Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Ordinance 2021 explained

Short Title:Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Ordinance 2021
Legislature:Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Long Title:An Ordinance to amend the Interpretation and General Clauses Ordinance to explain the meaning of a reference to upholding the Basic Law and bearing allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China; to amend the Oaths and Declarations Ordinance to include in Part IV of the Ordinance an oath to be taken by every member of the District Councils, the requirements for taking the oaths specified in that Part and the consequences of declining or neglecting to take an oath; to amend the Legislative Council Ordinance and the District Councils Ordinance to add new grounds for disqualification from being nominated as a candidate for election as a member of the Legislative Council or as a member of a District Council and for disqualification from being elected, and from holding office, as such a member, to remove the time limit within which proceedings may be brought by the Secretary for Justice against a person on the ground of disqualification from acting as such a member and to provide for suspension of functions and duties of such a member on certain of such proceedings being brought by the Secretary for Justice; to amend the Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal Ordinance to provide for application for leave to appeal to the Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal in relation to such proceedings; to amend the Chief Executive Election Ordinance to add new grounds for disqualification from being nominated as a candidate for election of the Chief Executive and from being elected as the Chief Executive; to amend the National Anthem Ordinance to add the oath-taking ceremony by members of the District Councils as an occasion on which the national anthem must be played and sung; and to provide for related matters.[1]
Citation:Ordinance 13 of 2021
Territorial Extent:Hong Kong
Enacted By:Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Bill:Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2021
Introduced By:Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Erick Tsang
Amends:Interpretation and General Clauses Ordinance
Oaths and Declarations Ordinance
Interpretation and General Clauses Ordinance
Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal Ordinance
Legislative Council Ordinance
District Councils Ordinance
Chief Executive Election Ordinance
National Anthem Ordinance
High Court Ordinance
Electoral Affairs Commission Ordinance
Status:in force

The Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Ordinance 2021 is an ordinance to amend the Oaths and Declarations Ordinance and other relating legislation which adds new requirements for the Chief Executive, Executive Council members, Legislative Council members and judges and other judicial officers, imposes oath-taking requirements on District Council members, and specifies requirements for candidates to swear to uphold the Basic Law and bear allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region when assuming office or standing for election and also adds new grounds and mechanism for disqualification from holding the office or being nominated as a candidate.[1] The ordinance was seen as another round of the Beijing authorities to bar the opposition from standing in elections or holding public offices and also raised concerns on the bill's vague parameters of the oath with such over-reaching scope would undermine Hong Kong's judicial independence.

Background

Article 104 of the Basic Law of Hong Kong and the Oaths and Declarations Ordinance originally stated that five categories of public officers, Chief Executive, principal officials, members of the Executive Council and of the Legislative Council, judges of the courts at all levels and other members of the judiciary must "swear to uphold the Basic Law of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China and swear allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China" when assuming office.[2] However, penalty for violating the oath was not specified in the laws, and the District Councillors were not included in the categories.

In the 2016 New Territories East by-election for the Legislative Council, pro-independence activist Edward Leung ran for the office and fared a better-than-expected result by obtaining more than 15 per cent of the popular vote. In the following general election in September, the returning officers unprecedentedly invalidated Edward Leung and five other localists' nominations for their pro-independence inclination.[3] The decision was challenged by the leading lawyers in Hong Kong, who questioned whether returning officers had the power to investigate the "genuineness" of candidates' declarations and accordingly disqualify their candidacies. In their joint statement, it wrote that "[the Section 40 of the Legislative Council Ordinance] does not give the returning officer any power to inquire into the so-called genuineness of the candidates' declarations, let alone making a subjective and political decision to disqualify a candidate without following any due process on the purported ground that the candidate will not genuinely uphold the Basic Law." It also wrote that "arbitrary and unlawful exercise of powers by government officials ... are most damaging to the rule of law in Hong Kong."[4]

