Polaris Music Prize Explained

Polaris Music Prize
Current Awards:2024 Polaris Music Prize
Awarded For:Best full-length Canadian album based on artistic merit, regardless of genre, sales, or record label.
Country:Canada
Year:2006

The Polaris Music Prize is a music award annually given to the best full-length Canadian album based on artistic merit, regardless of genre, sales, or record label.[1] The award was established in 2006 with a $20,000 cash prize;[2] the prize was increased to $30,000 for the 2011 award.[3] In May 2015, the Polaris Music Prize was increased to $50,000, an additional $20,000, sponsored by Slaight Music. Additionally, second place prizes for the nine other acts on the Short List increased from $2,000 to $3,000. Polaris officials also announced The Slaight Family Polaris Heritage Prize, an award that "will annually honour five albums from the five decades before Polaris launched in 2006." Details about the selection process for this prize are still to be revealed.[4]

The Polaris Music Prize is modeled after the United Kingdom/Ireland's Mercury Prize[5] and in turn, inspired the Atlantis Music Prize/Borealis Music Prize for Newfoundland and Labrador.[6]

Jury and selection process

There is no submission process or entry fee for the Polaris Music Prize.[1] Jurors select what they consider the five best Canadian albums released in the previous year. The ballots are tabulated with each number one pick awarded five points, a number two pick awarded four points and so on. A long list of 40 titles is classified, released in mid-June and promoted to the public. The long list is then sent back to the jury. The jurors then re-submit five top picks from this long list.[1]

These ballots are re-tabulated and the top ten titles form the Polaris short list. This list is released in early July and promoted to the public.[1] A smaller group of 11 jury members ("The Grand Jury") who convene in Toronto at the Polaris Music Prize gala in late September decide the ultimate winner. The decision is finalized during the gala as the nominated bands perform.[2] Grand jurors are selected so that each shortlisted album has one person in the jury room to advocate for it; ten are selected on the basis of having named one of the shortlisted albums as their top pick in the balloting, while the remaining jury position is given to a person who did not vote for any of the shortlisted albums at all.[7]

Polaris Music Prize board of directors selects the jurors.[1] The jury list includes more than 200 Canadian music journalists, bloggers, and broadcasters. To ensure an impartial outcome, no one with direct financial relationships with artists is eligible to become a jury member.[1] The organization itself is a registered, not-for-profit corporation. Another key benefit of enlisting music journalists, broadcasters and bloggers as judges is that increased media coverage draws attention to quality music in a cluttered commercial landscape and an increasingly fractured music scene.[8] [9]

Notable jurors have included former MuchMusic VJs Hannah Sung and Hannah Simone, and Toronto Star music columnist Ben Rayner.[10] Some of the 2018 judges include Lana Gay (Indie88), Mike Bell (YYSCENE), Stuart Derdeyn (Vancouver Province), Stephen Cooke (The Chronicle Herald), Brad Wheeler (The Globe and Mail), Alan Ranta (Exclaim!), Alan Cross (102.1 the edge), CBC Radio personalities Sandra Sperounes, Melody Lau, Lisa Christiansen and Raina Douris and Mitch Pollock, Voir music journalists Patrick Baillargeon and Olivier Boisvert-Magnen, Kimberly Cleave (APTN/Digital Drum) and Carl Wilson.[11]

On November 3, 2014, Jian Ghomeshi, the disgraced former CBC Q host and host of the first Polaris Gala, was removed from the Polaris juror pool. Polaris officials made no official announcement on the subject.[12]

Polaris winners and short list nominees

YearWinnerShortlisted nominees and albums
2006
Final FantasyHe Poos Clouds [13]
2007
Patrick WatsonClose to Paradise [14]
2008
CaribouAndorra [15]
2009
Fucked UpThe Chemistry of Common Life [16]
2010
KarkwaLes Chemins de verre [17]
2011
Arcade FireThe Suburbs [18]
2012
FeistMetals [19]
2013
Godspeed You! Black Emperor'Allelujah! Don't Bend! Ascend! [20]
2014
Tanya TagaqAnimism [21]
2015
Buffy Sainte-MariePower in the Blood [22]
2016
Kaytranada99.9% [23]
2017
Lido PimientaLa Papessa [24]
2018
Jeremy DutcherWolastoqiyik Lintuwakonawa
2019
Haviah Mighty13th Floor
2020
BackxwashGod Has Nothing to Do with This Leave Him Out of It
2021
Cadence WeaponParallel World [25]
2022
Pierre KwendersJosé Louis and the Paradox of LoveShortlist announced in July 2022.[26] [27]
2023
Debby FridayGood Luck
2024
[28]

