Rashi Explained

Rashi
Birth Place:Troyes, County of Champagne, France
Death Place:Troyes, County of Champagne, France
Resting Place:Troyes
Nationality:French
Known For:Writing commentaries, grammarian
Occupation:Traditionally a vintner (recently questioned, see article)
Children:3 daughters

Shlomo Yitzchaki (Hebrew: רבי שלמה יצחקי; Latin: Salomon Isaacides; French: Salomon de Troyes; 13 July 1105), commonly known by the acronym Rashi, was a French rabbi who authored comprehensive commentaries on the Talmud and Hebrew Bible.

Born in Troyes, Rashi studied Torah studies in Worms under German rabbi Yaakov ben Yakar and French rabbi Isaac ben Eliezer Halevi, both of whom were pupils of the famed scholar Gershom ben Judah. After returning to Troyes, Rashi joined the, began answering halakhic questions and later served as the 's head after the death of Zerach ben Abraham.

Rashi is generally considered a leading biblical exegete in the Middle Ages. Acclaimed for his ability to present the basic meaning of the text in a concise and lucid fashion, Rashi's commentaries appeal to both learned scholars and beginning students, and his works remain a centerpiece of contemporary Torah study. A large fraction of rabbinic literature published since the Middle Ages discusses Rashi, either using his view as supporting evidence or debating against it. His commentary on the Talmud, which covers nearly all of the Babylonian Talmud, has been included in every edition of the Talmud since its first printing by Daniel Bomberg in the 1520s. His commentaries on the Tanakh—especially his commentary on the Chumash (the "Five Books of Moses")—serves as the basis of more than 300 "supercommentaries" which analyze Rashi's choice of language and citations, penned by some of the greatest names in rabbinic literature.

Name

Rashi's surname, Yitzhaki, derives from his father's name, Yitzhak. The acronym "Rashi" stands for Rabbi Shlomo Yitzhaki, but is sometimes fancifully expanded as Rabban Shel YIsrael which means the "Rabbi of Israel", or as Rabbenu SheYichyeh (Our Rabbi, may he live). He may be cited in Hebrew and Aramaic texts as (1) "Shlomo son of Rabbi Yitzhak", (2) "Shlomo son of Yitzhak", (3) "Shlomo Yitzhaki", and myriad similar highly respectful derivatives.[1]

In older literature, Rashi is sometimes referred to as Jarchi or Yarhi, his abbreviated name being interpreted as Rabbi Shlomo Yarhi. This was understood to refer to the Hebrew name of Lunel in Provence, popularly derived from the occitan luna "moon", in Hebrew,[2] in which Rashi was assumed to have lived at some time[3] or to have been born, or where his ancestors were supposed to have originated.[4] Later Christian writers Richard Simon[5] and Johann Christoph Wolf[6] claimed that only Christian scholars referred to Rashi as Jarchi, and that this epithet was unknown to the Jews. Bernardo de Rossi, however, demonstrated that Hebrew scholars also referred to Rashi as Yarhi.[7] In 1839, Leopold Zunz[8] showed that the Hebrew usage of Jarchi was an erroneous propagation of the error by Christian writers, instead he interpreted the abbreviation as: Rabbi Shlomo Yitzhaki. The evolution of this term has been thoroughly traced.[9] [10]

Biography

Birth and early life

Rashi was an only child born at Troyes, Champagne, in northern France. His mother's brother was Simeon bar Isaac, rabbi of Mainz.[11] [12] Simon was a disciple of Gershom ben Judah,[13] who died that same year. On his father's side, Rashi has been claimed to be a 33rd-generation descendant of Johanan HaSandlar, who was a fourth-generation descendant of Gamaliel, who was reputedly descended from the Davidic line.[14] In his voluminous writings, Rashi himself made no such claim at all. The main early rabbinical source about his ancestry, Responsum No. 29 by Solomon Luria, makes no such claim either.[15] [16]

