Holy Lance Explained

The Holy Lance, also known as the Spear of Longinus (named after Saint Longinus), the Spear of Destiny, or the Holy Spear, is alleged to be the lance that pierced the side of Jesus as he hung on the cross during his crucifixion. As with other instruments of the Passion, the lance is only briefly mentioned in the Christian Bible, but later became the subject of extrabiblical traditions in the medieval church. Relics purported to be the lance began to appear as early as the 6th century, originally in Jerusalem. By the Late Middle Ages, relics identified as the spearhead of the Holy Lance (or fragments thereof) had been described throughout Europe. Several of these artifacts are still preserved to this day.

Holy Lance relics have typically been used for religious ceremonies, but at times some of them have been considered to be guarantees of victory in battle. For example, Henry the Fowler's lance was credited for winning the Battle of Riade, and the Crusaders believed their discovery of a Holy Lance brought them a favorable end to the Siege of Antioch.

In the modern era, at least four major relics are claimed to be the Holy Lance or parts of it. They are located in Rome, Vienna, Vagharshapat and Antioch. The most prominent Holy Lance relic has been the one in Vienna, adorned with a distinctive gold cuff. This version of the lance is on public display with the rest of the Imperial Regalia at the Hofburg.

Biblical references

See main article: Longinus.

The lance (Greek, Modern (1453-);: λόγχη,) is mentioned in the Gospel of John,[1] but not in the Synoptic Gospels. The gospel states that the Romans planned to break Jesus' legs, a practice known as Latin: crurifragium, which was a method of hastening death during a crucifixion. Because it was the eve of the Sabbath (Friday sundown to Saturday sundown), the followers of Jesus needed to "entomb" him because of Sabbath laws. Just before they did so, they noticed that Jesus was already dead and that there was no reason to break his legs ("and no bone will be broken").[2] To make sure that he was dead, a Roman soldier (named in extra-Biblical tradition as Longinus) stabbed him in the side.

The name of the soldier who pierced Christ's side with a is not given in the Gospel of John, but in the oldest known references to the legend, the apocryphal Gospel of Nicodemus appended to late manuscripts of the 4th century Acts of Pilate, the soldier is identified as a centurion and called Longinus (making the spear's Latin name Latin: Lancea Longini).[3] [4]

A form of the name Longinus occurs in the Rabula Gospels in the year 586. In a miniature, the name is written above the head of the soldier who is thrusting his lance into Christ's side. This is one of the earliest records of the name, if the inscription is not a later addition.

Relics

Rome

A Holy Lance relic is preserved at Saint Peter's Basilica in Vatican City, in a loggia carved into the pillar above the statue of Saint Longinus.[5] [6]

The earliest known references to Holy Lance relics date to the 6th century. The Breviary of Jerusalem (circa 530) describes the lance on display at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.[7] [3] In his Expositio Psalmorum (ca. 540-548),[8] Cassiodorus asserts the continued presence of the lance in Jerusalem.[9] A report by the Piacenza pilgrim (ca. 570) places the lance in the Church of Zion.[10] [11] Gregory of Tours described the lance and other relics of the Passion in his Libri Miraculorum (ca. 574-594).[12] [13] The holy lance is also supposed to have been stolen from Rome by Alaric and his Visigoths during their plundering in August 410. Therefore it could have been buried together with Alaric among tons of gold, silver and the golden menorah in Cosenza, southern Italy in the fall of 410. Nobody has found Alaric’s tomb and treasure that was probably emptied by the Byzantines, and therefore the holy lance could possibly appear some hundred years later in Jerusalem.

In 614, Jerusalem was captured by the Sasanian general Shahrbaraz.[14] The Chronicon Paschale says that the Holy Lance was among the relics captured, but one of Shahrbaraz's associates gave it to Nicetas who brought it to the Hagia Sophia in Constantinople later that year.[14] [15] However, De locis sanctis, describing the pilgrimage of Arculf in 670, places the lance in Jerusalem, at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.[16] Arculf is the last of the medieval pilgrims to report the lance in Jerusalem, as Willibald and Bernard made no mention of it.[17]

By the middle of the 10th century, a lance relic was venerated in Constantinople at the Church of the Virgin of the Pharos.[18] [15] [19] The relic was likely viewed by some of the soldiers and clergy participating in the First Crusade, adding to the confusion surrounding the emergence of another Holy Lance at Antioch in 1098.[20] During the Siege of Tripoli, Raymond of Toulose reportedly brought the Antioch lance to Constantinople, and presented it to Emperor Alexios I Komnenos.[21] [15] Scholars disagree on how this presumably awkward situation was resolved. Steven Runciman argued that the Byzantine court regarded the Antioch relic as a nail (ἧλος), relying on Raymond's ignorance of the Greek language to avoid offending him.[20] Alternatively, Edgar Robert Ashton Sewter believed that Alexios intended to denounce the crusaders' lance as a fraud,[22] and that this was accomplished when Prince Bohemond I of Antioch was compelled in 1108[15] to swear an oath to him on the other lance.[22] Whether Alexios kept the Antioch lance or returned it to Raymond is uncertain.[20] Several 12th century documents state that a single Holy Lance was among the relics at Constantinople, without any details that could identify it as either the crusaders' discovery or the Byzantine spear.[23] [24] [25] [26] [27]

