Republic F-84F Thunderstreak Explained

The Republic F-84F Thunderstreak was an American swept-wing turbojet-powered fighter-bomber. The RF-84F Thunderflash was a photo reconnaissance version.

The design was originally intended to be a relatively simple upgrade to the F-84 Thunderjet to make it more competitive with the F-86 Sabre, differing largely in the use of a swept-wing and tail. Given the small number of changes, it was assigned the next model letter in the F-84 series, F. The prototypes demonstrated a number of performance and handling issues, which resulted in marginal improvement over the previous versions. Production was repeatedly delayed and another run of the straight-wing Thunderjets were completed as the G models.

Looking for a clear performance edge compared to the G models, the engine was upgraded to the much more powerful British Armstrong Siddeley Sapphire built in the United States as the Wright J65. The larger engine required the fuselage to be stretched into an oval shape and the air intake to be modified. With these and other changes, the design was finally ready to enter production, but only a fraction of the original production systems could be used and the aircraft was effectively a new design. It finally entered service in November 1954, by which time the Sabre had also undergone many upgrades and the Thunderstreak was relegated to the fighter-bomber role. Its time as a front-line design was brief, it began to be moved to secondary roles as early as 1958.

F-84Fs were then offered to NATO member countries and other allies, who took them up in large numbers. Operators included the Belgian Air Force, Royal Danish Air Force, French Air Force, West German Air Force, Greek Air Force, Italian Air Force, Royal Netherlands Air Force, Royal Norwegian Air Force, Republic of China Air Force, Turkish Air Force, and for a brief period using ex-French examples, the Israeli Air Force.

Development

In 1948, a swept wing version of the F-84 was created with the hope of bringing performance to the level of the F-86. The last production F-84E was fitted with a swept tail, a new wing with 38.5 degrees of leading edge sweep and 3.5 degrees of anhedral, and a J35-A-25 engine producing 5,300 pound-force (23.58 kN) of thrust.[1] The aircraft was designated XF-96A. It flew on 3 June 1950 with Oscar P. Haas at the controls.[2] Although the airplane was capable of 602 knots (693 mph, 1,115 km/h), the performance gain over the F-84E was considered minor.[1] Nonetheless, it was ordered into production in July 1950 as the F-84F Thunderstreak. The F-84 designation was retained because the fighter was expected to be a low-cost improvement of the straight-wing Thunderjet with over 55 percent commonality in tooling.[1]

In the meantime, the USAF, hoping for improved high-altitude performance from a more powerful engine, arranged for the British Armstrong Siddeley Sapphire turbojet engine to be built in the United States as the Wright J65. To accommodate the larger engine, YF-84Fs with a British-built Sapphire as well as production F-84Fs with the J65 had a vertically stretched fuselage, with the air intake attaining an oval cross-section. Production delays with the F-84F forced the USAF to order a number of straight-wing F-84Gs as an interim measure.[1]

Production quickly ran into problems. Although tooling commonality with the Thunderjet was supposed to be 55 percent, in reality only fifteen percent of tools could be reused.[1] To make matters worse, the F-84F utilized press-forged wing spars and ribs. At the time, only three presses in the United States could manufacture these, and priority was given to the Boeing B-47 Stratojet bomber over the F-84.[1] The YJ65-W-1 engine was considered obsolete and the improved J65-W-3 did not become available until 1954. When the first production F-84F finally flew on 22 November 1952, it differed from the service test aircraft. It had a different canopy which opened up and back instead of sliding to the rear (a unique design, the canopy was mounted on a pair of hydraulic rams and a pivoted lever arm that allowed it to lift up and backwards while remaining almost level with the fuselage, instead of the more common simple hinged canopy), as well as airbrakes on the sides of the fuselage instead of the bottom of the aircraft.[1] The aircraft was considered not ready for operational deployment due to control and stability problems. The first 275 aircraft, equipped with conventional stabilizer-elevator tailplanes, suffered from accelerated stall pitch-up and poor turning ability at combat speeds. Beginning with Block 25, the problem was improved upon by the introduction of a hydraulically powered one-piece stabilator. A number of aircraft were also retrofitted with spoilers for improved high-speed control. As a result, the F-84F was not declared operational until 12 May 1954.[1]

