Self-immolation protests by Tibetans in China explained

As of May 2022, 160 monks, nuns, and ordinary people have self-immolated in Tibet[1] [2] [3] [4] since 27 February 2009, when Tapey, a young monk from Kirti Monastery, set himself on fire in the marketplace in Ngawa City, Ngawa County, Sichuan. According to the International Campaign for Tibet (ICT),[5] "Chinese police have beaten, shot, isolated, and disappeared self-immolators who survived."[6]

In 2011, a wave of self-immolations by Tibetans in Tibet, as well as in India and Nepal, occurred after the self-immolation of Phuntsog of 16 March 2011 in Ngawa County, Sichuan. Protests are ongoing.[7]

Summary

Most of the protesters have been monks and nuns, or ex-monks[8] Some of the protesters who set themselves on fire were teenagers.[9] [10] [11] [12]

Most protests have taken place in Amdo near the Kirti Monastery, especially in Ngawa City, Ngawa County, Sichuan,[13] others in Gansu and Qinghai and Tibet Autonomous Region. Self-immolation protests by Tibetans also occurred in India[14] and Kathmandu, Nepal.[15]

According to Reuters the Dalai Lama said in March 2012 he does not encourage the protests, but he has praised the courage of those who had engaged in self-immolation[16] and blamed the self-immolations on "cultural genocide" by the Chinese.[9] Four months later the Dalai Lama made clear that he wishes to remain neutral regarding this topic and he explained why to The Hindu:[17]

When asked by an Australian journalist – in the context of self-immolations to oppose Chinese rule and policies – if Tibetans are "losing patience with non-violence", the Dalai Lama replied:

French anthropologist Katia Buffetrille comments:

Wen Jiabao, then premier of China, said that such extreme actions hurt social harmony and that Tibet and the Tibetan areas of Sichuan are integral parts of Chinese territory.[18] According to The Economist, the self-immolations have caused the government's attitude to harden.[15] Stephen Prothero, a Boston University religion scholar, writing on CNN Belief Blog, suggests: "Why not create [what the Dalai Lama describes as] 'some kind of impression' that killing was wrong? Why not use his vast store of moral and spiritual capital to denounce this ritual of human sacrifice?", adding that "if the Dalai Lama were to speak out unequivocally against these deaths, they would surely stop. So in a very real sense, their (self-immolators’) blood is on his (the Dalai Lama's) hands."[19] Tenzin Dorjee, executive director of Students for a Free Tibet, opposed that view on the CNN Belief Blog, urging to "understand the self-immolations" and arguing "instead of responding to China’s oppression with revenge – a path far more tempting to the basic human instinct – Tibetans have chosen a means far more peaceful. Without harming a single Chinese…". He is of the opinion that Stephen Prothero expresses "a colossal indifference to the courage and circumstances of those fighting for the same democratic freedoms and human rights that he himself enjoys."[20]

Impact

Self-immolations by Tibetans protesting Chinese domination of Tibet have had a greater impact than earlier protests. Despite considerable loss of life during the Tibetan protests in 2008 on the part of both the Tibetan and Han population in Tibet, casualties were simply not reported by the Chinese government. Self-immolations, on the other hand, result in dramatic images of the protester, while burning or afterwards,[21] which can be easily transmitted over the internet to news media and supporters. Internet access has reached even remote areas in the parts of China where Tibetans live.[22]

However, sensitive areas of Tibet are often subject to communication clampdowns.[23] These blackouts, along with the ban of foreign journalists and human rights monitors, means obtaining exact numbers of self immolations in Tibet is difficult. However, a number of organizations, such as Free Tibet, do keep up-to-date lists of confirmed incidents. Most of the Tibetan independence movement organizations state that self-immolation acts of Tibetans are an affirmation of the Tibetan identity in the face of "cultural genocide". These records of self-immolation often receive significant international attention and are often referenced when conducting awareness fundraising activities for freedoms in Tibet, receiving with wide support from cultural exponents like Hollywood actors or famous musicians.[24]

Time and place

2009

February: Ngawa 1

2011

March: Ngawa 1,August: Kardze (Dau County) 1,September: Ngawa 2,October: Ngawa 5, Kardze 1,November: Kardze (Dau County) 1, India 1, Nepal 1,December: Chamdo 1

2012

January (4): Ngawa 3, Golog 1,February (6): Ngawa 4, Yushu (Thridu County) 1, Amdo Haixi 1,March (11): Kanlho 1, Ngawa 7, Malho (Rebkong County) 2, India 1,April (4): Kardze 2, Ngawa 2,May (3): Lhasa City 2, Ngawa 1,June (4): Malho (Cantsha County) 1, Yushu (Thridu County) 2, Yushu 1,July (2): Lhasa (Damshung County) 1, Ngawa 1,August (7): Ngawa 6, Kanlho 1,September (2): Beijing 1, Yushu (Zado County) 1,October (10): Nagchu 1, Kanlho 7, Nagchu (Driru County) 2,November (28): Malho (Rebkong County) 9, Malho (Zeku County) 3, Amdo Haidong 1, Ngawa 3, Ngawa (Zoige County) 2, Kardze 1, Nagchu (Driru County) 1, Kanlho 2, Kanlho (Sangchu County) 3, Kanlho (Luchu County) 3,December (5): Kanlho (Sangchu County) 1, Kanlho (Luchu County) 1, Golog 1, Ngawa 1, Malho 1,

