Sean McMeekin explained

Sean McMeekin
Birth Name:Sean McMeekin
Birth Date:10 May 1974
Birth Place:Idaho
Nationality:American
Occupation:Historian
Alma Mater:Stanford University

Sean McMeekin (born May 10, 1974) is an American historian, focused on European history of the early 20th century. His main research interests include modern German history, Russian history, communism, and the origins of the First and Second World Wars and the roles of Russia and the Ottoman Empire.

He has authored eight books, along with scholarly articles which have appeared in journals such as Contemporary European History, Common Knowledge, Current History, Historically Speaking, The World Today, and Communisme. He is currently Francis Flournoy Professor of European History and Culture at Bard College.

Early life and education

McMeekin grew up in Rochester, New York. He studied history at Stanford University (B.A. 1996) and the University of California, Berkeley (M.A. 1998 and PhD 2001). He held a Henry Chauncey Jr. '57 Postdoctoral Fellowship at Yale and was a fellow of the Remarque Institute at New York University.

Career

McMeekin taught in Turkey as an assistant professor in the Centre for Russian Studies at Bilkent University in Ankara,[1] then in the College of Social Sciences and Humanities of Koç University in Istanbul. He is now Francis Flournoy Professor of European History and Culture at Bard College in New York state.

Reception of published works

McMeekin's 2011 book The Russian Origins of the First World War was initially praised by the popular press as an insightful revisionist study for its use of Tsarist documents.[2] It was criticized by historians for its core theses, which advance a view of Russian involvement beyond what others have concluded.[3] [4] Because McMeekin was the first historian to publish questionable documents from the Tsarist archives suggesting Russian support for Armenian groups inside the Ottoman empire during the war, his treatment of the Armenian genocide has also been criticized, with one scholar pointing out that "The mass slaughter of Armenian civilians was in no way justified by the haphazard Russian support for Armenian paramilitary groups in Eastern Anatolia."[5] The Economist review noted, "if McMeekin's purpose was merely to exonerate all Ottoman behavior and play down Armenian suffering, he would not have included the observation of a Venezuelan soldier of fortune who saw on a mountainside 'thousands of half-nude and bleeding Armenian corpses, piled in heaps or interlaced in death's final embrace.'"[6]

McMeekin's 2013 book, July 1914: Countdown to War and his 2015 study, The Ottoman Endgame: War, Revolution, and the Making of the Modern Middle East were both well-received by the popular press.[7] [8]

His 2021 book, Stalin’s War, received positive reviews from the National Review,[9] The Times,[10] and The Financial Times.[11] Historian Serhii Plokhy called it "...a revisionist take on the second world war ."[12] It also received positive reviews from Historians Simon Sebag Montefiore, Geoffrey Wawro, and Antony Beevor who called it "...both original and refreshing, written as it is with a wonderful clarity.".[13] The book got negative reviews from Lawrence Freedman in Foreign Affairs and others for being revisionist and even "distorted".[14] [15] Similarly, historian Mark Edele noted that the book misquotes Stalin's speeches, and included sources refuted decades beforehand, or long ago shown to be fraudulent. Edele concluded:

"A gifted writer and a talented polemicist, he has lowered the historian’s craft to the level of propaganda. The result is a lamentable step back in our understanding of Stalin and his second world war."[16]

Nina L. Khrushcheva observed that "weighing in at some 800 pages, Stalin’s War compiles an impressive amount of historical information. But, given McMeekin’s procrustean framework, it comes across as cluelessly arrogant."[17]

Prizes

Selected works

References

  1. Web site: Staff . dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20160304074623/http://crs.bilkent.edu.tr/staff1.html. March 4, 2016 . February 28, 2021 . CRS . Bilkent University.
  2. News: Figes. Orlando. January 1, 2012. The Russian Origins of the First World War by Sam McMeekin . The Sunday Times. live. limited. 2021-02-25. 0140-0460. 2021-05-31. https://archive.today/20210531021830/https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/the-russian-origins-of-the-first-world-war-by-sam-mcmeekin-gwgwbhlc6jv.
  3. Bobroff. Ronald P.. 2013-06-01. The Russian Origins of the First World War . Revolutionary Russia . 26 . 1 . 82–84 . 10.1080/09546545.2013.780778 . 143759175. 0954-6545. subscription. .
  4. Rendle . Matthew . 2014-09-02 . The Russian origins of the First World War . First World War Studies . 5 . 3 . 340–342 . 10.1080/19475020.2014.969896. 162211839. 1947-5020. subscription. Taylor & Francis Online.
  5. Sanborn . Joshua . 2012 . Sean McMeekin. The Russian Origins of the First World War . . 117 . 4 . 1329–1330 . 10.1093/ahr/117.4.1329. subscription. Oxford Academic.
  6. News: 2015-10-29. All the world's a stage. . live. 2021-02-25. 0013-0613 . https://archive.today/20210531021741/https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2015/10/29/all-the-worlds-a-stage. 2021-05-31.
  7. News: Evans. R. J. W. . February 6, 2014. 'The Greatest Catastrophe the World Has Seen' . . live. 2021-02-25. 0028-7504. https://archive.today/20210508221758/https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2014/02/06/greatest-catastrophe-world-has-seen/ . 2021-05-08. subscription.
  8. News: de Bellaigue. Christopher. December 18, 2015 . The Ottoman Endgame by Sean McMeekin review – the breakup of an empire. . live . February 28, 2021 . 2021-05-31 . https://archive.today/20210531021636/https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/dec/18/ottoman-endgame-sean-mcmeekin-review.
  9. Web site: 2021-05-27 . The War Stalin Wanted . 2021-12-16 . National Review . en-US.
  10. News: Aaronovitch . David . Stalin's War by Sean McMeekin review — the Second World War was caused by Stalin. Discuss . . 2021-12-16. 0140-0460.
  11. News: MacMillan . Margaret . 2021-03-24 . Stalin's War by Sean McMeekin — alternative perspectives . Financial Times . 2021-12-16.
  12. News: 2021-04-06. Stalin's War by Sean McMeekin review – a revisionist take on the second world war. Serhii . Plokhy. The Guardian .
  13. Book: 978-1541672796 . Stalin's War: A New History of World War II . McMeekin . Sean . December 30, 2023 . Basic Books .
  14. News: Freedman . Lawrence D. . 2021-08-24. Stalin's War: A New History of World War II . 2021-12-16. 0015-7120. Foreign Affairs.
  15. News: Stalin's War: Distorted history of a complex second World War . 2021-07-16 . The Irish Times . 8 May 2021 . Geoffrey . Roberts.
  16. Web site: 2021-05-25. Better to lose Australia. Mark . Edele . 2021-05-26 . Inside Story . 2021-05-31 . live . https://archive.today/20210531021244/https://insidestory.org.au/better-to-lose-australia/.
  17. Web site: Khrushcheva. Nina L.. 2021-05-07. Stalin's War and Peace . 2021-12-16. Project Syndicate.

External links

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Sean McMeekin".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.