdorfRCA1963LP/CD
    New York PhilharmonicLeonard BernsteinSony1966LP/CD
    Berlin PhilharmonicHerbert von KarajanDeutsche Grammophon1968LP/CD
    Leningrad Philharmonic OrchestraEvgeny MravinskyRussian Disc, Leningrad Masters1968CD
    Leningrad Philharmonic OrchestraGennadi RozhdestvenskyBBC1971CD
    Concerts Colonne OrchestraJascha HorensteinVox1972CD/LP
    Orchestre National de FranceJean MartinonVox1974LP/CD
    Moscow Radio Symphony OrchestraGennadi RozhdestvenskyMelodiya1975LP
    Philadelphia OrchestraEugene OrmandyRCA1975CD (Japan only)
    London Symphony OrchestraWalter WellerDecca1976CD
    Czech Philharmonic OrchestraZdeněk KošlerSupraphon1979CD
    Israel Philharmonic OrchestraLeonard BernsteinCBS Masterworks1980CD
    Saint Louis Symphony OrchestraLeonard SlatkinRCA1984LP/CD
    Concertgebouw OrchestraVladimir AshkenazyDecca1985CD
    Scottish National OrchestraNeeme JärviChandos1985CD
    Los Angeles Philharmonic OrchestraAndré PrevinPhilips1986CD
    Leningrad Philharmonic OrchestraMariss JansonsChandos1987CD
    Moscow Philharmonic OrchestraDmitri KitajenkoRCA1987CD
    Orchestre National de FranceMstislav RostropovichErato1988CD
    Slovak Philharmonic OrchestraStephen GunzenhauserNaxos1989CD
    Berlin PhilharmonicSeiji OzawaDeutsche Grammophon1990CD
    Philadelphia OrchestraRiccardo MutiPhilips1990CD
    Atlanta Symphony OrchestraYoel LeviTelarc1991CD
    St. Petersburg PhilharmonicYuri TemirkanovRCA1991CD
    London Symphony OrchestraMichael Tilson ThomasSony Classical1991CD
    Chicago Symphony OrchestraJames LevineDeutsche Grammophon1992CD
    City of Birmingham Symphony OrchestraSimon RattleEMI1992CD
    National Symphony Orchestra of UkraineTheodore KucharNaxos1995CD
    London Symphony OrchestraValery GergievPhilips2004CD
    São Paulo State Symphony OrchestraMarin AlsopNaxos2011CD
    Bergen Symphony OrchestraAndrew LittonBIS Records2014SACD
    Bournemouth Symphony OrchestraKirill KarabitsOnyx Records2014SACD
    Royal Concertgebouw OrchestraMariss JansonsRCO Live2014SACD
    The Cleveland OrchestraFranz Welser-MöstThe Cleveland Orchestra2023SACD

    Notes and References

    1. Web site: Symphony No. 5 in B-flat major, Op. 100 (Sergei Prokofiev). 2021-06-30. LA Phil. en.
    2. Web site: 2017-10-16. Music At War: A Guide to Prokofiev's Symphony No. 5. 2024-03-06. Houston Symphony. en-US.
    3. Web site: 2019-08-20. Prokofiev: Symphony No. 5. 2021-06-30. Utah Symphony. en-US.
    4. Schwarz, Music and Musical Life in Soviet Russia, p.196, cited in Preston Stedman, The Symphony, p.290
    5. Book: Prokofiev, Sergey . Autobiography, Articles, Reminiscences . 134–135. University Press of the Pacific . Honolulu, Ha . 1960 . 9780898751499 .
    6. Web site: Prokofiev's Symphony No. 5 Reflects Drama of World War II . Evanston Symphony Orchestra . August 19, 2019 . en . 13 October 2014.
    7. Edinburgh Festival, 1951, Dennis Dobson. Music Survey, vol. IV, no. 2, February 1952, p. 425.