In the end, there were still six localist camp candidates who ran on the "right to self-determination" of Hong Kong got elected with 19 per cent of total vote share. Two localist legislators-elect, Baggio Leung and Yau Wai-ching of Youngspiration used the largely ritual oath-taking ceremony on the inaugural meeting of the Legislative Council on 12 October 2016 to protest, asserting "as a member of the Legislative Council, I shall pay earnest efforts in keeping guard over the interests of the Hong Kong nation," displayed a "Hong Kong is not China" banner, and mispronounced "People's Republic of China" as "people's re-fucking of Chee-na". As a result, Leung and Yau, as well as some other pro-democrats' oaths were invalidated by the Legislative Council President Andrew Leung. Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying and Secretary for Justice Rimsky Yuen also launched a judicial review against the duo. On 7 November 2016, the National People's Congress Standing Committee (NPCSC) controversially interpreted Article 104 of the Basic Law of Hong Kong to "clarify" the requirements that the legislators need to swear allegiance to Hong Kong as part of China when they take office, stating that a person "who intentionally reads out words which do not accord with the wording of the oath prescribed by law, or takes the oath in a manner which is not sincere or not solemn"[5] should be barred from taking their public office and cannot retake the oath. As a result, Baggio Leung and Yau Wai-ching were unseated by the court, followed by four other opposition legislators, Leung Kwok-hung, Nathan Law, Lau Siu-lai and Yiu Chung-yim who were also disqualified for their oath-taking manner on 14 July 2017.

Another wave of disqualification of opposition candidates occurred in the subsequently postponed 2020 Legislative Council election, where 12 opposition candidates including four incumbent legislators Alvin Yeung, Kwok Ka-ki, Dennis Kwok and Kenneth Leung and also four incumbent District Councillors Tiffany Yuen, Lester Shum, Fergus Leung and Cheng Tat-hung were also barred from running. Despite Chief Executive Carrie Lam's reassurance on the four incumbent legislators' eligibility to serve in the extended Legislative Council term, the National People Congress Standing Committee (NPCSC) on 11 November 2020 ruled in a decision which barred Legislative Council members from supporting Hong Kong independence, refusing to recognise Beijing's sovereignty over Hong Kong, seeking help from "foreign countries or foreign forces to interfere in the affairs of the region" or committing "other acts that endanger national security", targeting the four sitting legislators. On the same day, the SAR administration announced that four legislators had been stripped of their seats with immediate effect.[6] In response, the 15 remaining pro-democracy legislators announced they would resign en masse in solidarity with the disqualified members, leaving the legislature with virtually no opposition.[7]

On 30 June 2020, the National People Congress Standing Committee (NPCSC) imposed the national security law on Hong Kong, which stipulates that a candidate who stands for election or assumes public office shall confirm in writing or take an oath to uphold the Basic Law and swear allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region in accordance with the law besides other new restrictions,[2] which required the amendment to the existing local legislation to implement the new requirements imposed by the NPCSC.

Contents

According to the government's press release, the bill mainly comprises the following six key areas of amendments which seek to:[2]

  1. amend the Interpretation and General Clauses Ordinance to add the legal requirements and conditions of "upholding the Basic Law and bearing allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region" with reference to the 2016 NPCSC Interpretation, the national security law and the 11 November 2020 NPCSC's "Decision on Issues Relating to the Qualification of the Members of the Legislative Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region";
  2. impose an oath-taking requirement for District Council members which would be required with the same criteria as other public officers under Article 104 of the Basic Law;
  3. lay out the concrete oath-taking requirements in the Oaths and Declarations Ordinance, including that the oath-taking should comply with the oath-taking procedure and ceremony; an oath taker who intentionally reads out words which do not accord with the wording of the oath prescribed by law, or takes the oath in a manner which is not sincere or not solemn, shall be treated as declining to take the oath. The oath so taken is invalid and the oath taker is disqualified forthwith from assuming the public office;
  4. specify the arrangement of the oath administrator by standardising the arrangement for the Chief Executive or a person authorised by the Chief Executive to administer the oaths for Executive Council members, Legislative Council members, judges and other judicial officers, and District Council members;
  5. amend the Legislative Council Ordinance and the District Councils Ordinance to specify that a person who has breached an oath, or failed to fulfil the legal requirements and conditions on upholding the Basic Law and bearing allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region will be disqualified from holding the office; and provide for the mechanism in case of such a breach or failure; and
  6. introduce restriction in Chief Executive, Legislative Council and District Council elections such that persons who have been disqualified from entering on an office for declining or neglecting to take an oath, breached an oath or failed to fulfill the legal requirements and conditions on "upholding the Basic Law and bearing allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region", would be disqualified from being nominated or elected in the relevant elections held within five years.

