Proto-Uto-Aztecan language explained
Proto-Uto-Aztecan is the hypothetical common ancestor of the Uto-Aztecan languages. Authorities on the history of the language group have usually placed the Proto-Uto-Aztecan homeland in the border region between the United States and Mexico, namely the upland regions of Arizona and New Mexico and the adjacent areas of the Mexican states of Sonora and Chihuahua, roughly corresponding to the Sonoran Desert and the western part of the Chihuahuan Desert. It would have been spoken by Mesolithic foragers in Aridoamerica, about 5,000 years ago.
Homeland
Reconstructions of the botanical vocabulary offer clues to the ecological niche inhabited by the Proto-Uto-Aztecans. Fowler placed the center of Proto-Uto-Aztecan in Central Arizona with northern dialects extending into Nevada and the Mojave desert and southern dialects extending south through the Tepiman corridor into Mexico. The homeland of the Numic languages has been placed in Southern California near Death Valley, and the homeland of the proposed Southern Uto-Aztecan group has been placed on the coast of Sonora.
A contrary proposal suggests the homeland of Proto-Uto-Aztecan to have been much farther to the south; it was published in 2001 by Jane H. Hill, based on her reconstruction of maize-related vocabulary in Proto-Uto-Aztecan. By her theory, the assumed speakers of Proto-Uto-Aztecan were maize cultivators in Mesoamerica, who gradually moved north, bringing maize cultivation with them, during the period of roughly 4,500 to 3,000 years ago. The geographic diffusion of speakers corresponded to the breakup of linguistic unity. The hypothesis has been criticized on several grounds, and it is not generally accepted by Uto-Aztecanists. Using computational phylogenetic methods, Wheeler & Whiteley (2014)[1] also suggest a southern homeland for Proto-Uto-Aztecan in or near the area occupied by historical Cora and some Nahua. Nahuatl forms the most basal clade in Wheeler & Whiteley's (2014) Uto-Aztecan phylogram. A survey of agriculture-related vocabulary by Merrill (2012) found that the agricultural vocabulary can be reconstructed for only Southern Uto-Aztecan. That supports a conclusion that the Proto-Uto-Aztecan speech community did not practice agriculture but adopted it only after entering Mesoamerica from the north.
A more recent proposal from 2014, by David L. Shaul, presents evidence suggesting contact between Proto-Uto-Aztecan and languages of central California, such as Esselen and the Yokutsan languages. That leads Shaul to suggest that Proto-Uto-Aztecan was spoken in California's Central Valley area, and it formed part of an ancient Californian linguistic area.
Phonology
Vowels
Proto-Uto-Aztecan is reconstructed as having an unusual vowel inventory: pronounced as /
/. Langacker (1970) demonstrated that the fifth vowel should be reconstructed as pronounced as /
/ as opposed to pronounced as /
/, and there has been a long-running dispute over the proper reconstruction.
Consonants
pronounced as /
/ and pronounced as /
/ may have actually been pronounced as /
/ and pronounced as /
/, respectively.
Lexicon
The following are selected Proto-Uto-Aztecan reconstructions from Stubbs (2011).[2]
- Abbreviations
- NUA = Northern Uto-Aztecan
- SUA = Southern Uto-Aztecan
gloss | Proto-Uto-Aztecan |
---|
arrow |
|
breast |
|
|
|
claw, nail |
|
cook, boil, bake, roast |
|
cricket |
|
ear | - nakka / *naNkapa (< *na(N)kasapa ?)
|
eye |
|
give |
|
hand, arm |
|
head |
|
heart |
|
heavy | pïttï / *pïttiya / *pïttV’a |
heel | - tanapiCko / *tamukpi’-(ko)
|
horn, antler |
|
house, home | - kanni (NUA) / *kaLi (SUA); *ki
|
husband |
|
liver |
|
lungs |
|
moon |
|
mother | - yï’ï / *yïC / *yïk; *ya...
|
mouth | - tï’na > *tï’ni; *tï’nV-pa > *tï’n-pa > *tïmpa
|
navel |
|
neck |
|
no, not |
|
nose | - yakaC / *ya’ka; *mupiC / *mukpiC
|
|
|
rainbow |
|
road |
|
rock, stone |
|
rot, pus, infection |
|
salt |
|
skunk |
|
sky | NUA *tukuN(-pa) > SUA *tVkpa |
sleep | - ïppïwi / *ïCpïCi / *pïwi; *koci
|
snow |
|
summer | - taCcaC < *tattaC / *taCcaC
|
sun, day |
|
tail |
|
tongue |
|
tooth |
|
urinate |
|
water |
|
what | - han-ta / *hiCta / *hin-ta
|
when |
|
who |
|
wind, blow |
|
winter |
|
wolf |
|
one |
|
two |
|
three |
| |
Sources
- Brown . Cecil H. . Lack of linguistic support for Proto-Uto-Aztecan at 8900 BP (letter) . Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA . 2010 . 107 . 15 . E34; author reply E35–6 . 10.1073/pnas.0914859107 . 20231478 . 2841887. free .
