Swiss Avenue Historic District Explained

Swiss Avenue Historic District
Nrhp Type:hd
Coordinates:32.8069°N -96.7636°W
Map Label:Swiss Avenue Historic District
Locmap Relief:yes
Architect:Multiple
Added:March 28, 1974
Refnum:74002068
Designated Other1:Dallas Landmark
Designated Other1 Date:July 9, 1973[1]
Designated Other1 Number:H/1
Designated Other1 Num Position:bottom

The Swiss Avenue Historic District is a residential neighborhood in East Dallas, Dallas, Texas (USA). It consists of installations of the Munger Place addition, one of East Dallas' early subdivisions. The Swiss Avenue Historic District is a historic district of the city of Dallas, Texas.[2] The boundaries of the district comprise both sides of Swiss Avenue from Fitzhugh Street, to just north of La Vista, and includes portions of Bryan Parkway.[3] The District includes the 6100-6200 blocks of La Vista Drive, the west side of the 5500 block of Bryan Parkway the 6100-6300 blocks of Bryan Parkway, the east side of the 5200-5300 block of Live Oak Street, and the 4900-6100 blocks of Swiss Avenue.[4] The entire street of Swiss Avenue is not included within the bounds of the Swiss Avenue Historic District. Portions of the street run through Dallas' Peaks Suburban Addition neighborhood and Peak's Suburban Addition Historic District.[5] 5215 Swiss was built in 1914 and was the home of J. P. Cranfield

Early development

Swiss Avenue, at least the portions contained within the Swiss Avenue Historic District, was initially developed by Robert S. Munger, a Dallas cotton gin manufacturer and pioneering real estate developer, as part of a larger development, Munger Place, which was billed as the first deed-restricted community in Texas.[6] Munger had retired from the management of his ginning companies and started working in real estate with his son Collett (for whom Dallas' Collett Avenue is named) in 1902. The subdivision was also one of the first in Dallas to ensure that the front views of homes wouldn't be blocked by utility poles; all utilities were installed through the rear of the lots via alleys.[7] The lots in the Swiss Avenue section of Munger Place were larger than those in other areas of Munger Place, such as on Junius Street, Gaston Avenue, or portions of Worth Street that continue through Munger Place. In order to set off the development from others, Munger had gates erected at the entrances to Gaston Avenue, Swiss Avenue, and Junius Street, major thoroughfares in the development.

The original plat for Munger Place from 1907 showed twenty blocks of Swiss Avenue, Gaston Avenue, Junius Street, Worth Street, and Crutcher Street between Fitzhugh Avenue and Munger Boulevard platted; growth, however, was rapid and lots sold well, and Munger extended the development in 1910 to include the south side of Live Oak Street from Fitzhugh Avenue to Dumas Street and both sides of Swiss Avenue to Parkmont Street.

Seventy-foot lots on Swiss Avenue were being sold for $3,500 in August 1908; by comparison, lots on Junius Street that were 60-foot lots were selling for $2,400 at the same time.[8] In 1978, shortly after the historic district was formed, 5744 Swiss Avenue was marketed for $275,000.[9] Today, homes within the Swiss Avenue Historic District in good or well-remodeled condition routinely sell for over $1 million. Initially, Munger had set aside land for a private drive on the north side of Swiss Avenue, and a part to divide it from the public street on the south. The north side of the street was initially owned by residents, and both sides were intended for their private use. Today, the street and parkway is owned and maintained by the city of Dallas. Like most homes on Swiss Avenue, the community was deed restricted to white buyers only. An early deed to a lot on Swiss Avenue shows also that the front of residences were required to be set back not less than 60 feet nor more than 70 feet from the front line of the lot (the "setback"). Houses or quarters for renting were not allowed, but servant's quarters or stables for the use of the home's residents were allowed.

A trolley initially served the neighborhood, running through what is now the alley between Swiss and Gaston Avenues. Originally, Swiss Avenue was composed of two separate streets, one for public thoroughfare and one for private use, separated by a 40-foot park.[10]

Dr. R. W. Baird is credited as being the first to build on Swiss Avenue in 1905 at 5303 Swiss. He constructed a Classical Revival mansion. In 1910 the surge of building along Swiss Avenue began and, of the approximately 200 homes on the street, the majority of them were constructed during the 1910s and the 1920s.