Thunderflash

The second YF-84F prototype was completed with wing-root air intakes. These were not adopted for the fighter due to loss of thrust. However, this arrangement permitted placement of cameras in the nose and the design was adopted for the RF-84F Thunderflash reconnaissance version. The first YRF-84F was completed in February 1952.[1] The aircraft retained an armament of four machine guns and could carry up to fifteen cameras. Innovations included computerized controls which adjusted camera settings for light, speed, and altitude, a periscope to give the pilot better visualization of the target, and a voice recorder to let the pilot narrate his observations. Being largely identical to the F-84F, the Thunderflash suffered from the same production delays and engine problems, delaying operational service until March 1954. The aircraft was retired from active duty in 1957, only to be reactivated in 1961, and finally retired from the ANG in 1972.[1]

Several modified Thunderflashes were used in the FICON project.

Design

The Thunderstreak suffered from the same poor takeoff performance as the straight-wing Thunderjet despite having a more powerful engine. In reality, almost 700 pounds-force (3.11 kN) or ten percent of total thrust was lost because the J65 was installed at an angle and its jet pipe was not perfectly straight (in addition to the usual thrust losses from the long jet pipe). On a hot day, 7,500 feet (2,285 m) of runway were required for takeoff roll.[3] A typical takeoff speed was 160 knots (185 mph, 300 km/h).[3] Like the Thunderjet, the Thunderstreak excelled at cruise and had predictable handling characteristics within its performance envelope. Like its predecessor, it also suffered from accelerated stall pitch-up and potential resulting separation of wings from the airplane. In addition, spins in the F-84F were practically unrecoverable and ejection was the only recourse below 10,000 feet (3,000 m).[3]

Operational history

Project Run In completed operational tests in November 1954 and found the aircraft to be to USAF satisfaction and considerably better than the F-84G. However, ongoing engine failures resulted in the entire fleet being grounded in early 1955. Also, the J65 engine continued to suffer from flameouts when flying through heavy rain or snow.[1] As the result of the problems, the active duty phaseout began almost as soon as the F-84F entered service in 1954, and was completed by 1958. Increased tensions in Germany associated with construction of the Berlin Wall in 1961 resulted in reactivation of the F-84F fleet. In 1962, the fleet was grounded due to the corrosion of control rods. A total of 1,800 man hours were expended to bring each aircraft to full operational capacity.[1] Stress corrosion eventually forced the retirement of ANG F-84Fs in 1971.

On 9 March 1955, Lt. Col. Robert R. Scott, in a F-84F Thunderstreak, set a three-hour, 44-minute and 53-second record for the 2446miles flight from Los Angeles to New York.[4]

With the appearance of the Republic F-105 Thunderchief, which used wing-root mounted air intakes of a similar design to those fitted on the RF-84F, the photorecon variant Thunderflash became known as the Thud's Mother.[3] The earlier F-84A had been nicknamed the "Hog" and the F-84F "Super Hog," the F-105 becoming the "Ultra Hog".

In what is probably one of the very few air-to-air engagements involving the F-84F, two Turkish Air Force F-84F Thunderstreaks shot down two Iraqi Il-28 Beagle bombers that crossed the Turkish border by mistake during a bombing operation against Iraqi Kurdish insurgents. This engagement took place on 16 August 1962.[5]

The F-84F was retired from active service with the USAF in 1964, and replaced by the North American F-100 Super Sabre. The RF-84F was replaced by the RF-101 Voodoo in USAF units, and relegated to duty in the Air National Guard. The last RF-84F Thunderflash retired from the ANG in 1971. Three Hellenic Air Force RF-84Fs that were retired in 1991 were the last operational F-84s.

