Professional Game Match Officials Limited Explained

Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) is the body responsible for refereeing games in English professional football.

Formerly known as the Professional Game Match Officials Board (PGMOB), the PGMOL was formed when English referees became professional in 2001, to provide officials for all games played in the Premier League, English Football League (EFL) and Football Association (FA) competitions.[1] In doing so, England became the first country in the world to fully professionalise its referees. The organisation is a not-for-profit company limited by guarantee owned and funded by the Premier League, EFL, and the FA.[2] [3]

Staff

EmployeeTitle
Martin Glenn Chair[4]
Chief Refereeing Officer[5]
Danielle Every Chief Operating Officer
Adam Gale-Watts Technical Director
Vacant Select Group 1 Director
National Group Director
Women’s Professional Game Director
Coaching Director
Performance Support Director
Select Group 2 Manager
Video Assistant Referee Coach[6]
Select Group 1 Coach[7]
Referee Coach[8]
Mike Mullarkey Head of Assistant Referees[9]
Referee Coach
Steve Child Assistant Referee Coach[10]
Head of Community and Public Engagement[11]
International Referee Development Manager[12]
Paul Russell Head of Psychology[13]
Simon Breivik Head of Fitness and Medical[14]
Referee Coach[15]
Football Insights Coach
Football Insights Coach

Evaluation

The Select Group referees meet twice per month for training sessions and analysis of match videos and data.[2]

The PGMOL have their own sports scientists, sports psychologists, physiotherapists, sprint coaches, podiatrists and vision scientists which mirror football clubs to help improve referee performance.

Every Premier League match is evaluated by a former senior referee to measure the referee's technical performance, along with fellow players and managers (match delegates) who assess accuracy and consistency of their decision making and management of their game to ensure the correct result[2] PGMOL no longer sends evaluators to the match, instead relying solely on video analysis. Some referees in the Select Group have criticized this system, believing it misses critical environmental considerations in game management.[16]

Sponsorship

The PGMOL changed its sponsorship for the 2010–11 season from Air Asia to its parent group, Tune Group.

For the 2012–13 season Expedia sponsored the officials,[17] but this agreement ended after a year.

For the start of the 2013–14 Premier League season PGMOL had no sponsor, but part way through the season EA Sports signed a long term agreement which saw their logo on the arms of all officials in the Premier League and EFL until 2019. In 2022, the sponsorship was renewed until the end of the 2024–25 season.[18]

Controversies

Mark Halsey claim

In September 2016, Mark Halsey, a former member and referee, claimed that PGMOL asked him to lie in match reports. PGMOL denied the claim, and no further action was taken.[19] [20]

Employment status

In 2018, HMRC challenged the employment status of PGMOL appointed referees. The tax authority claimed that referees are employees, not self-employed as PGMOL claimed. The tax tribunals sided with HMRC, but the appellate court reversed, determining that their referees are self-employed.[21] The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom heard the HMRC's appeal on 26 June 2023.[22]

Implementation of Video Assistant Referees

Howard Webb acknowledged the turbulent implementation of Video Assistant Referees (VAR) after he became PGMOL's Chief. He stated that his goal is increased transparency in the VAR process.[23] [24] Such measures includes the introduction of an independent panel consisting of three players, a representative from the Premier League and a PGMOL official to evaluate VAR's performance during the 2022–23 season. The panel found six errors out of 48 decisions in the months before the 2022 FIFA World Cup break.[25] The same panel found just four incorrect interventions in the latter half of the season.[26] In the 2023–24 season, Webb consented to releasing the audio between VAR and on pitch officials for key and controversial calls in a regular TV programme, "Match Officials Mic'd Up".[27] The show airs at the end of every month and features Howard Webb and former footballer Michael Owen discussing the process and addressing errors made by officials for the previous four match weeks. This is an expansion on the special release of VAR audio to address an error made by VAR during the September 30, 2023, match between Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur.

