Political positions of Libertas explained

The political positions of Libertas were the political positions of members or affiliates of Libertas, the umbrella title given to a constellation of organizations associated with Declan Ganley. Candidates and parties underneath its pan-European arm, Libertas.eu contended the 2009 European Parliament elections.

Preamble

Libertas is a political party founded by Declan Ganley that took part in the 2009 European Parliament election in several member states of the European Union. For the purposes of contending those elections, Libertas candidates ran under lists (the lists of candidates presented to voters in a European election) branded with the Libertas identity, as exemplified by the French approach.[1] [2] Each list was made up of some combination of the following:

Their political positions were as follows:

EUProfiler

The EUProfiler was produced by a consortium of three institutions (Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies, Kieskompas and the University of Zurich)[4] analysing parties taking part in the 2009 elections. Some of those parties were Libertas. A summary of their analyses is given below.

Hix-Lord diagram

The EUProfiler gave the positions of political parties on the left-right and Eurosceptic spectra. Six of those parties were Libertas parties. They were as follows:

Those positions are summarized on the Hix-Lord diagram (a type of political compass) on the right. The Eurosceptic parties are towards the bottom, Europhile parties towards the top, the left-wing parties are towards the left, and right-wing parties towards the right.

Profile

The EUProfiler also collated party statements into their positions on distinct questions. A summary of those collations for the six Libertas parties analysed is as follows:

Category Question LI CPNT MPF LP MPT C
Finances and taxes The EU should acquire its own tax raising powers
Economy and work The EU should drastically reduce its subsidies to Europe's farmers
European integration The European Union should be enlarged to include Turkey
Society, religion and culture Euthanasia should be legalised
European integration Individual member states of the EU should have less veto power
Society, religion and culture The legalisation of same sex marriages is a good thing
Welfare, family and health Greater efforts should be made to privatise healthcare services in your member state
Migration and immigration Immigration policies oriented towards skilled workers should be encouraged as a means of fostering economic growth
Foreign policy On foreign policy issues, such as the relationship with Russia, the EU should speak with one voice
Society, religion and culture The decriminalisation of the personal use of soft drugs is to be welcomed
Finances and taxes Governments should bail out failing banks with public money
European integration European integration is a good thing
Environment, transport and energy The promotion of public transport should be fostered through green taxes (e.g. road taxing)
Law and order Restrictions of civil liberties should be accepted in the fight against terrorism
Foreign policy The European Union should strengthen its security and defence policy
Finances and taxes Government spending should be reduced in order to lower taxes
Economy and work Governments should reduce workers' protection regulations in order to fight unemployment
Environment, transport and energy Policies to fight global warming should be encouraged even if it hampers economic growth or employment
Environment, transport and energy Renewable sources of energy (e.g. solar or wind energy) should be supported even if this means higher energy costs
European integration Your member state is much better off in the EU than outside it
Welfare, family and health Social programmes should be maintained even at the cost of higher taxes
Society, religion and culture Religious values and principles should be shown greater respect in politics
European integration The European Parliament should be given more powers
Law and order Criminals should be punished more severely
Migration and immigration Immigrants from outside Europe should be required to accept our culture and values
Welfare, family and health State subsidies for crèches and child care should be increased substantially
Migration and immigration Immigration into your member state should be made more restrictive
European integration Any new European Treaty should be subject to approval in a referendum in your member state
Sources http://www.euprofiler.eu/party/171/19/ http://www.euprofiler.eu/party/109/3/ http://www.euprofiler.eu/party/111/3/ http://www.euprofiler.eu/party/385/27/ http://www.euprofiler.eu/party/238/28/ http://www.euprofiler.eu/party/269/32/

CPDS

The University of Bern Institute for Political Science (Universität Bern, Institut für Politikwissenschaft) maintains comparative political datasets CPDS I,II and III classifying political parties from the OECD and EU into distinct political families. Two of those parties were Libertas parties. The CPDS characterized those parties as follows:

Libertas member/affiliatePolitical familySources
League of Polish FamiliesReligioushttp://www.ipw.unibe.ch/unibe/wiso/ipw/content/e2425/e2426/e3672/e5116/files6358/CodebookCPDSIIIUpdate2008_ger.pdf
Komma FileftheronLiberalhttp://www.ipw.unibe.ch/unibe/wiso/ipw/content/e2425/e2426/e3672/e5109/files5111/CPDSICodebook1960-2006_ger.pdf

Human rights monitors

The Anti-Defamation League, United Nations, and Council of Europe monitor parties for use of racist, xenophobic and/or anti-Semitic discourse. Two of those parties were Libertas parties. They are as follows:

Libertas member/affiliateSources
League of Polish Familieshttps://web.archive.org/web/20081001193732/http://www.adl.org/international/PolandDemocracyandExtremism.pdfhttp://www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/ecri/activities/14-Public_Presentation_Paris_2005/Presentation2005_Paris_study_en.asphttp://daccess-ods.un.org/TMP/6406784.html
Mouvement pour la Francehttp://www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/ecri/activities/14-Public_Presentation_Paris_2005/Presentation2005_Paris_study_en.asphttp://daccess-ods.un.org/TMP/6406784.html

Left-right positions

The Oscarsson and Dahlberg paper "Mapping the European Party Space: Does Party System Simplicity produce Democratic Legitimacy?" characterized parties on the left-right spectrum. Three of those parties were Libertas parties. Oscarsson and Dahlberg characterized those parties as follows (data from 2004):

Libertas member/affiliateScore (0=extreme left, 10=extreme right)Sources
League of Polish Families7.25http://www.pol.gu.se/file/Person/Dahlberg/Mapping%20the%20European%20Party%20Space%20_2005_%20Gabor%20version%2013%20sept.pdf
Komma Fileftheron6.27http://www.pol.gu.se/file/Person/Dahlberg/Mapping%20the%20European%20Party%20Space%20_2005_%20Gabor%20version%2013%20sept.pdf
Mouvement pour la France6.27http://www.pol.gu.se/file/Person/Dahlberg/Mapping%20the%20European%20Party%20Space%20_2005_%20Gabor%20version%2013%20sept.pdf

Notes

  1. http://www.latribune.fr/actualites/economie/union-europeenne/20090304trib000350947/europeennes-frederic-nihous-et-philippe-de-villiers-feront-campagne-commune.html "Européennes : Frédéric Nihous et Philippe de Villiers feront campagne commune"
  2. http://www.lefigaro.fr/politique/2009/03/09/01002-20090309ARTFIG00343-villiers-et-nihous-pour-un-protectionnisme-europeen-.php "Villiers et Nihous pour un «protectionnisme européen»"
  3. http://www.libertas.eu/sweden/181-hjaelp-libertas-bli-ett-registrerat-parti "Hjälp Libertas bli ett registrerat parti"
  4. Web site: EUProfiler:FAQ . 2009-06-03 . 2009-06-26 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090626202129/http://www.euprofiler.eu/faq/ . live .
  5. "Libertas Poland" here refers to the party of that name in Poland, not to the Libertas list of the same name, a coalition of Libertas Poland with NP, PSL Piast, PR, LPF candidates