Legends

His fame later made him the subject of many legends. One tradition contends that his parents were childless for many years. Rashi's father, Yitzhak, a poor winemaker, once found a precious jewel and was approached by non-Jews who wished to buy it to adorn their idol. Yitzhak agreed to travel with them to their land, but en route, he cast the gem into the sea. Afterwards he was visited by either the Voice of God or the prophet Elijah, who told him that he would be rewarded with the birth of a noble son "who would illuminate the world with his Torah knowledge."[17]

Another legend also states that Rashi's parents moved to Worms, Germany while Rashi's mother was pregnant. As she walked down one of the narrow streets in the Jewish quarter, she was imperiled by two oncoming carriages. She turned and pressed herself against a wall, which opened to receive her. This miraculous niche is still visible in the wall of the Worms Synagogue.[18]

Additional legends, particularly in Hasidic literature, postulate that Rashi's tremendous works and accomplishments were inspired by the Holy Spirit, the Shekhinah, as no mere human could produce such immense works. One text goes so far as to claim that Rashi was beyond human; the author proposes that he never died a natural death, but rather ascended to Heaven alive like the immortal prophet Elijah.[19]

Yeshiva studies

According to tradition, Rashi was first brought to learn Torah by his father on Shavuot day at the age of five. His father was his main Torah teacher until his death when Rashi was still a youth. At the age of 17 he married and soon after went to learn in the yeshiva of Yaakov ben Yakar in Worms, returning to his wife three times yearly, for the Days of Awe, Passover and Shavuot. When Yaakov died in 1064, Rashi continued learning in Worms for another year in the yeshiva of his relative, Isaac ben Eliezer Halevi, who was also chief rabbi of Worms. Then he moved to Mainz, where he studied under another of his relatives, Isaac ben Judah, the rabbinic head of Mainz and one of the leading sages of the Lorraine region straddling France and Germany.

Rashi's teachers were students of Rabbeinu Gershom and Eliezer Hagadol, leading Talmudists of the previous generation. From his teachers, Rashi imbibed the oral traditions pertaining to the Talmud as they had been passed down for centuries, as well as an understanding of the Talmud's logic and forms of argument. Rashi took concise, copious notes from what he learned in yeshiva, incorporating this material in his commentaries. He was also greatly influenced by the exegetical principles of Menahem Kara.

Rosh yeshiva

He returned to Troyes at the age of 25, after which time his mother died, and he was asked to join the Troyes Beth din (rabbinical court). He also began answering halakhic questions. Upon the death of the head of the Bet din, Zerach ben Abraham, Rashi assumed the court's leadership and answered hundreds of halakhic queries.

At some time around 1070 he founded a yeshiva which attracted many disciples. It is thought by some that Rashi earned his living as a vintner since Rashi shows an extensive knowledge of its utensils and process, but there is no evidence for this.[20] Most scholars and a Jewish oral tradition contend that he was a vintner.[21] The only reason given for the centuries-old tradition that he was a vintner being not true is that the soil in all of Troyes is not optimal for growing wine grapes, claimed by the research of Haym Soloveitchik. There exists a reference to a seal said to be from his vineyard.[22]

Although there are many legends about his travels, Rashi likely never went further than from the Seine to the Rhine; his furthest destinations were the yeshivas of Lorraine.

In 1096, the People's Crusade swept through the Lorraine, murdering 12,000 Jews and uprooting whole communities. Among those murdered in Worms were the three sons of Isaac ben Eliezer Halevi, Rashi's teacher. Rashi wrote several Selichot (penitential poems) mourning the slaughter and the destruction of the region's great yeshivot. Seven of Rashi's Selichot still exist,[23] including Adonai Elohei Hatz'vaot, which is recited on the eve of Rosh Hashanah, and Az Terem Nimtehu, which is recited on the Fast of Gedalia.

