Steam whistle explained

A steam whistle is a device used to produce sound in the form of a whistle using live steam, which creates, projects, and amplifies its sound by acting as a vibrating system.[1]

Operation

The whistle consists of the following main parts, as seen on the drawing: the whistle bell (1), the steam orifice or aperture (2), and the valve (9).

When the lever (10) is actuated (usually via a pull cord), the valve opens and lets the steam escape through the orifice. The steam will alternately compress and rarefy in the bell, creating the sound. The pitch, or tone, is dependent on the length of the bell; and also how far the operator has opened the valve. Some locomotive engineers invented their own distinctive style of whistling.

Uses of steam whistles

Steam whistles were often used in factories and similar places to signal the start or end of a work shift, etc. Steam railway locomotives, traction engines, and steam ships have traditionally been fitted with a steam whistle for warning and communication purposes. Large diameter, low-pitched steam whistles were used on light houses, likely beginning in the 1850s.[2]

The earliest use of steam whistles was as boiler low-water alarms[3] in the 18th century[4] and early 19th century.[5] During the 1830s, whistles were adopted by railroads[6] and steamship companies.[7]

Railway whistles

Steam warning devices have been used on trains since 1833,[8] when George Stephenson invented and patented a steam trumpet for use on the Leicester and Swannington Railway.[9] Period literature makes a distinction between a steam trumpet and a steam whistle.[10] A copy of the trumpet drawing signed May 1833 shows a device about eighteen inches high with an ever-widening trumpet shape with a six-inch diameter at its top or mouth. It is said that George Stephenson invented his trumpet after an accident on the Leicester and Swannington Railway where a train hit either a cart, or a herd of cows, on a level crossing and there were calls for a better way of giving a warning. Although no-one was injured, the accident was deemed serious enough to warrant Stephenson's personal intervention. One account states that [driver] Weatherburn had 'mouthblown his horn' at the crossing in an attempt to prevent the accident, but that no attention had been paid to this audible warning, perhaps because it had not been heard.

Stephenson subsequently called a meeting of directors and accepted the suggestion of the company manager, Ashlin Bagster, that a horn or whistle which could be activated by steam should be constructed and fixed to the locomotives. Stephenson later visited a musical instrument maker on Duke Street in Leicester, who on Stephenson's instructions constructed a 'Steam Trumpet' which was tried out in the presence of the board of Directors ten days later.

Stephenson mounted the trumpet on the top of the boiler's steam dome, which delivers dry steam to the cylinders. The company went on to mount the device on its other locomotives

Locomotive steam trumpets were soon replaced by steam whistles. Air whistles were used on some diesel and electric locomotives, but these mostly employ air horns.

Music

An array of steam whistles arranged to play music is referred to as a calliope.

In York, Pennsylvania, a variable pitch steam whistle at the New York Wire Company has been played annually on Christmas Eve since 1925 (except in 1986 and 2005) in what has come to be known as "York's Annual Steam Whistle Christmas Concert". On windy nights, area residents report hearing the concert as far as 12 to 15 miles away. The whistle, which is in the Guinness Book of World Records, was powered by an air compressor during the 2010 concert due to the costs of maintaining and running the boiler.[11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16]

Lighthouse fog signals

Beginning in 1869,[17] steam whistles began being installed at lighthouse stations as a way of warning mariners in periods of fog, when the lighthouse is not visible. 10" diameter whistles were used as fog signals throughout the United States for many years, until they were later replaced by other compressed air diaphragm or diaphone horns.

Types of whistles

Whistle acoustics

Resonant frequency

A whistle has a characteristic natural resonant frequency[30] that can be detected by gently blowing human breath across the whistle rim, much as one might blow over the mouth of a bottle. The active sounding frequency (when the whistle is blown on steam) may differ from the natural frequency as discussed below. These comments apply to whistles with a mouth area at least equal to the cross-sectional area of the whistle.

