Selina Robinson Explained

Selina Robinson
Honorific-Suffix:MLA
Birth Name:Selina Mae Dardick
Birth Place:Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Office:Minister of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills of British Columbia
Term Start:December 7, 2022
Term End:February 5, 2024
Premier:David Eby
Predecessor:Anne Kang
Office1:Minister of Finance of British Columbia
Term Start1:November 26, 2020
Term End1:December 7, 2022
Premier1:John Horgan
David Eby
Predecessor1:Carole James
Successor1:Katrine Conroy
Office2:Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing of British Columbia
Term Start2:July 18, 2017
Term End2:November 26, 2020
Premier2:John Horgan
Predecessor2:Ellis Ross (Minister of Housing)
Successor2:David Eby (Minister Responsible for Housing)
Josie Osborne (Minister of Municipal Affairs)
Office3:Minister of Citizens' Services of British Columbia
Premier3:John Horgan
Term Start3:October 4, 2019
Term End3:January 22, 2020
Predecessor3:Jinny Sims
Successor3:Anne Kang
Assembly4:British Columbia Legislative
Constituency Am4:Coquitlam-Maillardville
Term Start4:May 14, 2013
Predecessor4:Diane Thorne
Party:Independent (2024–present)
Residence:Coquitlam, British Columbia
Alma Mater:Simon Fraser University
Successor:Lisa Beare
Otherparty:New Democrat (until 2024)

Selina Mae Robinson (née Dardick; born 1964) is a Canadian politician who was elected to the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia in the 2013 provincial election.[1] She represents the electoral district of Coquitlam-Maillardville as an Independent.[2] She previously served in the cabinet of British Columbia between 2017 and 2024 as a member of the British Columbia New Democratic Party (BC NDP).

Biography

Born in Montreal as Selina Dardick, she moved with her parents to Richmond, British Columbia, in 1978.[3] [4] After graduating from Simon Fraser University with a master's degree in counselling psychology,[1] she joined the Jewish Family Service Agency, eventually becoming its associate executive director.[4] A resident of Coquitlam since 1994, she worked as a family therapist before entering politics as a member of Coquitlam City Council.[5]

In September 2012, Robinson announced her intention to seek the BC NDP nomination for Coquitlam-Maillardville in the next provincial election;[6] she was acclaimed the NDP's candidate for the riding in November that year.[7] She was initially declared defeated on election night in 2013, with Steve Kim of the BC Liberals deemed winner by 105 votes. However, once absentee ballots were counted, she pulled ahead to win the riding by a 35-vote margin over Kim.[8] A judicial recount confirmed Robinson's victory by a final margin of 41 votes.[9] She served as critic for mental health and addictions, seniors, local government and sports in the NDP shadow cabinet.[10]

In the 2017 provincial election, Robinson once again faced Steve Kim, this time winning by more than 2400 votes.[11] She was subsequently appointed Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing in the new BC NDP government under Premier John Horgan.[12] [13] Following the resignation of Jinny Sims from cabinet in October 2019, Robinson briefly assumed the role of Minister of Citizens' Services,[14] until Anne Kang took over the position in January 2020.[15]

Following her re-election in 2020, she was appointed Minister of Finance.[16] [17] After Horgan announced his retirement as premier and party leader in 2022, Robinson considered running to replace him before deciding otherwise.[18] [19] On December 7, 2022, she was appointed Minister of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills by Premier David Eby.[20]

Following the terrorist attack on southern Israel by Hamas on October 7, 2023, Robinson claimed that Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General Mike Farnworth called her "every single day from Oct. 7 for about 10 days, to report in to me about what was happening on the ground".[21] Robinson worked with B'nai Brith to mandate Holocaust education in the school curriculum which would be organized by CIJA, an organization that has been pivotal in lobbying Canadian politicians to support Israel.

In early 2024, Robinson faced criticism for comments made during an online event hosted by B'nai Brith Canada, claiming that Israel was founded on "a crappy piece of land with nothing on it – you know, there were several hundred thousand people but other than that, it didn’t produce an economy. It couldn’t grow things it didn’t have anything on it".[22] Adel Iskandar, a professor at Simon Fraser University, stated that "There’s absolutely no history book that would affirm Minister Robinson’s articulation of that period in time... Obviously it was not a 'crappy piece of land'. It is the land that has had over 15,000 years of human habitability", and describing the suggestion that the land was empty as a "fundamentally colonialist narrative". Federal NDP MP Matthew Green characterised Robinson's comments as historically inaccurate and "deeply derogatory and insensitive", and called on Eby to reconsider Robinson's ministerial position.[23] Robinson apologised for the comments later that week, calling them "disrespectful," continuing to clarify "I was referring to the fact that the land has limited natural resources". In a statement, Eby said that Robinson's claim was "wrong and unacceptable... I thank her for withdrawing the comments and apologizing unreservedly", though Robinson did not publicly withdraw the comment.

On February 1, 2024, the Federation of Post-Secondary Educators of BC (FPSE) alongside the Canadian Association of University Teachers (CAUT) released a statement calling on David Eby to call for the immediate resignation of Robinson.[24] FPSE also describe Robinson as undermining "the democratic principles of freedom of expression, academic freedom, and a college and university system free of direct manipulation by the provincial government" given that Robinson had been directly involved in pressuring Langara College to fire Dr. Natalie Knight regarding her comments in support of the 7th October Massacre. They cite Robinson, retweeting a call by the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA) for Langara to fire Knight and that Robinson had later met with the College to express concerns about Knight’s reinstatement.

