Serial Item and Contribution Identifier explained

The Serial Item and Contribution Identifier (SICI) was a code (ANSI/NISO standard Z39.56-1996 [R2002]) used to uniquely identify specific volumes, articles or other identifiable parts of a serial. It was "intended primarily for use by those members of the bibliographic community involved in the use or management of serial titles and their contributions". Developed over 1993–1995, NISO adopted SICI as a standard in 1996, then reaffirmed it in 2002.[1] It was withdrawn in 2012.[2]

Description

It is an extension of the International Standard Serial Number, which identifies an entire serial (similar to the way an ISBN identifies a specific book). The ISSN applies to the entire publication, however, including every volume ever printed, so this more specific identifier was developed by the Serials Industry Systems Advisory Committee (SISAC) to allow references to specific parts of a journal.

The variable-length, free of charge, code is compatible with other identifiers, such as DOI, PII and URN.[3] [4] Prior to January 2009, SICIs were valid DOI suffixes for registration at the Crossref registration agency. However, to accommodate a security problem with Microsoft's Internet Explorer, they decided that they would soon refuse to register DOI suffixes that contain the colon character.[5]

The SICI is a recognized international standard and is in wide use by publishers and the bibliographic community, primarily as an aid to finding existing articles or issues.[6] JSTOR adopted SICIs in 2001 as its primary article-level identifier and the core of its stable and citation-derivable URLs. SICI was selected over simpler alternatives because of its ability to encompass the many varieties of journal metadata found in JSTOR's archive.[7] However, due to difficulties encountered by its partners in calculating the correct values for the title code and the check digit, JSTOR's implementation of the standard ignores those elements.[8] [9] JSTOR now recommends against using SICI, and instead strongly suggests using DOIs instead.[10] This is also done because sometimes multiple articles on the same page have exactly the same name (in particular "Obituary").

Details

The SICI code is composed of three segments, intended to be both human-readable and easy for machines to parse automatically. The following example SICI is explained below:[11]

Item
Abstract from Lynch, Clifford A. "The Integrity of Digital Information; Mechanics and Definitional Issues." JASIS 45:10 (Dec. 1994) p. 737-44
SICI
0002-8231(199412)45:10<737:TIODIM>2.3.TX;2-M

Item segment

0002-8231

This is the ISSN for the serial, in this case the Journal of the American Society for Information Science

(199412)

The chronology part is in parentheses and identifies the date of publication. In this case, it is signified by year and month; 1994 December

45:10

The enumeration part signifies the volume and number; Vol. 45, no. 10.

Contribution segment

<
  • Signifies the start of the contribution segment737

    Location code: signifies the page number, frame number, reel number, etc. In this case, page 737

    TIODIM

    Title code: based on the title of the article. In this case, an initialism: "The Integrity of Digital Information; Mechanics and Definitional Issues".

    >
  • Signifies the end of the contribution segment

    Control segment

    2
  • Code Structure Identifier (CSI) for the type of SICI being constructed3

    Derivative Part Identifier (DPI) identifies a part of the contribution, such as a table of contents or abstract

    TX
  • Format identifier two-letter code signifying the way content is presented. In this case, TX = printed text
    2-
  • Standard version number
    M
  • Check character allows a computer to detect errors in the code, similar to ISBN's check digit

    Examples

    Item
  • Bjorner, Susanne. "Who Are These Independent Information Brokers?" Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science, Feb-Mar. 1995, Vol. 21, no. 3, page 12
    SICI
  • 0095-4403(199502/03)21:3<12:WATIIB>2.0.TX;2-J

    Information

    To use as an info URI, the SICI is percent-encoded and prefixed.