Slaight Family Polaris Heritage Prize

In 2015, the Polaris jury also launched the Polaris Heritage Prize now known as the Slaight Family Polaris Heritage Prize,[29] an annual award program to honour classic Canadian albums released prior to the creation of the Polaris Prize.[30] Since its inception, the voting categories for Heritage Prize-nominated albums as well as the number of designated albums declared each year have changed multiple times.

In the first year, the Heritage Prizes were awarded in the categories 1960s–70s, 1980s, 1990s and 2000–2005, selected by public vote from a shortlist of five nominees put forward by a Heritage Prize jury. In the second year, the process and categories were revised with the initial shortlists increased to 10, the categories shifted to 1960–75, 1976–85, 1986–1995 and 1996–2005, and the addition of a second prize to be selected by a critical jury alongside the winner of the public vote.[31] The purpose of the jury award is to ensure that albums which were artistically important, but not necessarily as commercially popular, still have a fair shot at being selected as winners; to ensure that two different albums are selected, however, the jury does not meet to vote on its choice until after the popular vote winner has been determined.[31]

Between 2015 and 2018, non-winning nominees in a Heritage Prize category were renominated again, reincorporating all of the non-winning nominees from the previous year, with only the winning albums replaced by new titles. In 2019 Polaris chose to do away with the four time period format, reducing the total number of nominated albums from 40 to 12 and putting those 12 albums in one single category with no separation by time period. There was one public vote album winner and one jury vote winner in 2019. Non-winning albums can still be renominated in a future year, although the shortlists have shown increased variability since the category reduction.

Slaight Family Polaris Heritage Prize winners

YearWinnerCategory
2015Joni Mitchell – Blue1960-70s
Cowboy JunkiesThe Trinity Session1980s
SloanTwice Removed1990s
Peaches – The Teaches of Peaches2000–05
2016Neil YoungAfter the Gold Rush1960–75 public vote
Leonard CohenSongs of Leonard Cohen1960–75 jury vote
RushMoving Pictures1976–85 public vote
Kate & Anna McGarrigle – Kate & Anna McGarrigle1976–85 jury vote
Blue RodeoFive Days in July1986–95 public vote
Mary Margaret O'HaraMiss America1986–95 jury vote
Arcade FireFuneral1996–2005 public vote
Lhasa de SelaLa Llorona1996–2005 jury vote
2017Gordon LightfootLightfoot!1960–75 public vote
The BandThe Band1960–75 jury vote
HarmoniumL'Heptade1976–85 public vote
Glenn GouldThe Goldberg Variations1976–85 jury vote
The Tragically HipFully Completely1986–95 public vote
Eric's TripLove Tara1986–95 jury vote
FeistLet It Die1996–2005 public vote
k-osJoyful Rebellion1996–2005 jury vote
2018Neil YoungEverybody Knows This Is Nowhere1960–75 public vote
Jean-Pierre FerlandJaune1960–75 jury vote
Rush21121976–85 public vote
Bruce CockburnStealing Fire1976–85 jury vote
Alanis Morissette – Jagged Little Pill1986–95 public vote
Dream WarriorsAnd Now the Legacy Begins1986–95 jury vote
Broken Social SceneYou Forgot It In People1996–2005 public vote
Kid KoalaCarpal Tunnel Syndrome1996–2005 jury vote
2019D.O.A.Hardcore 81public vote
Oscar Peterson TrioNight Trainjury vote
2020Beverly Glenn-CopelandKeyboard Fantasiespublic vote
Main SourceBreaking Atomsjury vote (tie)
Buffy Sainte-MarieIt's My Way!
2021NomeansnoWrongpublic vote
Faith NolanAfricvillejury vote
2022SNFU – ...And No One Else Wanted to Playpublic vote
Four the MomentWe're Still Standingjury vote
2023Skinny Puppy – Bitespublic vote
Maestro Fresh WesSymphony in Effectjury vote

