Portmarnock Golf Club Explained

Portmarnock Golf Club
Location:Portmarnock, County Dublin, Ireland
Coordinates:53.407°N -6.124°W
Establishment:1894
Type:Private
Holes:27
Course1:Championship Course
Designer1:William Pickeman
Par1:72
Record1:68 - James Fox, Anton Albers
Pushpin Map:Dublin
Pushpin Relief:1
Pushpin Map Caption:Location in Greater Dublin

Portmarnock Golf Club is a links golf club in Portmarnock, County Dublin, Ireland, located close to Dublin Airport.

The golf course is often rated as one of the top courses in the UK and Ireland and is also often included in lists of the top 100 golf courses in the world.

History

On Christmas Eve 1893, an insurance broker named W. C. Pickeman and his friend George Ross rowed over from Sutton to Portmarnock peninsula to explore the possibility of creating a golf links. The peninsula is about two miles long and covers over 500 acres. The course opened on Saint Stephen's Day 1894 with nine holes. It was extended to eighteen holes in 1896 with a new clubhouse and a further nine holes were added in 1971. The championship course follows the original layout although considerably lengthened (over 7,500 yards of the Championship tees). The only major change in the routing was the insertion in 1927 of a new, now famous par three, the 15th hole.

Notable events hosted

Portmarnock was the venue for the first Irish Open in 1927, and has hosted the tournament on many occasions since, including 13 following its revival in 1975.[1] Many other important golf tournaments have been held at the club, including the British Amateur Championship in 1949 and 2019, the Walker Cup in 1991, and the Canada Cup in 1960. In October 2023 The R&A said that they were "keen to investigate the possibility" of Portmarnock hosting the Open Championship or Women's Open Championship.[2]

Discrimination claims

In 2003 the Equality Authority of Ireland brought a discrimination case in the Dublin District Court under which the club's drinks licence was suspended for 7 days.[3] The finding was overturned in the High Court in 2005,[4] and again in the Supreme Court in 2009,[5] allowing the club to keep its men-only policy.

In 2005, the High Courts decision in the Equal Authority v. Portmarnock Golf Club & Ors became a significant case in Irish gender equality law. While the authority argued such discrimination could not be protected by Section 9 of the ESA because the club providing a space for golf is not necessarily a “need” of men, the Supreme Court believed it was fair to hold Portmarnock Golf Club as a nondiscriminatory club under the Equal Status Act, ruling the fundamental purpose of the club was golf.[6]

Portmarnock Golf Club’s men-only policy was legally enforceable due to its exemption under equal status legislation. The reason for this discrimination against women is because the club has claimed their main purpose is to accommodate the needs of only one gender. Section 9 of the Equal Status Act states that clubs whose main purpose is to serve the needs of only one gender may be considered nondiscriminatory.[7] However, Section 8 of the ESA holds that a club will be considered discriminatory if there is anything, such as a rule or practice that exempts a qualified member or an applicant for membership from being a member of the club. In addition, Section 8 claims a club is considered to be discriminatory if there are different terms and conditions of membership for different individuals.[8] Because Section 8 prohibits gender discrimination, Portmarnock was technically a discriminating club under Section 8 of the ESA.[9]

In May 2021, Portmarnock ended its men-only membership policy.[10]

Events hosted

Honours

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Nissan Irish Open - Past Winners . . 2008-10-21.
  2. Web site: Portmarnock: R&A keen to explore possible Open or Women's Open at Dublin course . BBC Sport . 6 October 2023 . 6 October 2023.
  3. News: Portmarnock golf club breaches equality laws . . February 20, 2004 . 2008-10-21.
  4. News: Equality Authority may appeal golf club ruling . . June 10, 2005 . 2008-10-21.
  5. Web site: Supreme Court upholds golf club ban. 2009-11-03. RTÉ News. 2009-11-03.
  6. Web site: The Supreme Court, Equality, Golfing and 'Need' – Human Rights in Ireland. humanrights.ie. 2016-10-02. https://web.archive.org/web/20160307151457/http://humanrights.ie/gender-sexuality-and-the-law/the-supreme-court-equality-and-golfing-as-need/. 2016-03-07. dead.
  7. Web site: Portmarnock Golf club wins discrimination case. en-US. 2016-10-02.
  8. Web site: Portmarnock Golf club wins discrimination case. en-US. 2016-10-02.
  9. No Women (and Dogs) Allowed: A Comparative Analysis of Discriminating Private Golf Clubs in the United States, Ireland, and England. Washington University Global Studies Law Review. 6.
  10. Web site: Portmarnock Golf Club to allow female members. 26 May 2021. Fletcher. Laura.
  11. Web site: Heath . Elliott . Top 100 Golf Courses UK and Ireland 2021/22 . Golf Monthly Magazine . 15 July 2022 . en . 25 May 2022.
  12. Web site: Duncan . Derek . Whitten . Ron . Ranking: World's 100 Greatest Golf Courses . Golf Digest . 15 July 2022 . en.
  13. Web site: Top 100 Courses in the World: GOLF's 2021–22 ranking of the best designs on the planet . Golf Magazine . 15 July 2022.