According to Alberic of Trois-Fontaines, a fragment of the Holy Lance was set into the icon that Alexios V Doukas lost in battle with Henry of Flanders in 1204.[28] The capture of this icon by Henry's forces was considered important to many contemporary sources on the Fourth Crusade.[29] In addition to the crusaders' report to Pope Innocent III,[30] the incident was documented by Geoffrey of Villehardouin,[31] the Devastatio Constantinopolitana,[32] Niketas Choniates,[33] Robert de Clari,[29] Ralph of Coggeshall,[34] and Robert of Auxerre.[35] However, none of these sources mention the icon bearing any relics, whereas Alberic claimed it was adorned with the lance fragment, a portion of the Holy Shroud, one of Jesus's deciduous teeth, and other relics from thirty martyrs.[28] Modern historians have regarded Alberic's account with some skepticism, characterizing it as "fanciful"[36] and "pure invention."[37] In any case, after the battle the crusaders sent the icon to Cîteaux Abbey,[30] [29] but there is no record of whether it reached that destination.[30]

Following the sack of Constantinople, Robert de Clari described the spoils won by the newly-established Latin Empire, including "the iron of the lance with which Our Lord had His side pierced," in the Church of the Virgin of the Pharos.[29] However by the 1230s, the Latin Empire's financial state had grown desperate.[38] [39] In 1239, Baldwin II arranged to sell Constantinople's Crown of Thorns relic to King Louis IX of France.[38] Over the next several years, Baldwin sold a total of twenty-two relics to Louis.[15] [39] The Holy Lance was included in the final lot, which probably arrived at Paris in 1242.[38] [40] All of these relics were later enshrined in the Sainte Chapelle. During the French Revolution they were removed to the Bibliothèque Nationale, but the lance subsequently disappeared.

Despite the transfer of the Holy Lance to Paris, various travelers continued to report its presence in Constantinople throughout the late Byzantine period.[41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] Of particular interest, John Mandeville described the lance relics in both Paris and Constantinople, stating that the latter was much larger than the former.[42] Although the authenticity of Mandeville's travelogue is questionable,[51] the widespread popularity of the work demonstrates that the existence of multiple Holy Lance relics was public knowledge.[52]

The relics remaining in Constantinople, including the lance, were presumably seized by Sultan Mehmed II in 1453 when he conquered the city. In 1492, his son Bayezid II sent the lance to Pope Innocent VIII, to encourage the pope to continue to keep his brother and rival Cem prisoner.[53] At this time great doubts as to its authenticity were felt at Rome, as Johann Burchard records,[54] because of the presence of other rival lances in Paris, Nuremberg (see Holy Lance in Vienna below), and Armenia (see Holy Lance in Echmiadzin below). This relic has never since left Rome, and its resting place is at Saint Peter's. Innocent's tomb, created by Antonio del Pollaiuolo, features a bronze effigy of the pope holding the spear blade he received from Bayezid.[53]

In the mid-18th century Pope Benedict XIV states that he obtained an exact drawing of the Saint Chapelle lance, to compare it with the spearhead in St. Peter's. He concluded that former relic was the broken point missing from the latter, and that the two fragments had originally formed one blade.[55]

Vienna

The Holy Lance in Vienna is displayed in the Imperial Treasury or Weltliche Schatzkammer (lit. Worldly Treasure Room) at the Hofburg Palace in Vienna, Austria.[56] It is the head a typical winged lance of the Carolingian dynasty.[56] The shaft was presumably lost or destroyed by the reign of Conrad II (1024–1039), who commissioned the Reichskreuz ("Imperial Cross") to serve as a reliquary for the spearhead.

The spearhead is wrapped in a distinctive gold cuff, added by Charles IV around 1354. The cuff is inscribed with the Latin text "LANCEA ET CLAVVS DOMINI" ("The lance and nail of the Lord"), affirming that the lance was once used by Longinus and that one of the Holy Nails has been incorporated into the spearhead.[52] The gold cuff covers an older, silver cuff produced for Henry IV between 1084 and 1105, which also refers to the Holy Nail but identifies the spearhead as the lance of Saint Maurice. Gilded stripes on both sides of the silver cuff bear another Latin inscription: "CLAVVS DOMINICVS HEINRICVS D[EI] GR[ATI]A TERCIVS / ROMANO[RVM] IMPERATOR AVG[VSTVS] HOC ARGEN / TVM IVSSIT / FABRICARl AD CONFIRMATIONE[M] / CLAVI D[OMI]NI ET LANCEE SANCTI MAVRI / CII // SANCTVS MAVRICIVS" ("Nail of the Lord Henry by the Grace of God the Third, Emperor of the Romans and Augustus, ordered this silver piece to be made to reinforce the Nail of the Lord and the Lance of St. Maurice / Saint Maurice"). The inscription refers to Henry IV, the fourth of his name to reign as King of Germany, as "the third" because he was the third of his name crowned Holy Roman Emperor.

