Sydney Goldman Explained

Charles Sydney Goldman
Birth Date:	28 April 1868
Birth Place:	Cape Colony
Death Place:	British Columbia, Canada
Resting Place:	Yaverland, Isle of Wight
Nationality:	British
Other Names:	C.S. Goldman
Known For:	Nicola Ranch
Occupation:	Journalist, author, politician
Party:	Unionist
Spouse:	Hon. Agnes Mary Peel
Children:	Hazel Goldman (1904–1946) John Monk Goldman (1908–1999) Victor Robert Penryn Monk Goldman (1910–1987)
Parents:	Bernard Nahum Goldmann and Augusta Goldmann née Friedlander

Major Charles Sydney Goldman ^[1] (28 April 1868 – 7 April 1958) was a British businessman, author, and journalist who served as a Member of Parliament (MP) from 1910 until 1918.

Background

In early life, he used the family name in the spelling Goldmann.^[2] Born in Cape Colony, he was of German Jewish ancestry. His father Bernard Nahum Goldmann had left eastern Germany after the German revolutions of 1848–1849, because of his political involvements.^[3] It was reported in 1939 that his family name was originally Monck.^[4]

Bernard Goldmann ran a shop at Burgersdorp for the Mosenthal brothers, and prospered;^[5] he was appointed Justice of the Peace for the Albert district of Cape Colony in 1869.^[6] He was a director of the Albert Bank, with his brother Louis Goldmann, who had arrived in Cape Town in 1845 with his family from Breslau, had gone into business with the Mosenthals and moved to Burgersdorp.^{[7] [8]} The surgeon and medical researcher Edwin Goldmann was Sydney's elder brother.

In 1876 Bernard Goldmann and his family migrated to Europe, by a sea voyage on SS Nyanza to Southampton. After a period in London, they moved on to Breslau. As tutor in German, and to help with college preparation, the children had an uncle, Dr. Monck. The boys also attended the gymnasium school, where Adolf Anderssen taught. From there, Sydney and his brother Alfred moved back to South Africa; while Edwin and Richard, the other brothers, with their sister Alice, remained in Germany.^[9]

In business

Goldman and his elder brother Alfred returned to South Africa around 1882. Alfred settled at Graaff-Reinet as a dealer.^[10] Sydney Goldman went into agriculture.^[11] He was in business at Reddersburg, in the Orange Free State, around 1887.^[12]

Gold mines and their finance earned Goldman a fortune. He moved to the goldfields after the Witwatersrand Gold Rush, and was taken on by a mining company.^[13] He was elected a Fellow of the Royal Geographical Society in 1891, as Sydney Goldmann.^[1] From age 26, or 1895, he was a partner in S. Neumann & Co., Sigismund Neumann's holding company, at least to 1905;^{[11] [14]} later (by 1913) Neumann was the sole partner.^[15] As the other partners moved to London, Goldman was for a time the only partner resident in Johannesburg.^[13]

Goldman purchased an extensive estate known as Schoongezicht (later known as Lanzerac) in the Middelburg district. By 1900 it was owned by John X. Merriman.^[16] Bernard Goldmann having died (by 1894), the family moved by stages to London, with Edwin remaining in Freiburg, Germany; and Sydney left Johannesburg.^{[10] [17]} In 1899 in England he married a granddaughter of Sir Robert Peel.

Boer War

During the Second Anglo-Boer War, Goldman was a war correspondent for The Standard and was a major in the British forces. Initially attached to Sir Redvers Buller's relief force, he travelled with them as far as Ladysmith after which he transferred to the cavalry advancing north in order to report on their endeavours. At this period, Goldman worked as a cameraman for the Warwick Trading Company, taking over when Joseph Rosenthal left in the middle of 1900.^{[18] [19]} He is recorded as filming a ceremony on 25 October 1900 in Pretoria, in which Lord Roberts marked the annexation of the Transvaal. After that Goldman returned to Johannesburg, which had been captured by British forces.^[20]

