Ruhr Explained

Ruhr
Native Name:Ruhrgebiet
Official Name:Ruhr Metropolis
Metropole Ruhr
Mapsize:270px
Seal Type:Logo
Coordinates:51.5°N 37°W
Subdivision Type:Country
Subdivision Name: Germany
Subdivision Type1:State
Parts Type:Largest cities
Parts Style:list
Governing Body:Regionalverband Ruhr
Area Metro Km2:4435
Elevation Footnotes:[1]
Elevation Max M:441
Elevation Min M:13
Population As Of:2022
Population Urban:5,147,820
Population Density Urban Km2:1160
Population Metro:10,680,783
Demographics Type2:GDP
Demographics2 Footnotes:[2]
Demographics2 Title1:Metro
Demographics2 Info1:€180.467 billion (2021)
Timezone:CET
Utc Offset:+01:00

The Ruhr (; German: Ruhrgebiet pronounced as /de/, also Ruhrpott pronounced as /de/), also referred to as the Ruhr area, sometimes Ruhr district, Ruhr region, or Ruhr valley, is a polycentric urban area in North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany. With a population density of 2,800/km2 and a population of over 5 million (2017),[3] it is the largest urban area in Germany and the third of the European Union. It consists of several large cities bordered by the rivers Ruhr to the south, Rhine to the west, and Lippe to the north. In the southwest it borders the Bergisches Land. It is considered part of the larger Rhine-Ruhr metropolitan region of more than 10 million people, which is the third largest in Western Europe, behind only London and Paris.

The Ruhr cities are, from west to east: Duisburg, Oberhausen, Bottrop, Mülheim an der Ruhr, Essen, Gelsenkirchen, Bochum, Herne, Hagen, Dortmund, Hamm and the districts of Wesel, Recklinghausen, Unna and Ennepe-Ruhr-Kreis. The most populous cities are Dortmund (with a population of approximately 612,065),[4] Essen (about 583,000) and Duisburg (about 497,000).

In the Middle Ages, the Hellweg was an important trade route from the region of the Lower Rhine to the mountains of the Teutoburg Forest. The most important towns of the region from Duisburg to the imperial city of Dortmund were concentrated along the Hellweg from the Rhineland to Westphalia. Since the 19th century, these cities have grown together into a large complex with a vast industrial landscape, inhabited by some 7.3 million people (including Düsseldorf and Wuppertal, large cities that are nearby but officially not part of the Ruhr area).

The Ruhr area has no administrative centre; each city in the area has its own administration, although there is a supracommunal institution in Essen.[5] For 2010, the Ruhr region was one of the European Capitals of Culture.[6] [7]

Etymology

The 1911 edition of Encyclopædia Britannica has only one definition of "Ruhr": "a river of Germany, an important right-bank tributary of the lower Rhine". The use of the term "Ruhr" for the industrial region started in Britain only after World War I, when French and Belgian troops had occupied the Ruhr district and seized its prime industrial assets in lieu of unpaid reparations in 1923. In 1920, the International Labour Office published a report entitled Coal Production in the Ruhr District. In 1923, the Canadian Commercial Intelligence Journal, Volume 28, Issue 1013, includes the article, "Exports from the Ruhr district of Germany". In 1924 the English and American press was still talking of the "French occupation of the Ruhr Valley" or "Ruhr District". A 62-page publication seems to be responsible for the use of "Ruhr" as a short form of the then more common "Ruhr District" or "Ruhr Valley": Ben Tillett, A. Creech-Jones and Samuel Warren's The Ruhr: The Report of a Deputation from the Transport and General Workers Union (London 1923). Yet "The report of a deputation from the Transport and General Workers' Union which spent a fortnight examining the problems in the Ruhr Valley", published in The Economic Review, Volume 8, 1923, is still using the traditional term. In the same year, "Objections by the United States to discriminatory regulations on exports from the occupied region of the Ruhr" was published in Papers Relating to the Foreign Relations of the United States.

