Proto-Mienic | |
Also Known As: | Proto-Yao |
Familycolor: | Hmong-Mien |
Ancestor: | Proto-Hmong–Mien |
Target: | Mienic languages |
Proto-Mienic or Proto-Yao (Chinese: 原始瑶语) is the reconstructed ancestor of the Mienic languages.
Reconstructions of Proto-Mienic (Proto-Yao) include those of Purnell (1970),[1] L-Thongkum (1993),[2] Ratliff (2010),[3] and Liu (2021).[4]
Purnell (1970) and L-Thongkum (1993) do not include any data from the divergent Biao Min and Zao Min languages. Purnell's (1970) Proto-Yao reconstruction is based on Iu Mien (Chiengrai [Chiang Rai, in Hwei Kang Pa ห้วยก้างปลา], Hsing-an [Xing'an], and Taipan [Đại Bản 大板] dialects) and Kim Mun (Haininh [Quảng Ninh] and Ling-chun [Lingchuan] dialects).
Liu's (2021) Proto-Yao reconstruction is based on data from Iu Mien (Jiangdi 江底 and Miaoziyuan 庙子源 dialects), Biao Mwan (Luoxiang 罗香), Kim Mun (Liangzi 梁子 and Tansan 滩散 dialects), Biao Min (Dongshan 东山 and Shikou 石口 dialects), and Zao Min (Daping 大坪). More than 500 lexical items are reconstructed.[4]
Liu (2021:78-80) gives the following consonant inventory for Proto-Mienic.[4]
Labial | Alveolar | Palatal | Velar | Glottal | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stop, voiceless | pronounced as /p/ | pronounced as /t/ | pronounced as /c/ | pronounced as /k/ | pronounced as /ʔ/ | |
Stop, voiced | pronounced as /b/ | pronounced as /d/ | pronounced as /ɟ/ | |||
Affricate, voiceless | pronounced as /ts/ | |||||
Affricate, voiced | pronounced as /dz/ | |||||
Nasal | pronounced as /m/ | pronounced as /n/ | pronounced as /ɲ/ | pronounced as /ŋ/ | ||
Fricative, voiceless | pronounced as /s/ | pronounced as /x/ | pronounced as /h/ | |||
Fricative, voiced | pronounced as /ɣ/ | pronounced as /ɦ/ | ||||
Approximant | pronounced as /w/ | pronounced as /l/ | pronounced as /j/ | |||
Rhotic | pronounced as /r/ |
Initial consonants can be preglottalized, aspirated, or devoiced. Final consonants include /-p, -t, -k, -m, -n, -ŋ/.
Ostapirat (2016) proposes velarized initials in Proto-Mienic, which are not reconstructed by Liu (2021), Ratliff (2010), and others.[5] Below is a comparison of selected Proto-Mienic reconstructions with initial bilabial stops from Ostapirat (2016), Liu (2021), L-Thongkum (1993) ("Pre-Mjuenic" reconstructions), and Ratliff (2010).
Gloss | Ostapirat (2016) | Liu (2021) | L-Thongkum (1993) | Ratliff (2010) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
full, satisfied |
|
|
| pHM *pu̯ɛŋX | |
fruit |
|
|
| pHM *pji̯əuX | |
float |
|
|
|
| |
bedbug |
|
| – | pHM *pji | |
three |
|
|
| pHM *pjɔu | |
burn |
|
|
|
| |
name |
|
|
| pHM *mpɔuH | |
hand |
|
|
| pHM *-bɔuX |
Liu (2021:165) reconstructs 8 Proto-Mienic vowels.
Front | Back | ||
---|---|---|---|
High | pronounced as /ink/ | pronounced as /ink/ | |
Mid-high | pronounced as /ink/ | pronounced as /ink/ | |
Mid-low | pronounced as /ink/ | pronounced as /ink/ | |
Near-low | pronounced as /ink/ | ||
Low | pronounced as /ink/ |
*pronounced as /ink/ only occurs as part of the rimes *-pronounced as /ɛːŋ/ and *-pronounced as /ɛk/.