According to Liutprand of Cremona, the first German monarch to obtain the lance was King Henry the Fowler who purchased it in 926,[57] from King Rudolf II of Burgundy.[58] [59] Rudolf is supposed to have received the lance as a gift from a "Count Samson,",[58] about whom nothing else is known.[57] Liutprand associated the lance not with Longinus, but with Constantine the Great, citing a claim that the Roman emperor used the Holy Nails, discovered by his mother Helena, to make crosses in the middle of the spearhead.[58] [59] The description given by Liutprand closely corresponds to the relic kept in Vienna today.[57]

An alternative account of how Henry received the lance is offered by Widukind of Corvey. According to Widukind, King Conrad I of Germany made arrangements on his deathbed in 918 to send his royal insignia, including the Holy Lance, to Henry, who would succeed him as king of East Francia.[60] This version of events has been rejected by historians.[59]

On 15 March 933, Henry carried his lance as he led his forces against the Magyars in the Battle of Riade. From that point forward, the Ottonian dynasty regarded the lance as a talisman guaranteeing victory.[57] The timing of the battle—on the feast day of Longinus—indicates that by this time Henry associated the relic with the lance used in the crucifixion.[57] Along the same lines, it may be telling that Henry's son Otto the Great fought the Battle of Birten in the first half of March 939.[57] However, in 955 Otto sought support from Saint Lawrence to secure victory in the Battle of Lechfeld, which was planned to occur on Lawrence's feast day.[57] This shift may have resulted from the increased diplomatic ties between Germany and the Byzantine Empire circa 949/950. As the Germans became aware of the Byzantine version of the Holy Lance, it became politically inconvenient to associate the Ottonian lance with Longinus.[57] By 1008 the lance was identified with that of Saint Maurice,[57] who had been venerated by Otto the Great.[57]

Otto III commissioned two replicas of the lance. One of these was given to Prince Vajk of Hungary in 996, who was later crowned King Stephen I.[57] The other was presented to Duke of Poland, Bolesław I, at the Congress of Gniezno in 1000.[61] [62] The Polish lance is currently displayed in the John Paul II Cathedral Museum in Kraków.[63] The fate of the Hungarian lance is less clear. When Stephen's successor, Peter Orseolo was deposed in 1041, he sought the aid of German king Henry III, who captured the lance in the Battle of Ménfő. Whether Henry returned the lance to Peter upon his restoration is uncertain.[57] Shortly before World War I, a gold-inlaid spearhead, identified as a Germanic work from around the year 1000, was dredged from the Danube River near Budapest.[64] [65] The gold inlay suggests that this artifact could be Stephen's lance replica, but this has not been confirmed.[57]

In 1424, Sigismund had a collection of relics, including the lance, moved from his capital in Prague to his birthplace, Nuremberg, and decreed them to be kept there forever.[66] This collection was called the Imperial Regalia (German: Reichskleinodien).

When the French Revolutionary army approached Nuremberg in the spring of 1796, the local authorities turned over the Imperial Regalia to Johann Alois von Hügel, Chief Commissary of the Imperial Diet.[67] [68] Baron von Hügel took the regalia to Ratisbon for safekeeping, but by 1800 that city was also under threat of invasion, so he relocated them again to Passau, Linz, and Vienna.[67] When the French entered Vienna in 1805, the collection was moved again to Hungary, before ultimately returning to Vienna.[68] [67] These movements were conducted in secret, as the status of the regalia had not been resolved amid plans for the dissolution of the Holy Roman Empire. When Nuremberg later appealed for the return of the regalia, the city's requests were easily dismissed by the Austrian Empire.[68]

The Kunsthistorisches Museum has dated the lance to the 8th century.[56] Robert Feather, an English metallurgist and technical engineering writer, tested it for a documentary in January 2003.[69] Based on X-ray diffraction, fluorescence tests, and other noninvasive procedures, he dated the main body of the spear to the 7th century at the earliest.[69] Feather stated in the same documentary that an iron pin – long claimed to be a nail from the crucifixion, hammered into the blade and set off by tiny brass crosses – was "consistent" in length and shape with a 1st-century AD Roman nail.[69]

Not long afterward, researchers at the Interdisciplinary Research Institute for Archeology in Vienna used X-ray and other technology to examine a range of lances, and determined that the Vienna lance dates from around the 8th to the beginning of the 9th century, with the nail apparently being of the same metal, and ruled out the possibility of it dating back to the 1st century AD.[70]

The Hofburg spear has been re-imagined in popular culture as a magical talisman whose powers may be used for good or evil.[71]

Vagharshapat

A Holy Lance is conserved in Vagharshapat (previously known as Echmiadzin), the religious capital of Armenia. It was previously held in the monastery of Geghard.The first source that mentions it is a text Holy Relics of Our Lord Jesus Christ, in a thirteenth-century Armenian manuscript. According to this text, the spear which pierced Jesus was to have been brought to Armenia by the Apostle Thaddeus. The manuscript does not specify precisely where it was kept, but the Holy Relics gives a description that exactly matches the lance, the monastery gate (since the thirteenth century precisely), and the name of Geghardavank (Monastery of the Holy Lance).[72]

In 1655, the French traveler Jean-Baptiste Tavernier was the first Westerner to see this relic in Armenia. In 1805, the Russians captured the monastery and the relic was moved to Tchitchanov Geghard, Tbilisi, Georgia.[73]

It was later returned to Armenia, and is still on display at the Manoogian museum in Vagharshapat, enshrined in a 17th-century reliquary. Every year during the commemoration of the apostles St. Thaddeus and St. Bartholomew the relic is brought out for worship.[74]

Antioch

During the June 1098 Siege of Antioch, a monk named Peter Bartholomew reported that he had a vision in which St. Andrew told him that the Holy Lance was buried in the Church of St. Peter in Antioch.[75] After much digging in the cathedral, Bartholomew allegedly discovered a lance.[75] Despite the doubts of many, including the papal legate Adhemar of Le Puy, many of the crusaders credited the discovery of the lance for their subsequent victory in the Battle of Antioch, which broke the siege and secured the city.[75] [19]

