High Victorian Gothic Explained

High Victorian Gothic should not be confused with Victorian Gothic.

High Victorian Gothic was an eclectic architectural style and movement during the mid-late 19th century.^[1] It is seen by architectural historians as either a sub-style of the broader Gothic Revival style, or a separate style in its own right.^[2]

Promoted and derived from the works of the architect and theorist John Ruskin, though it eventually diverged, it is sometimes referred to as Ruskinian Gothic.^[3] It is characterised by the use of polychrome (multi-colour) decoration, "use of varying texture" and Gothic details. The architectural scholar James Stevens Curl describes it thus: "Style of the somewhat harsh polychrome structures of the Gothic Revival in the 1850s and 1860s when Ruskin held sway as the arbiter of taste. Like High Gothic, it is an unsatisfactory term, as it poses the question as to what is 'Low Victorian'. 'Mid-Victorian' would, perhaps, be more useful, but precise dates and description of styles would be more so."^[4]

Among the best-known practitioners of the style were William Butterfield,^[5] Sir Gilbert Scott,^[6] G. E. Street,^[7] and Alfred Waterhouse. Waterhouse's Victoria Building at Liverpool University, described by Sir Charles Reilly (an opponent of Victorian Gothic) as "the colour of mud and blood,"^[8] was the inspiration for the term "red brick university" (as opposed to Oxbridge and the other ancient universities).^[9]

The style began appearing in the United States, particularly New York, in the early 1860s with the work of English-born architects Frederick Clarke Withers, Jacob Wrey Mould, and Americans Edward Tuckerman Potter and Peter Bonnett Wight.^[10] By 1870, the style became popular nationwide for civic, commercial, and religious architecture, though was uncommon for residential structures.^[11] It was frequently used for what became the "Old Main" of various schools and universities in the late 19th century United States.^[12] The Stick Style is sometimes considered the wooden manifestation of the High Victorian Gothic style.^[13]

Examples

Canada

• Belleville City Hall, Belleville, Ontario, 1873

United Kingdom

• All Saints, Margaret Street, London. Butterfield, 1849–59
• Church of St James, Baldersby, Yorkshire. Butterfield, 1856–58
• Manchester Town Hall. Waterhouse, 1863–77
• Albert Memorial, London. Scott, 1872
• Royal Courts of Justice, London. Street, 1873–82
• No.s 2-7 Arden Street, Stratford upon Avon.^[14]
• The Kirna, Walkerburn, Scottish Borders, 1867^[15]

United States

• Hudson River State Hospital, Poughkeepsie, New York
• Jefferson Market Courthouse, New York, New York
• Memorial Hall (Harvard University), Cambridge, Massachusetts
• New Haven City Hall and County Courthouse, New Haven, Connecticut
• Converse House and Barn, Norwich, Connecticut
• The Miller School of Albemarle, Albemarle County, Virginia (1878-1884)
• Anderson Hall (Manhattan, Kansas), Kansas State University

See also

• Victorian architecture
• Venetian Gothic architecture

References

• Book: Brownell. Charles . Making of Virginia Architecture. 1992. Charlottesville . Virginia Museum of Fine Arts. 978-0917046346.
• Book: McAlester, Virginia . Lee McAlester . 1984. A Field Guide to American Houses. New York . Alfred H. Knopf . 978-0394739694 .
• Book: Charles Reilly & the Liverpool School of Architecture 1904–1933. Liverpool and Architectural Education in the Early Twentieth Century. Powers, Alan. Sharples, Joseph. 1 - 23. 978-0853239017. 1996.

Notes and References

1. Campbell, Gordon. "Victorian style", The Grove Encyclopedia of Decorative Arts, Oxford University Press 2006. accessed 22 June 2012
2. McAlester, p. 198
3. Garrigan, Kristine Ottesen. "'Ruskinian Gothic: The Architecture of Deane and Woodward, 1845–1861' by Eve Blau", Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, Vol. 42, No. 1 (March 1983), pp. 78–80
4. Curl, James Stevens. "High Victorian", A Dictionary of Architecture and Landscape Architecture, Oxford University Press 2006, Oxford Reference Online, accessed 22 June 2012
5. Crook, J. Mordaunt. "'William Butterfield' by Paul Thompson", The English Historical Review, Vol. 89, No. 350 (January 1974), pp. 131–133
6. Stamp, Gavin. "Sir Gilbert Scott's 'Recollections'", Architectural History, Vol. 19, (1976), pp. 54–73
7. Stamp, Gavin. "High Victorian Gothic and the Architecture of Normandy", Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, Vol. 62, No. 2 (June 2003), pp. 194–211
8. Powers, p. 1
9. The term was coined by Edgar Allison Peers, professor of Spanish at Liverpool University, writing under the pseudonym "Bruce Truscot"; in Redbrick University, 1943, he compares two fictional universities called Redbrick and Oxbridge. See: Oxford English Dictionary, "red brick, n. and adj.", OED Online. June 2012. Oxford University Press, accessed 22 June 2012)
10. Book: Brooks, Michael W.. John Ruskin and Victorian Architecture. Thames and Hudson. 1987. London. 276–299.
11. McAlester, p. 200
12. Browning, pp. 300–301
13. McAlester, p. 256
14. Book: Bearman. Robert. Stratford-upon-Avon: A History of Its Streets and Buildings. 1988. Hendon Publishing Co Ltd. 10.
15. Web site: THE KIRNA, B8323 . Historic Environment Scotland . 27 December 2018.