Imperialism and politics

In the 1890s Goldman was involved in the Eighty Club. His brother Richard dined there while Lord Rosebery, the Liberal Imperialist, was Prime Minister (i.e. 1894–5).^[21] Clinton Edward Dawkins described Goldman to Leo Maxse in 1904 as:

...full of S. African shares, also of public spirit and of imperial devotion...[who] desires to excel as a writer or pamphleteer. Nature—or his education—have deprived him of the least glimmering of literary skill.^[22]

Goldman joined the Compatriots Club formed that year.^[22] To gain influence, he purchased a struggling weekly journal, The Outlook, at the end of 1904. It had been founded by George Wyndham, and was then edited by Percy Hurd.^{[23] [24]} In order to develop it as an organ of the tariff reformers, Goldman hired the journalist J. L. Garvin as its editor. Garvin quickly transformed the journal into a publication of note, but the paper failed to turn a profit. After a series of disagreements between the two men over business matters, Goldman sold the paper to Lord Iveagh in October 1906.^[25] On the tone of Edwardian period imperialist writers, contrasted with Leonard Woolf, Simon Glassock writes:

Garvin, Goldman and St Loe Strachey demonstrate how writers at the turn of the twentieth century might have allied economics, politics and history with appeals for the reader to take modest but deserved pride in the imperial achievements of the British.^[26]

Goldman joined the Carlton Club. He was a member of the Unionist Social Reform Committee, while his wife Agnes was on the Council of the Conservative and Unionist Women's Franchise Association.^[27] He resided at Walpole House which he sold in 1925.^[28] He involved himself in politics directly by entering Parliament, winning the Penryn and Falmouth seat in the January 1910 general election as a Unionist.

In 1913 Goldman was a captain in the Royal Garrison Artillery;^[29] and during World War I, served as a major in it, in Cornwall. As a backbencher he was noted, like Arnold Ward, for his "jingoistic" views.^[22] He remained an MP until the borough was abolished in 1918 (the name was transferred to a new county division).

Later life

In 1919 Goldman purchased the Nicola Ranch and most of the Nicola townsite in the Nicola Country, British Columbia, which grew to some 300000acres. He owned all the way up to what is now the Monck Provincial Park, named after his son Commander Victor Robert Penryn Monck of the Royal Navy.

In England Goldman lived at Trefusis House, Falmouth until about 1929, after which he moved to the Jacobean mansion at Yaverland Manor.

Works

Goldman wrote an eyewitness account of the Boer War, and edited and translated other works.

• The financial, statistical, and general history of the gold & other companies of Witwatersrand, South Africa (1892)^[30]
• South African Mines: Volume I (1895): Rand mining companies^[31] and two succeeding volumes, II on Miscellaneous Companies,^[32] and III on maps (1896)
• With General French and the Cavalry in South Africa (1902).^[33] The illustrations to the book included a number of photographs taken by Charles Howard Foulkes of the Royal Engineers, who used a Newman & Guardia 5x4 camera, published with permission.^{[34] [35]}
• (as editor) The Empire and the century: A series of essays on imperial problems and possibilities (1905)https://books.google.com/books?id=-hELAAAAYAAJ&q=charles+sydney+goldman+empire+century
• (as translator) Cavalry in Future Wars (1906), from the German of Unsere Kavallerie im nächsten Kriege: Betrachtungen über ihre Verwendung, Organisation und Ausbildung (1899)^[36] by Friedrich von Bernhardi

In 1905 Goldman became the founding editor of The Cavalry Journal.^[37] From 1911 the editorship was an ex officio duty of the commandant of the Cavalry School at Netheravon.^[38]

Mapping

• Map of the Witwatersrand goldfield, compiled 1891 from government surveys by Ewan Currey and Brian Tucker, scale 1:29,779, published 1892.^[39]
• Atlas of the Witwatersrand and Other Goldfields in the South African Republic (1899), compiled under the direction of C. S. Goldmann, with Baron A. von Maltzan (Ago von Maltzan, in the later 1890s at university in Breslau).^[40]