Concerns

Some concerns regarded the "negative list" which proscribed unpatriotic acts in the bill was far too vague and could put judges and politicians under intense pressure if their rulings or voting patterns were viewed as challenging the government. The bill intended to include the community-level District Councilors to be scrutinised for their oath-taking manners, was expected to pave the way for mass disqualification of the pro-democracy councillors who humiliated Beijing when they won District Council election by a landslide in 2019 amid the historic anti-government protests. The ranks of judges in Hong Kong, including leading foreign jurists, must also take oaths to Hong Kong under long-standing requirements, would also come under the new layer of outside political scrutiny. "These references are extremely vague and it creates more possible complications for how the judiciary itself has to regulate judges against these new standards," University of Hong Kong law professor Simon Young said. "There is still time to clarify things... the point is we should not be defining these specific parameters of the oath in such vague ways with such over-reaching scope that it could undermine judicial independence."[8]

Passage

The Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2021 was passed by a 40-to-1 vote in the pro-Beijing-dominated legislature on 12 May 2021, with Civic Passion's Cheng Chung-tai the only one voted against.[9] Chief Executive Carrie Lam on 20 May signed the bill into the law which came into effect after it is published in the Gazette on 21 May.[10]

Effects

Resignations

In the past six months before the bill passage, dozens of opposition District Councillors resigned for refusal to take an oath under the new law.[11] In early July 2021, the government reportedly considered banning 230 councillors to take oath of office and would ask them return their accrued salaries which worth around a million dollars. Such reports triggered a mass resignation of more than 260 councillors, while eight other had been unseated as they were in custody or had left the city.[12]

