Renewable energy in Turkey explained

Renewables supply a quarter of energy in Turkey, including heat and electricity. Some houses have rooftop solar water heating, and hot water from underground warms many spas and greenhouses. In parts of the west hot rocks are shallow enough to generate electricity as well as heat. Wind turbines, also mainly near western cities and industry, generate a tenth of Turkey’s electricity. Hydropower, mostly from dams in the east, is the only modern renewable energy which is fully exploited. Hydropower averages about a fifth of the country's electricity, but much less in drought years.[1] Apart from wind and hydro, other renewables; such as geothermal, solar and biogas; together generated almost a tenth of Turkey’s electricity in 2022.[2] Türkiye has ranked 5th in Europe and 12th in the world in terms of installed capacity in renewable energy. The share of renewables in Türkiye’s installed power reached to 54% at the end of 2022.[3]

Turkey has a long history of wood burning, windmills, and bathing in hot springs. Many dams were built from the mid-20th to early 21st century, but some say that governments have not allowed civil society enough influence on energy policy, leading to protests against building dams, geothermal power plants, and at least one wind farm.[4] Despite Turkey’s sunny climate solar power is underdeveloped. As the electricity system is already flexible increasing to 70% renewables is easily feasible.Solar power could be expanded more quickly if the electricity grid was improved faster and energy policy revised, especially by abolishing fossil fuel subsidies.

Many hybrid power plants are planned, and batteries are being integrated. Companies with a lot of renewables include the state electricity generation company (mainly hydro), Aydem, and Kalyon. If renewables could help phase-out coal by 2030, instead of by the national net zero greenhouse gas emissions target year of 2053, that would have significant health benefits. As of 2022 renewables are not sufficient to meet that target year.[5] Various electric vehicles are being manufactured, which will use some of the increased renewable generation and help reduce air pollution.

Sources of renewable energy

Bioenergy

Hybrid projects, storage and integration

Solar is often added to existing power plants, such as geothermal,[6] hydro,[7] and wind.[8] A solar and biomass hybrid is also feasible.[9] Up to 15% of the existing installed capacity can be added without requiring a new licence, provided generation does not exceed that limit, although the extra capacity cannot receive a USD subsidy.[10] There is a virtual power plant which operates with geothermal, wind, solar and hydro.[11] Combining wind and/or solar with storage is also popular.[12] Increasing Turkey's proportion of electric cars in use to 10% by 2030 would help integrate variable electricity.[13]

Transmission and distribution cables are at medium risk from earthquakes and transformers at high risk whereas solar is low risk:[14] Think tank Shura suggests that microgrids of solar and batteries could increase resilience against earthquakes.

Future

Wind, and especially solar, could supply much more energy in Turkey.[15] It is estimated that over half of electricity generation could be from renewables by 2026,[16] but Turkey has invested less in solar and wind power than similar Mediterranean countries.[17] More renewable energy could be used to reduce the nation's greenhouse gas emissions,[18] and thus avoid paying other countries' carbon tariffs.[19] Turkey is a net exporter of wind power equipment, but a net importer of solar power equipment.[20] Total non-hydro renewables overtook hydro in 2021.[21] Solar is expected to overtake wind before 2030.[22] The Energy Minister said in 2023 that by 2035 renewables would supply almost a quarter of the nation’s energy.[23] According to one study, by massively increasing solar power in the south and wind power in the west the country's entire electricity demand could be met from renewable sources.[24]

A 2022 simulation by Shura of typical spring 2030 generation shows that wind and nuclear could provide baseload, and solar much of daytime demand, reserving dammed hydro for evening flexibility. Other experts believe that nuclear power will keep the grid stable from fluctuations in variable renewable energy,[25] while some state that more geothermal baseload capacity should be added.[26]

Think tank Ember said in 2022 that Turkey needs to expand renewables at least twice as fast, to decarbonize the electricity sector and lower import bills.[27] In 2023 they said that solar power rollout should be accelerated in the sunny south.[28] Shura states that renewables could generate 70% of electricity by 2030, with coal reduced to 5%.[29] Many new 400kV transmission lines are planned to be built by 2030.

