| Susan Brownlow Boynton | |
| Birth Name: | Susan Brownlow |
| Birth Date: | 23 July 1837 |
| Birth Place: | Kingsport, Tennessee, U.S. |
| Death Place: | Mountville, Pennsylvania, U.S. |
| Known For: | Loyalty to U.S. during American Civil War |
Susan Brownlow Sawyers Boynton (July 23, 1837 – March 12, 1913) was a folk heroine of the American Civil War. The story, popularized by her father's book tour in 1862–63, was that Confederate soldiers had come to their family home demanding she pull down the Stars and Stripes, the flag of the United States. At great personal risk to herself she defended the family's and the nation's flag by running off the Rebels with a loaded pistol.
Brownlow was from a Southern Unionist family of East Tennesseeans. Her father was the Fighting Parson, and her two brothers were notable Union cavalry officers: John "Belt" Brownlow, who commanded the 9th Tennessee during the war, and Jim Brownlow, the storied colonel of the 1st Tennessee.
Susan Brownlow was born July 23, 1837, in Kingsport, Sullivan County, the first of William Gannaway Brownlow and Eliza O'Brien's eight children.[1] Susan Brownlow was twice married. Susan Brownlow married first in October 1856 to James Houston Sawyers, a 24-year-old doctor. Dr. Sawyers contracted a contagious disease from one of his patients, dying young on May 22, 1858, leaving Susan widowed and six months pregnant.[2] As a consequence, she moved back into her parents' Knoxville home, the one she became famous for defending.[3] Her daughter Lillie Brownlow Sawyers was born September 9, 1858, and would have been about two or three years old at the time of the incident, which occurred in the first year or two of the war. Susan's four little sisters would likely have also been present in the home: 12-year-old Mary, nine-year-old Fanny, and the six-year-old twins Caledonia and Ann.
She accompanied her father on his 1862 book tour and was presented with a silk flag in Philadelphia and a Colt revolver in Connecticut.[4] Her story was retold in quasi-fictionalized form in the 1864 book Miss Martha Brownlow, or the Heroine of Tennessee. Major Reynolds, the author of the book, changed the main character's name from Susan Sawyers to Martha Brownlow for unknown reasons, perhaps to avoid needing to pay her royalties or possibly for security during the ongoing war.[5]
She was remarried in 1865 to Dr. Daniel Boynton, a Knoxville physician, with whom she had three daughters, Lucile, Ednee, and Ilia, and a son, who also became a doctor.[6] Daniel Tucker Boynton had been an assistant surgeon with the 104th Ohio Infantry during the war and afterward became a federal pension agent in Knoxville.[7] At some point Susan had a sixth child who died young. Susan's second husband, Dr. Boynton, died January 7, 1888. Susan B. Boynton died of uraemia in Mountville, Pennsylvania, a suburb of Lancaster, at home of her son Dr. Emerson Boynton, in 1913.[8] She was buried in the family plot at Old Gray Cemetery in Knoxville not far from the graves of both of her husbands.[9] Susan Boynton's chief characteristics were said to be "unfailing cheerfulness and generosity."