NY SAFE Act explained

State:New York
Full Name:New York Secure Ammunition and Firearms Enforcement Act
Signed:January 15, 2013
Governor:Andrew Cuomo
Associated Bills:Gun Legislation Bill
Status:partly_in_force
Status Extended:restriction allowing only 7 rounds ruled unconstitutional, changed to 10 rounds

The New York Secure Ammunition and Firearms Enforcement Act of 2013, commonly known as the NY SAFE Act, is a gun control law in the state of New York. The law was passed by the New York State Legislature and was signed into law by Governor of New York Andrew Cuomo in January 2013. The legislation was written in response to the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in Newtown, Connecticut, and the Webster, New York, shooting. Cuomo described the law as the toughest gun control law in the United States.

The NY SAFE Act contains a number of firearms regulations. It also contains a severability provision that allows other measures to remain in place in case the broad prohibitions against weapons are invalidated by the courts.

Legislative history

The New York State Senate approved the act on a 43–18 vote on January 14, 2013.[1] The vote was bipartisan,[2] with nine Senate Republicans voting in favor.[3] State Senator Jeffrey D. Klein sponsored the legislation.[4]

The following day (the second full day of the 2013 legislative session), the New York State Assembly approved the legislation by a 104–43 vote, and Governor Andrew Cuomo signed the bill into law less than one hour later.[1] The passage of the law made New York the first to pass restrictions on gun laws since the Sandy Hook massacre.[5] [6] Cuomo described the law as the toughest gun control law in the United States.[7]

The bill passed under the "message of necessity" procedure, a device in the New York State Constitution by which the governor may expedite a vote on a bill, bypassing a usual three-day waiting period. Although nominally used for emergencies, the "message of necessity" procedure has been frequently used in New York to pass many pieces of legislation (it has been used at least 415 times since 1938).[8]

Provisions

The NY SAFE Act includes the following provisions:[9]

Support

Support for the SAFE Act was strongly polarized by region, with support in New York City and its suburbs, but heavy opposition in upstate New York.[27] Fourteen months after its passage, a Siena College poll showed that 63% of registered New York voters statewide said that they support the SAFE Act, but only 45% upstate voters did.[28] The New York Times reported that in Upstate New York, "Counties, towns and villages have passed resolutions denouncing the laws, and some counties have even demanded that their official seals not be used on any paperwork relating to them. In response to an open records request, the governor's office shared hundreds of pages of such resolutions, from far-flung places like the Adirondack town of North Hudson, with 238 residents, to more populous areas like Erie County."[27] By contrast, Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance, Jr. strongly supported the law, saying that it would "provide law enforcement with stronger tools to protect our communities from gun violence, including provisions that better enable us to combat gun trafficking and violent gangs, and others that close the state gun show loophole and regulate large-quantity sales of ammunition and firearms."[29]

Following the passage of the Act, the New York State Sheriff's Association (NYSSA) wrote a letter offering a mixed opinion on the SAFE Act. The NYSSA favored the parts of the law that enhanced sentences for violent offenses committed with a gun, expanded background checks, and mandated safe storage of guns in households that included a member ineligible to legally use guns. The NYSSA opposed the parts of the law that expanded the definition of assault weapons, limited magazine usage, and limited ammunition sales via the Internet.[30]

Criticism

See also: Second Amendment sanctuary. A number of rallies opposing the law have been held at the New York State Capitol in Albany; one in 2014 featured Donald Trump, Rob Astorino, and Carl Paladino, and drew over 3,000 people.[31] [32] Smaller pro-SAFE Act rallies have also occurred in Albany.[33]

The law was criticized as "rushed through" by the state legislature without consideration of whether it would criminalize police and other law enforcement officers who carry firearms with magazines with a larger capacity than those allowed for civilians.[34]

Republicans in the New York Legislature have made a number of unsuccessful efforts over a series of years to repeal the Act; these efforts have been led by State Senator Kathleen A. Marchione[35] [36] [37] and State Assemblyman Marc Butler.[38] [39] [40]

Some mental health experts expressed concerns that the law might interfere with their treatment of potentially dangerous individuals, or discourage such people from seeking treatment.[41] The United States Veterans Health Administration (VA) has already said they will not comply with the provision requiring release of certain mental health records as it violates federal patient confidentiality laws.[42]