The national energy plan published in 2022 expects an increase in the share of renewable energy and intermittent renewable energy sources in electricity generation to 55% and 34% respectively by 2035.[30] According to the plan by 2035 installed capacity will increase to: 30 GW (25 GW onshore, 5 GW offshore) of wind power, and 53 GW of solar power. The plan is for installed capacity to increase to 35 GW of hydroelectricity and 5 GW total of geothermal and biomass power. The plan expects the share of renewable energy in primary energy consumption, which was 16.7% in 2020, to increase to 23.7% by 2035. The plan expects the share of electricity from variable renewable energy, which was 12% in 2020, to increase gradually to 34% by 2035.

Economics

The fuel-only cost of fossil gas-fired power in early 2022 was 128 USD/MWh,[31] which was more than double that of the levelized cost of electricity of new utility scale solar PV and new onshore wind. Renewable energy is competitive with domestic coal.[32] However in 2022 wind and solar remained more expensive than energy efficiency measures, which were estimated at 14 USD/MWh.

There are feed-in-tariffs in lira (but partly adjusted to USD) per kWh depending on the source and there may be extra if local components are used.[33] [34] Geothermal and pumped storage get 15 years of this YEKDEM.[35] Otherwise tariffs apply for 10 years and any local bonus for 5 years, and are revised quarterly. Although feed-in tariffs continue to 2030 investors are concerned about the volatility of the lira.[36]

Following the invasion of Ukraine in early 2022 the cost of imported fuel soared and the Energy Market Regulatory Authority (EMRA) was empowered to intervene in the electricity market.[37] According to the Industrial Development Bank of Turkey, the support fee based on source model depends on transferring money from low-cost solar, wind and hydroelectric power plants to those with high operating expenses, examples of which include imported coal and natural gas.[38] Despite some renewables generators calling for it to be scrapped, it was extended into 2023.[39] This applies to both the market exchange price and fixed prices determined by bilateral agreements. EMRA determining such fees has been criticised by some lawyers, who say that the fees are like a tax on low cost generators, and that according to the constitution taxes can only be imposed by parliament.

The World Bank said in 2022 that "the war in Ukraine and attendant energy supply disruptions and price increases highlight risks for countries like Türkiye that rely on fossil fuel imports, underscoring the urgency of climate action in support of energy security and affordability" and proposed a plan to integrate development with action on climate change.[40]

Earlier reports from other organisations say that such an expansion of renewables benefits employment,[41] industrial production, and balance of trade.[42]

A 2022 study by Ember in advance of the Energy Ministry long-term plan suggested that dependence on imported energy could be reduced from a half to a quarter by 2030 by energy efficiency and increasing solar capacity to 40 GW and wind to 30 GW: this would mean the increase in wind and solar accelerating from 1 GW a year each to 2.5 and 4 GW respectively. They said that domestic solar manufacturing capacity could achieve 8 GW a year. The report was based on 4 modeling studies by: the Istanbul Policy Center, the World Bank’s Climate and Development report, a report from Europe Beyond Coal and other local environmental organizations, and analysis from Turkish energy transition think tank Shura. In 2023 Shura estimated that doubling the capacity of wind and solar compared to 2022 would cut the wholesale cost of electricity by a quarter.[43]

If more renewable energy is generated it may be possible to export green hydrogen to the EU. Another example of such “sector coupling” would be using excess renewable energy for desalination. Eser Özdil at the Atlantic Council said in 2022 that interconnectors with the EU need to be greatly increased, and suggested joint electricity projects with Balkan companies. A green tariff has been offered since 2021.[44] Companies with a lot of renewables include the state electricity generation company (mainly hydro),[45] Aydem,[46] and Kalyon.[47]

Increasing export of electricity to the EU has also been proposed but analyst Kadri Taştan pointed out that this depends on "reliable and solid political relations between the two and an ambitious environmental policy in Turkey".[48] Using renewable electricity to produce green hydrogen for export has also been suggested, but would require substantial investment. The 60% import tariff on Chinese components has been criticised as favouring large companies over SMEs.[49] As of 2023 Chinese companies consider Turkey high risk, in part due to unpredictable and changeable regulations. SMEs buy solar parts from Malaysia due to the trade agreement.