Greek Orthodox sources such as the biography of patriarch Christopher indicate that a relic thought to be the Holy Lance was among the treasures of the church of St. Peter as early as the 10th century.[76] Historian Klaus-Peter Todt has suggested this relic could have been buried to hide it from Seljuk forces in 1084, allowing the crusaders to find it in 1098.[77]

Literary

The Holy Lance has been conflated with the bleeding lance depicted in the unfinished 12th century romance Perceval, the Story of the Grail by Chrétien de Troyes.[78] The story also refers to a javelot that has wounded the Fisher King, which may or may not be intended to be one and the same with the bleeding lance.[78] [79] Chrétien ascribes supernaturally destructive powers to the bleeding spear, which are inconsistent with any Christian tradition.[78] Nevertheless, the continuations of Chrétien's poem attempted to explain the mysteries of the bleeding spear by identifying it with the lance from John 19:34.[78] [3] [80]

Chrétien's Perceval was adapted by Wolfram von Eschenbach into the German epic Parzival.[81] [82] Like Chrétien, Wolfram depicts the bleeding lance in a manner that cannot easily be reconciled with the spear of Longinus.[78] Parzival became the primary source for Richard Wagner's 1882 opera Parsifal, in which the Fisher King is wounded by the spear that pierced Jesus's side.[83]