Sound pressure level

Whistle sound level varies with several factors:

Terminology

Acoustic length [75] or effective length [76] is the quarter wavelength generated by the whistle. It is calculated as one quarter the ratio of speed of sound to the whistle's frequency. Acoustic length may differ from the whistle's physical length,[77] also termed geometric length.[78] depending upon mouth configuration, etc.[30] The end correction is the difference between the acoustic length and the physical length above the mouth. The end correction is a function of diameter whereas the ratio of acoustic length to physical length is a function of scale. These calculations are useful in whistle design to obtain a desired sounding frequency. Working length in early usage meant whistle acoustic length, i.e., the effective length of the working whistle,[79] but recently has been used for physical length including the mouth.[80]

Loudest and largest whistles

Loudness is a subjective perception that is influenced by sound pressure level, sound duration, and sound frequency.[73] [74] High sound pressure level potential has been claimed for the whistles of Vladimir Gavreau,[81] who tested whistles as large as 1.5 meter (59-inch) diameter (37 Hz).[82]

A 20-inch diameter ring-shaped whistle (“Ultrawhistle”) patented and produced by Richard Weisenberger sounded 124 decibels at 100 feet.[83] The variable pitch steam whistle at the New York Wire Company in York, Pennsylvania, was entered in the Guinness Book of World Records in 2002 as the loudest steam whistle on record at 124.1dBA from used by Guinness.[84] The York whistle was also measured at 134.1 decibels from a distance of 23-feet.[12]

A fire-warning whistle supplied to a Canadian saw mill by the Eaton, Cole, and Burnham Company in 1882 measured 20 inches in diameter, four feet nine inches from bowl to ornament, and weighed 400 pounds. The spindle supporting the whistle bell measured 3.5 inches diameter and the whistle was supplied by a four-inch feed pipe.[85] [86]

Other records of large whistles include an 1893 account of U.S. President Grover Cleveland activating the “largest steam whistle in the world,” said to be “five feet” at the Chicago World's Fair.[87] [88]

The sounding chamber of a whistle installed at the 1924 Long-Bell Lumber Company, Longview, Washington measured 16 inches diameter x 49 inches in length.[89]

The whistle bells of multi-bell chimes used on ocean liners such as the RMS Titanic measured 9, 12, and 15 inches diameter.[90]

The whistle bells of the Canadian Pacific steamships Assiniboia and Keewatin measured 12 inches in diameter and that of the Keewatin measured 60 inches in length.[91] [92]

A multi-bell chime whistle installed at the Standard Sanitary Manufacturing Company in 1926 was composed of five separate whistle bells measuring 5 x15, 7 x 21, 8x 24, 10 x 30, and 12 x36 inches, all plumbed to a five-inch steam pipe.[93]

The Union Water Meter Company of Worcester Massachusetts produced a composed of three bells, 8 x 9-3/4, 12 x 15, and 12 x 25 inches.[94] Twelve-inch diameter steam whistles were commonly used at light houses in the 19th century.[95]

It has been claimed that the sound level of an Ultrawhistle would be significantly greater than that of a conventional whistle,[96] but comparative tests of large whistles have not been undertaken. Tests of small Ultrawhistles have not shown higher sound levels compared to conventional whistles of the same diameter.[70]