Swiss Avenue was originally named in 1857, well before serious development, by a Dallas resident from Switzerland.[11] It started out as Swiss Boulevard. It was known as White Rock Road shortly after the Civil War when William H. Gaston purchased 400 acres along the road.[12]

Deed restrictions drive development

The deed restrictions Munger put in place required homes to be a least two stories in height, and constructed on the exterior of brick or masonry. Homes were not permitted to face side streets, and each home had to cost at least $10,000 to build. In other parts of Munger Place, the same $10,000 cost to build applied, but other portions of Munger Place, such as homes on Junius and Worth Streets running through Munger Place, were allowed to be made of wood-sided exteriors.

As a result, very grand homes were built on Swiss Avenue. Architects and builders engaged by prominent Dallasites to build homes on the street included Bertram Hill, Lang & Witchell, Charles Bulger, Hal Thomson, Marion Foshee, C.P. Stiles, Marshall Barnett, W.H. Reeves, Dines & Kraft, and others. Swiss Avenue also boasts being the first paved street in the city of Dallas.

Heritage designations

The entire district, Swiss Avenue between Fitzhugh and La Vista, was listed as a historic district on the National Register of Historic Places on March 28, 1974, and is a Dallas Landmark Historic District, the city's first, established in 1973.[11] One home within the district is listed individually on the National Register while several more are designated as Recorded Texas Historic Landmarks.

The Historic Preservation League of Dallas (a forerunner of the non-profit organization Preservation Dallas), with the help of the Dallas Department of Urban Planning, performed the original research for the designations. The National Trust for Historic Preservation initially became aware of the Dallas Preservation League's work through its Department of Field Services in the fall of 1972, and in January of the next year, the preservation league was awarded a $500 grant to retain an architectural historian to conduct an architectural survey of the proposed district. Another matching grant of $800 was provided later to assist the league in hiring legal assistance to challenge a proposal to build a high-rise apartment complex in the district.[13]

According to the National Trust for Historic Preservation's study on the district's founding, getting the historic district ordinance passed was just one of many serious problems facing those seeking to preserve Swiss Avenue. Newspapers referred to the group as, "an unnamed group of interested citizens," which the Trust reports numbered only nine people. Two architects, an audiovisual expert, a freelance writer and journalist, a banker, contractor, and two lawyers were part of the initial group. Many absentee landlords of the Swiss Avenue homes felt that the value of the structures was only in the land, much of which was re-zoned for high-rise apartments.

Once the boundaries of the district and an ordinance covering the historic district were prepared by city staff, the Dallas Historic Landmark Preservation Committee (now the Dallas Landmark Commission), the Dallas City Plan Commission, and the Dallas City Council had to approve the plans and ordinance. The Trust claims that the City Plan department staff actually initiated the idea of the historic district.

Architectural styles

At least 16 architectural styles are visible on Swiss Avenue. These include: Mediterranean, Spanish, Georgian, Prairie, Craftsman, Queen Anne, Jacobethan (English), Neoclassical, Italian Renaissance, Tudor and Colonial Revival.

Frank Lloyd Wright's influence is visible is seen in the R. W. Higginbotham House at 5002 Swiss built in 1913. It was designed Lang and Witchell.

Homes with individual historic designations

These homes within the district are designated individually on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) or as Recorded Texas Historic Landmarks (RTHL).

Other significant and compatible homes

The street has been home to many prominent residents of Dallas over the years. The home at 5803 Swiss Avenue was home to Carrie Marcus Neiman, founder of the department store, Neiman Marcus. The home at 5614 Swiss Avenue was home to George F. Gibson, an early pastor of Munger Place Methodist Church and an instructor at Southern Methodist University's Perkins School of Theology. 5417 Swiss was owned by A.J. Langford, an executive with Ford Motor Company. The dining room of the home at 5020 Swiss appeared in the pilot for the television show "Dallas." The 1892 vice presidential candidate for the Prohibition Party, James B. Cranfill, also lived on the street, at 5121 Swiss Avenue.

Centennial photographs of every home on Swiss Avenue

One hundred years after the Munger brothers created Munger Place as the finest residence park in the South Land, all one hundred homes were photographed. This block by block photographic survey of the homes show the preservation and renovation of these architecturally significant homes over one hundred years.