Ceremonies

The 2018 Polaris sponsors include the CBC, the Government of Canada, FACTOR, Ontario Media Development Corporation, Slaight Communications, Radio Starmaker Fund, SiriusXM, Stingray Music/Galaxie, The Carlu, Shure Canada, Toronto radio station Indie88, SOCAN, and Re-Sound20.[32] Past sponsors have included Rogers Communications[33] and Scion.[34]

The Polaris Music Prize gala is video streamed live on CBC Music and, previously, AUX.[35]

Presentation venues

Controversies

The Polaris Music Prize can be the subject of intense scrutiny from fans, media and music industry insiders. A number of recurring debates have emerged throughout Polaris' history. Some of these include: perception the prize is either too "indie" or too "mainstream",[36] concern about gender balance amongst nominees and jurors, concern about racial balance amongst nominees and jurors, concern about geographical representation amongst nominees and jurors, and concern about fair representation of specific musical genres. These topics are discussed at length during the open-to-the-public "Polaris Salons" which usually feature Polaris jurors as panellists in various cities across North America during the lead-up to each year's Polaris Gala.[37]

Polaris Prize winners are often the centre of specific controversies as well.

Polaris Prize music releases

In 2006, compilation CD/souvenir program guides featuring one song each from every shortlisted artist were given out at the Polaris Gala. The same was done in 2007 with all shortlisted artists contributing to the compilation CD except Arcade Fire. Between 2008 and 2011, the souvenir program guides instead included download cards for recipients to obtain one song from each of the shortlisted artists.

Polaris began releasing promotional split seven-inch singles beginning in 2012 which were separate from the souvenir program guides. These singles were often given away through campaigns with independent record stores, via contests, at Polaris Salons, or at Polaris Galas.

In recent years, the Polaris Prize has also sponsored a series of promotional singles involving nominated or winning musicians. The "Polaris Cover Sessions"[47] series features past nominees recording a cover of a song by another nominee or Heritage Prize winner, while the "Polaris Collaboration Sessions" series features two past nominees collaborating on new original songs.

2012

Feist and Drake did not participate.

2013

Godspeed You! Black Emperor did not participate.

2014

Drake did not participate.

2015

Polaris Cover Sessions No. 1 (2015) [10 inch]

2016

Polaris Cover Sessions No. 2 (2016) [10 inch]

2017

Polaris Cover Sessions No. 3 (2017) [10 inch]

2018

Polaris Cover Sessions No. 4 (2018) [10 inch]

2019

Polaris Cover Sessions No. 5 (2019) [12 inch]

Polaris collaboration sessions

Polaris, the Banff Centre and Scion Sessions teamed up for a collaborative residency project featuring past shortlisted artists Shad and Holy Fuck. The result was the Scion Sessions-sponsored Holy Shad "Legend of Cy Borg Parts I and II" seven-inch single as well as a documentary video produced by AUX TV.[63]

In 2017, Buffy Sainte-Marie and Tanya Tagaq collaborated on the single "You Got to Run (Spirit of the Wind)".[64] A remix of the song by A Tribe Called Red was commissioned for the seven-inch release. The song was subsequently included on Sainte-Marie's album Medicine Songs.

In 2019, The Weather Station and Jennifer Castle came together to record a two-song split-single. The Weather Station's song was "I Tried To Wear The World (featuring Jennifer Castle)" and Castle's was "Midas Touch (featuring The Weather Station)."[65]