Legacy

Goldman was a collector of Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood art. His pictures were divided between his two sons.^[41]

One of Goldman's legacies is Monck Provincial Park on the shore of Nicola Lake, for which Goldman gave land in 1951.^[42] There was a memorial stone to Charles Sydney Goldman in the yard at the Murray United Church in the area. The church itself was burned down in 2019.^[43]

Family

Goldman married, in 1899, the Hon. Agnes Mary Peel (1869–1959), daughter of Liberal Party politician Arthur Peel, 1st Viscount Peel. They had met when she visited the Rand, and the house "Amerden" Sydney shared there with his brother Richard.^[44] During the Boer War she worked as a nurse in the military hospital at Pietermaritzburg.^[45] She was decorated with the Royal Red Cross, and was in December 1901 appointed a Lady of Grace of the Venerable Order of Saint John of Jerusalem.

After Emily Hobhouse had written in The Contemporary Review about British concentration camps in South Africa, and in particular about the number of Africans remaining in them, John Smith Moffat replied in the same periodical. Two months after Moffat's article, Agnes Goldmann contributed a further article on the topic. Her views included the desirability of segregation for Africans of the Transvaal.^[46]

The Goldmans had three children. Of those, Victor Robert Penryn Monk Goldman changed his surname legally to Monck, and John Goldman Monk Goldman changed his name legally to John Monk Monck, in both cases on 22 February 1939. The name Monck was stated to be the original family name.

• John (1908–1999), the elder son, was born at Rottingdean. He became a film editor at Gainsborough Pictures in the 1920s, and after visiting the Soviet Union joined the Communist Party of Great Britain and was an organiser for the Association of Cinematograph Television and Allied Technicians. In 1934 he married Margaret Thesiger, daughter of the late Frederic Thesiger, 1st Viscount Chelmsford.^[47] That year his sister purchased the island of Mewstone south of Tasmania to give to him.^[48] Also that year he edited Man of Aran, directed by Robert J. Flaherty. During WWII he was a film producer for the Crown Film Unit, and after the war he worked on documentaries with Sergei Nolbandov. He also farmed.^[47]
• Victor (known as Pen Goldman) published as Penryn Goldman the 1932 travel book To Hell and Gone about Australia, introduction by Wilfred Grenfell.^{[49] [50]} He was an RNVR officer, a temporary lieutenant on HMS Buxton in 1942, and as Lieutenant Commander sent to Hawaii to liaise with the US Navy in 1944 (reported by the International Grenfell Association magazine).^{[51] [52]} In later life he was often known as Commander Penryn Monck. He married in 1949 (Isolde) Sheila Tower Butler, sister of Patrick Theobald Tower Butler, 18th Baron Dunboyne .^{[53] [54]}
• Hazel, the daughter, carried the train of Una Duval, first cousin of her mother, at her 1912 "suffragist" wedding, the marriage vows omitting "to obey".^[55] At the time of her giving Mewstone to her brother John and wife Margaret in 1934 as a wedding present, she was living at Sydney Lodge, Hamble-le-Rice, designed by Sir John Soane. It was sold by her father in 1936.^{[56] [57]}

The Goldmans also had as ward Lorna Goldman(n), daughter of Sydney's brother Edwin, after his death in 1913. She met and then married Stewart Gore-Browne in 1927, at age 19 and still at Sherborne School for Girls. Gore-Browne's biographer comments that "The Goldmans travelled incessantly, to the Continent and the Orient".^[58]