- Caballero. G. . 2011. Behind the Mexican Mountains: Recent Developments and New Directions in Research on Uto-Aztecan Languages. Language and Linguistics Compass. 5. 7. 485–504. 10.1111/j.1749-818x.2011.00287.x.
- Book: Campbell . Lyle . 1997 . American Indian Languages: The Historical Linguistics of Native America. Oxford University Press.
- Book: Campbell, Lyle . 2003 . What drives linguistic diversification and language spread? . Examining the farming/language dispersal hypothesis . Bellwood . Peter . Renfrew . Colin . McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research . Cambridge(U.K.) . 49–63.
- Book: Campbell . Lyle . Poser . William J. . 2008 . Language classification, history and method . Cambridge University Press.
- Cortina-Borja. M. Valiñas-Coalla. L. 1989. Some remarks on Uto-Aztecan Classification. . International Journal of American Linguistics. 55. 2. 214–239. 10.1086/466114. 145309871.
- Cortina-Borja. M.. Stuart-Smith. J.. Valiñas-Coalla. L. . 2002. Multivariate classification methods for lexical and phonological dissimilarities and their application to the Uto-Aztecan family. Journal of Quantitative Linguistics. 9. 2. 97–124. 10.1076/jqul.9.2.97.8485. 205390627.
- Dakin . Karen . Long vowels and morpheme boundaries in Nahuatl and Uto-Aztecan: comments on historical developments . 1996 . Amerindia . 21 . 2020-05-05 . 2018-11-13 . https://web.archive.org/web/20181113061700/https://www.vjf.cnrs.fr/sedyl/amerindia/articles/pdf/A_21_04.pdf . dead .
- Fowler. Catherine S. . 1983. Some lexical clues to Uto-Aztecan prehistory. International Journal of American Linguistics. 49. 3. 224–257. 10.1086/465789. 143511895 .
- Book: Goddard . Ives . Ives . Goddard. Handbook of North American Indians . 17 . 1996. Smithsonian Institution. Washington, D.C.. 1–16. Introduction.
- Book: Haugen, J. D. . 2008. Morphology at the interfaces: reduplication and noun incorporation in Uto-Aztecan. 117. John Benjamins Publishing.
- Heath. J.. 1978. Uto-Aztecan* na-class verbs. International Journal of American Linguistics. 44. 3. 211–222. 10.1086/465546. 16989534.
- Hill. Jane H. . Proto-Uto-Aztecan . American Anthropologist . December 2001 . New Series . 103 . 4 . 913–934. 10.1525/aa.2001.103.4.913 . 684121.
- Hill . Jane H. . 2010 . New evidence for a Mesoamerican homeland for Proto-Uto-Aztecan . PNAS . 107 . 11 . E33; author reply E35–6 . 10.1073/pnas.0914473107 . 20231477 . 2841890. 2010PNAS..107E..33H . free .
- Hill. J. H. . 2011. Subgrouping in Uto-Aztecan. Language Dynamics and Change. 1. 2. 241–278. 10.1163/221058212x643978. Language Dynamics and Change.
- Book: Iannucci, David. 1972. Numic historical phonology. Cornell University PhD dissertation.
- Book: Kaufman . Terrence . Nawa linguistic prehistory . 2001 . Mesoamerican Language Documentation Project . 2020-05-05 . 2016-03-03 . https://web.archive.org/web/20160303175905/http://www.albany.edu/anthro/maldp/papers.htm . dead .
- Book: Kaufman, Terrence . Lyle Campbell . Unpublished manuscript. Comparative Uto-Aztecan Phonology. 1981.
- Kemp . González-Oliver. Malhi. Monroe . Schroeder. McDonough . Rhett. Resendéz. Peñalosa-Espinoza. Buentello-Malo. Gorodetsky. Smith. Evaluating the farming/language dispersal hypothesis with genetic variation exhibited by populations in the Southwest and Mesoamerica . Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA . 2010 . 107 . 15 . 6759–6764 . 10.1073/pnas.0905753107 . 20351276 . 2872417. 2010PNAS..107.6759K . free.
