Shadow bands explained

Shadow bands are thin, wavy lines of alternating light and dark that can be seen moving and undulating in parallel on plain-coloured surfaces immediately before and after a total solar eclipse.^[1] They are caused by the refraction by Earth's atmospheric turbulence^[2] of the solar crescent as it thins to a narrow slit, which increasingly collimates the light reaching Earth in the minute just before and after totality.^{[3] [4]}

The shadows' detailed structure is due to random patterns of fine air turbulence that refract the collimated sunlight arriving from the narrow eclipse crescent.

The bands' rapid sliding motion is due to shifting air currents combined with the angular motion of the Sun projecting through higher altitudes. The degree of collimation in the light gradually increases as the crescent thins, until the solar disk is completely covered and the eclipse is total.

Stars twinkle for the same reason. All light passing through the Earth's atmosphere encounters tiny disturbances in temperature, pressure, and humidity. These disturbances change the air's refractive index, so that the light essentially passes through innumerable tiny prisms. Thus, the entire sky essentially "dances" randomly at the scale of the disturbances. However, they are so small that even the visible disk of planets (Venus, Jupiter, etc) are larger than the "dancing" scale, and so their brightness appears to remain steady. Only stars are visibly affected, because they are so far away that they are essentially pinpoints of light. This is why astronomers sometimes use the phrase, "stars twinkle, planets don't". Similarly, shadow bands are essentially the "twinkling" of the Sun's thin crescent in the seconds surrounding totality.

History

• In 1820, Hermann Goldschmidt of Germany noted shadow bands visible just before and after totality at some eclipses.^{[5] [6] [7]}
• In 1842, George B. Airy, the English astronomer royal, saw his first total eclipse of the Sun. He recalled shadow bands as one of the highlights: "As the totality approached, a strange fluctuation of light was seen upon the walls and the ground, so striking that in some places children ran after it and tried to catch it with their hands."^[8]
• In 1905, Catherine Octavia Stevens observed shadow bands at the start of the total eclipse of August 30 at Cas Català, Majorca. "As to the character of their appearance and mode of progression, it was observed that they swept along with a flight that was at once rapid and orderly, there was no confusion of the wavy lines with one another, but all bore along in one and the same direction in parallel formation, traversing the ground as water-wave reflections may be seen to do on the under surface of a boat, only that there seemed in the case of the shadow-bands to be a more distinct expression of a forward movement." Clouds prevented observations after totality.^[9]
• In 2008, British astrophysicist Stuart Eves speculated that shadow bands might be an effect of infrasound, which involves the shadow of the Moon travelling at supersonic speed and inducing an atmospheric shock wave. However, astronomy professor Barrie Jones, an expert on shadow bands,^[10] stated, "The [accepted] theory works; there's no need to seek an alternative."^[11]
• In 2024, students at the University of Pittsburgh devised an empirical test to collect evidence for both the atmospheric turbulence theory and Eves's moon slit theory.^[12] The test of atmospheric turbulence involved using a high-altitude balloon with weather instruments to measure relationships between humidity, temperature, and barometric pressure in the atmosphere and the shadow bands on the ground. The test of the alternative theory involved sending another high-altitude balloon 90,000 feet above Concan, Texas to detect light patterns indicating shadow bands outside of the atmosphere.

Notes and References

1. http://www.earthview.com/tutorial/effects.htm Effects During a Total Solar Eclipse
2. The Scintillation Theory of Eclipse Shadow Bands. J. L. Codona. Astronomy and Astrophysics. 0004-6361. 164. 415–27. 1986. 2 . 18 July 2017. 1986A&A...164..415C .
3. Web site: Explanation from Barrie Jones, Open University. Barrie. Jones. 2010-07-24.
4. Web site: Wolfgang Strickling's eclipse observations 2001 page. Strickling. Wolfgang. 2007-01-26. The best theory for the emergence of the shadow bands is published by Codona 1986 [2]. His theory meanwhile accepted by the most scientists. ... movement of the shadow bands is caused by winds in the different atmospheric levels.. 24 July 2010.
5. Book: Total Eclipses: Science, Observations, Myths and Legends . Guillermier . Pierre . Koutchmy . Serge . . 1999 . 151 . The phenomenon of shadow bands – a success of light and dark striations – is somewhat random. German astronomer Hermann Goldschmidt was the first to remark upon this complex refraction phenomenon, in 1820..
6. Book: The Sun in Eclipse . Maunder . Michael J. de F. . Moore . Patrick . . 1998 . Eclipses – General Principles . 55 . Shadow Bands. In 1820 the German astronomer Hermann Goldschmidt was the first to notice wavy lines seen across the Earth's surface just before totality. These so-called shadow bands [...].
7. Book: Memoirs . 41 . Chapter IX: Shadow Bands . 40–41 . . 1857.
8. M. Littmann, K. Willcox, F. Espenak: Totality: eclipses of the sun 2nd edition. Oxford University Press. p. 119
9. Stevens, Catherine O., The Problem of "Shadow Bands", Journal of the British Astronomical Association, Volume 16, No 2, 1906, pp60-62
10. Shadow bands during the total solar eclipse of 26 February 1998. Jones, Barrie W.. Journal of Atmospheric and Solar-Terrestrial Physics. 1999 . 61 . 13 . 965–974 . 10.1016/S1364-6826(99)00072-3. 1999JASTP..61..965J .
11. News: 2009-11-14. BBC News. Sound 'cause of shadow spectacle' . May 21, 2008.
12. Web site: 2024-04-06 . Scientists get another chance to study a solar eclipse mystery . 2024-04-08 . KUNC . en.