Variants

YF-84F: Two swept-wing prototypes of the F-84F, initially designated YF-96.
  • F-84F Thunderstreak: Swept wing version with Wright J65 engine. Tactical Air Command aircraft were equipped with Low-Altitude Bombing System (LABS) for delivering nuclear bombs. 2,711 built, 1,301 went to NATO under Mutual Defense Assistance Program (MDAP).
  • GRF-84F:25 RF-84Fs were converted to be carried, and launched from the bomb bay of a GRB-36F bomber as part of the FICON project. The aircraft were later redesignated RF-84K.
  • RF-84F Thunderflash:Reconnaissance version of the F-84F with intakes relocated to the wing-roots, 715 built.
  • RF-84K Thunderflash (FICON): RF-84F with a retractable probe for hookup with carrier GRB-36Ds and tailplanes with marked anhedral, 25 redesignated from RF-84F.[6]
  • XF-84H
  • Two F-84Fs were converted into experimental aircraft. Each was fitted with an Allison XT40-A-1 turboprop engine of 5,850 shaft horsepower (4,365 kW) driving a supersonic propeller. Ground crews dubbed the XF-84H the Thunderscreech due to its extreme noise output.[1]
    YF-84J: Two F-84Fs were converted into YF-84J prototypes with enlarged nose intakes and a deepened fuselages for the General Electric J73 engine; the YF-84J reached Mach 1.09 in level flight on 7 April 1954.[1] The project was cancelled due to the excessive cost of converting existent F-84Fs.

    Operators

    Aircraft on display

    Belgium

    F-84F Thunderstreak
    RF-84F Thunderflash

    Denmark

    RF-84F

    France

    F-84F

    Germany

    F-84F Thunderstreak
    RF-84F Thunderflash

    Greece

    F-84F Thunderstreak
    RF-84F Thunderflash
    F-84F Thunderstreak

    Italy

    F-84F
    RF-84F Thunderflash

    Netherlands

    F-84F
    RF-84F

    Norway

    RF-84F Thunderflash

    Poland

    F-84F

    Russia

    F-84F

    Turkey

    F-84F
    RF-84F

    United Kingdom

    F-84F

    United States

    XF-84F
    F-84F
    RF-84F Thunderflash

    Accidents and incidents

    Specifications (F-84F)

    Communications Equipment

    Notable appearances in media

    Richard Bach, who later wrote the bestseller Jonathan Livingston Seagull, was an ANG F-84F pilot who was once activated for duty in Europe. His first book, Stranger to the Ground, described in detail what it was like to fly the Thunderstreak in the course of an operational flight at night from England to France in adverse weather.

    F-84Fs were also used to represent North Korean MiG-15 fighters in the 1958 film version of James Salters' novel "The Hunters", because none of the Soviet fighters were available during the ongoing Cold War for filming. They were painted a flat gray with red star insignia.