On February 5, 2024, she was dismissed from her position as Minister of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills because of comments about Israel being founded on a 'crappy piece of land,',[25] which reflected denial of the violence of colonialism and potential support for a settler colony, although Robinson clarified she was referring to the fact that the land has limited natural resources.[26] [27] After a protest of the BC NDP retreat in Surrey, BC, Robinson was dismissed.[28] Following her dismissal, she announced she feels unsupported as a Jewish woman in her party, that she faced double standards by her party and would not seek re-election as an MLA at the 2024 election.

On March 6, 2024, she announced she would sit as an independent.

Notes and References

  1. News: 2013-05-27. NDP candidate Selina Robinson wins in Coquitlam-Maillardville after final votes tallied. 2022-12-15. The Georgia Straight. Charlie. Smith. en-CA.
  2. News: 2024-03-06 . Selina Robinson resigns from NDP caucus . 2024-03-04 . CBC News.
  3. Web site: JHSBC Oral History Collection: Selina Robinson . 2022-12-15 . Jewish Museum and Archives of BC. en.
  4. Web site: 2017-04-28. NDP values in kishkes . 2022-12-15 . The Jewish Independent. en.
  5. Web site: Coquitlam MLA's role is building strong communities . 2022-12-15 . Tri-City News. September 27, 2022 . en.
  6. News: 2012-09-24. Robinson to run provincially. 2022-12-15. Tri-City News. Janis. Warren. en-CA.
  7. News: 2012-12-18. MLA, councillor acclaimed. 2022-12-15. Tri-City News. Janis. Warren. en-CA.
  8. News: 2013-05-28. NDP takes lead in Coquitlam-Maillardville final count. 2022-12-15. CBC News. en-CA.
  9. News: 2013-06-05. UPDATED: Selina Robinson wins MLA seat. 2022-12-15. Tri-City News. Janis. Warren. en-CA.
  10. Web site: MLA: Hon. Selina Robinson . Legislative Assembly of British Columbia . 2022-12-15.
  11. News: 2017-05-09.
    1. bcelxn17: Coquitlam-Maillardville: NDP's Robinson avoids repeat of 2013 recount with win over Kim
    . 2022-12-15. Tri-City News. en-CA.
  12. News: 2017-07-18 . B.C.'s new NDP government sworn into office . 2022-12-15 . . Richard . Zussman . Justin . McElroy . en-CA.
  13. 2017-07-18 . Premier John Horgan announces new cabinet to build a better B.C. . 2022-12-15 . Office of the Premier of British Columbia . en.
  14. News: 2019-10-04 . B.C. cabinet minister Jinny Sims resigns amid RCMP investigation . 2022-12-15 . . en-CA.
  15. News: 2020-01-22 . B.C. premier fills Jinny Sims vacancy, swaps jobs in cabinet tweak . 2022-12-15 . . en-CA.
  16. Web site: Breaking - Selina Robinson has been named BC's Minister of Finance . November 26, 2020 . Twitter.com. en.
  17. News: New faces join B.C.'s new cabinet, while stalwarts stay on in key roles . . Bethany . Lindsay . 2020-11-26 . 2022-04-24 .
  18. News: 2022-07-14 . Coquitlam's most powerful female politician thinking about NDP leadership bid. 2022-12-15 . Tri-City News . Diane . Strandberg . en-CA.
  19. News: 2022-07-18 . B.C. Finance Minister Selina Robinson won't seek BC NDP leadership. 2022-12-15 . Global News . Richard . Zussman . en-CA.
  20. Web site: B.C. Premier David Eby unveils new cabinet with Niki Sharma, Katrine Conroy and Ravi Kahlon in top posts . 2022-12-07 . . en-CA.
  21. Web site: Saks . Arly . 2023-11-13 . Students to learn of Holocaust . 2024-02-03 . B'nai Brith Canada . en-US.
  22. Web site: Selina Robinson under fire for calling Gaza 'a crappy piece of land' . Wadhwani . Ashley . Collins. Lauren. 1 February 2024 . Chilliwack Progress. 2 February 2024.
  23. Web site: Selina Robinson apologizes after 'disrespectful,' historically inaccurate comments about Israel . . 2 February 2024 . . 2 February 2024.
  24. Web site: FPSE Calls for Immediate Resignation of the Minister of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills . 2024-02-03 . fpse . en-CA.
  25. News: 2024-02-05 . Senior B.C. minister Selina Robinson removed from cabinet by premier for saying Israel founded on 'crappy piece of land' . 2024-02-05 . The Globe and Mail . en-CA.
  26. Web site: A closer look at the racist myth at the heart of Selina Robinson's comments . Ricochet . February 7, 2024 .
  27. Web site: 2024-02-02 . Selina Robinson under fire for calling Gaza ‘a crappy piece of land’ . 2024-07-02 . The Chilliwack Progress . en.
  28. Web site: Judd . Dozens protest BC NDP retreat, demanding Selina Robinson resign following Israel comments - BC | Globalnews.ca .