The 1926 Encyclopædia Britannica, in addition to its article on the river Ruhr, has a further article on "RUHR, the name given to a district of Westphalia, Germany". Thus the name "Ruhr" was given to the region (as a short form of "Ruhr District" or "Ruhr Valley") only a few years before the publication of this edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica. Even after World War II, the term "Ruhr" may not have been in general use for the region: it was defined in Documents on American Foreign Relations (1948): "For the purposes of the present Agreement: (i) the expression 'Ruhr' means the areas, as presently constituted, in Land North Rhine–Westphalia, listed in the Annex to this Agreement."[8] However, Lawrence K. Cecil and Philip Hauge Abelson still write in 1967: "In the first place, the average person uses the term 'Ruhr' indiscriminately as the Ruhr River or the Ruhr district, two entirely different things. The Ruhr River is only one of half a dozen rivers in the Ruhr district, in addition to the Rhine. The Rhine itself runs through the heart of the Ruhr district."[9] According to Merriam Webster's Geographical Dictionary, a standard reference on place names around the world, the name "Ruhr" refers to the river. The name preferred for the region in this dictionary is "Ruhrgebiet", followed by "Ruhr Valley".

Geography

The urban landscape of the Ruhr extends from the Lower Rhine Basin east to the Westphalian Plain and south to the hills of the Rhenish Massif. Through the centre of the Ruhr runs a segment of the loess belt that extends across Germany from west to east. Historically, this loess belt has underlain some of Germany's richest agricultural regions.

Geologically, the region is defined by coal-bearing layers from the upper Carboniferous period. The coal seams reach the surface in a strip along the river Ruhr and dip downward from the river to the north. Beneath the Lippe, the coal seams lie at a depth of 600 to 800 metres (2,000 to 2,600 feet). The thickness of the coal layers ranges from one to three metres (three to ten feet). This geological feature played a decisive role in the development of coal mining in the Ruhr.

According to the Regionalverband Ruhr (RVR, Ruhr Regional Association), 37.6% of the region's area is built up. A total of 40.7% of the region's land remains in agricultural use. Forests account for 17.6%, and bodies of water and other types of land use occupy the rest. The inclusion of four mainly rural districts in the otherwise mainly industrial Ruhr helps to explain the large proportion of agricultural and forested land. In addition, the city boroughs of the Ruhr region have outlying districts with a rural character.

Seen on a map, the Ruhr could be considered a single city, since there are no visible breaks between the individual city boroughs. Thus the Ruhr is described as a polycentric urban area, which shares a similar history of urban and economic development.

Because of its history, the Ruhr is structured differently from monocentric urban regions such as Munich, which developed through the rapid absorption of smaller towns and villages by the most significant city among them. Instead in the Ruhr, the individual city boroughs and urban districts of the Ruhr grew in a rapid and parallel fashion independently of one another during the Industrial Revolution. The population density of the central Ruhr is about 2,100 inhabitants per square kilometre (about 5,400 per square mile)—not too high compared to other German cities.

Between the constituent urban areas are relatively open suburbs and even some open land with agricultural fields. In many places however, the borders between cities in the central Ruhr are unrecognizable, blending into one urban landscape due to continuous development across them.

The replanting of brownfield land has created new parks and recreation areas in recent decades. The Emscher Landschaftspark (Emscher Landscape Park) lies along the river Emscher, formerly virtually an open sewer, parts of which have undergone natural restoration. This park connects strips of parkland running from north to south, which were developed through regional planning in the 1920s, to form a green belt between the Ruhr cities from east to west.

History

See main article: History of the Ruhr.

During the Middle Ages, much of the region that was later called the Ruhrgebiet was situated in the County of Mark, the Duchies of Cleves and Berg and the territories of the bishop of Münster and the archbishop of Cologne. The region included some villages and castles, and was mainly agrarian: its loess soil made it one of the richer parts of western Germany. The free imperial city of Dortmund was the trading and cultural centre, lying on the Hellweg, an important east–west trading route, that also brought prosperity to the town of Duisburg. Both towns were members of the Hanseatic League.

