Sabina Shoal Explained

Disputed:yes
Sabina Shoal
Type:atoll
Other Names:
Bãi Sa Bin (Vietnamese)
Buhanginan ng Escoda (Filipino)
Escoda Shoal (Philippine English)
仙賓礁 / 仙宾礁 Xiānbīn Jiāo (Chinese)
Pushpin Map:Spratly Islands relief
Location:South China Sea
Coordinates:9.75°N 144°W
Archipelago:Spratly Islands

Sabina Shoal, also known as Bãi Sa Bin (Vietnamese: Bãi Sa Bin); Escoda Shoal (Filipino; Pilipino: Buhanginan ng Escoda); Xianbin Jiao, is a disputed atoll in the North East of Dangerous Ground in the Spratly Islands. It is claimed by China, the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam. All of whom claim the Spratly Islands in their entirety.

Geography

Sabina Shoal is part of the Spratly Islands in the South China Sea. It lies in position 09° 45' N 116° 28' E,[1] 123.6 nautical miles from Palawan Island.[2] It is situated 56 nautical miles southwest of Carnatic Shoal, with two main parts and an area of 115km2.

The eastern half of Sabina Shoal consists of reefs awash, while the western half consists of banks 3.7m to 8.3mm (12.1feet to 27.2feetm) deep, and reefs enclosing a lagoon.[3]

Disputes and controversies

The reefs are a disputed low-tide elevation in the Spratly Islands, that are claimed by China, the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam. Because determining sovereignty of disputed features is beyond UNCLOS' jurisdiction and all claimants have not reached an agreement, the legal question of its ownership remains unresolved today in the South China Sea disputes.[4] [5]

In 1995, soon after occupying Mischief Reef, China (PRC) installed three buoys near Sabina Shoal. They were confiscated by the Philippines.[6]

On April 27, 2021, during a joint maritime patrol operations of the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) and Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR) in the area, seven Chinese maritime militia vessels were spotted anchored at the atoll. After several challenges from of the PCG, the militia vessels left the area.[7] [8]

On the Independence Day of the Philippines in 2024, Rear Admiral Armando Balilo of the PCG, aboard in that part of the South China Sea called by the Philippines the West Philippine Sea, held a flag-raising ceremony claiming Sabina Shoal for the Philippines.[9] China responded with a vow to take "strong measures" against the Philippines.[10]

The day after a clash between the two coast guards near the shoal on August 19, the Philippine government stated it was examining expanding the provisional agreement that had been established to de-escalate tensions near the Second Thomas Shoal to other areas.[11]

Notes and References

  1. Book: D.J Hancox . John Prescott. A Geographical Description of the Spratly Islands. International Boundaries Research Unit. UK. 28.
  2. Web site: PHL insists Escoda Shoal is within its sovereignty and maritime jurisdiction . balita.ph . 2012-01-11 . 2014-07-15.
  3. Book: Admiralty Sailing Directions - South China Sea . 2004 . UKHO - United Kingdom Hydrographic Office . Taunton . 64 .
  4. Web site: Andrea. Ho. 2021-05-06 . Professor Robert Beckman on the Role of UNCLOS in Maritime Disputes . 2024-07-09 . Georgetown Journal of International Affairs . en-US.
  5. News: Manila accuses Beijing of island building in South China Sea . RFA.
  6. News: Bondoc . Jarius . China out to grab Zambales shoal . 23 May 2014 . Philippine Star . 16 April 2012. (Zambales Shoal is also known as Scarborough Shoal.)
  7. News: 7 barko ng China, pinaalis ng PCG sa Sabina Shoal . Bagaoisan . Anjo . . May 5, 2021 . May 6, 2021.
  8. News: Chinese militia vessels at Sabina Shoal disperse after challenge by coast guard — Esperon . May 5, 2021 . Viray . Patricia Lourdes . . May 6, 2021.
  9. News: Dela Cruz. Raymond Carl . PH flag raised for 1st time at Sabina Shoal on Independence Day. June 21, 2024. . June 12, 2024.
  10. News: China vows ‘strong measures’ against Philippines over encroaching ships in South China Sea. South China Morning Post. n.d.. August 18, 2024.
  11. News: PH mulls expanding Ayungin Shoal 'provisional arrangement' with China . Darryl John Esguerra . Philippine News Agency . August 20, 2024 . August 20, 2024.