Death and burial site

Rashi died on July 13, 1105 (Tammuz 29, 4865) at the age of 65.[24] He was buried in Troyes. The approximate location of the cemetery in which he was buried was recorded in Seder ha-Dorot, but over time the location of the cemetery was forgotten. A number of years ago, a Sorbonne professor discovered an ancient map depicting the site of the cemetery, which lay under an open square in the city of Troyes. After this discovery, French Jews erected a large monument in the center of the square—a large, black and white globe featuring the three Hebrew letters of רשי artfully arranged counterclockwise in negative space, evoking the style of Hebrew microcalligraphy. The granite base of the monument is engraved: Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki — Commentator and Guide.

In 2005, Yisroel Meir Gabbai erected an additional plaque at this site marking the square as a burial ground. The plaque reads: "The place you are standing on is the cemetery of the town of Troyes. Many Rishonim are buried here, among them Rabbi Shlomo, known as Rashi the holy, may his merit protect us".[25]

Descendants

See main article: Rashi's daughters.

Rashi had no sons. All of his three children were girls, named Yocheved, Miriam and Rachel. He invested himself in their education; his writings and the legends which surround him suggest that his daughters were well-versed in the Torah and the Talmud (at a time when women were not expected to study) and would help him when he was too weak to write. His daughters married his disciples; most present-day Ashkenazi rabbinical dynasties can trace their lineage back to his daughters Miriam or Yocheved.[26]

A late-20th century legend claims that Rashi's daughters wore tefillin. While a few women in medieval Ashkenaz did wear tefillin, there is no evidence that Rashi's daughters did.[27]

It is reputed that the famous Polish Talmudist Moses Isserles (1530-1572) was a descendant of Rashi.[29]

Works

Commentary on the Tanakh

Rashi's commentary on the Tanakh—and especially his commentary on the Chumash—is the essential companion for any study of the Bible among Orthodox Jews. Drawing on the breadth of Midrashic, Talmudic and Aggadic literature (including literature that is no longer extant), as well as his knowledge of Hebrew grammar and halakhah, Rashi clarifies the "simple" meaning of the text so that a bright child of five could understand it.[30] At the same time, his commentary forms the foundation for some of the most profound legal analysis and mystical discourses that came after it. Scholars debate why Rashi chose a particular Midrash to illustrate a point, or why he used certain words and phrases and not others. Shneur Zalman of Liadi wrote that "Rashi's commentary on Torah is the 'wine of Torah'. It opens the heart and uncovers one's essential love and fear of G-d."[31]

Scholars believe that Rashi's commentary on the Torah grew out of the lectures he gave to his students in his yeshiva, and evolved with the questions and answers they raised on it. Rashi completed this commentary only in the last years of his life. It was immediately accepted as authoritative by all Jewish communities, Ashkenazi and Sephardi alike.

The first dated Hebrew printed book was Rashi's commentary on the Chumash, printed by Abraham ben Garton in Reggio di Calabria, Italy, 18 February 1475. (This version did not include the text of the Chumash itself.)[32]

Rashi wrote commentaries on all the books of Tanakh[33] except Chronicles I & II, and Ezra–Nehemiah.[34] His commentary to Job is incomplete, ending at 40:25.[35]

A main characteristic of Rashi's writing was his focus on grammar and syntax. His primary focus was on word choice, and "essentially [he acts] as a dictionary where he defines unusual Hebrew words." He searches for things that may not be clear to the reader and offers clarification on the inconsistency that may be present. Rashi does so by "filling in missing information that [helps] lead to a more complete understanding" of the Torah.[36] A portion of his writing is dedicated to making distinctions between the peshat, or plain and literal meaning of the text, and the aggadah or rabbinic interpretation. Rashbam, one of Rashi's grandchildren, heavily critiqued his response on his "commentary on the Torah [being] based primarily on the classic midrashim (rabbinic homilies)."[37]

Rashi himself explained his method as utilizing both peshat and derash: "I, however, am only concerned with the plain sense of Scripture (peshuto shel mikra) and with such Agadoth that explain the words of Scripture in a manner that fits in with them." In one place, he quotes a midrash and then states "But this midrash cannot be reconciled with Scripture for several reasons... Therefore I say: let scripture be reconciled according to its simple meaning, clearly, and the midrash may also be expounded, as is said: 'Is not My word... like a hammer which shatters the rock?'[38] - it is divided into many fragments."