Regulations

Unlicensed (about 2% of supply and over 90% of which is solar)[50] generators must apply to distribution companies or industrial park license holders in their region for technical checks and approval. Production could increase far more quickly if subsidies for coal were abolished[51] and the auction system was improved.[52] In 2022 the Unlicensed Electricity Generation Regulation was amended so that the amount of surplus energy that can be sold may not exceed the total consumption of the consumer the previous year: the excess goes to the Renewable Energy Resources Support Mechanism. This regulation might be unconstitutional by being retrospective.[53]

Politics

The Turkish Electricity Industry Association has suggested a taxonomy, including investments in renewable energy, based on the EU taxonomy for sustainable activities.[54] [55] Some academics say that governments have not allowed civil society enough say on energy policy, leading to protests against building hydropower, geothermal power, and at least one wind farm. In 2022 the EU complained about local content requirements, saying that they did not meet World Trade Organization and European Union–Turkey Customs Union rules.[56] Think tank Shura says that renewables could replace coal power by 2035.[57]

Health

Geothermal power in Turkey is used mainly for heating, and solar water heating is also widespread. However, burning wood for home heating (classified as "traditional biomass" within academic reports) has been causing indoor air pollution throughout history,[58] and still poses such problems.[59]

Possible health benefits of expanding modern renewable energy have been estimated at US$800 million a year. Health benefits could be greater if renewables succeeded in phasing out coal by 2030.[60]

History

Neolithic people in the Fertile Crescent burnt dung.[61] [62] The use of wood as "traditional biomass" in pre-republican times particularly affected Turkish forests in central and southeast Anatolia, whereas forests in coastal regions proved somewhat more renewable because these regions receive more precipitation.[63] Due to deforestation in arid regions, poor communities continued to burn dry dung in some remote villages into the late 20th century.[64] In the early 21st century wood was the major source of energy in rural areas.[65]

In late 20th century, biogas became the focus of much research.[66] The first residential heat pump was installed at the turn of the century. Geothermal heat and solar heat were developed early. Hydropower was expanded for many decades with geothermal, wind and solar electricity following.[67] Although there has been some academic research on solar houses since the 1970s this has been criticised as insufficient given the importance of the construction industry.[68]