    References

    Bibliography

    External links

    Notes and References

    1. Knaack 1978, p. 42.
    2. Web site: Chronology: 1950-1959 . Air Force Magazine . Air Force Association . 29 January 2022 . 24 November 2018.
    3. Higham, Robin and Carol Williams. Flying Combat Aircraft of USAAF-USAF (Vol.2). Rockville, Maryland: Air Force Historical Foundation, 1978. .
    4. Web site: Week In History. U.S. Air Force. 4 March 2013. https://archive.today/20120723151316/http://www.af.mil/information/heritage/weekinhistory.asp. 23 July 2012. dead.
    5. Cooper, Tom. "Europe & Cold War Database: Cyprus, 1955–1973." Air Combat Information Group, 26 October 2003. Retrieved: 8 September 2009.
    6. Book: Knaack, Marcelle Size. Encyclopedia of US Air Force Aircraft and Missile Systems. 2, Post-World War II Bombers 1945–1973. 1988 . Office of Air Force History. Washington, DC. 0-912799-59-5 . 38–39.
    7. Stafrace 2014, pp. 32–33.
    8. Schrøder, Hans (1991). "Royal Danish Airforce". Ed. Kay S. Nielsen. Tøjhusmuseet, 1991, p. 62. .
    9. Stafrace 2014, p. 37.
    10. Stafrace 2014, p. 42.
    11. Stafrace 2014, p. 47.
    12. Web site: Suez War: Israel Air Force--IAF (1956). 23 October 2021.
    13. Web site: Italian Air Force Aircraft Types. www.aeroflight.co.uk.
    14. Web site: Republic F-84 . Aeronautica Militare . 31 May 2019.
    15. Web site: Republic RF 84F . Aeronautica Militare . 31 May 2019.
    16. Stafrace 2014, p. 67.
    17. Web site: Republic F-84F Thundertreak FU-197 – Hangar Flying. www.luchtvaarterfgoed.be. 2016-10-16. 2017-08-07. https://web.archive.org/web/20170807022226/http://www.luchtvaarterfgoed.be/content/republic-f-84f-thundertreak-fu-197. dead.
    18. Web site: Republic F-84F Thunderstreak . 2023-09-26 . Belgian Wings . en.
    19. Web site: Republic F-84F Thunderstreak . 2023-09-26 . Belgian Wings . en.
    20. Web site: Poortwachter Thunderstreak FU177 – Hangar Flying. www.luchtvaarterfgoed.be. 2016-10-16. 2017-08-06. https://web.archive.org/web/20170806222309/http://www.luchtvaarterfgoed.be/content/poortwachter-thunderstreak-fu177. dead.
    21. Web site: FR-27 | Republic RF-84F Thunderflash | Belgium - Air Force | Sotos.
    22. Web site: Flystation Karup HIstoriske Forening Museet. 10 January 2016. en. 23 June 2016.
    23. Web site: Danmarks Flymuseum. 10 January 2016. en. 23 June 2016.
    24. Web site: Εκθέματα Εντός του Υποστέγου ΛΕΡΟΣ - Πολεμική Αεροπορία. Πολεμική. Αεροπορία. haf.gr.
    25. http://stanakshot.free.fr/photos/Grece-air-force/Republic-F-84F-Thunderstreak/10193 Republic F-84F Thunderstreak (37050/050) - Grèce airforce
    26. Web site: Museo Storico Aeronautica Militare: Republic F-84F . aeronautica.difesa.it . 10 February 2021.
    27. Web site: Catalogo collezioni - Aeroplano Republic F-84F Thunderstreak - museoscienza. www.museoscienza.org. 2019-01-29.
    28. Web site: Museo Storico Aeronautica Militare: Republic RF-84F . aeronautica.difesa.it . 10 February 2021.
    29. Web site: Republic F-84F 'Thunderstreak' P-134.
    30. Web site: Jachtbommenwerper Republic F-84F 'Thunderstreak' registratienummer P-254.
    31. Web site: Jachtbommenwerper Republic F-84F 'Thunderstreak' registratienummer P-226.
    32. Web site: Verkenningsvliegtuig Republic RF-84F 'Thunderflash' registratie TP-19.
    33. http://aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=11084 "RF-84F Thunderflash/51-17045."
    34. http://aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=12108 "RF-84F Thunderflash/51-17053."
    35. http://www.skrzydla.org/showphoto.php?photo_id=24209 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-7157."
    36. Web site: Republic F-84F Thunderstreak Aviation Photos – Planespotters.net Just Aviation. www.planespotters.net.
    37. Web site: Bursa Uludağ Üniversitesi.
    38. Web site: www.tayyareci.com REPUBLIC RF-84F THUNDERFLASH .. 1951 - 2006 Period TUAF AIRCRAFT 1951 - 2006 dönemi Turk HvKK UCAKLARI. Webmaster:Celal. UZAR. www.tayyareci.com.
    39. http://www.nelsam.org.uk/NEAM/Exhibits/History/26541.htm "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6541."
    40. 'Streak to Bentwaters . . November 2019 . 47 . 11 . 12 . 0143-7240.
    41. https://web.archive.org/web/20130404154449/http://www.nationalmuseum.af.mil/factsheets/factsheet.asp?id=587 "F-84 Thunderstreak/49-2430."
    42. https://www.flickr.com/photos/alan15108/4637693450/lightbox/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/unknown."
    43. http://barksdaleglobalpowermuseum.com/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1386."
    44. http://www.esam.org/images/F-84%20Photo3.JPG "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1620."
    45. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=10750 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1639."
    46. http://www.hill.af.mil/library/factsheets/factsheet.asp?id=5701 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1640."
    47. Web site: Republic F84. 2021-06-04. www.combatairmuseum.org.
    48. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=4032 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1713."
    49. http://www.sasmuseum.com/aircraft/f-84f-thunderstreak/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1714."
    50. http://www.coastcomp.com/av/pres/oldafjet.htm "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1739."
    51. http://www.aerospaceca.org/republic-f-84f-thunderstreak/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1772."
    52. http://www.vasc.org/visit/exhibits/aircraft "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1786."
    53. http://aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=3392 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1797."
    54. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=1721 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1817."
    55. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/AirframeDossier.php?Serial=82380 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1818."