Apologies and acknowledgements of error

!Date!Favored Team!Disfavored Team!Nature of the Call!Nature of the Mistake!PGMOL Action
22 February 2020[28] Tottenham HotspurChelseaRed card not awardedVAR did not think the challenge was avoidable.PGMOL Head of Public Engagement Chris Foy attribute mistake to "human error by video officials"
17 October 2020[29] EvertonLiverpoolRed card not awardedAll officials failed to consider all possible sanctions for the conduct. Head Official Michael Oliver acknowledged that Jordan Pickford should have been sent off for "serious foul play or violent conduct" regardless of how the game resumed otherwise.
26 February 2022[30] Manchester CityEvertonPenalty not awarded for handlingVAR deemed insufficient evidence of contact[31] PGMOL Referees Chief Mike Riley issued an apology to Everton.
6 November 2022[32] Aston VillaManchester UnitedExcessive distance on free kickHead official over-measured the distance and ignored the complaints of players.PGMOL Select Group 1 Manager Jon Moss assured the centre official would be spoken to.
7 January 2023[33] LiverpoolWolverhampton WanderersOnside goal disallowedVAR did not have access to appropriate camera anglesThe centre official allowed the coach to discuss the error before normal protocol would allow and personally apologise.
29 January 2023[34] LiverpoolBrighton Hove AlbionRed card not awardedVAR did not deem the yellow card a clear and obvious errorPGMOL stated that the foul was worthy of a red card.
11 February 2023[35] Crystal PalaceBrighton Hove AlbionOnside goal disallowedVAR incorrectly placed offsides lineHoward Webb issued an apology to Brighton. Referee John Brooks was removed from VAR for two games.
11 February 2023BrentfordArsenalOffsides goal allowedVAR did not fully investigate incidentHoward Webb issued an apology to Arsenal.
8 April 2023[36] Tottenham HotspurBrighton Hove AlbionPenalty not awardedVAR did not deem the non-call a clear and obvious errorChief Refereeing Officer Howard Webb issued an apology to Brighton.
14 August 2023[37] Manchester UnitedWolverhampton WanderersPenalty not awardedVAR did not deem the non-call a clear and obvious errorHead official and both VAR officials were suspended from further matches.
30 September 2023[38] Tottenham HotspurLiverpoolOnside goal disallowedMiscommunication between VAR and on-field officialsAcknowledged the "serious human error" and released the referee audio from the match as well as subsequent matches to indicate new preventative procedures.[39] [40] [41]
8 October 2023Manchester CityArsenalRed card not awardedError by head official and VAR Howard Webb admitted it was an error and review policies on officiating foreign games.
3 December 2023[42] Tottenham HotspurManchester CityAdvantage not playedError by head officialHoward Webb admitted to an "officiating mistake" by the head official.
23 December 2023[43] ArsenalLiverpool Penalty not awardedError in judgment by head official and VARHoward Webb admitted that it was the wrong call and released the VAR audio.
21 April 2024[44] EvertonNottingham ForestPenalty not awardedError in judgment by head official and VARHoward Webb admitted that it was the wrong call and released the VAR audio.

Notes and References

  1. News: Ralston . William . The impossible job: inside the world of Premier League referees . The Guardian. London. 22 March 2023 . 21 March 2023.