See also

Notes and References

  1. The Prize That Dare Not Speak Its Name . 2009-09-22 . Shasha . Frere-Jones . . September 22, 2009 .
  2. The Indie Rock Swindle . 2010-10-01 . Alexandra . Molotkow . . October 1, 2010 . https://web.archive.org/web/20101201055950/http://walrusmagazine.com/articles/2010.10-music-the-indie-rock-swindle/ . December 1, 2010 . dead .
  3. http://www.aux.tv/2011/06/2011-polaris-music-prize-long-list-announced/ "2011 Polaris Music Prize Long List announced"
  4. Web site: Polaris Music Prize Increased To $50,000 In 2015 – Polaris Music Prize. May 9, 2015. September 25, 2016.
  5. Web site: Polaris Music Prize: An Oral History as told by its founders, jurors, and winners. AUX.TV. November 25, 2014. https://web.archive.org/web/20130707004641/http://www.aux.tv/2012/07/polaris-music-prize-an-oral-history-as-told-by-its-founders-jurors-and-winners/. July 7, 2013. dead.
  6. The Polaris Music Prize Will Go To Canada's Best Album . https://web.archive.org/web/20110607171434/http://www.chartattack.com/news/41260/the-polaris-music-prize-will-go-to-canadas-best-album . usurped . June 7, 2011 . 2009-07-25 . Steve . McLean . . June 2, 2006 .
  7. Here and Now, September 22, 2014.
  8. News: Finn. Brad. Should it be called the Polaris 'Indie' Music Prize?. The Globe and Mail. Toronto. September 1, 2010.
  9. Web site: Predicting Polaris: Picking Canada's Best Album. September 26, 2008. August 29, 2012. https://web.archive.org/web/20120829154253/http://music.aol.ca/. dead.
  10. News: Sindrey. Curtis. Toronto music journalists debate 2012 Polaris Music Prize short-list on eve of gala. September 9, 2013. Aesthetic Magazine, Toronto. September 19, 2012.
  11. Web site: Polaris Prize Jury . polarismusicprize.ca . April 23, 2018.
  12. Web site: Polaris Music Prize removes Jian Ghomeshi from its jury . thestar.com . November 3, 2014 . April 23, 2018.
  13. News: Indie favourites among finalists for Polaris Music Prize . CBC News . July 4, 2010 . November 21, 2010. dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20070523171607/http://www.cbc.ca/arts/story/2006/07/04/polaris-prize-nominees.html . May 23, 2007 .
  14. Web site: 2007 Nominees – Polaris Music Prize Shortlist . polarismusicprize.ca . https://web.archive.org/web/20180423220147/https://polarismusicprize.ca/2007-nominees/ . April 23, 2018 . live . April 23, 2018.
  15. News: Rockers dominate Polaris prize short list . CBC News . July 7, 2008 . November 21, 2010 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20081004130901/http://www.cbc.ca/arts/music/story/2008/07/07/polaris-shortlist.html . October 4, 2008 .
  16. Ladies and Gentleman, the 2009 Short List . Polaris Music Prize . July 7, 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20110110100150/http://www.polarismusicprize.ca/blog/44 . January 10, 2011 . live . November 21, 2010.
  17. Web site: 2010 Nominees Polaris Music Prize . polarismusicprize.ca . April 24, 2018.
  18. News: Polaris Music Prize Rolls Out 2011 Short List . . July 6, 2011 . July 6, 2011. dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20121007083848/http://exclaim.ca/News/polaris_music_prize_rolls_out_2011_short_list. October 7, 2012.
  19. Web site: Polaris Music Prize 2012 Nominees . polarismusicprize.ca . April 24, 2018.
  20. News: Polaris Music Prize 2013 Short List Is Here . Polaris Music Prize . July 16, 2013 . July 16, 2013. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20140219121134/http://polarismusicprize.ca/article/648/polaris-music-prize-2013-short-list-is-here/. February 19, 2014.
  21. Web site: Polaris Prize Nominees 2014 . polarismusicprize.ca . April 24, 2018.
  22. Web site: Polaris Music Prize Nominees 2015 . polarismusicprize.ca . April 24, 2018.
  23. Web site: Polaris Music Prizde Nominees 2016 . polarismusicprize.ca . April 24, 2018.
  24. Web site: Polaris Music Prize Nominees 2017 . polarismusicprize.ca . April 24, 2018 . April 24, 2018 . https://web.archive.org/web/20180424204047/https://polarismusicprize.ca/2018-short-list/ . dead .