General and cited references

External links

Notes and References

  1. 19:31–37
  2. 19:36
  3. Book: Peebles . Rose Jeffries . 1911 . The Legend of Longinus in Ecclesiastical Tradition and in English Literature, and its connection with the Grail . Baltimore . J. H. Furst. . 2023-07-29 . The Internet Archive.
  4. Book: Hone . William . William Hone . The Lost Books of the Bible: being all the gospels, epistles, and other pieces now extant attributed in the first four centuries to Jesus Christ, His apostles and their companions, not included, by its compilers, in the authorized New Testament; and, the recently discovered Syriac mss. of Pilate's letters to Tiberius, etc. . Alpha House . New York . 1926 . 2023-07-27 . Internet Archive.
  5. Olivié . Antonio . 2017 . In the Footsteps of Christ in Rome. . Jerusalem Cross: Annales Ordinis Equestris Sancti Sepulchri Hierosolymitani . Vatican City . . 64–65 . 2023-08-08 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220504131044/https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/institutions_connected/oessh/ad/croce2017/croce2017_en.pdf . 2022-05-04 . live.
  6. Book: Kuhn . Albert . 1916 . Roma: Ancient, Subterranean, and Modern Rome . New York . Benziger Brothers . . 2023-08-08.
  7. Book: The 'Breviary'; or, Short Description of Jerusalem . The Epitome of S. Eucherius about Certain Holy Places (circ. A.D.440), and the Breviary or Short Description of Jerusalem (circ. A.D. 530) . The Library of the Palestine Pilgrims' Text Society . II . 1897 . London . Palestine Pilgrims' Text Society . Stewart . Aubrey . 13–16 . . 2024-02-03.
  8. Book: Cassiodorus . O'Donnell . James J. . 14 April 1979 . James J. O'Donnell . Berkeley . University of California . 0-520-03646-8 . 2024-02-03 . registration . Internet Archive.
  9. Book: Cassiodorus . Magnus Aurelius . Cassiodorus . Expositio Psalmum LXXXVI . Explanation of Psalm 86 . Patrologia Latina . Migne . Jacques Paul . Jacques Paul Migne . Paris . Jacques Paul Migne . la . LXX . col. 621 . yes . 1865 . Ibi manet lancea, quae latus Domini transforavit, ut nobis illius medicina succurreret. . There [Jerusalem] remains the lance which pierced the Lord's side, that his medicine might help us. . https://archive.org/details/patrologiaecurs27goog/page/n325/mode/1up . Internet Archive.
  10. Book: Piacenza pilgrim . Anonymous pilgrim of Piacenza . Stewart . Aubrey . Wilson . C. W. . Of the Holy Places Visited by Antoninus Martyr (Circ. 560–570 A.D.) . 1887 . Library of the Palestine Pilgrims' Text Society . 2024-02-03 . London . Palestine Pilgrim's Text Society.
  11. Web site: The Piacenza Pilgrim . Jacobs . Andrew S. . Andrew S. Jacobs, Ph.D. . 2024-02-03 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240106115359/https://andrewjacobs.org/translations/piacenzapilgrim.html . live . 2024-01-06.
  12. Book: Gregory of Tours . Gregory of Tours . Libri Miraculorum . Book of Miracles . Patrologia Latina . Migne . Jacques Paul . Jacques Paul Migne . Paris . Jacques Paul Migne . la . LXXI . col. 712 . yes . 1879 . De lancea vero, arundine, spongia, corona spinea et columna, ad quam verberatus est Dominus et Redemptor Hierosolymis, dicendum. . Let us speak about the lance, the reed, the sponge, the crown of thorns, and the pillar where our Lord and Redeemer was lashed, in Jerusalem. . https://archive.org/details/patrologiaecurs21unkngoog/page/n328/mode/1up . Internet Archive.
  13. So Many Saints--So Little Time...the "Libri Miraculorum" of Gregory of Tours . Danuta . Shanzer . The Journal of Medieval Latin . 2003 . 13 . 19–60 . Brepols . 10.1484/J.JML.2.304193 . 45019571.
  14. Book: Chronicon Paschale 284-628 AD . 2007 . Whitby . Michael . Michael Whitby . Whitby . Mary . 2023-08-04 . Internet Archive.
  15. Book: Gastgeber . Christian . Die Heilige Lanze im byzantinischen Osten . The Holy Lance in the Byzantine East . Kirchweger . Franz . Die Heilige Lanze in Wien: Insignie, Reliquie, "Schicksalsspeer" . The Holy Lance in Vienna: Insignia, Relic, "Spear of Destiny" . de . Vienna . Kunsthistorisches Museum . 2005 . 52–69.
  16. Book: Adomnán of Iona . Adomnán . The Pilgrimage of Arculfus in the Holy Land (About the Year A.D. 670) . MacPherson . James Rose . . London . 1889 . 2024-02-17 . Internet Archive.
  17. Book: Fernand . De Mély . Exuviae sacrae constantinopolitanae: la croix des premiers croisés, la Sainte Lance, la Sainte Couronne . The Holy Relics of Constantinople: The Cross of the First Crusaders, The Holy Lance, The Holy Crown . fr . Paris . Ernest LeRoux . 1904 . . 2024-02-17.
  18. Book: Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus . Constantine VII . De cerimoniis aulae Byzantinae, Lib. I, cap. XXXIV . Patrologiae Graeca, Vol. CXII . Migne . Jacques Paul . Jacques Paul Migne . Paris . Garnier . cols. 419-424 . la,el . https://archive.org/details/patrologiaecurs82migngoog/page/n217/mode/1up . . 2024-02-17 . 1897.
  19. Book: Morris . Colin . Policy and vision: The case of the Holy Lance found at Antioch . Gillingham . John . J. C. . Holt . War and Government in the Middle Ages: Essays in honour of J. O. Prestwich . Boydell . Totowa, NJ . 1984 . 33–45 . 978-0-85115-404-6 . https://archive.org/details/wargovernmentinm0000unse/page/33/mode/1up . 2023-07-27 . registration . .
  20. Runicman . Steven . Steven Runciman . The Holy Lance Found at Antioch . Analecta Bollandiana . 68 . 1950 . 197–209 . 0003-2468 . 10.1484/J.ABOL.4.01033.
  21. Book: Keightley . Thomas . Thomas Keightley . 1852 . The Crusaders; or, Scenes, Events, and Characters from the Times of the Crusades . 4th . London . John W. Parker . 2024-02-17 . Google Books.
  22. Book: Anna Comnena . Anna Komnene . The Alexiad . Sewter . E. R. A. . London . Penguin . 2009 . . 2024-02-17.
  23. Book: Relliquae Constantinopolitanae . Relics of Constantinople . la . Riant . Paul . Paul Riant . 1878 . c. 1150 . Exuvia sacrae constantinopolitanae: fasciculus documentorum ecclesiasticorum, ad byzantina lipsana in Occidentem saeculo XIII translata, spectantium, & historiam quarti belli sacri . The Holy Relics of Constantinople: A Collection of Ecclesiastical Documents, Relating to the Byzantine Relics Transferred to the West in the 13th Century, and the History of the Fourth Crusade . II . Geneva . 211–212 . . 2024-02-18.