Liu (2021) reconstructs contrastive vowel length for Proto-Mienic.[4] However, L-Thongkum (1993) and Ratliff (2010) do not reconstruct vowel length for Proto-Mienic, as they consider vowel length in synchronic Mienic languages to be later prosodic developments.
Sound correspondences among the Mienic languages from Liu (2021):
Reflexes of Proto-Mienic initials in synchronic Mienic languages are as follows (Liu 2021). Prenasalized Pre-Mienic initials are reconstructed; these developed into certain preglottalized and aspirated Proto-Mienic initials.
Proto-Mienic | Pre-Mienic | Jiangdi Mien | Miaoziyuan Mien | Luoxiang Mien | Liangzi Mun | Tansan Mun | Dongshan Biao Min | Shikou Biao Min | Daping Dzao Min | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| p | p | p | p | ʔp | p | b | b | ||
| pʰ | pʰ | pʰ | pʰ | pʰ | pʰ | pʰ | p | ||
| p | p | p | p | ʔp | p | b | p | ||
|
| b | b | b | b | b | b | p | b | |
|
| b | b | b | b | b | b | b | b | |
| b | b | b | b | b | b | p | b | ||
| m | m | m | m | m | m | m | m | ||
| m̥ | m̥ | m̥ | m | m̥ | m̥ | m | m | ||
| w | w | w | w | v | w | v | v | ||
| w | w | v | w | v | w | v | v | ||
| pw | pw | p | p | ʔp | p | b | b | ||
| pw | pw | p | p | ʔp | p | p | p | ||
|
| bw | bw | bw | b | b | b | pw | b | |
|
| bw | bw | b | b | b | b | b | b | |
| bw | bw | bw | b | b | b | p | b | ||
| mw | mw | m | m | m | m̥ | m | m | ||
| mw | mw | mw | m | m | m | m | m | ||
| pj | pj | pj | pj | ʔpj | pj | bj | b | ||
| pj | pj | pw | f | f | pj | b | pj | ||
|
| bj | bj | b | b | b | b | b | b | |
|
| bj | bj | bw | v | b | bj | b | bj | |
| mj | mj | m̥w | m | m | m̥j | m | mj | ||
| mj | mj | mw | m | m | m | m | m | ||
| wj | wj | v | w | v | w | ʔ | vj | ||
| wj | wj | w | w | v | w | v | vj | ||
| pj | p | pj | pj | ʔpj | pl | pl | pj | ||
| bj | b | bj | bj | bj | bl | pl | b | ||
| t | t | t | t | ʔt | t | d | d | ||
| tʰ | tʰ | tʰ | tʰ | tʰ | tʰ | tʰ | h | ||
| t | t | t | t | ʔt | t | d | t | ||
| d | d | d | d | d | d | t | d | ||
|
| d | d | d | d | d | d | d | d | |
| d | d | d | d | d | d | t | d | ||
| n | n | n | n | n | n | n | n | ||
| n̥ | n̥ | n̥ | n | n | n̥ | n | n | ||
| n | n | n | n | n | n | n | n | ||
| f | f | θ | tθ | θ | s | s | h | ||
| s | s | ɕ | tθ | θ | s | s | h | ||
| tw | tw | tw | t | ʔt | tw | d | d | ||
| d | dw | d | d | d | dw | tw | d | ||
|
| d | d | d | d | d | dw | tw | d | |
| f | f | θ | tθ | θ | sw | sj | h | ||
| s | s | ɕ | tθ | θ | sw | sj | h | ||
|