See also

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Chanaud . Robert . Aerodynamic whistles . . 1970 . 222 . 223 . 40–46 . 10.1038/scientificamerican0170-40 . 1970SciAm.222a..40C.
  2. Book: Jones, Ray . 2003 . The Lighthouse Encyclopedia . Globe Pequot Press . 0-7627-2735-7.
  3. Web site: Miller's Steam Boiler Alarm and Water Gage . lincolnarchives.us . 2007-09-08 . https://web.archive.org/web/20080328101643/http://www.lincolnarchives.us/index.php?act=election1860%2Fsciencetech&sub=invention01221859 . 2008-03-28 . dead.
  4. Book: Stuart, Robert . 1829 . Historical and Descriptive Anecdotes of Steam Engines and of their Inventors and Improvers . London . Wightman and Cramp . 301.
  5. Ommundsen . Peter . 2007 . Pre-1830 steam whistles . Horn and Whistle . 117 . 14.
  6. Book: Wood, Nicholas . A Practical Treatise on Rail-roads, and Interior Communication in General ... . Longman, Orme, Brown, Green, & Longmans . Making of the modern world . 1838 . 340.
  7. Pringle . R.E. . J. . Parkes . 1839 . The causes and means of prevention of steam-boat accidents . Mechanics Magazine . 31. 262.
  8. Book: Stretton, C.E. . The Locomotive Engine and Its Development: A Popular Treatise on the Gradual Improvements Made in Railway Engines Between 1803 and 1903 . Crosby Lockwood . Weale's scientific and technical series . 1903 .
  9. Book: Ross, David . The Willing Servant: A History of the Steam Locomotive . 2004 . 0-7524-2986-8 . Tempus . 42.
  10. Book: Russell, John Scott . 1841 . A Treatise on the Steam Engine . Adam and Charles Black . Edinburgh.
  11. Web site: York steam whistle ready to play -- without the steam. www.inyork.com.
  12. Web site: York Town Square. 2010-12-25. https://web.archive.org/web/20101227095721/http://www.yorkblog.com/yorktownsquare/2008/12/new-york-wire-cloth.html. 2010-12-27. dead.
  13. Web site: Steam whistle player's hospitalization won't stop concert. ydr.com. 2010-12-25. 2010-12-19. https://web.archive.org/web/20101219231527/http://www.ydr.com/local/ci_16886613. dead.
  14. Web site: York Town Square. 2010-12-25. https://web.archive.org/web/20101228192536/http://www.yorkblog.com/yorktownsquare/2007/12/new-york-wires-musical-factory.html. 2010-12-28. dead.
  15. York Pa wire company. https://ghostarchive.org/varchive/youtube/20211213/AwGLjW435XU . 2021-12-13 . live. YouTube.
  16. Web site: Has the steam whistle played its last Christmas carol? . The York Daily Record . 2009-12-26 . https://web.archive.org/web/20091229105549/http://ydr.inyork.com/ci_14070122 . 2009-12-29 . dead .
  17. Web site: The History of Fog Signals by Wayne Wheeler US Lighthouse Society. 2021-07-21. uslhs.org.
  18. Dampflokpfeifen / The Whistles of Steamtrains. https://ghostarchive.org/varchive/youtube/20211213/qoR1vsnr8SE . 2021-12-13 . live. YouTube.
  19. Patent . US. 186718 . Improvement in steam-whistles.
  20. SL津和野稲荷号 走行シーン SL "Tsuwano-inari " Running scene. https://ghostarchive.org/varchive/youtube/20211213/MTuX3qExokE . 2021-12-13 . live. YouTube.
  21. Patent . US. 48921 . Improvement in steam-whistles.
  22. Patent . US. 131176 . Improvement in steam-whistles.
  23. Patent . US. 2755767 . High power generators of sounds and ultra-sounds.
  24. Patent . US. 2678625 . Resonant sound signal device.
  25. Patent . US. 2013291784. Directional Isophasic Toroidal Whistle.
  26. Patent . US. 4429656 . Toroidal shaped closed chamber whistle.
  27. Patent . US. 4686928 . Toroidal whistle.
  28. Fagen . Ed . 1996 . Technical talk about flue pipes, cavities, and Helmholtz resonators . Horn and Whistle . 71 . 8.
  29. Bangham . Larry . 2002 . The Resonator Whistle . Steam in the Garden . 66 and 67 . Horn and Whistle (101): 12-15.
  30. Web site: Liljencrants . Johan . 2006 . End correction at a flue pipe mouth.
  31. Tohyama, M. (2011) Sound and Signals. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 389 pp.
  32. Ommundsen . Peter . 2003 . Effects of pressure on whistle frequency . Horn and Whistle . 101 . 18.