Industrial revolution

The development of the region into an urbanized industrial area started in the late 18th century with the early industrialisation in the nearby Wupper Valley in the Bergisches Land. By around 1820, hundreds of water-powered mills were producing textiles, lumber, shingles and iron in automated processes here. In additional workshops in the hills, highly skilled workers manufactured knives, tools, weapons and harnesses, using water, coal and charcoal.

As the machines became bigger and moved from water power to steam power, locally mined coal and charcoal became expensive and there was not enough of it. The Bergische industry ordered more and more coal from the new coal mining area along the Ruhr.[10] Impressive and expensive railways were constructed through the hilly Wupper region, to bring coal, and later steel, in from the Ruhr, and for outward transport of finished products.[11]

By 1850, there were almost 300 coal mines in operation in the Ruhr area, in and around the central cities of Duisburg, Essen, Bochum and Dortmund. The coal was exported or processed in coking ovens into coke, used in blast furnaces, producing iron and steel. In this period the name Ruhrgebiet became common. Before the coal deposits along the Ruhr were exhausted, the mining industry moved northward to the Emscher and finally to the Lippe, drilling ever deeper mines as it went. Locks built at Mülheim on the Ruhr led to the expansion of Mülheim as a port. With the construction of the Cologne-Minden railway in the late 19th century, several iron works were built within the borders of the present-day city of Oberhausen.

Moreover, the urbanization also boosted the expansion of railroad connections. At the beginning of the 1880s, agricultural regions did not benefit from the newly built transport facilities as much as non-agricultural regions did. This in its turn increased inequality, and made anthropometric measurements, e.g. height, more dependent on wages. In the long run, however, effects of the railroad proximity diminished.[12]

Consequently, the population climbed rapidly. Towns with only 2,000 to 5,000 people in the early 19th century grew in the following 100 years to over 100,000. Skilled mineworkers were recruited from other regions to the Ruhr's mines and steel mills and unskilled people started to move in. From 1860 onwards there was large-scale migration of Polish speakers from Silesia, Pomerania, East Prussia and Posen to the Ruhr, who were known as Ruhrpolen since. The Poles were treated as second class citizens. In 1899 this led to a revolt in Herne of young Polish workers, who later established a Workers' Union. Skilled workers in the mines were often housed in "miners' colonies", built by the mining firms. By 1870, over 3 million people lived in the Ruhrgebiet and the new coal-mining district had become the largest industrial region of Europe.[13]

During World War I the Ruhrgebiet functioned as Germany's central weapon factory. At a big Essen company, F. Krupp A.G., the number of employees rose from 40,000 to 120,000 or more, in four years. They were partly women, partly forced labourers.

Weimar Republic

In the March 1920 Kapp Putsch, nationalist and monarchist elements with the armed support of Freikorps units attempted to overthrow the government of the Weimar Republic. It was able to defeat the putsch by advocating a general strike that all but shut down Berlin.[14] The work action effectively ended the putsch, but in the Ruhr it was the instigation for an armed revolt. In the Ruhr Uprising, the Ruhr Red Army was able to take control of the Ruhr industrial area. The Reichswehr, with assistance from Freikorps units, put down the rebellion in early April 1920 and re-established the Weimar Republic's control of the district. An estimated 1,000 insurgents and 200 Reichswehr soldiers were killed in the battles.[15]

In March 1921, French and Belgian troops occupied Duisburg,[16] which under the Treaty of Versailles formed part of the demilitarized Rhineland. In January 1923 the whole Ruhr district was occupied after Germany failed to fulfill part of its World War I reparation payments as agreed in the Versailles Treaty. The German government responded with a policy of passive resistance, letting workers and civil servants refuse orders and instructions by the occupation forces. Production and transport came to a standstill and the financial consequences contributed to German hyperinflation.[17] After passive resistance was called off in late 1923, Germany implemented a currency reform and negotiated the Dawes Plan, which led to the withdrawal of the French and Belgian troops from the Ruhr in 1925. However, the occupation of the Ruhr caused several direct and indirect consequences to the German economy and government, including accelerating the growth of right wing parties due to the Weimar government's inability to successfully resolve the problem.[18]