| dj | dj | d | d | d | t | d | d | |
| sj | sj | ɕ | s | ɕ | s | ɕ | sj | ||
| l | l | l | l | l | l | l | l | ||
| lj | lj | l | lj | lj | lj | lj | lj | ||
| ɬ | l | l | l | l | ɬ | l | l | ||
| ɬ | ɬ | l̥ | l | l | ɬ | lj | lj | ||
| l | l | l | l | l | l | l | l | ||
| l | l | g | g | g | l | l | dz | ||
| l | l | g | gj | gj | l | l | dz | ||
| ɬ | ɬ | g | g | g | ɬ | l | dz | ||
| ɬj | ɬj | gj | gj | gj | ɬj | lj | dz | ||
| l | l | g | g | g | l | l | dz | ||
| l | l | g | gj | gj | l | l | dz | ||
| ts | ts | θ | tθ | θ | ts | ts | t | ||
| tsʰ | tsʰ | θ | t | tʰ | tɕʰ | tsʰj | h | ||
| ts | ts | θ | tθ | tθ | ts | ts | h | ||
| dz | dz | d | d | d | dz | ts | dz | ||
|
| dz | dz | d | d | d | dz | tʰ | d | |
| dz | dz | d | d | d | dz | ts | d | ||
| tsw | tsw | θw | tθ | θ | tsw | ts | t | ||
| tsw | tsw | θw | tθ | tθ | tsw | ts | h | ||
|
| dʑw | dʑw | j | ȡ | ȡ | ȡ | tɕ | g | |
| tsj | tsj | tɕ | s | ɕ | ȶ | tɕ | ts | ||
| tsʰj | tsʰj | θj | tj | kʰj | tsʰ | tsʰ | h | ||
| tsj | tsj | tɕ | s | ɕ | ȶʰ | tɕ | sj | ||
|
| dzj | dzj | dʑ | ȡ | ȡ | hj | j | dz | |
|
| dzj | dzj | dʑ | ȡ | ȡ | ȡ | tɕʰ | dzj | |
| dzj | dzj | dʑ | ȡ | ȡ | tɕ | tɕ | h | ||
| ts | ts | tɕ | ȶ | ȶ | ȶ | tɕ | ts | ||
| tsʰ | tsʰ | ɕ | ȶ | ȶʰ | ȶʰ | ȶʰ | h | ||
| ts | ts | tɕ | ȶ | ȶ | ȶ | tɕ | s | ||
|
| dʑ | dʑ | j | ȡ | ȡ | dz | tɕ | dz | |
|
| dzj | dzj | ɕ | s | ɕ | s | tɕʰ | dzj | |
| dz | dz | dʑ | ȡ | ȡ | ȡ | tɕ | dz | ||
| ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ||
| ȵ̥ | ȵ̥ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ̥ | ȵ | ȵ | ||
| ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ||
| j | j | j | j | j | j | j | j | ||
| j | j | j | j | j | j | j | dz | ||
| tsw | tsw | tɕw | s | ɕ | ȶ | tɕ | ts | ||
| tsʰ | tsʰ | ɕw | s | ɕ | ȶʰw | tɕʰ | ts | ||
| tsw | tsw | tɕw | ȶ | ȶ | ȶw | tɕw | ts | ||
| ȵ | ȵw | ȵw | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ȵ | ||
| k | k | k | k | k | k | k | k | ||
| kʰ | k/kʰ | kʰ | k | kʰ | k | kʰ | k/f | ||
|
| g | g | d | d | d | k | k | k | |
| ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ||
| ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ŋ | ||
| dʑ | j | j | ȡ | ȡ | ȡ | k | k | ||
| dʑ | j | j | ȡ | ȡ | ȡ | k | g | ||
| kw | kw | kw | kw | kw | kw | kw | k | ||
| kʰ | kʰw | kʰ | k | kʰ | kʰw | kʰw | h | ||
| kw | kw | kw | kw | kw | kw | kw | f | ||
|
| g | g | g | g | g | gw | k/kw | g | |
|
| g | g | g | g | g | gw | g | g | |
| g | g | g | g | g | gw | kw | g | ||
