Religious satire explained
Religious satire is a form of satire that refers to religious beliefs and can take the form of texts, plays, films, and parody. From the earliest times, at least since the plays of Aristophanes, religion has been one of the three primary topics of literary satire, along with politics and sex.[1] [2] [3] Satire which targets the clergy is a type of political satire, while religious satire is that which targets religious beliefs.[4] Religious satire is also sometimes called philosophical satire, and is thought to be the result of agnosticism or atheism. Notable works of religious satire surfaced during the Renaissance, with works by Geoffrey Chaucer, Erasmus and Albrecht Dürer.
Religious satire has been criticised and at times censored to avoid offence, for example the film Life of Brian was initially banned in Ireland, Norway, some states of the US, and some towns and councils of the United Kingdom. This potential for censorship often leads to debates on the issue of freedom of speech such as in the case of the Religious Hatred Bill in January 2006. Critics of the original version of the Bill (such as comedian Rowan Atkinson) feared that satirists could be prosecuted.
Notable examples of religious satire and satirists
Films and documentaries
Characters
Literature and publications
Plays and musicals
- Tartuffe (1664) by Molière
- Le fanatisme, ou Mahomet le prophète (1736) by Voltaire, notable for its critical depiction of Muhammad,[6] described as a self-deceived,[7] perverted[7] religious fanatic and manipulator,[6] [7] and his hunger for political power behind the foundation of Islam.[6] [7]
- Inherit the Wind (1955), which fictionalizes the Scopes Monkey Trial of the 1920s
- Mistero Buffo (1969) by Dario Fo.
- , notable for its irreverent treatment of Judeo-Christian themes
- A Very Merry Unauthorized Children's Scientology Pageant (2003), which makes fun of L. Ron Hubbard and Scientology
- Altar Boyz (2005) Off-Broadway musical about Christian Boysband
- Saturday's Voyeur is a parody of life in Utah and Mormon culture
- The Book of Mormon (2011) A broadway production about two young Mormon Missionaries sent to Uganda, written by South Park creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone
- Letting Go of God (2004), Julia Sweeney, an autobiographical monologue taking aim at Catholicism and Mormonism
Television
- The Barchester Chronicles, 1982 television serial produced by the BBC, from the Anthony Trollope novels satirizing Victorian clergy
- Futurama episode "A Pharaoh to Remember" features a religious ceremony in which a priest chants, "Great Wall of Prophecy, reveal to us God's Will, that we might blindly obey!" and celebrants answer, "Free us from thought and responsibility."
- Curb Your Enthusiasm has episodes that have satirized Orthodox Judaism and Christianity
- South Park has satirized Christianity, Mormonism, Judaism, Islam, Scientology, and other religions
- Family Guy has satirized elements of Christianity and other religions in several episodes
- Satirical Australian documentary miniseries John Safran vs God (2004)
- British sitcom Father Ted, which lampooned the role of the Catholic Church in Ireland
- Blackadder episode "The Archbishop" sees Edmund invested as Archbishop of Canterbury amid a Machiavellian plot by the King to acquire lands from the Catholic Church. In Series 2, in the episode "Money", the Bishop of Bath and Wells comments "Never, in all my years, have I encountered such cruel and foul-minded perversity! Have you ever considered a career in the church?"
Characters
- Princess Clara of Drawn Together is a devout Christian who is often used to lampoon conservative Christian viewpoints
- Ned Flanders of The Simpsons is an Evangelical Christian who practices sola scriptura
On the web
- Sinfest, an internet comic strip by Tatsuya Ishida that frequently stresses religious issues (since 2000)
- Semiweekly comic Jesus and Mo (since 2005)
- Comedic short film series Mr. Deity, which stars God, his assistant, Jesus, Lucifer, and several other characters from the Bible (since 2006)
- The LOLCat Bible Translation Project, a wiki-based project by Martin Grondin (since 2007)
- Net Authority, a site that purported to be a Christian Internet censorship site (2001–2008).
- The Babylon Bee, a parody news site, mainly focusing on satirizing American Evangelical Christianity from a conservative Evangelical perspective (since 2016)
People
- Betty Bowers plays a character called "America's Best Christian". In the persona of a right-wing evangelical Christian, she references Bible verses, using the persona to point out the inconsistencies in the Bible
Parody religions
- Boogyism is a fun loving cult that follows the teachings of The Great Booga, an 8 ft stuffed bunny look-alike who created the entire universe after an accident involving an unattended barbecue. It has its own religious text, The Spiritual Arghh.
- The Flying Spaghetti Monster is the deity of the "Pastafarian" parody religion, which asserts that a supernatural creator resembling spaghetti with meatballs is responsible for the creation of the universe. Its purpose is to mock intelligent design.
- The Invisible Pink Unicorn is a goddess which takes the form of a unicorn that is paradoxically both invisible pink. These attributes serve to satirize the apparent contradictions in properties which some attribute to a theistic God, specifically omniscience, omnipotence, and omnibenevolence.
- Dinkoism or Dinkamatham is a parody religion and social movement that emerged and evolved on social networks[8] organized by independent welfare groups.[9] The BBC described Dinkoism in 2016 as an atheist movement with significant growth on social media.[10] With its own scripture Dinka Puranam and Balamangalam[11] [8]
- Discordianism is centered around the ancient Greco-Roman goddess of chaos, Eris, but draws much of its tone from Zen Buddhism, Christianity, and the beatnik and hippie countercultures of the 1950s and 1960s (respectively). Its main holy book, the Principia Discordia contains things such as a commandment to "not believe anything that you read",April 2024. and proposes that all statements are both true and false at the same time. There is some discourse as to whether Discordianism should be regarded as a parody religion, and if so, to what degree.