    56. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2451 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-1822."
    57. http://afftcmuseum.org/exhibits/museum-aircraft-exhibits/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9350."
    58. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=3080 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9396."
    59. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=3054 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9430."
    60. http://www.marchfield.org/aircraft-exhibits/aircraft/f-84f-thunderstreak-republic/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9432."
    61. http://www.castleairmuseum.org/ondisplay "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9433."
    62. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2553 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9444."
    63. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2402 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9451."
    64. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/AirframeDossier.php?Serial=13959 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9480."
    65. http://www.afarmamentmuseum.com/outside.shtml "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9495."
    66. http://www.yankeeairmuseum.org/adopt-a-plane/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9501."
    67. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2481 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9514."
    68. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/AirframeDossier.php?Serial=1011 "F-84 Thunderstreak/51-9522."
    69. Web site: USAF Serial Number Search (51-9531). 2018-02-14.
    70. Web site: Aerial Visuals Airframe Dossier (51-9531). 2018-03-11.
    71. Web site: vfw post 2503 – Omaha, Nebraska. 2021-04-19. en-US.
    72. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2259 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6438."
    73. http://www.legion490.com/our%20F-84F.htm "Our F-84F"
    74. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=5654 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6456."
    75. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/AirframeDossier.php?Serial=84360 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6461."
    76. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2332 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6470."
    77. Web site: Airframe Dossier - Republic F-84F-35-RE Thunderstreak, s/n 52-6476 USAF . Aerial Visuals . 14 November 2023.
    78. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2561 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6497."
    79. https://web.archive.org/web/20130423152302/http://www.nationalmuseum.af.mil/factsheets/factsheet.asp?id=375 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6526."
    80. http://dumasmuseumandartcenter.org/lawnmower%20races.jpg "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6553."
    81. https://wingsoffreedommuseum.org/wp/aircraft/republic-f-84f-thunderstreak/ "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6555."
    82. http://www.pimaair.org/visit/aircraft-by-name/item/republic-f-84f-thunderstreak "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6563."
    83. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=3955 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6634."
    84. http://www.museumofaviation.org/F84F.php "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6701."
    85. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=1642 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6782."
    86. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/AirframeDossier.php?Serial=72268 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-6993."
    87. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=4102 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-7019."
    88. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=2663 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-7080."
    89. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=3958 "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-8837."
    90. http://www.sdairandspacemuseum.com/exhibits "F-84 Thunderstreak/52-8886."
    91. Web site: Republic F-84 .
    92. https://www.airport-data.com/aircraft/51-1929.html "Aircraft 51-1929 Data".
    93. http://www.pimaair.org/visit/aircraft-by-name/item/republic-rf-84f-thunderflash "RF-84 Thunderflash/51-1944."
    94. https://www.skytamer.com/6.1.USA.Iowa.htm "Republic RF-84F Thunderflash #51-1948."
    95. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=3000 "RF-84 Thunderflash/51-11259."
    96. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=1570 "RF-84 Thunderflash/52-7249."
    97. https://web.archive.org/web/20130404160252/http://www.nationalmuseum.af.mil/factsheets/factsheet.asp?id=4659 "RF-84 Thunderflash/52-7259."
    98. http://planesoffame.org/index.php?page=81&itemsperpage=All "RF-84 Thunderflash/52-7265."
    99. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=1528 "RF-84 Thunderflash/52-7409."
    100. http://www.yankeeairmuseum.org/adopt-a-plane/ "RF-84 Thunderflash/52-7421."
    101. https://www.aerialvisuals.ca/LocationDossier.php?Serial=3683 "RF-84 Thunderflash/53-7529"
    102. http://www.aerialvisuals.ca/AirframeDossier.php?Serial=14213 "RF-84 Thunderflash/53-7595."
    103. Kansas City Star, Main Edition, Pg. 1, July 7, 1954
    104. Web site: Finn Erik Andersen . Flyhistorisk Museum Sola . 30 July 2023 . nn-NO . 14 May 2020.
    105. Web site: Eirik . Veum . Disse norske pilotene omkom . NRK . 30 July 2023 . nb-NO . 29 March 2014.
    106. Web site: Twitter report of wreckage in 2023. Twitter . 30 July 2023 . en.
    107. Web site: Straaljager stortte neer: 7 doden . 22 November 1960. leiden.courant.nu . Leidsch Dagblad. 1. nl.
    108. http://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/print/d-45139958.html "Strauss-Befehl: Bier-Order 61".