Nazi period

On 7 March 1936,[19] Adolf Hitler took a massive gamble by sending 30,000 troops into the Rhineland. As Hitler and other Nazis admitted, the French army alone could have destroyed the Wehrmacht.[20] The French passed the problem to the British, who found that the Germans had the right to "enter their own backyard", and no action was taken.[21] In the League of Nations, the Soviet delegate Maxim Litvinov was the only one who proposed economic sanctions against Germany.[21] All restraint on German rearmament was now removed. France's eastern allies (the Soviet Union, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Romania and Yugoslavia) concluded that since the French refused to defend their own border, they certainly would not stand up for their allies in the East. Hitler could now continue eroding the alliance system that France had built since 1919.[22] On 16 October 1936, Belgium repudiated the 1921 alliance with France and declared its absolute neutrality.[23] In October 1937, Belgium signed a non-aggression pact with Germany.[24]

Bodystyle:width:auto;
Header1:WWII Ruhr Bombing Operations
Labelstyle:font-weight:normal;
Label2:1943 March–July:
Data2:Battle of the Ruhr
Label3:1943 May:
Data3:Operation Chastise
Label4:1944 October:
Data4:Operation Hurricane
Label5:1944 September:
Data5:Bombing of German oil
facilities during World War II

During World War II, the bombing of the Ruhr in 1940–1944 caused a loss of 30% of plant and equipment (compared to 15–20% for German industry as a whole).[25] A second battle of the Ruhr (6/7 October 1944 – end of 1944) began with an attack on Dortmund. The devastating bombing raids of Dortmund on 12 March 1945 with 1,108 aircraft – 748 Lancasters, 292 Halifaxes, 68 Mosquitos – was a record to a single target in the whole of World War II. More than 4,800 tons of bombs were dropped through the city centre and the south of the city.[26]

In addition to the strategic bombing of the Ruhr, in April 1945, the Allies trapped several hundred thousand Wehrmacht troops in the Ruhr Pocket.

Postwar period

After the war, the region fell within the British occupation zone, and Level of Industry plans for Germany abolished all German munitions factories and civilian industries that could support them and severely restricted civilian industries of military potential. The Ruhr Authority, an international body to regulate the Ruhr's coal and steel industries, was created as a condition for the establishment of the Federal Republic of Germany.[27]

During the Cold War, the Western allies anticipated that any Red Army thrust into Western Europe would begin in the Fulda Gap and have the Ruhr as a primary target. Increased German control of the area was limited by the pooling of German coal and steel into the multinational European Coal and Steel Community in 1951. The nearby Saar region, containing much of Germany's remaining coal deposits, was handed over to economic administration by France as a protectorate in 1947 and did not politically return to Germany until January 1957, with economic reintegration occurring two years later. Parallel to the question of political control of the Ruhr, the Allies tried to decrease German industrial potential by limitations on production and dismantling of factories and steel plants, predominantly in the Ruhr. By 1950, after the virtual completion of the by-then much watered-down "level of industry" plans, equipment had been removed from 706 manufacturing plants in the west, and steel production capacity had been reduced by 6.7 million tons.[28] Dismantling finally ended in 1951. In all, less than 5% of the industrial base was dismantled.[29]

The Ruhr was at the centre of the German economic miracle Wirtschaftswunder of the 1950s and 1960s, as very rapid economic growth (9% a year) created a heavy demand for coal and steel.

After 1973, Germany was hard hit by a worldwide economic crisis, soaring oil prices, and increasing unemployment, which jumped from 300,000 in 1973 to 1.1 million in 1975. The Ruhr region was hardest hit, as the easy-to-reach coal mines became exhausted, and German coal was no longer competitive. Likewise the Ruhr steel industry went into sharp decline, as its prices were undercut by lower-cost suppliers such as Japan. The welfare system provided a safety net for the large number of unemployed workers, and many factories reduced their labor force and began to concentrate on high-profit specialty items.[30] [31]

As demand for coal decreased after 1958, the area went through phases of structural crisis (see steel crisis) and industrial diversification, first developing traditional heavy industry, then moving into service industries and high technology. The air and water pollution of the area are largely a thing of the past although some issues take a long time to solve.[32] [33] In 2005 Essen[34] was the official candidate for nomination as European Capital of Culture for 2010.