  33. Science Magazine, Volume 2, No. 46 December 21, 1883 page 799.
  34. Book: Elliott, Brian S. . 2006 . Compressed Air Operations Manual . McGraw-Hill . New York . 0-07-147526-5.
  35. Book: Crocker, Malcolm J. . 1998 . Handbook of Acoustics . Wiley . New York . 0-471-25293-X.
  36. Book: Lerner, L.S. . Physics for Scientists and Engineers . Jones and Bartlett . Physics Series . 1 . 1996 . 978-0-86720-479-7.
  37. Book: Heisler, S.I. . The Wiley Engineer's Desk Reference: A Concise Guide for the Professional Engineer . Wiley . 1998 . 978-0-471-16827-0 . 266–267.
  38. Book: Menon, E. Sashi . 2005 . Piping Calculations Manual . New York . McGraw-Hill.
  39. Ommundsen. Peter (2012). "Whistle steam and air consumption." Horn and Whistle (127):4.
  40. Gilbert . T.M. . 1897 . A test of the steam consumption of a locomotive whistle . Sibley Journal of Engineering . 11 . 108–110.
  41. Ommundsen, Peter (2013). "Steam whistle harmonics and whistle length." Horn and Whistle 129:31-33
  42. Fletcher . N. H. . Nonlinear interactions in organ flue pipes . The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America . Acoustical Society of America (ASA) . 56 . 2 . 1974-08-01 . 0001-4966 . 10.1121/1.1903303 . 645–652. 1974ASAJ...56..645F . free .
  43. Fletcher . N. H. . Douglas . Lorna M. . Harmonic generation in organ pipes, recorders, and flutes . The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America . Acoustical Society of America (ASA) . 68 . 3 . 1980-09-01 . 0001-4966 . 10.1121/1.384815 . 767–771. 1980ASAJ...68..767F . 1885/213247 . free .
  44. Šafarík . Pavel . Nový . Adam . Jícha . David . Hajšman . Miroslav . On the Speed of Sound in Steam . Acta Polytechnica . Czech Technical University in Prague - Central Library . 55 . 6 . 2015-12-31 . 1805-2363 . 10.14311/ap.2015.55.0422 . 422. free . 10467/67225 . free .
  45. Book: Soo, S.L. . Particulates And Continuum-Multiphase Fluid Dynamics: Multiphase Fluid Dynamics . Taylor & Francis . 1989 . 978-0-89116-918-5 .
  46. Ommundsen, Peter (2017). Estimating speed of sound in steam. Horn and Whistle (136) 17.
  47. Web site: Pipe sensitivity . Johan Liljencrants on organs, pipes, air supply . 2011-10-30 .
  48. Web site: Liljencrants . Johan . 2006 . Q value of a pipe resonator.
  49. Ommundsen . Peter . 2004 . Whistle mouth area and lip height in relation to manifold pressure . Horn and Whistle . 103 . 7–8.
  50. Atchison, Topeka, and Santa Fe Railway 1925 engineering drawing, published 1984, Horn and Whistle 13:12-13.
  51. Ommundsen . Peter . 2005 . Effect of mouth size on frequency of a single bell chime whistle . Horn and Whistle . 110 . 29–30.
  52. Ommundsen . Peter . 2007 . Observations on whistle cut-up and frequency . Horn and Whistle . 116 . 4–7.
  53. Airchime Manufacturing Company, May 15, 1960, Steam Whistle Installation: Adjustments. Horn and Whistle Magazine No. 25, page 37, July – August 1986.
  54. Nathan Manufacturing Company 1910, December 3, General Information, Pattern 30146.
  55. Ommundsen . Peter . 2007 . Factors to consider in whistle slot width prescriptions . Horn and Whistle . 115 . 6–8.
  56. Ommundsen . Peter . 2006 . Observations on whistle resonance frequency . Horn and Whistle . 112 . 7–8.
  57. Barry, Harry, and Peter Ommundsen. (2012). "Whistle frequency differences on steam vs. compressed air." Horn and Whistle 126:5 - 6.
  58. Burrows . Lewis M. . 1957 . Patent . 2784693., column 5, lines 29-31
  59. Ommundsen . Peter . 2005 . Effect of slot width on whistle performance . Horn and Whistle . 109 . 31–32.
  60. Barry, Harry and Peter Ommundsen (2015). "Whistle sound levels revisited." Horn and Whistle (133):4-5.
  61. Burrows . Lewis M. . 1957 . Patent . 2784693., column 5, lines 30-34
  62. Barry . Harry . 2002 . Sound levels of my whistles . Horn and Whistle . 98 . 19.
  63. Weisenberger . Richard . 1983 . The loudest whistle . Horn and Whistle . 6 . 7–9.
  64. Carruthers . James A. . 1984 . More on loudest sounds . Horn and Whistle . 10 . 6.