  2. Corporate information from UK Companies House at https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/04195554/filing-history
  3. Web site: Chair.
  4. Web site: Leadership Team.
  5. Web site: Phil Bentham.
  6. Web site: Premier League to undergo 'radical referee shake-up' after clubs complain over declining standards. 24 June 2022 .
  7. Web site: Alan Wiley.
  8. Web site: PGMOL.
  9. Web site: PGMOL.
  10. Web site: PGMOL.
  11. Web site: We want to create a pathway for Indian referees to reach elite level. 10 December 2021 .
  12. Web site: For me well-being is like a cup.
  13. Web site: PGMOL.
  14. Web site: Lee Mason set for PGMOL return as referees' coach after VAR blunder last season. 9 August 2023 .
  15. News: Ralston . William . 2023-03-21 . The impossible job: inside the world of Premier League referees . en-GB . The Guardian . 2023-12-13 . 0261-3077.
  16. Web site: Expedia Signs Up As Official Sponsor Of Professional Referees And Match Officials . 13 April 2014 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20140414074401/http://inside.expedia.co.uk/press-centre/expedia-signs-official-sponsor-professional-referees-and-match-officials-242 . 14 April 2014 . dmy-all . Expedia.
  17. Web site: Sonawane . Akshay . 2022-08-29 . EA Sports, PGMOL sign partnership extension . 2023-10-11 . SportsMint Media . en-US.
  18. News: Mark Halsey reveals incident he claims he was told to lie about by referee bosses as Gary Neville calls for investigation. Ben. Rumsby. The Telegraph. 4 September 2016. telegraph.co.uk.
  19. News: Mark Halsey: Professional Game Match Officials Limited denies former referee's lie claims. BBC Sport. Manchester. 3 September 2016.
  20. Revenue and Customs v Professional Game Match Officials Ltd. EWCA. [2021] STC 1956, [2021] EWCA Civ 1370, [2022] 1 All ER 971, [2021] BTC 27. 17-Sep-23. http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2021/1370.html.
  21. Web site: The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom . 2023-10-10 . Commissioners for His Majesty's Revenue and Customs (Respondent) v Professional Game Match Officials Ltd (Appellant) . 2023-10-10.
  22. News: Stone . Simon . 21 December 2022 . Six incorrect VAR interventions in Premier League . en-GB . . Manchester. 13 December 2023.
  23. News: 23 December 2022 . Howard Webb exclusive: New PGMOL chief refereeing officer says VAR talks could be aired for better transparency . 2023-10-10 . Sky Sports. London. en.
  24. News: Johnson . Dale . 2022-12-21 . Sources: Arsenal nixed goal at Utd was VAR error . 2023-12-13 . ESPN. London. en.
  25. News: 19 April 2023 . VAR use in Premier League has improved, says independent panel, as Howard Webb targets specialists . 13 December 2023 . Sky Sports. London. en.
  26. News: Match Officials: Mic'd Up - Premier League in-game audio to be shown in new programme on Sky Sports . 2023-12-28 . Sky Sports. London. en.
  27. News: VAR made wrong call on Lo Celso – Foy . en-GB . . Manchester. 2023-10-10.
  28. News: Virgil van Dijk: Referee Michael Oliver admits mistake over Jordan Pickford tackle on Liverpool defender . Sky Sports. London. 24 January 2024.
  29. News: Magowan . Alistair . 1 March 2022 . Everton receive handball apology . en-GB . BBC Sport. Manchester. 2023-10-10.
  30. News: Johnson . Dale . 2022-03-01 . Man City handball controversy: PGMOL sorry . 2023-10-10 . ESPN. . en.
  31. News: Luckhurst . Samuel . 2022-12-27 . Referee group agrees with Manchester United over wall vs Aston Villa . 2023-10-10 . Manchester Evening News. Manchester. Reach plc. en.
  32. News: Madeley . Steve . The images VAR didn't see of Wolves' disallowed winner at Liverpool - and the reasons why . 2023-10-10 . The Athletic. London. The New York Times. en.
  33. News: Johnson . Dale . 2023-01-30 . PGMOL: VAR red-card error over Fabinho tackle . 2023-10-10 . London. ESPN. en.
  34. News: Humayun . Ali . Howard Webb contacts Arsenal about VAR 'error' . 2023-10-10 . The Athletic. London. . en.
  35. News: Johnson . Dale . 2023-04-09 . Sources: PGMOL sorry to Brighton for VAR error . 2023-10-10 . ESPN. London. en.
  36. News: Humayun . Ali . Man Utd-Wolves ref, VAR dropped after Onana pen error . 2023-10-10 . The Athletic. London. The New York Times. en.
  37. News: 30 September 2023 . Tottenham 2-1 Liverpool: Contrasting emotions but both sides can be Premier League title contenders . McNulty. Phil. BBC Sport. Manchester.
  38. News: 3 October 2023 . VAR audio released from Liverpool's disallowed goal by Luis Diaz in defeat at Spurs . Sky Sports. London.
  39. 3 October 2023 . PGMOL release VAR audio from Spurs v Liverpool . The Football Association Premier League Limited. London.
  40. News: Rumsby . Ben . 2023-10-10 . Michael Oliver was wrong not to show Mateo Kovacic a red card, admits referees chief Howard Webb . en-GB . The Telegraph. London. subscription . 2023-10-11 . 0307-1235.
  41. News: Buckingham. Phillip. Burrows. Ben. Webb admits to 'mistake' over Man City advantage decision vs Spurs . 2023-12-13 . The Athletic. London. . en.
  42. News: Liverpool should have had penalty v Arsenal - Webb . 2024-01-17 . BBC Sport. Manchester . en-GB.
  43. News: MacInnes . Paul . 2024-04-30 . Howard Webb admits VAR made error over Forest penalty claim at Everton . 2024-05-03 . The Guardian . en-GB . 0261-3077.