  24. Book: Nicholas of Thingeyre . Catalogus reliquiarium C.P. . la . Riant . Paul . Paul Riant . 1878 . 1157 . Exuvia sacrae constantinopolitanae: fasciculus documentorum ecclesiasticorum, ad byzantina lipsana in Occidentem saeculo XIII translata, spectantium, & historiam quarti belli sacri . The Holy Relics of Constantinople: A Collection of Ecclesiastical Documents, Relating to the Byzantine Relics Transferred to the West in the 13th Century, and the History of the Fourth Crusade . II . Geneva . 213–216 . . 2024-02-18.
  25. Book: William of Tyre . William of Tyre . Historia belli sacri, XX, cap. 23. . History of the Crusade, book 20, chapter 23 . la . Riant . Paul . Paul Riant . 1878 . 1171 . Exuvia sacrae constantinopolitanae: fasciculus documentorum ecclesiasticorum, ad byzantina lipsana in Occidentem saeculo XIII translata, spectantium, & historiam quarti belli sacri . The Holy Relics of Constantinople: A Collection of Ecclesiastical Documents, Relating to the Byzantine Relics Transferred to the West in the 13th Century, and the History of the Fourth Crusade . II . Geneva . 216 . . 2024-02-18.
  26. Book: William of Tyre . William of Tyre . A History of Deeds Done Beyond the Sea . II . Babcock . Emily Atwater . Krey . A. C. . New York . Columbia University . 1943 . 2024-02-18 . Internet Archive.
  27. Book: Anthony of Novgorod . Anthony of Novgorod . Le Livre du Pèlerin . The Pilgrim's Book . de Khitrowo . B. . 1889 . Itinéraires Russes en Orient . Russian itineraries in the East . fr . 88–111 . Geneva . Fick . 2024-02-21 . Internet Archive.
  28. Book: Alberic of Trois-Fontaines . Alberic of Trois-Fontaines . Chronicle . Andrea . Alfred J. . Andrea . Alfred J. . 2008 . 291–309 . Contemporary Sources for the Fourth Crusade . Revised . Leiden . Brill.
  29. Book: Robert de Clari . Robert de Clari . 2005 . The Conquest of Constantinople . McNeal . Edgar Holmes . New York . Columbia University . . 2024-02-21.
  30. Book: Baldwin I . Baldwin I, Latin Emperor . The Registers of Innocent III: Reg 7:152 . Andrea . Alfred J. . Andrea . Alfred J. . 2008 . 98–112 . Contemporary Sources for the Fourth Crusade . Revised . Leiden . Brill.
  31. Book: Geoffrey of Villehardouin . Geoffrey of Villehardouin . 1985 . The Conquest of Constantinople . Shaw . M.R.B. . Chronicles of the Crusades . New York . Dorset . 978-0-88029-035-7 . 2021-02-21 . . registration.
  32. Book: Devastatio of Constantinopolitana . 212–221 . Andrea . Alfred J. . Andrea . Alfred J. . 2008 . Contemporary Sources for the Fourth Crusade . Revised . Leiden . Brill.
  33. Book: Niketas Choniates . Niketas Choniates . 1984 . O City of Byzantium, Annals of Niketas Choniates . Magoulias . Harry J. . Detroit . Wayne State University . 2024-02-21 . Internet Archive.
  34. Book: Ralph of Coggeshall . Ralph of Coggeshall . Chronicle . Andrea . Alfred J. . Andrea . Alfred J. . 2008 . 277–290 . Contemporary Sources for the Fourth Crusade . Revised . Leiden . Brill.
  35. Book: Robert of Auxerre . Robert of Auxerre . 1822 . Ex Chronologia Roberti Altissiodorensis, praemonstratensis ad S. Marianum canonici . Bouquet . Martin . Rerum Gallicarum et Francicarum Scriptores . XVIII . 247–290 . la . Paris . De L'Imprimerie Royale . 2024-02-21 . Bibliothèque nationale de France.
  36. Hendrickx . Benjamin . Matzukis . Corinna . 1979 . Alexios V Doukas Mourtzouphlos: His Life, Reign, and Death (?-1204) . Ελληνικά . Hellenika . 31 . 108–132 . . 2024-02-21.
  37. Book: Queller . Donald E. . Madden . Thomas F. . 1997 . The Fourth Crusade: The Conquest of Constantinople . 2 . Philadelphia . University of Pennsylvania . 978-0-8122-3387-2 . 2024-02-21 . . registration.
  38. Klein . Holger A. . Eastern Objects and Western Desires: Relics and Reliquaries between Byzantium and the West . Dumberton Oaks Papers . 2004 . 58 . 283–314 . Dumberton Oakes . 10.2307/3591389 . 3591389.
  39. Book: Baldwin II . Baldwin II, Latin Emperor . 1878 . June 1247 . Balduinus II Ludovico IX reliquas omnes S. Capella in perpetuum concedit . Baldwin II grants to Louis IX all the relics of the Saint-Chapelle in perpetuity . la . Riant . Paul . Paul Riant . Exuvia sacrae constantinopolitanae . Holy relics of Constantinople . II . Geneva . 133–135 . 2024-02-25 . Internet Archive.
  40. Book: Gerard de St. Quentin . Translatio sancte corone Domini nostri Ihesu Christi a Constantinopolitana urbe ad civitatem Parisiensem, facta anno Domini Mº CCº XLlº . The transfer of the holy crown of our Lord Jesus Christ from the city of Constantinople to the city of Paris, made in the year of the Lord 1241 . la . Fernand . De Mély . Exuviae sacrae constantinopolitanae: la croix des premiers croisés, la Sainte Lance, la Sainte Couronne . The Holy Relics of Constantinople: The Cross of the First Crusaders, The Holy Lance, The Holy Crown . Paris . Ernest LeRoux . 1904 . 1241 . 102–112 . . 2024-02-17.
  41. Brock . Sebastian P. . Sebastian Brock . 1967 . A Medieval Armenian Pilgrim's Description of Constantinople . Revue des Études Arméniennes . Nouvelle Série [New Series] . Review of Armenian Studies . 4 . 81–102 . 2024-02-25 . Union Catalog of Armenian Continuing Resources.
  42. Book: John Mandeville . 1900 . ca. 1357-1371 . The Travels of John Mandeville: The version of the Cotton Manuscript in modern spelling. . London . Macmillan . 2024-02-26 . Internet Archive.
  43. Book: Anonymous Description of Constantinople . 1984 . Majeska . George P. . Russian Travelers to Constantinople in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries . Washington, DC . Dumbarton Oaks . 114–154 . 2024-02-25 . Internet Archive.
  44. Book: Alexander the Clerk . 1984 . 1394–1395 . Alexander the Clerk: On Constantinople . 156–165 . Majeska . George P. . Russian Travelers to Constantinople in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries . Washington, DC . Dumbarton Oaks . 2024-02-25 . Internet Archive.
  45. Book: Clavijo . Ruy González de . Ruy González de Clavijo . 1859 . 1403–1406 . Narrative of the Embassy of Ruy Gonzalez de Clavijo to the Court of Timour at Samarcand, A.D. 1403-6 . Markham . Clements R. . Clements Markham . London . Hakluyt Society . 978-0-8337-2234-8 . Google Books.
  46. Book: Zosima the Deacon .