| tɕ | tɕ | tɕ | s | ɕ | ȶ | tɕ | k | ||
| tɕ | tɕw | tɕw | s | ɕ | ȶw | tɕw | ts | ||
| tɕ | tɕ | tɕ | ȶ | ȶ | ȶ | tɕ | k | ||
| kwj | kj | kj | kw | kw | ȶ | tɕ | kj | ||
| g | g | g | gj | gj | g | k/kj | g | ||
| tɕ | k | kj | kj | kj | kl | kl | ts | ||
| tɕ | k | k | kj | kj | kl | kl | k | ||
| tɕ | k | kj | kj | kj | kl | kl | t | ||
| tɕw | kw | kw | kw | kw | kl | kl | k | ||
| tɕ | kj | kj | kj | kj | kl | klj | kj | ||
| tɕ | k | kl | tl | kl | kl | kl | k | ||
| tɕ | k | kl | tl | kl | kl | klj | kj | ||
| dʑ | g | gl | dl | gl | gl | kl | g | ||
| ʔ | ʔ | ʔ | ʔ | ʔ | ʔ | ʔ | ʔ | ||
| h | h | h | h | h | h | h | v | ||
| ɦ | Ø | ɦ | ɦ | ɦ | ɦ | ɦ | ɦ |
Reflexes of Proto-Mienic rimes in synchronic Mienic languages (Liu 2021):
Proto-Mienic | Jiangdi Mien | Miaoziyuan Mien | Luoxiang Mien | Liangzi Mun | Tansan Mun | Dongshan Biao Min | Shikou Biao Min | Daping Dzao Min | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| e | e | i | i | i | i | i/e | i/ɛi | |
| im | iŋ | im | im | im | ɛn | en | um | |
| iːm | iŋ | im | im | im | in | iŋ | ɛm | |
| in | iŋ | in | in | in | ɛn | en | ɛn | |
| iːn | iŋ | in | in | iːn | ən | eŋ | ɛn | |
| aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | iŋ | iŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | |
| iːŋ | iŋ | iŋ | iŋ | iːŋ | ɛ | aŋ | aŋ | |
| ip | i | ip | ip | iːp | in | ɛ | ɛp | |
| it | i | it | i | |||||
| i | ei | i | i | i | i | iŋ | ɛ | |
| i | ei | i | i | i | i | i | ɛ | |
| ei | ei | ei | ei | ɛi | əi | i | ɛi | |
| ei | ei | ei | ei | ɛi | əi | i | i | |
| ei | ei | ei | ei | ɛi | i | e | i | |
| om | əŋ | em | am | am | an | en | um | |
| iːm | əŋ | em | eːm | iːm | ən | eŋ | um | |
| en | əŋ | en | in | in | in | en | ɛn | |
| eːn | əŋ | en | eːn | iːn | ən | eŋ | ɛn | |
| et | ei | et | eːt | iːt | ən | e | ɛt | |
| ɛːŋ | ɛŋ | ɛŋ | ɛŋ | ɛːŋ | ɛ | iŋ | ɛŋ | |
| ɛ | ɛ | ɛ | ɛ | ɛ | ɛ | a | a | |
| e | e | a | a | a | a | a | a | |
| om | əŋ | em | im | im | an | an | ɛm | |
| en | əŋ | an | an | an | an | ən | ɛn | |
| en | əŋ | an | aːn | aːn | an | ən | ɛn | |
| eŋ | əŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | ɛŋ | |
| op | e | ep | ap | ap | an | æ | ɛp | |
| at | ə | ət | et | et | an | ɛ | ɔt | |
| at | ə | ət | ɛt | ɛːt | ə | ɛ | ɔt | |
| e | e | a | a | a | a | a | a | |
| a | a | a | a | a | a | a | a | |
| ai | ai | ai | ai | ai | ai | ai | ɛi | |
| aːi | a | aːi | aːi | aːi | a | ai | ai | |
| ai | ai | ai | ai | aːi | ai | ai | ai | |
| aːi | a | aːi | aːi | aːi | a | ai | ai | |