Climate

The Ruhr has an oceanic climate in spite of its inland position, with winds from the Atlantic travelling over the lowlands to moderate temperature extremes, in spite of its relatively northerly latitude that sees significant variety in daylight hours. A consequence of the marine influence is a cloudy and wet climate with low sunshine hours. Summers normally average in the low 20s, with winters being somewhat above the freezing point.

From the onset of the 21st century, the effects of global warming have become more profound. The area has been affected by severe droughts (like 2018), heat waves with temperatures above 40C (2019)[35] and severe weather events like the bow echo that hit the cities on June 9, 2014, and caused tens of thousands of trees to fall[36] which was publicly dubbed the "Pfingststurm" (German for "Whitsun storm"). Winters have become more mild which poses a risk for crops such as apples whose blooms are vulnerable to late freezes if bud break happens too early.

Demographics

See also: List of cities in Germany with more than 100,000 inhabitants.

The ten largest cities of the Ruhr:

Pos.NamePop. 2020Area (km2)Pop. per km2Map
1 587,696 280.37 2,071
2 582,415 210.38 2,733
3 495,885 232.81 2,154
4 364,454 145.43 2,652
5 259,105 104.86 2,557
6 209,566 77.04 2,841
7 188,687 160.36 1,228
8 178,967 226.24 814
9 170,921 91.28 1,872
10 156,940 51.41 3,100

The local regiolect of German is commonly called Ruhrdeutsch (Ruhrgebietsdeutsch, Ruhrpottdeutsch, Ruhrpottisch, Ruhrpöttisch) although there is really no uniform regiolect that justifies designation as a single regiolect. It is rather a working-class sociolect with influences from the various dialects found in the area and changing even with the professions of the workers. A major common influence stems from the coal mining tradition of the area. For example, quite a few locals prefer to call the Ruhr either "Pott", which is a derivate of "Pütt" (pitmen's term for mine; cp. the English "pit"), or "Revier".

During the nineteenth century, the Ruhr attracted up to 500,000 ethnic Poles, Masurians and Silesians from East Prussia and Silesia in a migration known as Ostflucht (flight from the east). By 1925, the Ruhrgebiet had around 3,800,000 inhabitants. Most of the new inhabitants came from Eastern Europe, but immigrants also came from France, Ireland, and the United Kingdom. It has been claimed that immigrants came to the Ruhr from over 140 countries. Almost all their descendants today speak German as a first language, and for various reasons, they do not identify with their Polish roots and traditions, often their Polish family names only remain as a sign of their past.

Culture

The Industrial Heritage Trail (German: Route der Industriekultur) links tourist attractions related to the European Route of Industrial Heritage in the Ruhr area.

Ruhr is known for its numerous cultural institutions, many of which enjoy international reputation. Ruhr has three major opera houses and more than 10 theaters and stages.

There are special classical music halls like the Bochumer Symphoniker, the Duisburg Mercatorhalle, the Saalbau Essen or the Dortmunder Philharmoniker. Each year in spring time, there is the Klavier-Festival Ruhr in the Ruhr area with 50 to 80 events of classical and jazz music.

With more than 50 museums, Ruhr has one of the largest variety of museums in Europe.

Industrial Museum

The city of Essen (representing the Ruhr) was selected as European Capital of Culture for 2010 by the Council of the European Union.

In association football, the Revierderby is the rivalry between Borussia Dortmund and FC Schalke 04, and to a lesser extent between either club and/or VfL Bochum, MSV Duisburg or Rot-Weiss Essen (kleines Revierderby).