Notes and References

1. Second Meeting, 23rd November, 1891. Election of Fellows. 1891. Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society . New Series. 13. 731.
2. Book: Wills . Walter H. . Barrett . R. J. . The Anglo-African Who's who and Biographical Sketch-book . 1884 . George Routledge & Sons, Limited . 62 . en.
3. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 5 . en.
4. News: Robert Frederick Thesiger Monck . The Bystander . 15 March 1939. 11.
5. Book: Jewish Life in the South African Country Communities: Camdeboo. Cape Midlands. Garden Route. Langkloof. Little Karoo. North-Eastern Cape. Overberg. Settler Country. Transkei. Griqualand East . 2002 . South African Friends of Beth Hatefutsoth . 978-0-9584602-6-2 . 266 . en.
6. Book: Cape of Good Hope (Colony) . Government Gazette . 1869 . Government Printer, South Africa . 581 . en.
7. Book: Quarterly Bulletin of the National Library of South Africa . 2006 . Friends of the National Library of South Africa . 142. 60-91 . en.
8. Book: Jewish Life in the South African Country Communities: Camdeboo. Cape Midlands. Garden Route. Langkloof. Little Karoo. North-Eastern Cape. Overberg. Settler Country. Transkei. Griqualand East . 2002 . South African Friends of Beth Hatefutsoth . 978-0-9584602-6-2 . 262 . en.
9. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 17–33 . en.
10. Web site: Yamey . Adam . Men of Gold - The Goldmanns of Burghersdorp . www.jewishgen.org. 5.
11. Book: Emden . Paul Herman . Jews of Britain: A Series of Biographies . 1944 . S. Low, Marston & Co. . London . 424 . en.
12. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 38 . en.
13. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 51 . en.
14. Book: Wills . Walter H. . Barrett . R. J. . The Anglo-African Who's Who and biographical sketch-book . 1905 . George Routledge & Sons, Ltd. . London . 62 .
15. Book: Whitaker's Peerage, Baronetage, Knightage, and Companionage. 1913 . 585 . en.
16. Web site: Schoongezicht - Lanzerac details . artefacts.co.za.
17. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 70 . en.
18. Web site: Who's Who of Victorian Cinema . www.victorian-cinema.net.
19. Bottomore . Stephen . From Theatre Manager to Globetrotting Cameraman: The Strange Career of Charles Rider Noble (1854–1914) . Film History . 2012 . 24 . 3 . 297 note 29 . 10.2979/filmhistory.24.3.281 . 10.2979/filmhistory.24.3.281 . 192122159 . 0892-2160.
20. Web site: Stephen Bottomore: Filming, faking and propaganda: The origins of the war film, 1897-1902: Chapter IX . dspace.library.uu.nl. 20–21.
21. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 72 . en.
22. Book: Davenport-Hines . R. P. T. . Speculators and Patriots: Essays in Business Biography . 28 June 2005 . Routledge . 978-1-135-77933-7 . 131 note 9 . en.
23. [Stephen Koss]
24. Cohen . Scott A. . Imperialism Tempered by Expediency: Conrad and "The Outlook" . Conradiana . 2009 . 41 . 1 . 53 . 24635192 . 0010-6356.
25. Alfred M. Gollin, The Observer and J. L. Garvin, 1908-1914: A Study in a Great Editorship (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1960), p. 14-15
26. Book: Macdonald . Kate . Waddell . Nathan . John Buchan and the Idea of Modernity . 6 October 2015 . Routledge . 978-1-317-31984-9 . 36 . en.
27. Book: Auchterlonie . Mitzi . Conservative Suffragists: The Women's Vote and the Tory Party (International Library of Political Studies) - PDF Free Download . 2007 . Bloomsbury Academic . 160 . en.
28. News: "Mrs Pinkerton's Academy" . Dundee Courier . 10 October 1925. 8 . British Newspaper Archive . subscription.
29. Book: Kelly's Handbook to the Titled, Landed and Official Classes . 1913 . London . 725 .
30. Book: Goldman . Charles Sydney . The Financial, Statistical, and General History of the Gold & Other Companies of Witwatersrand, South Africa . 1892 . E. Wilson and Company . en.