| aːi | a | aːi | aːi | aːi | a | ai | ai | |
| ai | ai | ai | ai | aːi | ai | ai | ai | |
| au | au | au | au | au | a | ɔu | iu | |
| aːu | a | aːu | au | aːu | a | au | au | |
| am | aŋ | am | am | am | an | an | am | |
| aːm | aŋ | aːm | aːm | aːm | an | ɔn | ɔm | |
| an | əŋ | ən | an | an | an | ən | an | |
| aːn | aŋ | aːn | an | aːn | an | ən | ɔn | |
| aːn | aŋ | an | an | aːn | an | ən | an | |
| aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | |
| aːŋ | aŋ | aːŋ | aŋ | aːŋ | aŋ | aŋ | aŋ | |
| ap | a | ap | ap | ap | an | æ | ap | |
| aːp | a | aːp | aːp | aːp | an | æ | ap | |
| at | a | at | at | at | an | æ | at | |
| aːt | a | aːt | aːt | aːt | an | æ | at | |
| a | a | a | a | a | a | a | a | |
| o | ɔ | ɔːk | aːk | ak | ɔ | ɔ | ɔu | |
| u | u | o | u | u | u | u | ɔu | |
| u | u | ou | ou | ɔu | ɔ | eu | au | |
| oŋ | oŋ | oŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ/uŋ | |
| oŋ | oŋ | oŋ | ɔŋ | ɔːŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | uŋ | |
| op | əu | up | op | up | in | ɛ | ip | |
| op | oːp | op | ɔk | ɔp | u | |||
| ot | ə | ot | ɔt | ɔt | an | ɛ | ||
| u | u | o | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔu | |
| o | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔu | |
| oːi | a | ɔi | ɔi | ɔːi | ai | ei | æ | |
| o | ə | u | u | u | au | ɔu | u | |
| ou | əu | eu | ou | ɔu | au | ɔu | iu | |
| ou | əu | eu | ou | ɔu | au | ɔu | u | |
| ou | əu | ou | ou | ɔu | əu | eu | u | |
| ou | əu | ou | ou | ɔu | əu | iu | u | |
| ou | əu | eu | ou | ɔu | au | ɔu | ɛu | |
| om | oŋ | om | ɔm | ɔm | an | ɔn | ɔn | |
| oːm | ɔŋ | ɔm | ɔm | ɔːm | ɔ | ɔ | ɔm | |
| oːn | aŋ | ɔːŋ | ɔn | ɔːn | an | ən | an | |
| aŋ | əŋ | əŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | uŋ | |
| oːŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | ɔːŋ | ɔ | oŋ | ɔŋ | |
| at | a | ɔt | ɔi | ɔːi | a | ɛ | ɛt | |
| o | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔ | ɔu | |
| u | u | ok | ɔːk | ɔːk | u | u | u | |
| o | ə | u | u | u | u | u | u | |
| uːi | ui | ui | ui | uːi | əi | ei | ai | |
| uːi | ui | ui | ui | uːi | əi | i | i | |
| iu | iu | iu | iu | iu | iu | iu | iu | |
| iu | iu | eu | eu | iːu | au | iu | ɛu | |
| om | oŋ | um | um | um | in | œn | um | |
| un | uŋ | un | un | un | un | un | in | |
| uŋ | uŋ | uŋ | uŋ | uŋ | ə | ɔŋ | ɔŋ | |
| uŋ | uŋ | uŋ | uŋ | uŋ | ə | ɔŋ | iŋ | |
| aŋ | əŋ | oŋ | uŋ | uŋ | ɔŋ | aŋ | aŋ | |
| uŋ | uŋ | uŋ | uːŋ | uːŋ | ə | ɔŋ | iŋ | |
