South African Class GA 2-6-0+0-6-2 explained

South African Class GA 2-6-0+0-6-2
Powertype:Steam
Designer:Beyer, Peacock & Company
Builder:Beyer, Peacock & Company
Serialnumber:5941
Buildmodel:Class GA
Builddate:1920
Totalproduction:1
Whytetype:2-6-0+0-6-2 (Double Mogul)
Uicclass:1’C+C1’h4
Driver:3rd & 4th coupled axles
Leadingdiameter:300NaN0
Coupleddiameter:480NaN0
Wheelbase:58feet
Engine Total:16feet each
Coupled:90NaN0 each
Pivotcentres:33feet
Over Couplers:65feet
Height:12feet
Frametype:Plate
Axleload:17lt
Leadingbogie/Pony:14lt front
14lt rear
Coupled 1:17lt
Coupled 2:17lt
Coupled 3:17lt
Coupled 4:17lt
Coupled 5:17lt
Coupled 6:17lt
Weightondrivers:104lt
Locoweight:133lt
Fueltype:Coal
Fuelcap:91NaN1
Watercap:3350sigfig=3NaNsigfig=3 front
1250sigfig=3NaNsigfig=3 rear
Fireboxtype:Belpaire
Firearea:51.8square feet
Pitch:7feet
Diameterinside:6feet
Lengthinside:11feet
Smalltubediameter:279: 20NaN0
Largetubediameter:40: NaN0NaN0
Boilerpressure:1800NaN0
Safetyvalvetype:Ramsbottom
Totalsurface:2554.5square feet
Tubearea:2342.2square feet
Fireboxarea:211.3square feet
Superheaterarea:526.5square feet
Cylindercount:Four
Cylindersize:180NaN0 bore
260NaN0 stroke
Valvegear:Walschaerts
Valvetype:Piston
Coupling:Johnston link-and-pin
AAR knuckle (1930s)
Tractiveeffort:47390lbf @ 75%
Operator:South African Railways
Operatorclass:Class GA
Numinclass:1
Fleetnumbers:1649, renumbered 2140
Deliverydate:1921
Firstrundate:1921
Withdrawndate:1938

The South African Railways Class GA 2-6-0+0-6-2 of 1921 was an articulated steam locomotive.

In February 1921, the South African Railways placed a single experimental Garratt articulated steam locomotive with a Double Mogul type wheel arrangement in service. It was the first Cape gauge Garratt to enter service in South Africa.[1]

The Garratt solution

A powerful steam locomotive is problematic on Cape gauge light-rail single-line track. Train lengths were limited on such lines because, due to restrictions on axle loading, conventional locomotives had been enlarged to the limit of their possible power. Alternative solutions would either be double-heading longer trains or rebuilding and re-aligning large parts of the lines to accommodate heavier locomotives. Either method was expensive, especially across the type of mountainous terrain that was encountered inland from all South Africa's major ports. In such conditions, the Garratt design had distinct advantages.[2]

Manufacturer

The Class GA experimental mainline articulated locomotive was one of altogether five Garratt locomotives that had been ordered by the South African Railways (SAR) from Beyer, Peacock & Company in 1914. The rest consisted of the first of the eventual seven Class GB branchline locomotives and three narrow gauge Class locomotives. Production was disrupted by World War I, however, and Beyer, Peacock & Company was only able to deliver the narrow gauge locomotives in 1919 and the Cape gauge locomotives in 1921, after cessation of hostilities.[1]

The single Class GA locomotive was numbered 1649, but the engine number was later changed to 2140. The locomotive was erected in the Durban shops and placed in service in February 1921. At the time, it was 401NaN1 heavier than any Garratt engine constructed previously and, of all Garratts in service worldwide, the locomotive with the highest tractive effort.[1]

Characteristics

The superheated Class GA had a commodious cab and had plate frames, with a copper Belpaire firebox and combustion chamber. The piston valves were actuated by Walschaerts valve gear, driven from the coupled wheels furthest from the respective cylinders and controlled by steam reversing gear which was fitted under the boiler barrel between the cradle frame plates. The bissel trucks at the extremities of the locomotive were fitted with Cartazzi axle box control to allow the axles sideways play since the truck itself did not pivot, but was compensated with the adjacent pair of coupled wheels.[1] [3]

The locomotive had valves to allow the steam supply to either engine unit to be shut off, if necessary. Exhaust steam from the cylinders of each engine unit was led to the smokebox by separate pipes. The ball joints which gave flexibility to the steam and exhaust pipes were located immediately under and concentric with the pivot centres and were served by forced lubrication from Wakefield mechanical lubricators. Two 80NaN0 lubricators, one on each engine unit, supplied one feed to each cylinder and each steam chest, two to the ball joints and two to the tail-end extensions of the piston rods. The oil pipes which fed the steam chests and cylinders were fitted with anti-carbonisers. The locomotive was fitted with two Gresham and Craven no. 12 self-acting feedwater injectors and had steam sanding gear, applied to the front and rear of both engine units.[1]

Comparative trials

The Class GA, which had apparently been designed as a direct competitor to the Class MH 2-6-6-2 Mallet locomotive, was placed in trial service on the Natal mainline. It closely matched the Mallet in terms of tractive effort, boiler capacity, grate area and axle loading, which made it a locomotive of equal power but with 461NaN1 less weight. Tests were carried out with varying loads on various sections of the line, while comparative tests were carried out with the Class MH Mallets.[1]

During the trials, the locomotive gave some trouble due to broken plate frames on the engine units and it was also found that the absence of trailing carrying wheels on the engine units was a disadvantage since it led to excessive flange wear on the coupled wheels. As a result, no. 2140 remained the only representative of its Class. All subsequent Garratt models of the SAR were equipped with trailing Bissel trucks.[1]

The Garratt took greater loads than the Mallet and its running times were better, while its coal and water consumption were lower. With the Garratt's superiority established, no further Mallet locomotives were ordered by the SAR. During the remaining years of the South African steam traction era, whenever the use of an articulated locomotive was desirable for flexibility, reduced axle loading and high tractive force, the Garratt type was chosen. Two derivative designs, the Modified Fairlie and Union Garratt, would be tried but would both prove to be less successful than the purebred Garratt.[1]

Service

The locomotive worked across Van Reenen's Pass between Ladysmith and Harrismith for most of the rest of its service life. It was withdrawn from service in 1938 because of a cracked frame and scrapped. The boiler was retained and reconditioned as a spare boiler for Class GE locomotives.[1]

Notes and References

  1. Espitalier, T.J.; Day, W.A.J. (1945). The Locomotive in South Africa - A Brief History of Railway Development. Chapter VII - South African Railways (Continued). South African Railways and Harbours Magazine, November 1945. pp. 866-867.
  2. http://www.beyerpeacock.co.uk/main/Beyer%20Peacock%20Garratt%20Locomotives.html Beyer, Peacock Garratt Locomotives
  3. Hendrie. Engine Power on the S.A.R.. South African Mining and Engineering Journal. 10 December 1921. XXXII. 1576. 529.