See also

Further reading

External links

Notes and References

  1. Lessons from global experiences for accelerating energy transition in Turkey through solar and wind power . Shura . 19 February 2019 . 2019.
  2. Web site: 2023 . Executive Summary: Net Zero 2053: A Roadmap for the Turkish Electricity Sector . Shura . "the share of the renewables is almost 40%".
  3. https://www.mfa.gov.tr/turkeys-energy-strategy.en.mfa#:~:text=Furthermore%2C%20T%C3%BCrkiye%20has%20ranked%205th,at%20the%20end%20of%202022.
  4. Book: Tezcür, Günes Murat . The Oxford Handbook of Turkish Politics . 2022 . . 978-0-19-006489-1 . en.
  5. Web site: Ergenç . Ceren . Göçer . Derya . 5 May 2023 . China's Response to Türkiye's Volatile Authoritarianism . Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
  6. Web site: Cariaga . Carlo . 2022-06-10 . Zorlu Energy to invest on hybrid power plant in Kizildere III GPP, Turkiye . 2022-06-24 . Think GeoEnergy . en-US.
  7. Web site: Todorović . Igor . 2021-07-30 . Turkey's first hydro-solar hybrid power plant Lower Kaleköy comes online . 2023-04-02 . Balkan Green Energy News . en-US.
  8. News: 23 June 2022 . Wind - GE, Inogen and Sertavul to build first Hybrid Wind + Solar project in Turkey . 2022-06-24 . Renewable Energy Magazine, at the Heart of Clean Energy Journalism . en . Com . Viaintermedia .
  9. Kirim . Yavuz . Sadikoglu . Hasan . Melikoglu . Mehmet . 2022-04-01 . Technical and economic analysis of biogas and solar photovoltaic (PV) hybrid renewable energy system for dairy cattle barns . Renewable Energy . en . 188 . 873–889 . 10.1016/j.renene.2022.02.082 . 247114342 . 0960-1481.
  10. Web site: 2022-04-28 . Sponsored briefing: Hot topics in Turkish renewable energy market . 2022-05-09 . Legal Business . en-GB.
  11. Web site: First integration of geothermal power assets into virtual power plant in Turkey . 2020-09-07 . Think GeoEnergy. 6 September 2020 .
  12. Web site: Todorović . Igor . 2022-11-30 . Turkey's new energy storage regulation to spur unseen investment boom . 2023-04-02 . Balkan Green Energy News . en-US.
  13. Transport sector transformation: Integrating electric vehicles into Turkey's distribution grids. 2019. Shura. 2019-12-26. 2020-08-01. https://web.archive.org/web/20200801065245/https://www.shura.org.tr/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Transport-sector-transformation.Integrating-electric-vehicles-into-Turkey%E2%80%99s-distribution-grids.pdf. dead.
  14. Web site: 2023-03-31 . Doğal Afetler Karşısında Elektrik Sisteminin Güçlendirilmesi . Strengthening the electricity system against natural disasters . 2023-04-02 . tr-TR.
  15. Dawood . Kamran . 2016 . Hybrid wind-solar reliable solution for Turkey to meet electric demand . Balkan Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering . 4 . 2 . 62–66 . 10.17694/bajece.06954. 2024-02-07 .
  16. Web site: 9 March 2022 . Legislation to promote use of renewable energy . 2022-03-23 . . en.
  17. Web site: Saygılı . Hülya . Renewable Energy use in Turkey . 17 February 2019 . Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey blog. June 2018 .
  18. Sahin . Habip . Esen . Hikmet . 2022-06-01 . The usage of renewable energy sources and its effects on GHG emission intensity of electricity generation in Turkey . . en . 192 . 859–869 . 10.1016/j.renene.2022.03.141 . 0960-1481 . 247903903.
  19. Web site: 2022-06-20 . Domestic share of wind turbine production in Turkey reaches 72% . 2022-06-22 . Balkan Green Energy News . en-US.
  20. Web site: Saygin . Deger . Godron . Philipp . Hoffman . Max . 10 July 2018 . How Turkey Can Ensure a Successful Energy Transition . 19 February 2019 . Center for American Progress.
  21. Web site: 22 January 2022 . Non-hydro renewables overtake hydro for first time . 2022-04-18 . . en.
  22. Türkiye energy independence only comes with clean . Alparslan . Ufuk . 2022-10-04 . en-US . 2022-10-10 . Ember.
