Rural Representative elections explained

The Rural Representative elections are the quadrennial elections to elect the rural representatives which consist of the village representatives and kaifong representatives in the New Territories of Hong Kong. The rural representatives are responsible for electing the executive committees of their respective rural committees in which to elect the members of the Heung Yee Kuk.

Background

The Rural community in the New Territories has all the time had its own village representative elections. The previous electoral systems for a village or a group of villages came up around the end of World War II, in which they were conducted privately on a clan basis. All the candidates and electors were the indigenous inhabitants, ie person who could establish their patrilineal descent from a resident of a village that was in existence before the 1898 Convention for the Extension of Hong Kong Territory.

In 1994, the Heung Yee Kuk drew up a set of "Model Rules" for the elections of some 700 villages, which were held every four years. The appointment of the elected village representatives had to be approved by the Secretary for Home Affairs. The "Model rules" system prevailed until 1999 when two non-indigenous inhabitants, Chan Wah of Po Toi O in Sai Kung and Tse Kwan-sang of Shek Wu Tong in Yuen Long challenged the validity of the electoral arrangements in their villages by judicial review proceedings. Chan was denied the right to vote even though he married an indigenous inhabitants while Tse was denied the right to stand. The cases were eventually heard by the Court of Final Appeal in December 2000, which ruled that the electoral arrangements were inconsistent with the Hong Kong Bill of Rights Ordinance while those in Po Toi O were also inconsistent with the Sex Discrimination Ordinance.

In view of the rulings, there were calls on the government to bring village representative elections under a statutory framework. In 2003, the government enacted the Village Representative Election Ordinance (Cap. 576), which was later renamed as Rural Representative Election Ordinance in 2014. In the proposal, the election would be held in a electoral system of two types of village representatives which represent both the indigenous and non-indigenous inhabitants.^[1]

The Village Representative Election Ordinance (Cap. 576) was later renamed as Rural Representative Election Ordinance in 2014, which created a new type of kaifong representative which only were introduced in Cheung Chau and Peng Chau Rural Committee of the Islands District, for the electing non-village representatives to reflect views on local affairs on behalf of Cheung Chau and Peng Chau residents.^[2]

Composition

There are three different types of rural representatives. Under the village representatives, there are indigenous inhabitant representatives and resident representatives. Indigenous inhabitants are returned by the elector of indigenous inhabitants which have the exclusive power to deal with all affairs relating to traditional rights and interests of the indigenous villages, while resident representatives are to reflect view on behalf of the non-indigenous residents. Kaifong representatives only exist in Cheung Chau and Peng Chau which are elected by the market towns of the respective areas.^[3]

Elections

2003

Breakdown of Number of Villages and Village Representatives By District^[4]
District	No. of Indigenous Village &<br>Composite Indigenous Villages	No. of Indigenous Inhabitants Representatives (IIR)	No. of Existing Village	No. of Resident Resident Representatives (RR)	Total no. of IIR & RR
	66	71	80	80	151
	9	18	8	8	26
	97	132	117	117	249
	77	89	91	91	180
	46	55	48	48	103
	124	150	121	121	271
	38	69	39	39	108
	24	33	35	35	68
	120	170	154	154	324
Total	601	787	693	693	1,480

2007

Breakdown of Number of Villages and Village Representatives By District^[5]
District	No. of Indigenous Village &<br>Composite Indigenous Villages	No. of Indigenous Inhabitants Representatives (IIR)	No. of Existing Village	No. of Resident Resident Representatives (RR)	Total no. of IIR & RR
	66	71	80	80	151
	9	18	8	8	26
	97	132	117	117	249
	77	89	91	91	180
	46	55	48	48	103
	124	150	121	121	271
	38	69	39	39	108
	24	33	35	35	68
	120	170	154	154	324
Total	601	787	693	693	1,480