    ru:Зосима (иеромонах)

    . The Xenos of Zosima the Deacon . 166–195 . Majeska . George P. . Russian Travelers to Constantinople in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries . Washington, DC . Dumbarton Oaks . 2024-02-25 . Internet Archive.
  47. Book: Buondelmonti . Cristoforo . Cristoforo Buondelmonti . 1864 . ca. 1420s . Descriptio Urbis Constantinopoleos . Migne . Jacques Paul . Patrologiae Graeci, Vol. CXXXIII . J.-P. Migne . cols. 695-708 . la . . 2024-02-26.
  48. Book: Lannoy . Ghillebert de . Ghillebert de Lannoy . 1878 . Oeuvres de Ghillebert de Lannoy . Potvin . Charles . Louvain . Lefever . fr . . 2024-02-26.
  49. Book: Pedro Tafur . Tafur . Pedro . 1926 . Travels and Adventures 1435-1439 . Letts . Malcom . London . George Routledge . . 2024-02-26.
  50. Book: Bertrandon de la Broquière . Bertrandon de la Broquière . 1807 . 1453 . The Travels of Bertrandon de la Broquiere, counsellor & first esquire-carver to Philippe le Bon, Duke of Burgundy, to Palestine, and his return from Jerusalem overland to France, during the years 1432 & 1433 . Johnes . Thomas . Thomas Johnes . Hafod Press . 2024-02-26 . Internet Archive.
  51. Book: Introduction . Kohanski . Tamarah . Benson . C. David . John Mandeville . The Book of John Mandeville . Kalamazoo . Medieval Institute Publications . https://d.lib.rochester.edu/teams/text/kohanski-and-benson-the-book-of-john-mandeville-introduction . University of Rochester . 2024-02-27.
  52. Book: Kirchweger. Franz . Die Geschichte der Heiligen Lanze vom späteren Mittelalter bis zum Ende des Heiligen Römischen Reiches (1806) . The History of the Holy Lance from the Late Middle Ages to the End of the Holy Roman Empire (1806) . Kirchweger . Franz . Die Heilige Lanze in Wien: Insignie, Reliquie, "Schicksalsspeer" . The Holy Lance in Vienna: Insignia, Relic, "Spear of Destiny" . de . Vienna . Kunsthistorisches Museum . 2005 . 71–109.
  53. Book: von Pastor . Ludwig . Ludwig von Pastor . 1901 . The History of the Popes, from the Close of the Middle Ages. . Antrobus . Frederick Ignatius . V . 2 . London . Kegan Paul, Trench, Trübner, & Co. . . 2023-08-04.
  54. Book: Burchard . Johann . Johann Burchard . The Diary of John Burchard of Strasburg Vol. I: A.D. 1483-1492 . Matthew . Arnold Harris . Arnold Mathew . London . Francis Griffiths . 1910 . 337–339 . 2023-08-07 . Internet Archive.
  55. Book: Benedict XIV . Pope Benedict XIV . Doctrina de Servorum Dei Beatificatione et Beatorum Canonizatione . Book IV, Part II, Chapter XXXI . 322–325 . 1840 . Brussels . la . Societatis Belgicae . https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_MoYPAAAAQAAJ/page/n333/mode/1up . 2023-08-03 . Internet Archive.
  56. Web site: Die Heilige Lanze . Kunsthistorisches Museum . 2023-08-05 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230806021613/https://www.khm.at/en/objectdb/detail/100443/ . The Holy Lance. live . 2023-08-06.
  57. Book: Wolf . Gunther G. . Nochmals zur Geschicthe der Heiligen Lanze bis zum Ende des Mittelalters . Once more the History of the Holy Lance through the End of the Middle Ages . Kirchweger . Franz . Die Heilige Lanze in Wien: Insignie, Reliquie, "Schicksalsspeer" . 2005 . The Holy Lance in Vienna: Insignia, Relic, "Spear of Destiny" . de . Vienna . Kunsthistorisches Museum . 23–51.
  58. Book: Liutprand of Cremona . Liutprand of Cremona . 1930 . Antapodosis, Book IV . The Works of Liudprand of Cremona . Wright . F. A. . 139–172 . London . Routledge & Sons . 2024-03-08 . Internet Archive.
  59. Adelson . Howard L. . The Holy Lance and the Hereditary German Monarchy . The Art Bulletin . June 1966 . 48 . 2 . 177–192 . 3048362 . 10.2307/3048362 . College Art Association.
  60. Book: Widukind of Corvey . Widukind of Corvey . 2014 . Deeds of the Saxons . Bachrach . Bernard S. . Bachrach . Davis S. . Washington, DC . Catholic University of America . . 2024-03-04.
  61. Czajkowski . Anthony F. . July 1949 . The Congress of Gniezno in the Year 1000 . Speculum . 24 . 3 . 339–356 . The University of Chicago Press . 10.2307/2848012 . 2848012. 162927768.
  62. Book: Gallus Anonymus . Gallus Anonymus . . la . Pertz . Georg Heinrich . Georg Heinrich Pertz . Scriptores (in Folio) 9: Chronica et annales aevi Salici . . Hanover . 1851 . 429 . dMGH.
  63. Web site: Wawel's Cathedral Museum: History . The Wawel Royal Cathedral of St Stanislaus B. M. and St Wenceslaus M. . 2024-03-09 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240117215416/https://www.katedra-wawelska.pl/en/muzeum-wawelskie/historia/ . live . 2024-01-17.
  64. Paulsen . Peter . Magyarországi viking leletek az észak- és nyugat-európai kultúrtörténet megvilágításában / Wikingerfunde aus Ungarn im Lichte der nord- und westeuropäischen Frühgeschichte . Viking finds from Hungary in Light of Early Northern and Western European History . hu,de . Archaeologia Hungarica . 12 . registration.
