Sandbagging (law) explained

Sandbagging, in the field of mergers and acquisitions law, refers to the act of claiming a breach of a contractual representation or warranty despite having known at the time of the contract that it was untrue.[1]

Legal status of sandbagging

United States

Delaware and New York law both generally permit sandbagging when a contract is silent on the point, whereas California law does not allow it unless the contract explicitly permits it.[2] New York case law indicates that sandbagging is not allowed in cases where the information about the falsehood of the representation or warranty came directly from the seller.[3]

United Kingdom

English law provides that "purchaser's knowledge" precludes post-closing remedies for breach of warranty, but that a contract may allow sandbagging based on pre-closing constructive knowledge or imputed knowledge (as opposed to actual knowledge).[4]

Canada

Ontario case law has not dealt with default rules for sandbagging but has indicated that sandbagging may be permitted by contract. The civil code of Quebec imposes a requirement of good faith in the exercise of contractual rights which would likely preclude sandbagging.

Japan

The Japanese Civil Code does not allow sandbagging unless the contract explicitly permits it.[5]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Jenkins. John. Strategic Sandbagging: Let the Buyer Beware. DealLawyers.com. 23 August 2013.
  2. Web site: Iovine. Luke. Sandbagging in M&A Deals: Silence May Not Be Golden. Paul Hastings. 28 January 2014. October 2012.
  3. Web site: Spilko. Howard. The Importance of Sandbagging Provisions from a Buyer's Perspective: What You Know May Harm You. Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel. 28 January 2014. June 2009. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20111125012025/http://www.kramerlevin.com/files/Publication/1f4bc50a-ec7a-491b-92e3-01e2c90898c9/Presentation/PublicationAttachment/90cfc07a-0ee2-4ee4-bfa0-01f8eb0d393a/KramerLevinCorporateAlert.pdf. 25 November 2011.
  4. Web site: Moncrieff. Jonathan. A little knowledge can be a dangerous thing: Sandbagging clauses in acquisition agreements. Stikeman Elliott. 19 October 2012. 28 January 2014.
  5. Web site: Solomon. Richard. Avoiding Japan’s legal traps − Common mistakes in a (mostly) civil country. Beacon Reports. 22 January 2016.