DistrictConstituencyNamePolitical affiliationTerm EndNotes
Central and WesternMid Levels EastNg Siu-hong1 May 2021Personal reasons
Castle RoadCheng Lai-king9 July 2021
UniversityCamille Yam Ka-yi12 July 2021
Kennedy Town & Mount DavisCherry Wong Kin-ching (previously Civic)4 June 2021Personal reasons
Shek Tong TsuiSam Yip Kam-lung8 July 2021
Sai Ying PunWong Weng-chi11 July 2021
Sheung WanKam Nai-wai8 July 2021
Tung WahBonnie Ng Hoi-yan9 July 2021
Centre StreetCheung Kai-yin9 July 2021
Water StreetHo Chi-wang27 May 2021Personal reasons
Wan ChaiOi KwanLaw Wai-shan9 July 2021
Canal RoadMak King-sing9 July 2021
Causeway BayCathy Yau Man-shan9 July 2021
Victoria ParkLi Wing-choi9 July 2021
Tin HauChan Yuk-lam9 July 2021
Happy ValleyClara Cheung8 July 2021
EasternTai Koo Shing WestAndrew Chiu Ka-yin/PC8 July 2021
Tai Koo Shing EastPatrick Wong Chun-sing8 July 2021
Sai Wan HoMak Tak-ching9 July 2021
A Kung NgamKwok Chi-chung9 July 2021
Heng Fa ChuenChristine Wong Yi1 April 2021Personal reasons
Tsui WanKu Kwai-yiu15 July 2021
Yan LamAlice Ishigami Lee Fung-king11 July 2021
King YeePhoenix Tsang Yan-ying1 June 2021
Wan TsuiPeter Ng Cheuk-ip10 July 2021
Fei TsuiJoseph Lai Chi-keong9 July 2021
Fortress HillJason Chan Ka-yau1 June 2021Protest against oath-taking
Fort StreetKarrine Fu Kai-lam1 June 2021Protest against oath-taking
Kam PingLee Yue-shun (previously Civic)1 September 2021Personal reasons
TannerTat Cheng Tat-hung (previously Civic)11 May 2021Personal reasons
Healthy VillageJames Pui Chi-lap9 July 2021
Quarry BayKelly Chan Po-king8 July 2021
Nam FungCheung Kwok-cheong15 July 2021
KornhillDerek Ngai Chi-ho10 July 2021
Kornhill GardenLeung Siu-sun9 July 2021
Hing TungCheung Chun-kit8 July 2021
Lower Yiu TungHo Wai-lun9 July 2021
Hing ManTse Miu-yee11 July 2021
Lok HongBull Tsang Kin-shing8 July 2021
SouthernAberdeenAngus Wong Yui-hei9 July 2021
Ap Lei Chau NorthChan Ping-yeung9 July 2021
Lei Tung IChan Yan-yi9 July 2021
Lei Tung IILo Kin-hei11 July 2021
South Horizons EastJames Yu Chun-hei (previously Civic)9 July 2021
South Horizons WestKelvin Lam Ho-por11 July 2021
Wah KwaiPoon Ping-hong9 July 2021
Wah Fu SouthLi Shee-lin9 July 2021
Wah Fu NorthYim Chun-ho9 July 2021
Chi FuAndrew Lam Tak-wo10 July 2021
Shek YueChan Hin-chung9 July 2021
Wong Chuk HangTsui Yuen-wa9 July 2021
Yau Tsim MongTsim Sha Tsui WestLeslie Chan Ka-long16 July 2021
Jordan WestNatalie Tsui Wai-fong9 July 2021
Fu PakYu Tak-po (previously Civic)11 July 2021
Tai Kok Tsui NorthOwan Li9 July 2021
Tai NanLee Kwok-kuen8 July 2021
Mong Kok NorthLucifer Siu Tak-kin10 July 2021
Mong Kok EastBen Lam Siu-pan9 July 2021
Jordan SouthChan Tsz-wai12 July 2021
Tsim Sha Tsui CentralHo Cheuk-hin8 July 2021
Sham Shui PoNam Cheong NorthLao Ka-hang (previously Civic)12 July 2021
Shek Kip MeiJeffrey Sin Kam-ho9 July 2021
Nam Cheong EastKalvin Ho Kai-ming12 July 2021
Nam Cheong WestWai Woon-nam8 July 2021
Fu CheongWong Kit-long8 July 2021
Lai KokLi Kwing8 July 2021
FortuneRonald Tsui Yat-hin9 July 2021
Pik WuiZoe Chow Wing-heng8 July 2021
Lai Chi Kok SouthYeung Yuk9 July 2021
Mei Foo SouthChau Yuen-man1 June 2021Personal reasons
Mei Foo NorthJoshua Li Chun-hei (previously Civic)8 July 2021
Un ChauLee Hon-ting8 July 2021
Lei Cheng UkKong Kwai-sang9 July 2021
Ha Pak TinYan Kai-wing9 July 2021
Nam Shan, Tai Hang Tung & Tai Hang SaiTam Kwok-kiu8 July 2021
Kowloon CityMa Hang ChungLai Kwong-wai9 July 2021
Ma Tau KokMa Hei-pang9 July 2021
Sheung LokWong Wing-kit11 July 2021
Ho Man TinJoshua Fung Man-tao9 July 2021
KadoorieSiu Leong-sing9 July 2021
Whampoa EastKwan Ka-lun8 July 2021
Whampoa WestKwong Po-yin8 July 2021
Ka WaiChau Hei-man12 July 2021
Oi ManMak Sui-ki11 July 2021
Wong Tai SinLung TsuiChong Ting-wai11 July 2021
Lung HaKwok Sau-ying10 July 2021