  23. Web site: Türkiye to increase energy investments with zero emission target . 2023-01-21 . . 21 January 2023 . en.
  24. Kilickaplan. Anil. Bogdanov. Dmitrii. Peker. Onur. Caldera. Upeksha. Aghahosseini. Arman. Breyer. Christian. 2017-12-01. An energy transition pathway for Turkey to achieve 100% renewable energy powered electricity, desalination and non-energetic industrial gas demand sectors by 2050. Solar Energy. 158. 218–235. 10.1016/j.solener.2017.09.030. 2017SoEn..158..218K. 0038-092X.
  25. Web site: Matalucci . Sergio . 30 March 2022 . Turkey targets Balkans and EU renewables markets . 2022-04-18 . . en-GB.
  26. Chandrasekharam . Dornadula . Baba . Alper . 2022-04-07 . Carbon dioxide emissions mitigation strategy through enhanced geothermal systems: western Anatolia, Turkey . Environmental Earth Sciences . en . 81 . 8 . 235 . 10.1007/s12665-022-10345-5 . 1866-6299 . 8986971 . 35411211. 2022EES....81..235C .
  27. Web site: Turkey Electricity Review 2022 . 2022-01-20 . . 20 January 2022 . en-GB.
  28. Web site: 2023-04-04 . The south can unlock Türkiye's solar ambitions . 2023-04-08 . Ember . en-US.
  29. 2022-04-28 . Integration of Renewable Energy into the Turkish Electricity System . 2022-06-24. Shura . en-US.
  30. 2022 . Türkiye national energy plan . Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources.
  31. Renewable Power Generation Costs in 2021 . July 2022 . . en . 978-92-9260-452-3 .
  32. Web site: Energy crisis is an opportunity to accelerate Türkiye's energy transition: Op-ed . 2022-07-26 . . 29 June 2022 . en.
  33. Web site: Olğun . Kinstellar-Şeyma . February 2021 . New Turkish-Lira tariff scheme for renewable energy projects in Turkey . 2021-02-03 . Lexology . en.
  34. Web site: April 2022 . Doing business in Turkey: Energy . 2022-04-18 . . en.
  35. Web site: Turkey introduces subsidies for wave, tidal energy, offshore wind . 4 May 2023 .
  36. Web site: Türkiye 2022 Report . 2023-01-13 . EU Delegation to Türkiye . en.
  37. Web site: Ardiyok . Sahin . Kıl . İlker . 20 April 2022 . (In)Visible Hand Of EMRA: Recent Regulatory Developments In Turkish Electricity Prices - Energy and Natural Resources - Turkey . 2022-04-20 . Mondaq.
  38. Web site: 2022 energy outlook . Industrial Development Bank of Turkey.
  39. Web site: August 2022 . Monthly Energy Bulletin . Industrial Development Bank of Turkey.
  40. Türkiye - Country Climate and Development Report . 2022-06-13 . . en.
  41. Social and Employment Impacts of Climate Change and Green Economy Policies in Türkiye . Simas . Moana . Wiebe . Kirsten Svenja . June 2022 . en . Sodersten . Carl Johan . United Nations Development Programme.
  42. COBENEFITS Policy Report Turkey . December 2020 . en-US.
  43. 2023-05-29 . Yenilenebilir Enerji Kaynaklarının Elektrik Piyasasına Etkisi - 2022 Yılı Analizi . The Impact of Renewable Energy Resources on the Electricity Market - Analysis for the Year 2022. 2023-08-19 . tr-TR. 2022 yılı itibarıyla, Rüzgâr ve Güneşin Fazla Olduğu Senaryo’da hesaplanan piyasa maliyetleri aynı dönemde gerçekleşmiş reel maliyetlerin %24,7 altında seyretmiştir..
  44. Web site: 14 November 2020 . Elektri̇k Pi̇yasasinda Yeni̇lenebi̇li̇r Enerji̇ Kaynak Garanti̇ Belgesi̇ Yönetmeli̇ği̇ . Renewable Energy Source Guarantee Certificate Regulation in the Electricity Market . 2021-01-02 . Official Gazette of the Republic of Turkey.
  45. Web site: 2021-09-02 . Turkey's hydropower capacity grows despite drought lowering output . . en.
  46. Web site: Todorović . Igor . 2021-04-20 . Five renewable energy firms preparing to enter stock market in Turkey . 2022-07-08 . Balkan Green Energy News . en-US.
  47. Web site: Aslanhan . Ugur . 18 April 2022 . Europe's biggest solar power plant in Turkiye to meet power needs of 2M . 2022-07-08 . Anadolu Agency.
  48. Web site: Taştan . Kadri . 2022 . Decarbonising EU-Turkey Energy Cooperation: Challenges and Prospects . 2022-04-21 . . en-EN.
  49. Web site: Ergenç . Ceren . Göçer . Derya . 5 May 2023 . China's Response to Türkiye's Volatile Authoritarianism . Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