2013

January (3): Kanlho (Sangchu County) 2, Ngawa 1,February (9): Ngawa 1, Kanlho (Sangchu County) 2, Nepal 1, Ngawa (Zoige County) 3, Amdo Haidong 1, Kanlho (Luchu County) 1,March (5): Ngawa (Zoige County) 1, Ngawa 2, Kanlho (Sangchu County) 1, Kanlho (Luchu County) 1,April (3): Ngawa 1, Ngawa (Zoige) 2,May (1): Yushu (Chumarleb County) 1,June (1): Kardze (Dau County) 1,July (1): Ngawa (Zoige County) 1,August (1): Nepal 1,September (1): Ngawa 1,November (1): Golog 1,December (2): Ngawa 1, Kanlho (Sangchu County) 1,

2014

February (2): Malho 1, Ngawa 1,March (3): Malho 1, Ngawa 1, Kardze (Litang County) 1,April (1): Kardze (Dau County) 1,September: (2) Golog 1, Kanlho 1,December (3): Kanlho 1, Ngawa 1, Kardze (Dau County) 1,

2015

March: Ngawa 1,April (2): Kardze 1, Ngawa 1,May (2): Kardze (Dau County) 1, Kanlho (Jonê County) 1, July (1): Yushu, August (1): Kanlho (Sangqu county)1,

2016

February (1): Kardze (Nyarong county), March (1): Ngawa (Dzoege county), December (1): Kardze (Machu county),

2017

March (1): Kardze, April (1): Kardze, May (2): Kanlho (Bora county) 1, Chentsa (Malho county), November (1): Kardze, December (1): Chukle Gongma pastoral community in Cha village, Ngaba county[25]

2018

March (1): (5th village, Meuruma Township, Ngaba County), November (1): (Jakorma village in the Choejema area, Ngaba County)[26]

2019

November (1): (Meruma in Ngaba)[27]

2022

February (1): Nagchu, March (1): Kirti (Ngaba county)

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. News: Fadiman. Anne. 2020-07-28. The Chinese Town That Became the Self-Immolation Capital of the World. en-US. The New York Times. 2020-10-21. 0362-4331.
  2. News: Tibetan Monk Dies After Self-Immolating In Eastern Tibet. Free Tibet. 20 May 2017.
  3. News: Wong. Edward. 11 April 2015. Nun Sets Herself on Fire to Protest Chinese Rule in Tibet. The New York Times. 11 April 2015. She was the second woman to set herself on fire this year and the 138th Tibetan to do so since 2009 in Tibetan regions ruled by China, according to the International Campaign for Tibet, an advocacy group based in Washington..
  4. Web site: Self-immolations . 2022-07-17 . International Campaign for Tibet . en-US.
  5. Self-immolation fact sheet, (2 December 2019), https://savetibet.org/tibetan-self-immolations/
  6. News: Ross. Tracy. 24 September 2019. Tibet Is Still Burning. Outside. 21 October 2020.
  7. Web site: Latest news & blogs | Free Tibet. freetibet.org. 16 September 2020.
  8. News: Teenage Tibetan nun sets herself on fire in China . Associated Press . 12 February 2012. 12 February 2012. . London.
  9. News: Teenage Tibetan monk self-immolates, dies: rights group . Reuters . 19 February 2012 . 29 May 2012.
  10. News: Tibetan teen burns himself to death in China protest . BBC News . 6 March 2012 . 29 May 2012.
  11. News: Teenage Tibetan nun sets herself on fire in China . The Daily Telegraph . 12 February 2012 . 29 May 2012 . London.
  12. News: Two Tibetan teenagers die in self-immolations . BBC News . 28 August 2012.
  13. News: In Occupied Tibetan Monastery, a Reason for Fiery Deaths. 3 June 2012. The New York Times. 2 June 2012. Edward Wong.
  14. News: Self-immolation in India: Frighteningly common . The Economist . 26 March 2012 . 29 May 2012.
  15. News: No impact: Tibetan protests seem increasingly ineffective . The Economist . 31 March 2012 . 29 May 2012.
  16. News: Teenage monk sets himself on fire on 53rd anniversary of failed Tibetan uprising . The Daily Telegraph . 13 March 2012 . 29 May 2012 . London.
  17. News: Dalai Lama speaks of dilemma on spreading self-immolations . The Hindu . 9 July 2012 . 1 January 2015 .
  18. News: China Premier Wen Jiabao's comments at NPC press conference . Reuters . 14 March 2012 . 29 May 2012.
  19. Book: Richard B. Miller. Friends and Other Strangers: Studies in Religion, Ethics, and Culture. 2016. Columbia University Press. 978-0-231-54155-8. 90–. and My Take: Dalai Lama should condemn Tibetan self-immolations
  20. Web site: My Take: Why the Dalai Lama cannot condemn Tibetan self-immolations. 16 September 2020.
  21. Web site: Photos of immolations . 15 June 2012 . 20 June 2012 . SaveTibet.org . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20120303182336/http://savetibet.org/resource-center/maps-data-fact-sheets/photos-protests-crackdowns-and-self-immolations-self-immolations . 3 March 2012 . dmy-all .
  22. News: Technology Reaches Remote Tibetan Corners, Fanning Unrest. 24 May 2012. The New York Times. 23 May 2012. Andrew Jacobs. Andrew Jacobs (journalist).
  23. Web site: Communications clampdown . Free Tibet . 19 March 2013 . 13 June 2013.
  24. Web site: Twitter. 2009-03-13. Stars support Dalai Lama. 2021-11-29. Los Angeles Times. en-US.
  25. Web site: Immolations . 31 January 2012 . 22 January 2023.
  26. Web site: Immolations . 31 January 2012 . 22 January 2023.
  27. Web site: Immolations . 31 January 2012 . 22 January 2023.