2011

Breakdown of Number of Villages and Village Representatives By District^[6]
District	No. of Indigenous Village &<br>Composite Indigenous Villages	No. of Indigenous Inhabitants Representatives (IIR)	No. of Existing Village	No. of Resident Resident Representatives (RR)	Total no. of IIR & RR
	66	71	80	80	151
	9	18	10	10	28
	97	132	117	117	249
	77	89	91	91	180
	46	55	48	48	103
	125	151	122	122	273
	38	69	37	37	106
	24	33	35	35	68
	121	171	155	155	326
Total	601	789	695	695	1,484

2015

Breakdown of Number of Rural Areas and Rural Representatives By District^[7]
District	No. of Existing Village	No. of Resident Representatives	No. of Indigenous Villages &<br>Composite Indigenous Villages	No. of Indigenous Inhabitants Representatives	No. of Market Towns	No. of Kaifong Representatives	Total no. of Rural Representatives
	80	80	66	71	2	56	207
	10	10	9	18	-	-	28
	117	117	97	132	-	-	249
	91	91	77	89	-	-	180
	48	48	46	55	-	-	103
	122	122	125	151	-	-	273
	37	37	38	69	-	-	106
	35	35	24	33	-	-	68
	155	155	121	171	-	-	326
Total	695	695	601	789	2	56	1,540

2019

See main article: 2019 Hong Kong Rural Representative election.

2023

Breakdown of Number of Rural Areas and Rural Representatives By District^[8]
District	No. of Existing Village	No. of Resident Representatives	No. of Indigenous Villages &<br>Composite Indigenous Villages	No. of Indigenous Inhabitants Representatives	No. of Market Towns	No. of Kaifong Representatives	Total no. of Rural Representatives
	80	80	66	71	2	56	207
	10	10	9	18	-	-	28
	117	117	97	132	-	-	249
	91	91	77	89	-	-	180
	48	48	46	55	-	-	103
	122	122	125	151	-	-	273
	37	37	38	69	-	-	106
	35	35	24	33	-	-	68
	155	155	121	171	-	-	326
Total	695	695	601	789	2	56	1,540

Cheung Chau results

As most of the representatives were elected without opposition under a limited electoral base, Cheung Chau's Kaifong Representatives election was the focus for its relatively large number of seats and constituents.

Since Cheung Chau rural election became statutorily regulated by the authorities in 2015, it had been dominated by two main lists: reformist Cheung Chau Synergy, led by ex-Cheung Chau South councillor Ken Kwong Koon-wan, and conservative Cheung Chau Community Alliance, led by ex-Cheung Chau North councillor Lee Kwai-chun and chairman of Cheung Chau Rural Committee Yung Chi-ming.

Year!colspan=3
Conservative				Reformist	Unaligned
Elected_/Standing	Result	Turnout	Ref
bgcolor=Darkblue					bgcolor=Gold
2015	bgcolor=Lightblue align=center	31_/31	6_/30	2_/9		56.19%	^[9]
2019	bgcolor=Lightblue align=center	25_/33	14_/32	0_/0		50.01%
2023	bgcolor=Lightblue align=center	37_/37	2_/25	0_/5		37.77%	^[10]

External links

Notes and References

News: Report on the 2003 Village Representative Election. Electoral Affairs Commission.
Web site: Background. Home Affairs Department.
Web site: Types of Rural Representatives and their Functions. Home Affairs Department.
Breakdown of Number of Villages and Village Representatives By District. Election Affairs Commission.
Breakdown of Number of Villages and Village Representatives By District. Election Affairs Commission.
Breakdown of Number of Villages and Village Representatives By District. Election Affairs Commission.
Breakdown of Number of Rural Areas and Rural Representatives By District. Election Affairs Commission.
Breakdown of Number of Rural Areas and Rural Representatives By District. Election Affairs Commission.
Web site: Wong . Michael . 2015-01-29 . 長洲改革派挑戰選舉失敗 . 2023-03-20 . Harbour Times . en-GB.
Web site: 【Emily】長洲街坊代表選舉投票率跌12百分點 - 20230116 - 港聞 . 2023-03-20 . 明報新聞網 - 每日明報 daily news . zh-hant.