Lung SheungChan Chun-yue11 July 2021
Fung WongTang Wai-keung9 July 2021
Fung TakCheung Ka-yi11 July 2021
San Po KongChan Kai-shun8 July 2021
Tung TauHiroko Wan Chi-chung13 July 2021
Tung MeiSze Tak-loy9 July 2021
Lok FuLeung Ming-hong8 July 2021
Wang Tau HomCarmen Lau Ka-man9 June 2021Protest against oath-taking
Tin KeungJay Cheng Man-kit (previously Civic)9 July 2021
Tsui Chuk & Pang ChingYau Hon-pong9 July 2021
Chuk Yuen SouthHui Kam-shing8 July 2021
Chuk Yuen NorthCheng Tsz-kin1 June 2021Protest against political change
Tsz Wan WestCheung Mau-ching10 July 2021
Ching OiSham Yu-hin11 July 2021
Ching OnRoger Wong Yat-yuk8 July 2021
Tsz Wan EastMok Yee-ha10 July 2021
King FuRosanda Mok Ka-han9 July 2021
Choi Wan SouthShum Wan-wa9 July 2021
Choi Wan WestChan Lee-shing9 July 2021
Chi ChoiWu Chi-kin10 July 2021
Kwun TongKai YipWan Ka-him9 July 2021
Lai ChingSheik Anthony Bux1 June 2021Personal reasons
Shun TinMok Kin-shing20 July 2021
On LeeChoy Chak-hung20 July 2021
Sau Mau Ping NorthRaymond Tang Wai-man12 July 2021
Po TatFung Ka-lung9 July 2021
Hing TinNelson Ip Tsz-kit10 July 2021
Ping TinEason Chan Yik-shun12 July 2021
Pak NgaChan Man-kin10 July 2021
Yau Tong EastKung Chun-ki19 July 2021
Yau LaiWang Wai-lun18 July 2021
Laguna CityWilliam Li Wai-lam (previously Civic)12 July 2021
King TinWong Ka-ying (previously Civic)11 July 2021
Hiu LaiWilson Cheung Man-fung18 July 2021
Po LokCheng Keng-ieong9 July 2021
Yuet WahJannelle Rosalynne Leung10 July 2021
Lok Wah NorthWong Chi-ken20 July 2021
Hong LokChris Chan Ka-yin1 June 2021Personal reasons
Ting OnWong Kai-ming10 July 2021
Lower Ngau Tau Kok EstateLi Wing-shan9 July 2021
To TaiLee Kwan-chak (previously Civic)11 July 2021
Tsuen WanTak WahJackson Lau11 July 2021
Tsuen Wan WestAngus Yick Shing-chung11 July 2021
Clague GardenChan Kim-kam12 July 2021
Luk YeungRoy Pun Long-chung (previously Neo Democrats)8 July 2021
Tsuen Wan RuralNorris Ng Hin-lung9 July 2021
Ting ShamLau Chi-hung9 July 2021
Lai ToRonald Tse Man-chak9 July 2021
AllwayChiu Yan-loy18 July 2021
Cheung ShekMatthew Lai Man-fai13 July 2021
Tuen MunTuen Mun Town CentreAlfred Lai Chun-wing7 July 2021
Siu TsuiYan Pui-lam (previously Team Chu)8 July 2021
Yau Oi SouthLam Kin-cheung8 July 2021
Yau Oi NorthLam Ming-yan8 July 2021
Hing TsakTsang Chun-hing10 July 2021
So Kwun WatMa Kee1 June 2021
Sam ShingMichael Mo Kwan-tai9 July 2021
HanfordBeatrice Chu Shun-nga9 July 2021
ButterflyYeung Chi-hang9 July 2021
Lok TsuiLo Chun-yu8 July 2021
San KingCatherine Wong Lai-sheung8 July 2021
Kin SangLaw Pei-lee (previously Team Chu)9 July 2021
Siu HongJosephine Chan Shu-ying7 July 2021
Fu TaiHo Kwok-ho9 July 2021
Prime ViewHo Hang-mui8 July 2021
Yuen LongFung NinKisslan Chan King-lun15 July 2021
Yuen Long CentreShek King-ching13 July 2021
Fung CheungMak Ip-sing13 July 2021
Yuen LungCheung Sau-yin22 October 2021Personal reasons
Shap Pat Heung CentralWillis Fong Ho-hin9 July 2021
Yuen Long Tung TauLam Ting-wai13 July 2021
Shap Pat Heung EastLee Chun-wai12 July 2021
Shap Pat Heung WestSzeto Pok-man1 June 2021Personal reasons
Ping Shan SouthLeung Tak-ming (previously Team Chu)8 July 2021
Hung FukEddie Chan Shu-fai (previously Team Chu)8 July 2021
Shing YanAu Kwok-kuen (previously Team Chu)8 July 2021
Tin ShingHau Man-kin8 July 2021
Tin YiuHo Wai-pan14 July 2021
Kingswood SouthKaty Ng Yuk-ying13 July 2021
Shui WahLam Chun8 July 2021
Yuet YanHong Chin-wah14 July 2021
Ching KingKwok Man-ho11 July 2021
Fu YanKwan Chun-sang9 July 2021
Yat ChakWong Wing-sze3 September 2021Party dissolved
Wang YatMo Kai-hong12 July 2021
Fairview ParkTo Ka-lun1 May 2021
NorthCheung WahChan Yuk-ming8 July 2021
Wah MingChan Wai-tat (previously Neo Democrats)8 July 2021
Yan ShingLam Shuk-ching1 June 2021Protest against oath-taking
Fanling SouthFranco Cheung Ching-ho9 July 2021