Modern controversies

The Aldredge House, located at 5500 Swiss Avenue, owned by the Dallas Medical Society, was named to Preservation Dallas' 2015 list of “Most Endangered Historic Places.”[30] This is because of an ongoing controversy relating to the zoning of the house allowing it to be used for private events, such as weddings. Preservation Dallas, in naming the house to its list, noted that the home is located in the city's first residential historic district, and is one of architect Hal Thomson's key works in the French Eclectic style featuring Renaissance detailing. Preservation Dallas noted that, while the home isn't threatened with demolition, the removal of the zoning allowing private events to be held at the home would likely mean the home would be required to be sold by its owners, thus closing off to the public historically intact interiors, and subjecting those to modernization.[31]

In 2000, a controversy was created when former Texas Secretary of State David Dean requested to add a 400-foot extension on to his home, including space for a closet. The Dallas Landmark Commission refused to allow Dean to make the addition in August 2000. The Dallas City Council, on October 4, 2000, approved his request. Then-mayor Ron Kirk, later mayor Laura Miller, and Councilman John Loza opposed the request. Council members Leo Chaney, Jr., and Donna Blumer recused themselves from the votes citing unspecified conflicts stemming from their relationships with parties in the dispute.[32] Dean, who later chaired the North Texas Crime Commission, served as counsel to Texas Governors William P. Clements, Jr., and Dolph Briscoe.[33]

In 1997, the Dallas Observer ran a multi-page article discussing an attempted coup d'état of the Swiss Avenue Historic District Association's leadership, and controversies surrounding the Swiss Avenue Women's Guild.[34]

in 1973, the old Terrill Preparatory School home at 4217 Swiss had several mysterious fires, and was a "haven for hippies and transients," and some area residents wanted the house demolished.[35] Also in 1973, a state district judge ordered the city to issue a building permit to a high-rise apartment builder wishing to construct apartments at Swiss Avenue and Collett Streets. The city had denied the permit, because of the expectation that the area was being made into a historic district. The city appealed the case.[36]

Education

Swiss Avenue is within the Dallas Independent School District (DISD).[37]