Education

With 22 universities and colleges and more than 250,000[37] students, the Ruhr region has the highest density of further education establishments anywhere in Germany. These include five universities alone in the cities of Bochum, Duisburg, Dortmund, Essen and Witten. In addition, Folkwang University of the Arts is an internationally acclaimed art college with its base in the Ruhr region. Furthermore, the universities are not the only places in the Ruhr region where academic qualifications can be obtained. There are 17 different universities of applied sciences which offer students to have the opportunity to undertake practice-relevant and qualified studies in various subjects, such as economics, logistics, administration or management.[38]

Universities

The Ruhr area has 5 major universities in 6 cities with about 120,000 students.

UA Ruhr

The three largest universities (Ruhr University Bochum, TU Dortmund University, and the University of Duisburg-Essen) opened an alliance called "UA Ruhr". Students enrolled at one of the UA Ruhr universities can attend lectures and seminars at all three institutions without having to pay a visiting student fee. Consequently, they have many options to specialize in and to explore their chosen disciplines in depth. The UA Ruhr has three liaison offices for interested students in New York City, Moscow and São Paulo.

Universities of Applied Sciences and Arts

Bochum

Bottrop

Dortmund

Duisburg

Essen

Gelsenkirchen

Hagen

Hamm

Kamp-Lintfort

Mülheim an der Ruhr

Recklinghausen

Unna

Transport

Public transport

With the exception of public transport companies serving Hamm and Kreis Unna, all such companies in the Ruhr region are run under the umbrella of the Verkehrsverbund Rhein-Ruhr, which provides a uniform ticket system valid for the entire area. The Ruhr region is well-integrated into the national rail system, the Deutsche Bahn, for both passenger and goods services, each city in the region has at least one train stations. The bigger central stations have hourly direct connections to the bigger European cities as Amsterdam, Brussels, Paris, Vienna or Zürich.

The Ruhr area also contains the longest tram system in the world, with tram and Stadtbahn services from Witten to Krefeld as well as the Rhine-Ruhr S-Bahn network.Originally the system was even bigger, it was possible to travel from Unna to Bad Honnef without using railway or bus services.

Road transport

The Ruhr has one of the densest motorway networks in all of Europe, with dozens of Autobahns and similar Schnellstraßen (expressways) crossing the region. The Autobahn network is built in a grid network, with four east–west (A2, A40, A42, A44) and seven north–south (A1, A3, A43, A45, A52, A57, A59) routes. The A1, A2 and A3 are mostly used by through traffic, while the other autobahns have a more regional function.

Both the A44 and the A52 have several missing links, in various stages of planning. Some missing sections are currently in construction or planned to be constructed in the near future.

Additional expressways serve as bypasses and local routes, especially around Dortmund and Bochum. Due to the density of the autobahns and expressways, Bundesstraßen are less important for intercity traffic. The first Autobahns in the Ruhr opened during the mid-1930s. Due to the density of the network, and the number of alternative routes, traffic volumes are generally lower than other major metropolitan areas in Europe. Traffic congestion is an everyday occurrence, but far less so than in the Randstad in the Netherlands, another polycentric urban area. Most important Autobahns have six lanes, but there are no eight-lane Autobahns in the Ruhr.

Air transport

Düsseldorf Airport is the intercontinental airport for North Rhine-Westphalia and is within 20 km of most of the Western Ruhr area.It is served by the Düsseldorf Flughafen and Düsseldorf Flughafen Terminal railway stations, with its several parking lots, terminals and stations being connected by the Skytrain.

Dortmund Airport in the Eastern Ruhr is a mid-sized airport, offering scheduled flights to domestic and European destinations and its approximately 1.9 million passengers in 2013. Dortmund Airport is served by an express bus to Dortmund main station, a shuttle bus to the nearby railway station Holzwickede/Dortmund Flughafen, a bus connecting to Stadtbahn line U47, as well as a bus to the city of Unna.