Ching HoYuen Ho-lun1 June 2021Protest against oath-taking
Yu TaiVincent Chan Chi-fung12 July 2021
Choi YuenLam Tsz-king8 July 2021
Tin Ping WestKwok Long-fung11 July 2021
Fung TsuiChiang Man-ching8 July 2021
Tin Ping EastLau Ki-fung (previously Neo Democrats)8 July 2021Personal reasons
Tai PoTai Po HuiNick Lam Ming-yat12 May 2021Personal reasons
Chung TingMan Nim-chi13 July 2021
Tai Po CentralRay Au Chun-wah/TPDA21 July 2021
Yee FuYam Kai-bong (previously Neo Democrats)8 July 2021
Fu Ming SunKwan Wing-yip (previously Neo Democrats)8 July 2021
Kwong Fuk & Plover CoveDalu Lin Kok-cheung11 May 2021Protest against political change
Wan Tau TongWong Siu-kin3 September 2021Party dissolved
San FuMax Wu Yiu-cheong11 May 2021Protest against political change
Po NgaPaul Chow Yuen-wai (previously Neo Democrats)12 July 2021Personal reasons
Hong Lok YuenManson Yiu Yeuk-sang17 May 2021Personal reasons
Sai KungSai Kung CentralZoe Leung Hin-yan10 July 2021
Pak Sha WanStanley Ho Wai-hong/Labour13 July 2021
Sai Kung IslandsDebby Chan Ka-lam12 July 2021
Hang Hau WestYu Tsun-ning30 September 2021Personal reasons
Choi KinChan Wai-lit8 July 2021
Kin MingLeung Li (previously Neo Democrats)1 June 2021Personal reasons
Wai KingBrandon Kenneth Yip11 July 2021
Hoi ChunIvan Lai Wai-tong (previously Neo Democrats)12 July 2021
Po YeeTse Ching-fung13 July 2021
Fu KwanLuk Ping-choi/CA13 July 2021
O TongLui Man-kwong (previously Neo Democrats)13 July 2021
Hong KingFrankie Lam Siu-chung (previously Neo Democrats)12 July 2021
Po LamFung Kwan-on (previously Neo Democrats)9 July 2021
Wai YanChun Hoi-shing (previously Neo Democrats)13 July 2021
King LamCheung Wai-chiu9 July 2021
Tak MingCheng Chung-man13 July 2021
Kwan PoLai Ming-chak1 May 2021Protest against oath-taking
Sha TinLek YuenJimmy Sham Tsz-kit8 July 2021
City OneWong Man-huen4 June 2021Protest against oath-taking
Sha KokBilly Chan Shiu-yeung7 July 2021
Pok HongChiu Chu-pong (previously CST)9 July 2021
Jat ChuenYau Man-chun9 July 2021
Chun FungChan Nok-hang (previously CST)30 September 2021Personal reasons
Sun Tin WaiChing Cheung-ying8 July 2021
Chui TinHui Yui-yu9 July 2021
Hin KaChan Wang-tung8 July 2021
Wan ShingCheung Hing-wa (previously Neo Democrats)8 July 2021
Tin SumTsang Kit (previously CST)15 July 2021
Chui KaLi Sai-hung10 July 2021
Sui WoMak Tsz-kin (previously Civic)11 July 2021
Fo TanLui Kai-wing (previously Civic)15 July 2021
Hoi NamChan Pui-ming2 October 2021Protest against oath-taking
Chung OnYip Wing8 July 2021
Wu Kai ShaLi Wing-shing (previously CST)7 July 2021
Fu LungTsang So-lai9 July 2021
Kam YingTing Tsz-yuen1 June 2021Protest against political change
Tai Shui HangMichael Yung Ming-chau12 July 2021
Yu YanLo Yuet-chau8 July 2021
Bik WooLuk Tsz-tung (previously Civic)12 July 2021
Kwong HongRicardo Liao Pak-hong9 July 2021
Kwong YuenYeung Sze-kin8 July 2021
Kwai TsingKwai LuenNg Kim-sing10 July 2021
Kwai Shing East EstateRayman Chow Wai-hung19 July 2021
Upper Tai Wo HauHui Kei-cheung10 July 2021
Lower Tai Wo HauWong Bing-kuen9 July 2021
Kwai Chung Estate SouthIvan Wong Yun-tat1 June 2021
On YamLeung Wing-kuen10 July 2021
Shek Lei SouthLeung Kwok-wah9 July 2021
Lai WahSteve Cheung Kwan-kiu (previously Civic)8 July 2021
Cho YiuChoi Nga-man9 July 2021
Lai KingWong Tin-yan8 July 2021
On HoWarren Tam Ka-chun (previously Civic)12 July 2021
Wai YingHenry Sin Ho-fai (previously Civic)9 July 2021
Tsing Yi EstateWong Pit-man9 July 2021
GreenfieldWong Chun-tat10 July 2021
Cheung ChingNicholas Hon Chun-yin9 July 2021
Ching FatLau Chi-kit12 July 2021
Cheung OnDennis Cheung Man-lung20 July 2021
IslandsTung Chung CentralLee Ka-ho (previously Civic)9 July 2021
Discovery BayAmy Yung Wing-sheung (previously Civic)10 July 2021
Cheung ChauLeung Kwok-ho11 July 2021