    INFO
  • info:sici/1046-8188(199501)13:1%3C69:FTTHBI%3E2.0.TX;2-4

    URN

    To use in a URN, the SICI is percent-encoded and prefixed.[12] For example, to create a URN for a specific article "From text to hypertext by indexing" in the journal ACM Transactions on Information Systems:

    SICI
  • 1046-8188(199501)13:1<69:FTTHBI>2.0.TX;2-4
    URN
  • URN:SICI:1046-8188(199501)13:1%3C69:FTTHBI%3E2.0.TX;2-4

    This could then be used to refer to the article inside an HTML citation (in the [[HTML element#General phrase elements|<nowiki><cite></nowiki>]] element), for instance, in a way that is superior to an HTTP link for documents that are not on the web or have transient URLs:[13]

    A model is presented for converting a collection of documents to hypertextby means of indexing. The documents are assumed to be semistructured, i.e.,their text is a hierarchy of parts, and some of the parts consist of naturallanguage. The model is intended as a framework for specifying hypertextualreading capabilities for specific application areas and for developing newautomated tools for the conversion of semistructured text to hypertext.

    An Internet Draft proposal to officially register the SICI namespace for URNs with IANA was made in 2002, but is currently dormant.[14] [15]

    DOI

    SICI codes can be used as the item ID in a DOI identifier.[16] In the following example, the number 10.1002 is the DOI's publisher ID, a slash acts as a separator, and the rest, which is publisher-specific, is the SICI code:

    CrossRef no longer allows DOIs with colons to be registered, greatly reducing the usefulness of such SICIs.[5]

    Revisions

    See also

    Further reading

    External links

    Notes and References

    1. See "Published & Approved NISO Standards," in "Year in Review & State of the Standards, January 31, 2012," by National Information Standards Organization (NISO), special issue, Information Standards Quarterly, 24, 1 (Winter 2012): 33–34 at 34,, .
    2. "Withdrawn NISO Standards," in "State of the Standards, January 31, 2013," by National Information Standards Organization (NISO), special issue, Information Standards Quarterly, 25, 1 (Spring 2013): 27–33 at 33,, .
    3. Web site: The DOI (Digital Object Identifier) . Cliff . Morgan . https://web.archive.org/web/20040317053452/http://www.uksg.org/serials/doi.asp . 2004-03-17.
    4. Paskin. Norman. Document identifiers: an update on current activities. ICSTI Forum. September 1996. 23. https://web.archive.org/web/20021118041502/http://www.icsti.org/forum/23/index.html . 2002-11-18.
    5. Web site: Creating a DOI suffix.
    6. Web site: 6. Evaluation of the Identification Schemes. https://web.archive.org/web/20120205011615/http://hosted.ukoln.ac.uk/biblink/wp2/d2.1/doc0006.htm. 2012-02-05.
    7. http://news.jstor.org/jstornews/2001/06/june_2001_no_5_issue_2_jstor_a.html JSTOR and "Deep Linking"
    8. Koppel. Ted. July 2004. The SICI Emerges, Cicada-Like, After Eight Years of Dormancy. Information Standards Quarterly. 16. 3. 1–6 at 1, 4. 1041-0031. 2020-04-03.
    9. http://makealink.jstor.org/sici.standard.html The SICI Standard
    10. Web site: SICI Linking. While we will continue to support SICI linking, we advise that linking partners use OpenURL syntax for the most reliable linking experience. 2016-08-12 . 2016-11-14 . https://web.archive.org/web/20161114033558/http://about.jstor.org/jstor-help-support/discovery-linking#399081. dead.
    11. http://www.ukoln.ac.uk/bib-man/factfile/standard-numbers/sici/ What is the SICI?
    12. http://www.scit.wlv.ac.uk/rfc/rfc22xx/RFC2288.html Using Existing Bibliographic Identifiers as Uniform Resource Names
    13. Web site: URNs and bibliographic citations in web authoring – BenMeadowcroft.com.
    14. Web site: Using Serial Item and Contribution Identifiers as Uniform Resource Names. Juna. Hakala.
    15. http://refactored-networks.com/urn/urn-nid-status.html URN NID Assignment Status
    16. Unique Identifiers in a Digital World. Ariadne. Andy. Powell. 1 January 1997. 8.