See also

Further reading

External links

Notes and References

  1. highest: Wengeberg in Breckerfeld, lowest: Xanten
  2. Web site: Gross domestic product (GDP) at current market prices by metropolitan regions. ec.europa.eu.
  3. Web site: Zensus 2011 . Ruhr . Regionalverband . 2018-01-09 . www.metropoleruhr.de . de . 2018-02-05 . 6 February 2018 . https://web.archive.org/web/20180206073601/http://www.metropoleruhr.de/regionalverband-ruhr/regionalstatistik/bevoelkerung/zensus-2011.html . live .
  4. Web site: Bevölkerung in Zahlen 2023 . dortmund.de . 2024-05-08.
  5. Web site: Ruhr Regional Association . 2023-09-28 . www.rvr.ruhr . en.
  6. Web site: EUR-Lex - 52011DC0921 - EN - EUR-Lex. eur-lex.europa.eu. 14 July 2020. 29 December 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20201229130951/https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52011DC0921. live.
  7. Web site: Home: RUHR.2010 . 31 May 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090511075016/http://www.essen-fuer-das-ruhrgebiet.ruhr2010.de/ . 11 May 2009 . dead .
  8. Samuel Shepard Jones and Denys Peter Myers, Documents on American Foreign Relations, Volume 10 (1948), p. 125: "Part IX: Definitions Article 29".
  9. Lawrence K. Cecil and Philip Hauge Abelson, Water Reuse (American Institute of Chemical Engineers, 1967), p. 122.
  10. Web site: "Das Ruhrgebiet! Von der Steinzeit bis zur Kulturhauptsatdt 2010" part 2. Prof. Dr. Klaus Tenfelde. 2001-11-20. 13 November 2009. https://web.archive.org/web/20091113073605/http://www.bild.de/BILD/regional/ruhrgebiet/aktuell/2009/03/02/geschichte-des-ruhrgebiets/fruehzeit-und-mittelalter-geburtsstunde-zweiter-artikelteil.html. live.
  11. [Friedrich Harkort]
  12. Baten . Jörg . Did the Railway Increase Inequality? A Micro-Regional Analysis of Heights in the Hinterland of the Booming Ruhr Area During the Late Nineteenth Century . The Journal of European Economic History . Summer 2009 . 38 . 2.
  13. Web site: "Das Ruhrgebiet! Von der Steinzeit bis zur Kulturhauptsatdt 2010" part 3 . Prof. Dr. Klaus Tenfelde . 2001-11-20 . 23 January 2010 . https://web.archive.org/web/20100123042828/http://www.bild.de/BILD/regional/ruhrgebiet/aktuell/2009/03/04/geschichte-des-ruhrgebiets/die-kohle-der-kaiser-und-die-kanonen-1.html . live .
  14. Web site: Llewellyn . Jennifer . Thompson . Steve . 17 September 2019 . The Kapp Putsch . 14 April 2023 . Alpha History.
  15. Web site: Wulfert . Anja . 22 January 2002 . Der Märzaufstand 1920 . The March Uprising 1920 . 14 April 2023 . Deutsches Historisches Museum . de . 14 April 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230414115718/https://www.dhm.de/lemo/kapitel/weimarer-republik/innenpolitik/maerzaufstand-1920.html . live .
  16. Web site: 14 April 2009 . Ruhr Occupation . 14 April 2023 . Encyclopedia Britannica . 14 April 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230414115718/https://www.britannica.com/topic/Ruhr-occupation . live .
  17. Web site: Llewellyn . Jennifer . Thompson . Steve . 25 September 2019 . The Ruhr Occupation . 14 April 2023 . Alpha History.
  18. Book: Schmidt, Royal J. . Versailles and the Ruhr: Seedbed of World War II . Springer . 2012 . 9789401510813 . Heidelberg . 14 April 2023 . 14 April 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230414115721/https://books.google.com/books?id=lWZ-BgAAQBAJ&q=right-wing . live .
  19. Book: R. W. Davies. The Industrialisation of Soviet Russia Volume 6: The Years of Progress: The Soviet Economy, 1934-1936. 2014. Palgrave Macmillan. 275. 9781137362575. 11 September 2017. 10 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230110215522/https://books.google.com/books?id=iM9CBAAAQBAJ&pg=PA275. live.
