Product Liability Directive 1985 Explained

Type:Directive
Number:85/374/EEC
Directive on the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States concerning liability for defective products
Madeby:Council of the European Union
Madeunder:Art. 100 TEEC
Eea:yes
Ojrefurl:http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:31985L0374:EN:HTML
Ojref:L210, 07/08/1985, pp. 29-33
Made:25 July 1985
Commenced:30 July 1985
Implementation:See table detailing implementation by state
Amendedby:1999/34/EC
Status:Amended

The Product Liability Directive 85/374/EEC is a directive of the Council of the European Communities (now the European Union) which created a regime of strict liability for defective products applicable in all member states of the European Union, the other EEA members (Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway) and the United Kingdom.

Background

The Council adopted a resolution in 1975 for a preliminary programme on consumer protection and information technology.[1] [2] Moves towards a strict liability regime in Europe began with the Council of Europe Convention on Products Liability in regard to Personal Injury and Death (the Strasbourg Convention) in 1977.[3] The Pearson Commission in the UK noted that this work had started, and refrained from making their own recommendations.[4] A second EU programme followed in 1981.[5]

The preamble to the directive cites Art. 100 (subsequently renumbered to Art. 94, then to Art. 115) of the Treaty of Rome and the aim to achieve a single market:

The preamble then goes on:

Content

Articles 1 to 12 create a scheme of strict product liability for damage arising from defective products. This liability is in addition to any existing rights that consumers enjoy under domestic law (article 13).

The directive does not extend to nuclear accidents, these being covered by existing international conventions (article 14). The original directive did not extend to game or primary agricultural produce (article 2) but this exception was repealed by directive 1999/34/EC following concerns over BSE.[6]

Development risks defence

Article 15(1)(b) of the directive gives member states the option of adopting the development risks defence:

, all EU member states other than Finland and Luxembourg had taken advantage of it to some extent.[7]

Implementation by state

Because EU directives do not have direct effect, they only come into force on persons in member states when implemented in national legislation. Article 19 demanded implementation within 3 years.[8]

Member stateMeans of implementationDate of implementationComments
BelgiumLoi du 25/02/1991 relative à la responsabilité du fait des produits défectueux - Wet van 25/02/1991 betreffende de aansprakelijkheid voor produkten met gebreken. Moniteur belge du 22/03/1991 Page 588425 February 1991
Czech Republic1. Zákon o odpovědnosti za škodu způsobenou vadou výrobku
2. Zákon, kterým se mění zákon č. 59/1998 Sb., o odpovědnosti za škodu způsobenou vadou výrobku
?
DenmarkLov nr. 371 af 07/06/1989 om produktansvar. Justitsmin.L.A. 1988-46002-11. Lovtidende A haefte 58 udgivet den 09/06/1989 s.1260. JLOV9 June 1989
EstoniaVõlaõigusseadus?
FranceAct 98-389, Arts 1386–1 to 1386-18 of the Civil Code19 May 1998
GermanyProdukthaftungsgesetz15 December 1989
IrelandLiability for Defective Products Act 19914 December 1991
NetherlandsWet van 13 September 1990 houdende aanpassing van het Burgerlijk Wetboek aan de richtlijn van de Raad van de Europese Gemeenschappen inzake de aansprakelijkheid voor produkten met gebreken1 November 1990
United KingdomConsumer Protection Act 19871 March 1988

Review

Article 21 demanded that the Commission report to the council on the application of the directive every five years.

DateReferencePrincipal recommendations
12 December 1995COM/95/617 finalNone
9 February 2000COM/2000/0893 finalConsultation of the basis of a Green Paper[9] was carried out before the review.
No changes to directive but recommendations on further data gathering and expert review[10]
14 September 2006COM/2006/0496 finalNone[11]
In 2021, the European Commission conducted an Impact Assessment study on the possible revision of the Product Liability Directive.[12] [13]

References

External links

Notes and References

  1. Official Journal of the European Community [1975] C 92/2
  2. van Gerven (2000) p.643
  3. Web site: European Convention on Products Liability in regard to Personal Injury and Death . 1977 . Council of Europe . 2008-04-30 .
  4. News: . 17 March 1978 . 4, col D . Pearson Report: Plan for 'no fault' compensation for road accident victims financed by petrol tax . Marcel Berlins . Berlins, M. .
  5. OJ [1981] C 133/1
  6. Shears (2001)
  7. Giliker & Beckwith (2004) 9-029
  8. Web site: Council Directive 85/374/EEC - national provisions . 2008-04-16 . EUR-Lex .
  9. European Commission (1999)
  10. Web site: Report from the Commission on the Application of Directive 85/374 on Liability for Defective Products . 2008-04-16 . EUR-Lex .
  11. Web site: Third report on the application of Council Directive on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States concerning liability for defective products . 2008-04-16 . EUR-Lex .
  12. CSES (2021) Web site: Targeted consultation: Impact Assessment study on the possible revision of the Product Liability Directive 85/374/EEC . 2021-10-20 .
  13. Web site: Product Liability for Consumer Healthcare Products in the EU . mhc.ie . Mason Hayes & Curran . 27 February 2024.