Disqualifications

The government began the oath-taking ceremonies for the District Councillors from September 2021, and said it would consider the past conduct of the oath-takers when reviewing whether their pledges of allegiance are sincere.[12] Following four oath-taking ceremonies starting in early September, oaths taken by 49 District Councillors were ruled invalid without any explanation, leaving more than 70 per cent seats in the 18 District Councils vacant. Under the amended Oaths and Declarations Ordinance, the disqualified District Councillors would be banned from standing in elections for the next five years, including former Democratic Legislative Councillor Roy Kwong and James To and some other Democrats who had expressed their interest in running in the upcoming Legislative Council election in December.[13]

DistrictConstituencyNamePolitical affiliationTerm EndNotes
Wan ChaiTai HangClarisse Yeung Suet-ying15 September 2021Oath invalid
Tai Fat HauLeung Pak-kin15 September 2021Oath invalid
EasternLei King WanAlice Wei Siu-lik15 September 2021Oath invalid
Aldrich BaySo Yat-hang15 September 2021Oath invalid
Siu Sai WanChan Wing-tai15 September 2021Oath invalid
Tsui TakPeter Choi Chi-keung10 September 2021Declined oath-taking
Kai HiuLai Tsz-yan15 September 2021Oath invalid
SouthernTin WanTiffany Yuen Ka-wai21 May 2021Requirements not met[14]
Stanley & Shek OMichael Pang Cheuk-kei15 September 2021Oath invalid
Yau Tsim MongYau Ma Tei SouthSuzanne Wu Sui-shan (previously Community March)29 September 2021Oath invalid
OlympicJames To Kun-sun29 September 2021Oath invalid
Tai Kok Tsui SouthTsang Tsz-ming29 September 2021Oath invalid
Mong Kok SouthChu Kong-wai (previously Community March)29 September 2021Oath invalid
Sham Shui PoCheung Sha WanLeos Lee Man-ho (previously CSWCEP)24 September 2021Declined oath-taking
Yau Yat TsuenLau Wai-chung 29 September 2021Oath invalid
Kowloon CityMa Tau WaiTsang Kin-chiu29 September 2021Oath invalid
Hok Yuen Laguna VerdeTony Kwok Tin-lap/PC29 September 2021Oath invalid
Hung Hom BayPius Yum Kwok-tung29 September 2021Oath invalid
Wong Tai SinChoi HungSean Mock Ho-chit29 September 2021Oath invalid
Kwun TongKwun Tong CentralEdith Leung Yik-ting29 September 2021Oath invalid
Tsuen WanYeung Uk RoadLam Sek-tim21 October 2021Oath invalid
Hoi BunLester Shum (previously Team Chu)21 May 2021Requirements not met
Tsuen Wan CentreLi Hung-por21 October 2021Oath invalid
Tuen MunTsui HingPoon Chi-kin (previously TMCN)7 October 2021Declined oath-taking
Fu SunLee Ka-wai17 July 2021Absent meetings
Lung MunTsang Kam-wing21 October 2021Oath invalid
Leung KingWong Tak-yuen (previously TMCN)7 October 2021Declined oath-taking
Tuen Mun RuralKenneth Cheung Kam-hung21 October 2021Oath invalid
Yuen LongShui PinLai Kwok-wing (previously Team Chu)21 October 2021Oath invalid
Nam PingZachary Wong Wai-yin21 October 2021Oath invalid
Pek LongKwong Chun-yu21 October 2021Oath invalid
Ping Shan CentralFelix Cheung Chi-yeung21 October 2021Oath invalid
Yiu YauNg Hin-wang21 October 2021Oath invalid
Shui OiLai Po-wa21 October 2021Oath invalid
Chung WahChan Sze-nga21 October 2021Oath invalid
Chung PakLee Wai-fung21 October 2021Oath invalid
Kam TinChris Li Chung-chi7 October 2021Declined oath-taking
Tai PoLam Tsuen ValleyRichard Chan Chun-chit (previously TPDA)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Tai WoOlive Chan Wai-ka8 October 2021Oath invalid
Shuen WanSo Tat-leung8 October 2021Oath invalid
Sai KungHang Hau EastRyan Lee Yin-ho (previously CGPLTKO)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Sheung TakLee Ka-yui (previously CGPLTKO)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Kwong MingRicky Or Yiu-lam (previously CGPLTKO)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Hau TakWong Cheuk-nga8 October 2021Oath invalid
Sha TinWo Che EstateLi Chi-wang8 October 2021Oath invalid
Yue ShingWilliam Shek (previously CST)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Wong UkLai Tsz-yan (previously CST)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Shui Chuen OLo Tak-ming (previously CST)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Lower Shing MunKen Wong Ho-fung (previously CST)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Keng HauNg Kam-hung (previously CST)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Tai WaiKudama Ng Ting-lam8 October 2021Oath invalid
Chung TinWong Hok-lai (previously CST)8 October 2021Oath invalid
Heng OnCheng Tsuk-man8 October 2021Oath invalid
Kwai TsingHing FongTong Ho-man21 October 2021Oath invalid
Kwai Shing West EstateIvy Leung Ching-shan (previously NWSC)21 October 2021Oath invalid
Tsing Yi SouthDaniel Kwok Tsz-kin7 October 2021Declined oath-taking
IslandsTung Chung SouthSheep Wong Chun-yeung21 October 2021Oath invalid
Tung Chung NorthSammy Tsui Sang-hung21 October 2021Oath invalid