  50. Web site: Electricity Generation in Turkey . 2022-10-06. Güleryüz Partners . en. Keskin . Yasemin . Koç . M. R. Cafer.
  51. February 2019 . Turkey 2019 . Environmental Performance Reviews . OECD Environmental Performance Reviews . . 10.1787/9789264309753-en . 9789264309746 . 242969625.
  52. Opportunities to strengthen the YEKA auction model for enhancing the regulatory framework of Turkey's power system transformation . 2018 . Ayşe Ceren. Sarı. Değer. Saygın . Shura.
  53. Web site: Turkey Causes A Splash: New Rules For Generating Unlicensed Electricity! . 2022-09-25 . Mondaq.
  54. Web site: Taksonomi: Avrupa Birliği Taksonomi Mevzuatı Çerçevesinde Türkiye Elektrik Sektörünün Değerlendirilmesi ve Dünyadan Örnekler . Analysis of the Turkish Electricity Sector in the Framework of the European Union Taxonomy Legislation and global examples . Türki̇ye Elektri̇k Sanayi̇ Bi̇rli̇ği̇. December 2022 . tr.
  55. Web site: 2023-02-03 . Turkey's Green Taxonomy explained: read the book! . 2023-03-21 . . en-US.
  56. Web site: Türkiye 2022 Report . 2023-01-13 . EU Delegation to Türkiye . en.
  57. Web site: 2023 . Executive Summary: Net Zero 2053: A Roadmap for the Turkish Electricity Sector . SHURA Energy Transition Center.
  58. Shillito . Lisa-Marie . Namdeo . Anil . Bapat . Aishwarya Vikram . Mackay . Helen . Haddow . Scott D. . 2022-03-01 . Analysis of fine particulates from fuel burning in a reconstructed building at Çatalhöyük World Heritage Site, Turkey: assessing air pollution in prehistoric settled communities . Environmental Geochemistry and Health . en . 44 . 3 . 1033–1048 . 10.1007/s10653-021-01000-2 . 1573-2983 . 8863713 . 34155558. 2022EnvGH..44.1033S .
  59. Web site: 2022-01-27 . Health and Environment Alliance Health experts demand more attention and action on the public health threat of wood burning in the Western Balkans . 2023-04-04 . Health and Environment Alliance . en-GB.
  60. Web site: 2022-12-22 . Health and Environment Alliance Curing Chronic Coal: The health benefits of a 2030 coal phase out in Turkey . 2023-04-02 . Health and Environment Alliance . en-GB.
  61. Web site: Davies . Caleb . 13 August 2019 . Neolithic remains help sniff out the earliest human use of dung . 2023-04-04 . . en.
  62. Allen . Susan E. . 2019-05-01 . Context and contents: Distinguishing variation in archaeobotanical assemblage formation processes at Early Halaf Fistıklı Höyük, Turkey . Vegetation History and Archaeobotany . en . 28 . 3 . 247–262 . 10.1007/s00334-019-00728-3 . 2019VegHA..28..247A . 134417004 . 1617-6278.
  63. Gümüşçü . Osman . Uğur . Abdullah . Aygören . Tülay . 2014 . Deforestation in Sixteenth Century Anatolia: The Case of Hüdavendi̇gar (Bursa) Sancak . Belleten . 78 . 281 . 167–200 . 10.37879/belleten.2014.167 . 245293300 . 0041-4255.
  64. Anderson . Seona . Ertug-Yaras . Fusün . 1998-06-01 . Fuel Fodder and Faeces: An Ethnographic and Botanical Study of Dung Fuel Use in Central Anatolia . Environmental Archaeology . 1 . 1 . 99–109 . 10.1179/env.1996.1.1.99 . 1998EnvAr...1...99A . 1461-4103.
  65. Balat . Mustafa . Acici . Neslihan . Ersoy . Gulyeter . 2005 . Turkey's Wood Reserves, Potential Trends and Future Perspectives of Wood Use . Energy Exploration & Exploitation . 23 . 1 . 71–80 . 10.1260/0144-5987.23.1.71 . 43754661 . 2005EExEx..23...71B . 130507400 . 0144-5987.
  66. Hepbaşlı . Arif . Özgener . Onder . 2004-08-01 . Turkey's Renewable Energy Sources: Part 1. Historical Development . Energy Sources . 26 . 10 . 961–969 . 10.1080/00908310490473183 . 2004EneSA..26..961H . 0090-8312 . 110777951.
  67. Şahin . Cem . August 2021 . The Development of Renewable Energy in Turkish Electricity Markets . European Journal of Science and Technology. 10.31590/ejosat.893539 . 237991754 . free .
  68. Web site: Dikmen . Çiğdem Belgin . 2 December 2021 . Comparative Evaluation of Solar Houses Applied in Turkey .