Others argued that this is a backdoor ban on handgun sales, noting that seven-round magazines simply do not exist for many popular models.[43] [44] After realizing seven-round magazines do not exist for most firearms, New York governor Andrew Cuomo reversed his position on the seven-round limit, stating, "There is no such thing as a seven-bullet magazine [sic]. That doesn't exist, so you really have no practical option." He went on to say the state needs to allow the sale of handguns and rifles with ten-round magazines, but requires the people of New York only load seven rounds in them, except at shooting ranges and competitions. He claimed the law is still enforceable.[45] [46] Cuomo and New York State Senate leaders planned an indefinite suspension of the seven-round magazine limit until they could rewrite the measure.[47] In March 2013 during budget negotiations, Cuomo and lawmakers agreed to continue to allow 10-round magazines to be sold, but could still only be loaded with 7 cartridges.[48]

As of 2015, the number of assault weapons registered had not met expectations, suggesting mass non-compliance with the law. Only around 45,000 such registrations were performed, while the estimated number of assault weapons requiring registration neared 1 million.[49]

Legal challenges

On March 11, 2013, the United States Department of Veterans Affairs announced that it would not follow the provision of the NY SAFE Act requiring mental health professionals to report patients who seem more likely to hurt themselves or others. A Department spokesman stated that federal laws protecting the privacy of veterans take precedence over state laws. Advocates for military veterans had expressed concern that the reporting requirement would deter some people from seeking needed treatment.[50]

Robert L. Schulz and several hundred other gun-rights activists pursued a legal challenge against the NY SAFE Act in New York state court, arguing that the act was unconstitutional as Governor Cuomo's use of a "message of necessity" to waive the usual three-day waiting period had violated the New York State Constitution. Judge Thomas J. McNamara of the New York Supreme Court denied the plaintiffs' request for an injunction and later dismissed the challenge, finding no constitutional violation.[51]

A separate challenge took place in federal court. In December 2013, Chief U.S. District Judge William M. Skretny, of the Federal District Court in Buffalo, upheld most of the New York SAFE Act, saying that its provisions "further the state's important interest in public safety.... it does not totally disarm New York's citizens; and it does not meaningfully jeopardize their right to self-defense".[13] However he struck down the provision that only seven rounds of ammunition could be loaded into a ten-round magazine, calling it "an arbitrary restriction" that violated the Second Amendment, and saying that it could result in "pitting the criminal with a loaded magazine against the law-abiding citizen limited to seven rounds."[13]

The New York State Rifle and Pistol Association dropped its suit in March 2016. Following the death of Justice Antonin Scalia, it decided it was unlikely to win a favorable Supreme Court opinion.[52]

Since the 2022 NYSRPA v. Bruen Supreme Court decision striking down another New York gun law, the Sullivan Act (a law pertaining to the application of a pistol/conceal carry permit) from 1911, as unconstitutional, the old standard of interest balancing for deciding the constitutionality of a law has been abolished.[53] Under the previous standard, a law found to be a violation of the Second Amendment could be upheld if it was in the state's interest of public safety. Under the new standard, interest balancing no longer exists. Rather, a law may be struck down if it is a violation of the Second Amendment and if there is no text, history, or tradition of a similar law dating back to the ratification of the Second Amendment in the 1780s.

Due to the recent changes, new challenges to the SAFE Act and other New York gun laws have been proposed and discussed.

Subsequent amendments

The NY SAFE Act as originally passed did not explicitly exempt police officers from some of the law's provisions, such as the seven-round limit, although older law (not repealed by the NY SAFE Act) did provide such an exemption. This prompted some initial confusion, but the office of Governor Andrew Cuomo said soon after passage that police officers were exempt from the seven-round limit.[54] In July 2013, Cuomo signed into law a measure that expressly exempted qualified retired law enforcement officers from some of the provisions of the Act. The exemption allows retired officers (who served for at least ten years and left in good standing) to retain guns and magazines purchased as part of official duty, so long as registered with the state within 60 days of retiring.[55] [56] [57]

Impact on gun manufacturers

In 2013, Justin Moon's Kahr Arms of Pearl River, a gun manufacturer, announced that it would be moving its headquarters from New York to Pennsylvania after the passing of the NY SAFE Act. The company also announced that it would be building a manufacturing facility in Pennsylvania, rather than Orange County, New York, as it had looked into.[58] AR15.com moved in 2013 from Farmington to Texas after passage of the act.[59]