  65. Book: Schramm . Percy Ernst . Percy Ernst Schramm . Die „Heilige Lanze“, Reliquie und Herrschaftszeichen des Reiches und ihre Replik in Krakau. Ein Überblick über die Geschichte der Königslanze. . The "Holy Lance", Relic and Symbol of Power of the Empire and its Replica in Krakow. An Overview of the History of the King's Lance. . Herrschaftszeichen und Staatssymbolik. Beiträge zu ihrer Geschichte vom dritten bis zum sechzehnten Jahrhundert. . II . Signs of power and state symbolism. Contributions to its history from the third to the sixteenth century. . 492–537 . de . https://archive.org/details/DieHeiligeLanze/ . . 1955 . 2024-03-09.
  66. Web site: Schier . Volker . Schleif . Corine . Corine Schleif . How was the Geese Book made? . Opening the Geese Book . Arizona State University . 20 November 2018.
  67. Book: Guide to the Treasury of the Imperial House of Austria in the Imperial and Royal Palace in Vienna . 1910 . Vienna . Adolf . Holzhausen . 2023-08-07 . Google Books.
  68. Bolstering the Prestige of the Habsburgs: The End of the Holy Roman Empire in 1806 . Peter H. . Wilson . The International History Review . December 2006 . 28 . 4 . 709–736 . Taylor & Francis, Ltd. . 10.1080/07075332.2006.9641109 . 40109811. 154316830.
  69. Bird . Maryann . Piercing An Ancient Tale: Solving the mystery of a Christian relic . 25 June 2018 . . 8 June 2003 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20030803151706/http://www.time.com/time/europe/html/030616/science.html . 3 August 2003.
  70. News: Der geheimnisvolle Kreuznagel . 25 June 2018 . . 4 September 2004 . https://web.archive.org/web/20041112034143/http://www.zdf.de/ZDFde/inhalt/26/0,1872,2117690,00.html . 12 November 2004 . dead.
  71. Book: Schier . Volker . Die Heilige Lanze in Wien: Insignie, Reliquie, "Schicksalsspeer" . Schleif . Corine . Corine Schleif . 2005 . Kunsthistorisches Museum . Vienna . 110–143 . de . The Holy Lance in Vienna: Insignia, Relic, "Spear of Destiny" . Die heilige und die unheilige Lanze. Von Richard Wagner bis zum World Wide Web . 2023-07-27 . https://www.academia.edu/8295541/Volker_Schier_und_Corine_Schleif_Die_Heilige_und_die_unheilige_Lanze_Von_Richard_Wagner_bis_zum_World_Wide_Web . . The Holy and the Unholy Lance. From Richard Wagner to the World Wide Web . registration.
  72. Book: Ballian . Anna . Liturgical Objects from Holy Etchmiadzin . Armenia: Art, Religion, and Trade in the Middle Ages . 250–259 . Evans . Helen C. . 2018 . Metropolitan Museum of Art . New York . 9781588396600 . . 2023-08-04.
  73. Christopher H. Zakian and Fr. Krikor Maksoudian (2024). The Holy Lance in Armenian Tradition & Legend. The Armenian Church.
  74. Web site: Holy Lance "Geghard" Will be Brought out on December 04 . 2023-11-16 . beta.armenianchurch.org . en.
  75. Book: Runciman, Steven . Steven Runciman . A History of the Crusades, Volume I: The First Crusade and the Foundation of the Kingdom of Jerusalem . Cambridge University Press . 1971 . registration . 2023-08-04 . Internet Archive.
  76. Book: Giorgi . Andrea U. De . Eger . A. Asa . Antioch: A History . 30 May 2021 . Routledge . 978-1-317-54041-0 . 361–362 . 8 February 2024 . en.
  77. Book: Weltecke . Dorothea . The Syriac Orthodox in the Principality of Antioch During the Crusader Period . Ciggaar . Krijna Nelly . Metcalf . David Michael . Antioch from the Byzantine Reconquest Until the End of the Crusader Principality: Acta of the congress held at Hernen Castle in May 2003 . 2006 . 95–124 . East and West in the Medieval Mediterranean . I . http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:352-194119 . Leuven . Uitgeverij Peeters & Department of Oriental Studies . University of Konstanz . 2023-07-29.
  78. Brown . Arthur Charles Lewis . Arthur Charles Lewis Brown . The Bleeding Lance . Publications of the Modern Language Association of America . 1910 . XXV . 1 . 1–59 . 456810 . 10.2307/456810 . 163517936 . 2023-07-27 . Internet Archive.
  79. The Bleeding Lance and Philip of Flanders . William A. . Nitze . Speculum . July 1946 . 21 . 3 . 303–311 . University of Chicago Press . 10.2307/2851373 . 2851373. 162229439 .
  80. Book: The Grail: From Celtic Myth to Christian Symbol . Loomis . Roger Sherman . Roger Sherman Loomis . 1991 . Princeton, NJ . Princeton University . 9780691020754 . . registration . 2023-08-07.
  81. Two Notes on Chrétien and Wolfram . Arthur Thomas Hatto . Hatto . A. T. . The Modern Language Review . April 1947 . 42 . 2 . 243–246 . Modern Humanities Research Association . 10.2307/3717233 . 3717233.
  82. On Chretien and Wolfram . Arthur Thomas Hatto . Hatto . A. T. . The Modern Language Review . July 1949 . 44 . 3 . 380–385 . Modern Humanities Research Association . 10.2307/3717658 . 3717658.
  83. Book: Beckett, Lucy . Richard Wagner: Parsifal . Cambridge University Press . 1981 . 0-521-29662-5 . . registration.

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Holy Lance".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.