Swatantra Party Explained

Party Name:Swatantra Party
Abbreviation:SWA
Foundation:4 June 1959
Dissolution:4 August 1974[1]
Founder:C. Rajagopalachari
Ideology:Conservatism (Indian)
Classical liberalism[2]
Liberal conservatism[3]
Secularism[4]
Agrarianism[5]
Position:Centre-right[6] [7]
Split:Indian National Congress
Merged:Bharatiya Lok Dal
Party Logo:Swatantra-Party-flag.svg

The Swatantra Party was an Indian classical liberal political party that existed from 1959 to 1974. It was founded by C. Rajagopalachari[8] in reaction to what he felt was the Jawaharlal Nehru-dominated Indian National Congress's increasingly socialist and statist outlook.[9]

The party had a number of distinguished leaders, most of them old Congressmen, like C. Rajagopalachari, Minoo Masani, N.G. Ranga, Darshan Singh Pheruman,[10] [11] Udham Singh Nagoke[12] and K.M. Munshi. The provocation for the formation of the party was the left turn that the Congress took at Avadi[13] and the Nagpur Resolutions.

Swatantra stood for a market-based economy and the dismantling of the "Licence Raj" although it opposed laissez-faire policies. Swatantra was not a religion-based party, unlike the Hindu nationalism of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh. In 1960, Rajagopalachari and his colleagues drafted a 21-point manifesto detailing why Swatantra had to be formed even though they had been Congressmen and associates of Nehru during the struggle for independence.[14] Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru was highly critical of Swatantra and dubbed it as belonging to "the middle ages of lords, castles and zamindars".[15]

In Parliament

N.G.Ranga rebuked the Nehru government for being ill-prepared in defence on November 8, 1962 in a speech during parliamentary debate.[16]

Minoo Masani, the party MP from Rajkot, voiced his opposition to the bank nationalisation bill by Indira Gandhi's government on 25 July, 1969.[17]

Electoral history

In the 1962 general election, the first after its formation, Swatantra received 7.89 percent of the total votes and won 18 seats in the third Lok Sabha (1962–67). It emerged as the main opposition to the dominant Congress in four states: Bihar, Rajasthan, Gujarat and Orissa. By the next general election in 1967, Swatantra had become a significant force in some parts of India; it won 8.7 percent of the votes and became the single-largest opposition party in the fourth Lok Sabha (1967–71) with 44 seats. In 1971, Swatantra joined a "Grand Alliance" of parties from across the political spectrum that aimed to defeat Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. The party secured eight seats by winning 3% of the votes. The next year, in 1972, its founder, Rajagopalachari, died, and Swatantra declined rapidly. By 1974, it had dissolved, with many of its members joining the Charan Singh-led Bharatiya Lok Dal.

Year data-sort-type="text" Election Popular-
vote
Seats
1962 data-sort-value="1962 Indian general election"1962 Indian general election7.9 % data-sort-value="18"[18]
1967 data-sort-value="1962 Indian general election"1967 Indian general election8.7 % data-sort-value="44"
1971 data-sort-value="1962 Indian general election"1971 Indian general election3.1 % data-sort-value="8"

Ideology

Fundamental principles

First and foremost, the Swatantra Party committed to social justice and equality of opportunity of all people "without distinction of religion, caste, occupation, or political affiliation".[19]

The party felt that progress, welfare and happiness of the people could be achieved by giving maximum freedom to individuals with the state minimising intervention. The state should replace its intervention with fostering the Indian tradition of helping other people directly.

In particular, the party believed that the state should adhere to the Fundamental Rights guaranteed by the Constitution of India and, in particular, should compensate individuals if their property had to be acquired for public purposes. It also believed in giving citizens full freedom to educate their children as they wanted. It recognised the need for increasing food production and sought to do so by giving peasants full land rights and incentives for increasing production in agriculture. In industry, it sought to reduce state presence only to the minimum necessary to supplement private enterprise and in national services like the Indian Railways. It sought to do away with controls on trade and commerce. However, it committed against unreasonable profits, prices and dividends. It believed in placing equal emphasis on the development of capital goods industries, consumer goods industries and rural and small industries. In the fields of taxation and state expenditure, it believed in thrift and called for taxation to suffice for carrying on of administration and social and economic activities taken upon by the state but should not depress capital formation and private investment. The government should also desist from running abnormally large deficits or taking foreign loans that are beyond the capacity of the country to repay. In particular, it resisted unnecessary expansion of the bureaucracy.

While standing for minimising state intervention in the economy, the Swatantra Party committed to securing a fair deal for labour, correlating wages to increased productivity and workers' right to collective bargaining. It also gave their members full freedom to question and criticise any point not included in the fundamental principles of that party.

Others

Party's fundamental principles had not covered several issues like foreign policy, national language, state reorganisation and religious and social reform.