- Book: Kroeber, Alfred Louis. Alfred L Kroeber. Shoshonean dialects of California. 24 August 2012. 1907. The University Press.
- Book: Kroeber, Alfred Louis. Alfred L Kroeber. 1934. Uto-Aztecan Languages of Mexico. 8. University of California Press.
- Langacker. Ronald W.. The Vowels of Proto Uto-Aztecan. International Journal of American Linguistics. 1970. 36. 3. 169–180. 10.1086/465108. 144762214.
- Book: Langacker, R. W. . 1977. An overview of Uto-Aztecan grammar. Summer Institute of Linguistics.
- Book: Langacker, R. W. . 1976. Non-distinct arguments in Uto-Aztecan. Berkeley. University of California Press.
- A Northern Uto-Aztecan Sound Law: *-c- → -y-¹. Alexis . Manaster Ramer. International Journal of American Linguistics. 58. 3. 1992. 251–268. 3519784 . 10.1086/ijal.58.3.3519784 . 148412173 .
- Merrill . William L. . Hard . Robert J. . Mabry . Jonathan B. . Fritz. Adams. Roney. MacWilliams. 2010 . Reply to Hill and Brown: Maize and Uto-Aztecan cultural history . Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA . 107 . 11 . E35–E36 . 10.1073/pnas.1000923107 . 2841871. 2010PNAS..107E..35M . free .
- Merrill. W. 2013. The genetic unity of southern Uto-Aztecan. Language Dynamics and Change. 3. 68–104. 10.1163/22105832-13030102.
- William L. . Merrill. The Historical Linguistics of Uto-Aztecan Agriculture. Anthropological Linguistics. 54. 3. 2012. 203–260. 10.1353/anl.2012.0017. 144089923.
- Book: Miller, Wick R. . 1986. Numic Languages. Handbook of North American Indians, Volume 11, Great Basin. Warren L. d’Azevedo. Washington. Smithsonian Institution. 98–106.
- Miller. Wick R. . 1983. A note on extinct languages of northwest Mexico of supposed Uto-Aztecan affiliation.. International Journal of American Linguistics. 49. 3 . 328–333. 10.1086/465793. 144510097 .
- Book: Miller . Wick R.. Alfonso . Ortiz . Handbook of North American Indians. 10 . 1983 . Smithsonian Institution . Washington, D.C.. 113–124 . Uto-Aztecan languages.
- Miller. Wick R.. 1984. The classification of the Uto-Aztecan languages based on lexical evidence. . International Journal of American Linguistics. 50. 1. 1–24. 10.1086/465813 . 144398421.
- Book: Mithun . Marianne . 1999 . The languages of Native America. Cambridge University Press.
- Sapir. E. . 1913. Southern Paiute and Nahuatl, a study in Uto-Aztekan. Journal de la Société des Américanistes. 10. 2. 379–425. 10.3406/jsa.1913.2866.
- Book: Shaul, David L. . 2014. A Prehistory of Western North America: The Impact of Uto-Aztecan Languages. University of New Mexico Press.
- Shaul. David L.. Hill. Jane H.. Tepimans, Yumans, and other Hohokam. American Antiquity. 63. 3. 1998. 375–396. 10.2307/2694626. 2694626. 162215129 .
- Book: Steele . Susan . Lyle . Campbell. Marianne . Mithun . 1979 . The Languages of Native America: Historical and Comparative Assessment. University of Texas Press. Austin. 444–544 . Uto-Aztecan: An assessment for historical and comparative linguistics.
- Book: Voegelin. C. F.. Voegelin. F.. Hale. K. . 1962. Typological and Comparative Grammar of Uto-Aztecan: Phonology. 17. Waverly Press. Memoirs of the International Journal of American Linguistics.
- Whorf. B. L. . The Comparative Linguistics of Uto-Aztecan . 1935. American Anthropologist. 37. 4. 600–608. 10.1525/aa.1935.37.4.02a00050.
Notes and References
- Wheeler . W. C. . Whiteley . P. M. . 2014 . Historical linguistics as a sequence optimization problem: the evolution and biogeography of Uto-Aztecan languages . Cladistics . 31 . 2. 113–125 . 10.1111/cla.12078 . 34758582 . 86030904 .
- Stubbs, Brian D. 2011. Uto-Aztecan: A comparative vocabulary. Flower Mound, Texas: Shumway Family History Services.