Commentary on the Talmud

Notes and References

  1. HaCohen-Kerner . Yaakov . Schweitzer . Nadav . Mughaz . Dror . 2011 . Automatically Identifying Citations in Hebrew-Aramaic Documents . Cybernetics and Systems . 42 . 3. 180–197 . 10.1080/01969722.2011.567893 . 40235689 . For example, the Pardes book written by Rabbi Shlomo Yitzhaki, known by the abbreviation Rashi, can be cited using the following patterns: (1) "Shlomo son of Rabbi Yitzhak", (2) "Shlomo son of Yitzhak", (3) "Shlomo Yitzhaki", (4) "In the name of Rashi who wrote in the Pardes.
  2. Book: Ockley, Simon . 1707 . History of the Present Jews Throughout the World . 74.
  3. Book: Abraham, Philip . 1879 . Curiosities of Judaism . By and for the author . 2.
  4. Book: 1857 . The Literary Churchman . 286.
  5. Book: fr. Histoire critique du Vieux Testament. Simon, R.. 1685. chez Reinier Leers. 545. 2015-08-01.
  6. Book: Wolf, Johann Christoph . 1715 . R. Schelomo ben Isaac . https://books.google.com/books?id=zQIVAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA1057 . Bibliotheca Hebræa . la . 1 . Hamburg & Leipzig . 1057–1058. 01010257.
  7. Book: Histoire littéraire de la France: Treizième siècle. Benedictinos. Congregación de Santo Mauro (Francia). Académie des inscriptions et belles-lettres (Francia). Treuttel et Wü rtz (Estrasburgo). 1824. fr. 16. Firmin Didot. 337. 2015-08-01.
  8. Book: de. Israelitische Annalen. 1839. J.D. Sauerländer. 328. 2015-08-01.
  9. Book: Mayer I. Gruber. Rashi's Commentary on Psalms. 10 October 2007. Jewish Publication Society. 978-0-8276-0872-6. 1–.
  10. Book: John Kitto. A Cyclopædia of Biblical Literature. 1876. Black. 643–.
  11. Web site: Index to Articles on Rabbinic Genealogy in Avotaynu: The International Review of Jewish Genealogy . 2008-06-11 . Avotaynu . 2023-06-03 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230603103922/https://www.jewishgen.org/Rabbinic/infofiles/avotaynu.htm . live .
  12. [s:he:שבת פה ב#רש"י|Shabbat 85b]
  13. See Rashi's comments in Shabbat 85b.
  14. Web site: Rabbi Yehiel Ben Shlomo Heilprin - (Circa 5420-5506; 1660-1746). 2020-06-28. www.chabad.org. en. 2020-06-28. https://web.archive.org/web/20200628203224/https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/112344/jewish/Rabbi-Yehiel-Ben-Shlomo-Heilprin.htm. live.
  15. Book: Hurwitz, Simon . Solomon Luria . The Responsa of Solomon Luria . en. 1938 . New York, New York . 146–151.
  16. Can We Prove Descent from King David?. Avotaynu. 1992. David. Einsiedler. VIII. 3(Fall). 29. 2008-06-11. 2023-02-03. https://web.archive.org/web/20230203172425/https://www.jewishgen.org/Rabbinic/journal/descent.htm. live.
  17. Web site: Shiur 08 - Rashi, Tosfos, And The Development Of Ashkenazi Jewry - Rabbi Menachem Levine - TD19191. torahdownloads.com. 2018-12-17. 2018-12-17. https://web.archive.org/web/20181217154640/http://torahdownloads.com/shiur-19191.html. live.
  18. Liber, Maurice. Rashi, Kessinger Publishing, 2004. pg. 18–19.
  19. Book: Wiesel, Elie . Rashi: A Portrait . Schocken Books Inc . 2009 . 9780805242546 . New York, NY . 1-14 . English.
  20. How Did Rashi Make a Living? . Mayer I. Gruber . the Seforim blog . 2023-09-03 . 2023-09-03 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230903172229/https://seforimblog.com/2007/08/mayer-i-gruber-how-did-rashi-make/ . live .