Almost all residents are zoned to William Lipscomb Elementary School in Junius Heights,[38] J. L. Long Middle School,[39] and Woodrow Wilson High School.[40] A part of a block is zoned to Cesar Chavez Elementary School,[41] Alex W. Spence Middle School,[42] and North Dallas High School.[43]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Swiss Avenue Report. . 27. Dallas Department of Urban Planning. September 4, 2018.
  2. Web site: Swiss Avenue Historic District Ordinance. City of Dallas Sustainable Development Historic Preservation. 2016-10-28.
  3. Web site: swiss_avenue. dallascityhall.com. 2016-10-28.
  4. Book: Dooley, Elizabeth Schwartz. A History and Guide to the Swiss Avenue Historic District: 1905-1916. University of Texas At Arlington. 1978. Arlington, Texas. iii, iv, v, 7, 12, 13, 14, 16, 41, 44, 47, 49, 58, 61, 69, 70, 74, 81–83, 90–91, 101.
  5. Web site: peaks_suburban_addition. dallascityhall.com. 2016-10-28.
  6. Web site: History . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20230529020622/https://www.sahd.org/history . 2023-05-29 . 2024-01-13 . Swiss Avenue Historic District.
  7. News: Home In Munger Place. 1908-08-14. The Dallas Morning News. Newsbank.com.
  8. News: Dallas Morning News. August 16, 1908. Newsbank.com.
  9. Book: Canavan, Robert Linus. A History and Guide to the Swiss Avenue Historic District, 1923-1932. University of Texas At Arlington. 1978. Arlington, Texas. 39, 45, 54, 62, 68, 94–95, 100, 106, 108–109.
  10. Web site: Swiss Avenue - Texas Historical Markers on Waymarking.com. www.waymarking.com. 2016-10-28.
  11. Web site: Swiss Avenue: Where Dallas History Lives – D Magazine. www.dmagazine.com. 2016-10-28.
  12. Book: Peak's Suburban Addition Historic District Official Ordinance. City of Dallas. 1995. Dallas, Texas. History section. 30.
  13. Book: The Making of A Historic District: Swiss Avenue, Dallas, Texas [Case Studies In Preservation 2]. Dunsavage. Lyn. Talkington. Virginia. U.S. National Trust for Historic Preservation. 1975. Washington, D.C..
  14. Web site: Details for Aldredge House. Texas Historical Commons.
  15. Web site: Spreadsheet of Historical Markers in Dallas County. Dallas County Historical Commission. 2016-10-28.
  16. Web site: Details for Cristler-Rodgers House. Texas Historical Commons.
  17. Web site: Details for George C. Greer House. Texas Historical Commons.
  18. Web site: FOOSHEE, MARION FRESENIUS. Fulton. Duncan T. III. 2010-06-12. www.tshaonline.org. 2016-10-28.
  19. Web site: Details for Harris-Savage House. Texas Historical Commons.
  20. Web site: Details for Robert and Marie Stubbs House House. Texas Historical Commons.
  21. Web site: Uncovered Texas Historical Markers Robert and Marie Stubbs House. www.uncoveredtexas.com. 2016-10-28.
  22. Web site: Details for the Louis Wagner Home. Texas Historical Commons.
  23. Web site: Details for The Louis Wagner Home (Atlas Number 5113006910). Texas Historical Commission. September 5, 2018.
  24. Book: Canavan, Patricia. history and guide to the Swiss Avenue Historic District: 1917-1922. University of Texas at Arlington. 1978. Arlington, Texas. 52, 55, 62, 63–64, 67–68, 71, 74, 89.
  25. Dallas Morning News - Jan 26, 1942 - Section I, Page: 1
  26. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Fourteenth Census of the United States: 1920--Population. State of Texas, County of Dallas, Justice Precinct No. 1, Dallas City, Part of voting precinct Belmont Addition, Bev Heaton, enumerator, Supervisor District 5, Enumeration District 81, Sheet No. 2B, 16 February 1920.
  27. Web site: KETTLER v. STEPHENS | 424 S.W.2d 454 (1968) | sw2d4541818 . Leagle.com . 2022-08-12.
  28. Book: The First 100 Presidents Of The Dallas Bar Association. Dallas Bar Association. 2009. Dallas, Texas.
  29. Web site: Carrie Marcus House on Swiss Hits Market. 23 April 2015. 2016-10-28.
  30. Web site: Aldredge House Tops Most Endangered Places List. 15 September 2015. 2016-10-28.
  31. News: Familiar and forgotten landmarks appear on Preservation Dallas' new 'Most Endangered List' Dallas City Hall Dallas News. 2015-09-15. Dallas News. 2016-10-28.
  32. News: Council Approves Addition to Home On Swiss Avenue. Saul. Michael. October 5, 2000. Dallas Morning News.
  33. News: David Dean - Chair - North Texas Crime Commission. North Texas Crime Commission. en-US. 2016-10-28.
  34. News: Swiss Misses: A Tempest in a Teacup over Azaleas and Moonlights Erupts into a Class War in Dallas' Swiss Avenue Historic District. Farley. Rose. October 30, 1997. Dallas Observer.
  35. News: Vacant Swiss Mansion Said Menace. February 7, 1973. Dallas Times Herald.
  36. News: Judge Knocks Hole in Plans for Swiss. Tatum. Henry. May 16, 1973. Dallas Morning News.
  37. Web site: Swiss Avenue Historic District. Dallas City Hall. 2019-11-09.
  38. Web site: 2019-20 William Lipscomb Elementary Attendance Zone Grades PK-5. Dallas Independent School District. 2019-11-09.
  39. Web site: 2019-20 J. L. Long Middle Attendance Zone Grades 6-8. Dallas Independent School District. 2019-11-09.
  40. Web site: 2019-20 Woodrow Wilson High Attendance Zone Grades 9-12. Dallas Independent School District. 2019-11-09.
  41. Web site: 2019-20 Cesar Chavez Elementary Attendance Zone Grades PK-5. Dallas Independent School District. 2019-11-09.
  42. Web site: 2019-20 Alex W. Spence Middle Attendance Zone Grades 6-8. Dallas Independent School District. 2019-11-09.
  43. Web site: 2019-20 North Dallas High Attendance Zone Grades 9-12. Dallas Independent School District. 2019-11-09.