- The Church of the SubGenius pokes fun at many different religions, particularly Scientology, Televangelism (and its associated scandals), and other modern beliefs.
- The worship of "Ceiling Cat" among Lolcats. Ceiling Cat's enemy is Basement Cat, a black cat representing the devil.
Miscellaneous
- Voltaire
- The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence, a street performance organization that uses Catholic imagery to call attention to sexual intolerance and satirize issues of gender and morality.
- The Brick Testament, a project in which the stories of the Bible are illustrated with Lego.
- Purim Torah, traditional parodies of Jewish life written out, and/or acted out, for the holiday of Purim.
- "Sheep" by progressive rock band Pink Floyd includes a humorous version of Psalm 23.
- "Jesus He Knows Me" by rock band Genesis, a 1991 response to the then-current televangelism scandals
Reactions, criticism and censorship
Religious satire has been criticised by those who feel that sincerely held religious views should not be subject to ridicule. In some cases religious satire has been censored – for example, Molière's play Tartuffe was banned in 1664.
The film Life of Brian was initially banned in Ireland, Norway, some states of the US, and some towns and councils of the United Kingdom.[12] In an interesting case of life mirroring art, activist groups who protested the film during its release bore striking similarities to some bands of religious zealots within the film itself.[13] Like much religious satire, the intent of the film has been misinterpreted and distorted by protesters. According to the Pythons, Life of Brian is not a critique of religion so much as an indictment of the hysteria and bureaucratic excess that often surrounds it.[14]
The issue of freedom of speech was hotly debated by the UK Parliament during the passing of the Religious Hatred Bill in January 2006. Critics of the original version of the Bill (such as comedian Rowan Atkinson) feared that satirists could be prosecuted, but an amendment by the House of Lords making it clear that this was not the case was passed – by just one vote.[15]
In 2006, Rachel Bevilacqua, a member of the Church of the SubGenius, known as Rev. Magdalen in the SubGenius hierarchy, lost custody and contact with her son after a district court judge took offense at her participation in the Church's X-Day festival.
See also
References
Works cited
- Book: Robertson, David G. . Carole M. . Cusack . Alex . Norman . Handbook of New Religions and Cultural Production . 2012 . Brill . 978-90-04-22187-1 . Making the Donkey Visible: Discordianism in the Works of Robert Anton Wilson . https://books.google.com/books?id=5aRyJ-vbrJsC&dq=Discordia&pg=PA421 . 421–444.
- Book: Robertson, David G. . SubGenius vs The Conspiracy: Playfulness and sincerity in invented religions . Carole M. . Cusack . Pavol . Kosnáč . Fiction, Invention and Hyper-reality: From Popular Culture to Religion . 2016 . Taylor & Francis . 978-1-317-13549-4 . https://books.google.com/books?id=0CIlDwAAQBAJ.
Notes and References
- Clark (1991) pp.116–8 quotation:
- Clark, John R. and Motto, Anna Lydia (1973) Satire—that blasted art p.20
- Clark, John R. and Motto, Anna Lydia (1980) Menippeans & Their Satire: Concerning Monstrous Leamed Old Dogs and Hippocentaurs, in Scholia satyrica, Volume 6, 3/4, 1980 p.45 quotation:
- Hodgart (2009) p.39
- Encyclopedia: Al-Maʿarrī (Biography) . . . May 2018.
- Book: Quinn, Frederick . 2008 . The Sum of All Heresies: The Image of Islam in Western Thought . New York City . . 62–64 . 978-0-19-532563-8.
- Book: Almond, Philip C. . 1989 . Heretic and Hero: Muhammad and the Victorians . . . 33–35 . 3-447-02913-7.
- Web site: The Curious Case of Lord Dinkan . Graphics Shelf.com . 23 November 2017 . 9 June 2021 . https://archive.today/20210610011217/https://graphicshelf.com/curious-case-lord-dinkan/ . 10 June 2021 . live.
- Web site: 'Dinkoists' Gather Under a Troll Tree . https://web.archive.org/web/20160325143022/http://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/Dinkoists-Gather-Under-a-Troll-Tree/2016/03/21/article3337791.ece . dead . 25 March 2016 . Express News Service . 21 March 2016 . . 12 October 2020 . ...threatening calls and opposition from staunch religious followers... the social media religion, ‘Dinkoists’ here on Sunday. ... no official registration ... attention entirely through Facebook... .
- News: The mouse messiah bringing salvation to India's atheists . . 11 April 2016 . 12 October 2020.
- Web site: Kerala's Dinkoists take on Akshaya Tritiya, hit the market with their brand of underwear . . Megha Varier . 6 May 2016 . 9 June 2021 . https://archive.today/20210610004349/https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/keralas-dinkoists-take-akshaya-tritiya-hit-market-their-brand-underwear-42811 . 10 June 2021 . live.
- http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/mid/7530542.stm Vicar supports Life of Brian ban
- Dyke, C: Screening Scripture, pp. 238–240. Trinity Press International, 2002
- Web site: The Secret Life of Brian . . 2007 . https://web.archive.org/web/20111128155105/http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDCAJTrF1gg . 2011-11-28 . dead.
- Web site: Votes on the Racial and Religious Hatred Bill . 2006 .