In 2014, the Remington Arms Co. decided to open a manufacturing plant in Huntsville, Alabama. The president of United Mine Workers Local 717, which represents workers at Remington's existing plant in Ilion, New York expressed fears about the future of the New York facility and citing the NY SAFE Act for the company's decision to expand in Alabama rather than New York.[60] Subsequently, about 100 Remington jobs were shifted from New York to Alabama; a Remington Outdoor Company CEO said that the SAFE Act (alongside other factors such as "workforce quality, business environment, tax and economic incentives, and existing infrastructure") contributed to the shift.[61]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Thomas Kaplan, Sweeping Limits on Guns Become Law in New York, The New York Times (January 15, 2013).
  2. News: Cuomo Gun Safety Legislation Passes NY State Senate With Bipartisan Support, Assembly Action Today . Glaser. Howard. January 15, 2013. The Huffington Post. 25 January 2013.
  3. Jimmy Vielkind, Senate set to vote on SAFE Act tweaks, Politico (July 8, 2015).
  4. Teri Weaver, NY senator pushes to ban gun sales, possession for those on U.S. terrorist watch lists, Syracuse.com (December 11, 2015).
  5. News: Campbell. John. N.Y. first state to tighten gun laws after Newtown. 16 January 2013. USA Today. 15 January 2013.
  6. News: New York passes first U.S. gun control bill since Newtown massacre. 16 January 2013. CBS News. 15 January 2013.
  7. News: Walshie. Shushannah. New York Passes Nation's Toughest Gun-Control Law. 16 January 2013. ABC News. 15 January 2013.
  8. Michelle Breidenbach, The Safe Act "emergency": How Cuomo, past governors bypassed public to make laws, Syracuse.com (March 13, 2013).
  9. http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/01/15/16515653-new-york-passes-major-gun-control-law-first-since-newtown-massacre?lite New York passes major gun control law  - first since Newtown massacre
  10. Tom Precious, Appeals court upholds SAFE Act but rules against seven-bullet limit, Buffalo News (October 19, 2015).
  11. http://www.governor.ny.gov/sites/governor.ny.gov/files/archive/assets/documents/safeactfaq.pdf SAFE Act FAQ
  12. James B. Jacobs & Zoe Fuhr, The SAFE Act: New York's Ban on Assault Weapons and Large Capacity Magazines Criminal Law Bulletin (forthcoming, 2017).
  13. Thomas Kaplan, Federal Judge Upholds Majority of New York Gun Law, The New York Times (December 31, 2013).
  14. Web site: Federal court upholds NY SAFE Act.
  15. Thomas Kaplan, Plan to Require Background Checks for Ammunition Sales Is Suspended in New York, The New York Times (July 10, 2015).
  16. Teri Weaver, Cuomo agrees to changes to NY Safe Act regarding ammunition sales, Syracuse.com (July 10, 2015).
  17. http://www.uticaod.com/article/20150713/NEWS/150719769 Questions whether Safe Act deal changes anything
  18. Web site: Six years later, key SAFE Act database undone. Chris. Bragg. August 5, 2019. Times Union.
  19. http://www.nyspsych.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=73 The SAFE Act: Guidelines for Complying With the New Mental Health Reporting Requirement
  20. Anemona Hartocollis, Mental Health Issues Put 34,500 on New York’s No-Guns List, The New York Times (October 19, 2014).
  21. http://www.buffalonews.com/city-region/state/a-closer-look-at-new-york-states-gun-laws-obamas-directives-20160109 A closer look at New York State’s gun laws, Obama’s directives
  22. James B. Jacobs & Zoe Fuhr, Universal Background Checking – New York State's SAFE Act, 79 Albany Law Review (forthcoming 2016).
  23. Teri Weaver, New York's new gun law: Answers to some questions, Syracuse.com (January 16, 2013).
  24. Jon Campbell, Webster Gun Provision, WENY (January 15, 2013).
  25. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/01/14/cuomo-new-york-guns/1833271/ New York Senate passes tough gun law
  26. Rick Karlin, County clerks: State delays handgun permit updates under NY SAFE Act, Times Union (April 16, 2014).
  27. Thomas Kaplan, Cuomo's Gun Law Plays Well Downstate but Alienates Upstate, The New York Times (October 24, 2014).
  28. http://www.wwnytv.com/news/local/New-Yorkers-Favor-SAFE-Act-2-1-Poll-Says-251929471.html New Yorkers Favor SAFE Act 2-1, Poll Says
  29. http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/01/15/16515653-new-york-passes-major-gun-control-law-first-since-newtown-massacre?lite New York passes major gun control law  - first since Newtown massacre