  20. Book: William L. Shirer, Ron Rosenbaum. The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany. 1960. Simon & Schuster. 293. 9781451651683. 11 September 2017. 10 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230110215522/https://books.google.com/books?id=6QngAAAAQBAJ&pg=PA293. live.
  21. Book: A. J. P. Taylor. English History 1914-1945. 2001. Oxford University Press. 386. 9780192801401. 11 September 2017. 10 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230110215526/https://books.google.com/books?id=l4CbmiuJe50C&pg=PA386. live.
  22. Book: Mitcham, Samuel W.. Samuel W. Mitcham. The Rise of the Wehrmacht: Vol. 1. 2008. Praeger. 66–67. 9780275996413. 11 September 2017. 10 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230110215524/https://books.google.com/books?id=DW66ejQS2xoC&pg=PA66. live.
  23. Book: Mitcham, Samuel W.. Samuel W. Mitcham. The Rise of the Wehrmacht, Volume 1. 2008. Praeger. 66. 9780275996413. 11 September 2017. 10 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230110215524/https://books.google.com/books?id=DW66ejQS2xoC&pg=PA66. live.
  24. https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=950&dat=19371013&id=ePVPAAAAIBAJ&sjid=MFUDAAAAIBAJ&pg=5438,2426020&hl=en German-Belgian Pact Concluded
  25. Botting (1985), p. 125
  26. Web site: RAF Bomber Command 748 Lancasters carried out a large attack on Dortmund on 12th of March 1945. Fred. Vogels. Back to Normandy. 12 March 1945 . 16 December 2017. 17 December 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20171217014827/https://www.backtonormandy.org/component/mtree/air-force-operations/airplanes-in-actions/lancaster/16345-raf-bomber-command-748-lancasters-carried-out-a-large-attack-on-dorthmund-on-1112th-of-march-1945.html. live.
  27. Yoder (1955), pp. 345–358
  28. Gareau (1961), pp. 517–534
  29. [John Ardagh]
  30. Ardagh, Germany and the Germans (1987) pp 74–82
  31. Christian Berndt, "Ruhr Firms between Dynamic Change and Structural Persistence. Globalization, the 'German Model' and Regional Place-Dependence", Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers New Series, Vol. 23, No. 3 (1998), pp. 331–352 in JSTOR
  32. De Ridder K. et al., 2008. Simulating the impact of urban sprawl on air quality and population exposure in the German Ruhr area. Part I: Reproducing the base state. Atmospheric Environment 42,7059–7069
  33. De Ridder K et al., 2008. Simulating the impact of urban sprawl on air quality and population exposure in the German Ruhr area. Part II: Development and evaluation of an urban growth scenario. Atmospheric Environment 42,7070–7077
  34. http://en.kulturhauptstadt-europas.de/start.php
  35. Web site: Schunck. Britta. 2020-12-17. 41,2 Grad im Sommer 2019: Duisburg und Tönisvorst sind neue Hitze-Spitzenreiter in Deutschland. 2021-06-20. RP ONLINE. de. 24 June 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210624204812/https://rp-online.de/nrw/panorama/duisburg-toenisvorst-heisseste-stadt-in-deutschland-41-2-grad-in-2019_aid-55260643. live.
  36. Web site: 2019-06-09. Fünf Jahre nach "Ela" – Erinnerungen an den Pfingststurm. 2021-06-20. www.waz.de. de-DE. 24 June 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210624203517/https://www.waz.de/region/rhein-und-ruhr/fuenf-jahre-nach-ela-erinnerungen-an-den-pfingststurm-id225980923.html. live.
  37. Web site: Studierende. Ruhr. Regionalverband. 2017-09-28. www.metropoleruhr.de. de. 2017-10-02. 7 October 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20171007152949/http://www.metropoleruhr.de/regionalverband-ruhr/regionalstatistik/daten-zur-metropole-ruhr/bildung/studierende.html. dead.
  38. Web site: Studying in the Ruhr region: 22 universities and colleges - welcome.ruhr. www.welcome.ruhr. en. 2017-10-02. 3 October 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20171003030608/http://www.welcome.ruhr/en/career/studying/. live.