  21. Maurice Liber, Rashi, trans. Adele Szold (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1906), p 56; Irving Agus, The Heroic Age of Franco-German Jewry (New York: Yeshiva University Press, 1969), 173; Israel S. Elfenbein, "Rashi in His Responsa", in Rashi, His Teachings and Personality, ed. Simon Federbusch (New York: Cultural Division of the World Jewish Congress, 1958), p 67; Salo W. Baron, "Rashi and the Community of Troyes", in Rashi Anniversary Volume, ed. H. L. Ginsberg (New York: American Academy for Jewish Research, 1941), p 60. "Rashi was a vintner who grew grapes and sold wine."
  22. Oxford Bodleian Ms. Oppenheim 276, p. 35a, cited by Avraham Grossman, The Early Sages of France, 132; 135, n. 45.
  23. R. Halperin, Rashi: Chayav u'Ferushav, vol. 1 (Tel Aviv: Hekdesh Ruach Yaakov, 1997), 107-22. Referred to in Yonatan Kolatch, Masters of the Word: Traditional Jewish Bible Commentary from the First Through Tenth Centuries (Brooklyn NY: KTAV Publishing House, Inc., 2006), 18., 9780881259391
  24. Grossman, Avraham (2012). Rashi, p.12
  25. News: The Discovery of the Resting Places of Rashi and the Baalei Hatosfos . Y. Friedman . Dei'ah Vedibur . 2005-07-25 . 2013-07-12 . 2014-03-26 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140326141413/http://www.chareidi.org/archives5765/mattos/MTS65features.htm . live .
  26. Book: Shereshevsky, Ezra. Rashi - the Man and His World. Sepher-Hermon. 1982.
  27. [Avraham Grossman]
  28. [s:he:מכות יט ב#רש"י|Makkot 19b]
  29. Jacobi Papers, Vol 4, p. 8, B.5
  30. Web site: רבן של ישראל (Hebrew) . Mordechai Menashe Laufer . he . 2007-07-13 . 2023-05-28 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230528140628/http://www.chabad.org.il/Magazines/Article.asp?ArticleID=3822&CategoryID=957 . live .
  31. Web site: Rashi's Method of Biblical Commentary - Rashi's Method of Biblical Commentary, and the Rebbe's approach to Rashi's works - Jewish History . chabad.org . 2015-08-01 . 2017-06-27 . https://web.archive.org/web/20170627032957/http://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/476620/jewish/Rashis-Method-of-Biblical-Commentary.htm . live .
  32. Web site: The Books of the People of the Book - Hebraic Collections: An Illustrated Guide (Library of Congress - African & Middle Eastern Division). www.loc.gov. 2019-11-03. 2011-02-27. https://web.archive.org/web/20110227093742/http://www.loc.gov/rr/amed/guide/hs-books.html. live.
  33. I.Gruber, Mayer. Rashi's Commentary on Psalms, Brill - The Jewish Publication Society, Philadelphia 2007
  34. Eran Viezel, The Commentary on Chronicles Attributed to Rashi, Jerusalem: The Hebrew University Magnes Press, 2010
  35. Penkower . Jordan S. . 2003 . The End of Rashi's Commentary on Job. The Manuscripts and the Printed Editions (with three appendices) . Jewish Studies Quarterly . 10 . 1 . 18–48 . 10.1628/0944570033029194 . 40753321 . 0944-5706.
  36. Levy, Steven, and Sarah Levy. “Introduction.” The JPS Rashi Discussion Torah Commentary, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, 2017, pp. xv-xx. JSTOR (link)
  37. Viezel, Eran. "“The Anxiety of Influence”: Rashbam's Approach to Rashi's Commentary on the Torah." AJS Review 40.2 (2016): 279-303. Print.
  38. 23:29 HE