| ut | u | ut | ut | ut | un | ɛ | ut | |
| ut | u | ut | uːt | uːt | in | ɛ | ut | |
| u | əu | u | u | u | u | ɔ | iu |
Proto-Mienic tonal categories and their respective tone pitch reflexes in synchronic Mienic languages (Liu 2021):
Proto-Mienic | Jiangdi Mien | Miaoziyuan Mien | Luoxiang Mien | Liangzi Mun | Tansan Mun | Dongshan Biao Min | Shikou Biao Min | Daping Dzao Min | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 33 | 33 | 33 | 35 | 35 | 33 | 33 | 44 | |
| 33 | 33 | 33 | 31 | 13 | 33 | 33 | 44 | |
| 31 | 31 | 31 | 33 | 33 | 31 | 55 | 53 | |
| 52 | 53 | 53 | 545 | 55 | 35 | 35 | 24 | |
| 52 | 53 | 53 | 43 | 42 | 35 | 35 | 24 | |
| 231 | 232 | 213 | 32 | 31 | 42 | 31 | 44 | |
| 24 | 35 | 35 | 44 | 335 | 24 | 44 | 42 | |
| 24 | 35 | 55 | 21 | 331 | 24 | 44 | 42 | |
| 13 | 11 | 11 | 22 | 32 | 42 | 13 | 22 | |
| 55 | 54 | 43 | 24 | 35 | 53 | 35 | 44 | |
| 55 | 54 | 43 | 54 | 35 | 53 | 35 | 44 | |
| 55 | 54 | 43 | 31 | 12 | 53 | 35 | 44 | |
| 55 | 54 | 43 | 32 | 12 | 53 | 35 | 44 | |
| 12 | 21 | 32 | 42 | 32 | 42 | 22 | 22 | |
| 12 | 21 | 32 | 21 | 32 | 42 | 22 | 22 |
Sound change innovations in synchronic Mienic languages (Liu 2021:156–157, 228):
| b | Shikou, Daping | |
| p | Liangzi, Daping | |
| m | all Mienic lects | |
| m | Liangzi, Tansan, Shikou, Daping | |
| b | Shikou, Daping | |
| d | Shikou, Daping | |
| t | Liangzi | |
| h | Daping | |
| n | all Mienic lects | |
| n | Liangzi, Tansan, Shikou, Daping | |
| l | Liangzi, Tansan, Shikou, Daping | |
| d | Luoxiang, Liangzi, Tansan | |
| f | Jiangdi, Miaoziyuan | |
| h | Daping | |
| h | Daping | |
| d | Shikou, Daping | |
| θ | Luoxiang, Tansan | |
| t | Daping | |
| h | Daping | |
| ɲ | all Mienic lects | |
| dz | Daping | |
| zero | Miaoziyuan | |
| bj > b | Shikou, Daping | |
| f | Liangzi, Tansan | |
| l | all Mienic lects | |
| l | Jiangdi, Miaoziyuan, Dongshan, Shikou | |
| g | Luoxiang, Liangzi, Tansan | |
| dz | Daping | |
| ɲ | Liangzi, Tansan, Shikou, Daping | |
| ŋ | all Mienic lects |
| e | Jiangdi, Miaoziyuan | |
| n | Miaoziyuan, Dongshan, Shikou | |
| n | Dongshan | |
| ɛi | Daping | |
| iŋ | Shikou | |
| e | Jiangdi, Miaoziyuan | |
| a | Shikou, Daping | |
| ə | Miaoziyuan | |
| o | Jiangdi | |
| ə | Miaoziyuan | |
| o | Jiangdi | |
| aŋ | Jiangdi | |
| əŋ | Miaoziyuan, Luoxiang | |
| ə | Dongshan | |
| ɔŋ | Shikou, Daping | |
| e | Jiangdi, Miaoziyuan | |
| ən | Shikou | |
| an | Dongshan | |
| a | Miaoziyuan, Dongshan | |
| ɛ | Daping | |
| an | Dongshan |