  65. Elias . I. . 1962 IRE National Convention . Evaluation and Applications of the Levavasseur Whistle . IEEE . 1962 . 36–42 . 10.1109/irenc.1962.199221.
  66. BIRCH . A. D. . BROWN . D. R. . DODSON . M. G. . SWAFFIELD . F. . The Structure and Concentration Decay of High Pressure Jets of Natural Gas . Combustion Science and Technology . Informa UK Limited . 36 . 5–6 . 1984 . 0010-2202 . 10.1080/00102208408923739 . 249–261.
  67. Außerlechner . Hubert J. . Trommer . Thomas . Angster . Judit . Miklós . András . Experimental jet velocity and edge tone investigations on a foot model of an organ pipe . The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America . Acoustical Society of America (ASA) . 126 . 2 . 2009-08-01 . 0001-4966 . 10.1121/1.3158935 . 878–886. 19640052 . 2009ASAJ..126..878A .
  68. Burrows . Lewis M. . 1957 . Patent . 2784693., column 5, lines 20-28.
  69. Rhodes, Tom (1984). Building a steamboat whistle. Live Steam, November:42-44.
  70. Ommundsen . Peter . 2008 . The Levavasseur toroidal whistle and other loud whistles . Horn and Whistle . 119 . 5.
  71. Ommundsen, Peter (2009). "Whistle engineering questions". Horn and Whistle (121): 26–27.
  72. Fagen . Edward . 2005 . Whistles as Sound Sources . Horn and Whistle . 107 . 18–24.
  73. Fagen . Edward . 2005 . Whistles as Sound Sources, Part 2 . Horn and Whistle . 108 . 35–39.
  74. Book: Piercy . J.E. . Tony F.W. . Embleton . 1979 . Sound propagation in the open air . Harris . Cyril M. . Handbook of Noise Control . Second . New York . McGraw-Hill.
  75. Book: Talbot-Smith, Michael . 1999 . Audio Engineer's Reference Book . Focal . Oxford . 2nd . 0-7506-0386-0.
  76. Book: Serway, Raymond A. . 1990 . Physics for Scientists and Engineers . Philadelphia . Saunders College Publishing . 0-03-005922-4.
  77. Book: Rossing, T.D. . The Science of Sound . Addison-Wesley Publishing Company . 1990 . 978-0-201-15727-7.
  78. Book: Fahy, F.J. . Foundations of Engineering Acoustics . Elsevier Science . 2000 . 978-0-08-050683-8 .
  79. Book: Hadley, H.E. . Everyday Physics . Macmillan and Company, limited . 1926 .
  80. Weisenberger, Richard (1986). Mathematics for the whistle builder. Horn and Whistle 23:10-16.
  81. Altmann . Jürgen . Acoustic weapons ‐ a prospective assessment . Science & Global Security . Informa UK Limited . 9 . 3 . 2001 . 0892-9882 . 10.1080/08929880108426495 . 165–234. 2001S&GS....9..165A . 31795453 .
  82. Gavreau . V. . 1968 . Infrasound . Science Journal . 4 . 33–37.
  83. Weisenberger, Richard (1983). The loudest whistle. Horn and Whistle 6:7-9.
  84. Web site: Loudest whistle, steam . Guinness World Records . 2002-12-12 .
  85. The New York Times, May 26, 1882.
  86. The Chronicle – a journal devoted to the interests of insurance. Vol xxix page 346 1882.
  87. Book: Crofford, Maurice . The Rich Cut Glass of Charles Guernsey Tuthill . Texas A&M University Press . College Station . 2001 . 978-1-58544-148-8 . 64.
  88. News: FEATURES OF THE OPENING.; People Likely to Jump When the President Touches the Button at Chicago. . The New York Times . April 27, 1893 .
  89. Drummond, Michael (1996) Steam whistle buffs abuzz over Big Benjamin. The daily News of Longview Washington, December 21, reprinted in Horn and Whistle 75:8-9.
  90. Fagen, Ed (1997). Titanic’s whistle blow a bit less than titanic. Horn and whistle 75:8-11.
  91. Barry, Harry (1983). The Assiniboia steam whistle. Horn and Whistle 4:13-14
  92. Barry, Harry (1998). A survey of large whistles. Horn and Whistle 79:6-7
  93. Louisville Herald, June 8, 1926.
  94. Barry, Harry (2002). The twelve inch diameter, three bell Union Water meter gong whistle. Horn and Whistle 98:14-15.
  95. Clarke . F.L. . 1888 . Fog and fog signals on the pacific coast . Overland Monthly . 12 . 353.
  96. For example, Weisenberger, Richard (1986). Build an eight inch super whistle: an introduction to the toroidal whistle. Horn and Whistle 25:4-6.