Responses

On 21 October 2021, UK Foreign Secretary Liz Truss issued a statement on the disqualification of District Councillors in Hong Kong, expressing its concern on the disqualifications of 55 District Councillors and resignations of over 250 who were pressured for political reasons. "The Hong Kong SAR Government must uphold freedom of speech and allow the public a genuine choice of political representatives," the statement wrote.[15]

The United States also slammed the mass disqualification. "These retroactive and targeted disqualifications, based on the Hong Kong authorities’ arbitrary determination that these district councillors' loyalty oaths are invalid, prevent people in Hong Kong from participating meaningfully in their own governance," US State Department spokesman Ned Price said on 21 October.[16]

In the 21 October statement, an EU spokesperson said that the expulsions and resignations negate the results of the 2019 District Council election and had weakened Hong Kong's "democratic governance structure". "The protection of civil and political rights in Hong Kong is a fundamental part of the 'One Country, Two Systems' principle, which the EU supports," the spokesperson said. "The EU calls on China to act in accordance with its international commitments and its legal obligations and to respect Hong Kong's high degree of autonomy and rights and freedoms."[16]

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2021. Legislative Council of Hong Kong.
  2. News: Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2021 gazetted today. Hong Kong Government. 26 February 2021.
  3. News: 梁天琦遭選管會 取消參選資格. Stand News. 2 August 2016.
  4. News: Lawyers question power of returning officers to disqualify Hong Kong poll candidates. 3 August 2016. South China Morning Post. Joyce. Ng.
  5. Web site: Interpretation of Article 104 of the Basic Law of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China by the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress. www.elegislation.gov.hk. 2018-01-05.
  6. News: Booted out. 12 November 2020. The Standard.
  7. News: Hong Kong pro-democracy lawmakers resign after China ruling. 12 November 2020. BBC News.
  8. News: Concerns mount that new Hong Kong law on patriotic oaths could trap judges. Reuters. 16 March 2021.
  9. News: HKSAR's legislature requires district councilors to take oath. 13 May 2021. China Daily.
  10. News: CE signs Public Offices (Candidacy and Taking Up Offices) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Ordinance 2021 (with photos). Hong Kong Government. 20 May 2020.
  11. News: 全港區議員快要宣誓 逾30人已辭職或表明拒誓 但民主派主導區議會形勢不變. 2021-05-13. 法廣.
  12. News: Hong Kong's remaining district councillors must take oaths of loyalty to gov't from Fri. 7 September 2021. Hong Kong Free Press.
  13. News: 16 more Hong Kong democratically-elected district councillors ousted over loyalty oaths, as democrats left in the minority. Hong Kong Free Press. 21 October 2021.
  14. News: Axe falls on pro-democracy Hong Kong councillors as law mandating oath of loyalty to gov't enacted. 21 May 2021. Hong Kong Free Press.
  15. News: Hong Kong Councillors: Foreign Secretary's statement. 21 October 2021. UK Government.
  16. News: US, Britain and EU voice objections to Hong Kong's disqualification of opposition district councillors. Owen. Churchill. 21 October 2021. South China Morning Post.