The party was generally opposed to communism and in 1969, urged the Indian government to ban the three major communist parties in India at that time, the CPI, CPI(M) and the Naxalites, because of their open or tacit support for armed struggles, which the Swatantra Party viewed as a major security threat to the nation.[20]

In foreign affairs, it opposed non-alignment and a close relationship with the Soviet Union and advocated an intimate connection with the United States and Western Europe.[21]

Decline and legacy

In 1969, the Congress party split, leading to consolidation of right-leaning votes under Congress (O).This proved detrimental to the electoral prospects of the Swatantra party.[22] By 1971,the Swatantra party had disintegrated due to infighting and changed political scenarios.[23]
The party made some tactical mistakes like joining the Grand Alliance against Indira Gandhi's Congress in 1971 instead of fighting on an issue-based common programme.This resulted in the decimation of the party in the elections of that year.
After the death of Rajaji in 1972, personality clashes took a further toll.All this occurred while Indira Gandhi pressurised the royalty to support her. This resulted in Swatantra losing the backing of princes. Another potential benefactor,the business community couldn't advocate for the party since they were too reliant on state patronage.[24] Moreover, big business houses like Birla benefitted from the protectionist aspects of the Nehruvian state and didn't see Swatantra policies as being advantageous.[25]
Finally the party was dissolved on August 4, 1974 by party president Piloo Mody who merged it with Charan Singh's Bharatiya Kranti Dal.The few independent state units except for Maharashtra later merged with Janata Party in 1977.[26]

See also

Sources

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 45 years after its dissolution, here's what opposition parties must learn from Swatantra Party. dailyO. 18 July 2019. 6 July 2024.
  2. Book: Das, Gurcharan. The Elephant Paradigm. 244. 2002. Penguin.
  3. Book: Pratapchandra Rasam, Vasanti. Swatantra Party: a political biography. 1997. 199. Dattsons.
  4. Book: Smith, Donald E.. South Asian Politics and Religion. 110. 1966. Princeton University Press.
  5. Web site: The contemporary relevance of Swatantra Party’s liberal view. Rajadhyaksha. Niranjan. 2019-05-28. Mint. en. 2024-01-13.
  6. Book: Raghbendra Jha . Facets of India's Economy and Her Society Volume I . 2014 . 263 . Springer .
  7. Book: Rudra Chaudhuri . Forged in Crisis: India and the United States Since 1947 . 2014 . 100 . Oxford University Press, Incorporated .
  8. Web site: C. Rajagopalachari Why Swatantra?. Rajagopalachari. C.. 2016-07-16. Mint. en. 2019-03-24.
  9. Book: Erdman , H.L. . The Swatantra Party and Indian Conservatism . Cambridge University Press . Cambridge South Asian Studies . 2007 . 978-0521049801 . 2019-07-02 . 2, 62–63, 75.
  10. Book: Singh. Ranjit. Sikh Achievers. 2008. Hemkunt Publishers. New Delhi, India. 978-8170103653. 36 - 37.
  11. Web site: Darshan Signh Pheruman (1885 - 1969). 20 January 2015. https://web.archive.org/web/20150105014455/http://www.sikh-history.com/sikhhist/personalities/sewadars/pheruman.html. 5 January 2015. dead. dmy-all.
  12. Web site: Fifty Years of Punjab Politics (1920-70). Panjab Digital Library. 2019-07-21.
  13. Web site: Long way from Avadi. Ramakrishnan. Venkitesh. 2012-09-22. frontline.thehindu.com. 2019-08-12.
  14. http://www.liberalpartyofindia.sabhlokcity.com/party/21prin.doc The 21 Principles of the Swatantra Party
  15. Erdman, 1963–64.
  16. Web site: Swatantra Party had a lot to say on China after 1962. If only Nehru had heard them. Kashyap. Sanjeet. 2020-07-22. The Print. en. 2024-07-06.
  17. Web site: For Minoo Masani, Indira Gandhi’s bank nationalisation Bill ‘came in the dark, like a thief’. Masani. Minoo. 2024-01-28. The Print. en. 2024-07-06.
  18. Web site: Statistical Report On General Elections, 1962 To The Third Lok Sabha . Election Commission of India . 30 April 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140718185518/http://eci.nic.in/eci_main/StatisticalReports/LS_1962/Vol_I_LS_62.pdf. 18 July 2014.
  19. Web site: Statement of Principles of the Swatantra Party, Principle 1. Indian Liberals. 23 December 2017.
  20. News: From the Archives (May 13, 1969): Swatantra urges ban on Communist Parties. 2019-05-13. The Hindu. 2019-08-12. en-IN. 0971-751X.
  21. Erdman. Howard L.. 1963. India's Swatantra Party. Pacific Affairs. 36. 4. 394–410. 10.2307/2754685. 2754685. 0030-851X.
  22. Web site: Why Today's India Needs a Resurrected Swatantra Party. The Wire. 17 January 2021. 6 July 2024.
  23. Web site: India’s journey in Conservatism. The Hindu Business Line . 7 September 2023. 6 July 2024.
  24. Web site: When Maharajas, business tycoons and peasant leaders joined the mundu-clad Rajaji to form the Swatantra Party. The Print. 3 February 2018. 6 July 2024.
  25. Web site: Masani, Rajaji and Shenoy — the free-market troika that challenged the Nehruvian State. Kashyap. Sanjeet. 2020-11-16. The Print. en. 2024-07-06.
  26. Web site: A Case For Swatantra. Outlook India. 5 February 2022. 6 July 2024.