  30. http://www.nysheriffs.org/articles/sheriffs%E2%80%99-response-ny-safe-act Sheriffs' Response to NY SAFE Act
  31. Rick Karlin, Voter bloc hears stars Trump, Paladino; Astorino shows up, Albany Times Union (April 2, 2014).
  32. Gino Geruntino, Critics speak out against SAFE Act during Albany rally, WRVO (April 2, 2014).
  33. Web site: SAFE Act supporters were also out in numbers in Albany this week. 3 April 2014 .
  34. News: NY SAFE Act Faces Changes. Elzufon. Rachel. January 23, 2013. WWKB. 25 January 2013. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20130125030741/http://www.wkbw.com/news/local/NY-SAFE-Act-Faces-Changes-188127761.html. 25 January 2013.
  35. Jordan Carleo-Evangelist, S.C.O.P.E. lauds Marchione for anti-SAFE Act work, Albany Times Union (June 20, 2014).
  36. Michael Goot, http://poststar.com/news/local/safe-act-big-on-marchione-s-agenda/article_2266df8d-681f-5b9a-a7f9-196457f7c1ef.html, Post-Star (July 12, 2015).
  37. http://www.nystateofpolitics.com/2013/02/marchione-introduces-bill-to-overturn-safe-act/ Marchione Introduces Bill To Overturn SAFE Act
  38. Mike McAndrew, After Orlando shooting, Assemblyman cancels news conference on repealing NY SAFE Act, Syracuse.com (June 13, 2016).
  39. http://romesentinel.com/public-safety/butler-presses-for-repeal-of-safe-act-legislation/QBqoft!gAtttGYnirEStz4grMY8DQ/ Butler presses for repeal of SAFE ACT legislation
  40. http://northcountrynow.com/news/st-lawrence-county-republican-assemblyman-marc-butler-working-legislation-repeal-safe-act-votes St. Lawrence County GOP Assemblyman Butler working on legislation to repeal SAFE Act, votes against funding
  41. News: Experts Fear Proposed N.Y. Gun Law Might Hinder Therapy . Associated Press . USA Today . January 15, 2013 . January 19, 2013.
  42. Web site: VA refuses to follow Cuomo gun-registry law. 11 March 2013.
  43. Web site: Anger greets new law at Rochester-area gun shops | Democrat and Chronicle | democratandchronicle.com. https://archive.today/20130215193809/http://www.democratandchronicle.com/article/20130115/NEWS01/301150056/gun-stores-Rochester-law?nclick_check=1. dead. 2013-02-15. 2013-01-30.
  44. Web site: N.Y. gun law mandates magazines that don't exist. .
  45. Web site: NY gun control: Gov. Cuomo opts to reverse decision on magazine size. March 25, 2013 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20130324052804/http://newyork.newsday.com/news/region-state/ny-gun-control-gov-cuomo-opts-to-reverse-decision-on-magazine-size-1.4852695 . March 24, 2013 .
  46. Web site: Katie Pavlich - Oops: New York Governor Wants to Repeal Own Gun Control Law. Katie. Pavlich.
  47. News: KRISS. ERIK. State's new limit on gun magazines put on hold because 7-bullet magazines don't exist. March 22, 2013. New York Post. March 22, 2013.
  48. http://www.democratandchronicle.com/article/20130413/NEWS01/130413006 Magazine limit, gun registration period to begin Monday
  49. Web site: Low assault-weapon registration stats suggest low compliance with Gov. Cuomo's landmark SAFE Act gun control law. Edelman. Adam. nydailynews.com. 23 June 2015 . 2019-03-04.
  50. Virtanen, Michael (March 11, 2013). "VA Says It Won't Follow New York Gun Law", Huffington Post. Retrieved March 11, 2013.
  51. Teri Weaver, NY judge dismisses lawsuit challenging Safe Act, Syracuse.com (April 16, 2016).
  52. Web site: Gun rights group drops SAFE Act challenge.
  53. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-843_7j80.pdf Court document
  54. News: NY Guv Looks to Clarify Gun Law After Concern About Exemption for Police . Berger, Judson . Fox News. January 18, 2013.
  55. Teri Weaver, Gov. Andrew Cuomo signs amendment to NY Safe Act allowing exceptions for retired police, Syracuse.com (July 8, 2013).
  56. Nick Reismanm Cuomo Approves Law Enforcement Exemption In SAFE Act, Capital Tonight, Time Warner Cable News Capital Region, (July 8, 2013).
  57. Glenn Blain, NY Gov. Cuomo Signs SAFE Act Exemption For Retired Cops, New York Daily News (July 8, 2013).
  58. http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/08/08/ny-firearms-maker-blames-new-law-for-move-to-pa/ Firearms maker blames New York gun law for move to Pennsylvania
  59. News: Business blames SAFE Act for move from Farmington. Canandaigua, New York. Melody Burri. . December 8, 2013.
  60. Rick Moriarty, Union official blames Remington Arms expansion in Alabama on NY SAFE Act, Syracuse.com (February 15, 2015).
  61. Ken Lovett, Remington CEO: SAFE Act impacted decision to expand - in Alabama, New York Daily News (November 17, 2014).