31. Book: Goldman . Charles Sydney . Kitchin . Joseph . South African Mines. I: Rand Mining Companies . 1895 . E. Wilson & Company . en.
32. Book: Goldman . Charles Sydney . Kitchin . Joseph . Miscellaneous companies . 1896 . E. Wilson & Company . en.
33. Book: Goldman . Charles Sydney . With General French and the cavalry in South Africa . 1902 . Macmillan & Co. . London, New York .
34. Foulkes . Major-General C. H. . The Photo-Reconnaissance Section R.E. . The Royal Engineers Journal . September 1957. LXXI . 288 .
35. Book: The Royal Engineers Journal . 1957 . Institution of Royal Engineers . en.
36. Book: Bernhardi . Friedrich von . Unsere Kavallerie im nächsten Kriege: Betrachtungen über ihre Verwendung, Organisation und Ausbildung . 1899 . Mittler . de.
37. Book: Badsey . Stephen . Doctrine and Reform in the British Cavalry 1880–1918 . 5 December 2016 . Routledge . 978-1-351-94318-5 . 296 . en.
38. Book: Badsey . Stephen . Doctrine and Reform in the British Cavalry 1880–1918 . 5 December 2016 . Routledge . 978-1-351-94318-5 . 342 . en.
39. Book: Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society and monthly record of geography . 1892 . Stanford . 202 . en.
40. Book: Atlas of the Witwatersrand and Other Goldfields . 1899 . Edward Stanford . en.
41. Web site: Burne-Jones Catalogue Raisonné, Study of a female head looking left for the Mourning Queen standing behind Arthur's feet for the painting The Last Sleep of Arthur in Avalon, Portrait of Olive Maxse . www.eb-j.org.
42. Book: Akrigg . G. P. (Philip) V. . Akrigg . Helen . British Columbia Place Names: Third Edition . 1 November 2011 . UBC Press . 978-0-7748-4170-2 . 177 . en.
43. News: Lirette . Dominika . Community members say goodbye to historic B.C. church destroyed by fire . April 29, 2019.
44. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 51 . en.
45. Book: Goldmann . Richard . A South African Remembers . 1946 . Cape Times . 108 . en.
46. Book: Sherwood . Marika . Origins of Pan-Africanism: Henry Sylvester Williams, Africa, and the African Diaspora . 26 July 2012 . Routledge . 978-1-136-89113-7 . 142 . en.
47. News: Giesler . Rodney . Obituary: John Monck . The Independent . 6 July 1999 . en.
48. News: Giving Island to Her Brother . Western Morning News . 16 April 1934. 4 . British Newspaper Archive . subscription.
49. Book: McGrath . Ann . In Search of the Never-Never: Mickey Dewar: Champion of History Across Many Genres . 9 April 2019 . ANU Press . 978-1-76046-269-7 . 111 . en.
50. Book: Office . Library of Congress Copyright . Catalog of Copyright Entries. New Series: 1932 . 1932 . Copyright Office, Library of Congress . 1929 . en.
51. Book: (1433) - Navy lists > Bimonthly > 1942 > December - British Military lists - National Library of Scotland . 1407 .
52. Among the Deep Sea Fishers . Alumni News . 42 . 2 . July 1944 . 2426 . usurped . Jan 15, 2023 . en . 29 July 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230115065003/http://lib-lespaul.library.mun.ca/PDFs/hs_fisher/ADSF4202.pdf.
53. Book: Montague-Smith . Patrick W. . Debrett's Peerage and Baronetage . 1985 . Debrett's Peerage Ltd. . 978-0-333-37824-3 . 381 . en.
54. News: The Last Big Dance of the London Season . The Tatler . 16 August 1950. 19 . British Newspaper Archive . subscription.
55. News: Duval-Dugdale Wedding: Suffragist Ceremony . Aberdeen Press and Journal . 15 January 1912. 5 . British Newspaper Archive . subscription.
56. News: Island Gift . Dundee Courier . 11 July 1934. 12 . British Newspaper Archive . subscription.
57. Web site: Sydney Lodge, Hamble, Hampshire for the Hon. Mrs Yorke, 1792-1796 (15) . collections.soane.org.
58. Book: Rotberg . Robert I. . Black Heart: Gore-Browne and the Politics of Multiracial Zambia . 8 January 2021 . Univ of California Press . 978-0-520-32816-7 . 133–134 . en.