  25. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/arts/music/article-cadence-weapon-wins-polaris-music-prize-for-parallel-world/ "Cadence Weapon wins Polaris Music Prize for Parallel World"
  26. Web site: Quebec comes in strong, Shad extends his history making record on Polaris short list Globalnews.ca . 2022-07-15 . Global News . en-US.
  27. Web site: 2022 Short List . 2022-07-15 . Polaris Music Prize . en.
  28. News: Chelosky . Danielle . July 11, 2024 . Polaris Music Prize 2024 Shortlist Includes Cindy Lee, The Beaches, Allison Russell, & More . July 13, 2024 . Stereogum.
  29. Web site: About the Heritage Prize . polarismusicprize.ca . April 23, 2018.
  30. http://exclaim.ca/Music/article/polaris_music_prize_announces_heritage_prize_nominees "Polaris Music Prize Announces Heritage Prize Nominees"
  31. http://www.billboard.com/articles/news/7556695/polaris-heritage-prize-arcade-fire-neil-young-rush-leonard-cohen "Arcade Fire, Neil Young and Rush Among Winners of Polaris Heritage Prize"
  32. Web site: Polaris Music Prize Sponsors. April 23, 2018. polarismusicprize.ca.
  33. Web site: Sirius Sponsors Polaris Music Prize. April 23, 2018. billboard.com.
  34. Web site: Scion Canada supports Canadian talent as new presenting sponsor of Polaris Music Prize. April 23, 2018. media.scion.ca. March 22, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210322020329/https://s7.addthis.com/js/300/addthis_widget.js. dead.
  35. News: Wheeler. Brad. October 1, 2010. Should it be called the Polaris 'Indie' Music Prize?. The Globe and Mail. 2010-10-01.
  36. News: Should it be called the Polaris 'Indie' Music Prize?. The Globe and Mail. November 25, 2014.
  37. Web site: Polaris Salons Announced For Toronto, Ottawa, Vancouver, Montreal, Halifax . polarismusicprize.ca . August 28, 2013 . April 24, 2018.
  38. Web site: F***** Up (language alert, language alert below) wins the 2009 Polaris Music Prize on Monday night, Ancaster's Simone Caruso wins the 29th youth talent competition at the Western Fair on Sunday before a packed London City Music Theatre. https://archive.today/20141124232954/http://blogs.canoe.ca/brandnewblog/entertainment/f-up-language-alert-language-alert-below-wins-the-2009-polaris-music-prize-on-monday-night-ancasters-simone-caruso-wins-the-29th-youth-talent-competition-at-the-western-fair-on-sunday-befo/. usurped. November 24, 2014. james-reaney. James' Brand New Blog. November 25, 2014.
  39. News: Toronto hardcore band wins Polaris Music Prize. The Globe and Mail. November 25, 2014.
  40. The Prize That Dare Not Speak Its Name. September 22, 2009. The New Yorker. November 25, 2014.
  41. Web site: A Brief History of the Times' Valiant Attempts to Give Fucked Up Press Without Mentioning Them by Name. Rob Harvilla. May 11, 2009. Sound of the City. November 25, 2014.
  42. Web site: Godspeed You! Black Emperor Win The 2013 Polaris Music Prize. Polaris Music Prize. September 23, 2013. November 25, 2014.
  43. Web site: Statement from Godspeed You! Black Emperor on Polaris – Constellation Records. November 25, 2014. November 25, 2014. https://web.archive.org/web/20141125065909/http://cstrecords.com/statement-from-godspeed-you-black-emperor-on-polaris/. dead.
  44. Web site: People Hating on Tanya Tagaq's 'Fuck PETA' Polaris Speech Are Missing the Point. VICE. September 27, 2014 . November 25, 2014.
  45. Web site: Tanya Tagaq: Being An Aboriginal Woman Is Like Being Scared At A Horror Movie. All The Time. The Huffington Post. October 8, 2014. November 25, 2014.
  46. News: Lido Pimienta launches expletive-driven speech as she wins Polaris Music Prize. NATIONAL POST. September 19, 2017 . January 4, 2018.
  47. Web site: Free Polaris Cover Sessions 10-Inch Vinyl At Select Retailers . polarismusic.ca . October 7, 2015 . April 24, 2018.
  48. Web site: WATCH: Sarah Harmer Cover Caribou's 'Odessa' . polarismusicprize.ca . August 21, 2014 . April 24, 2018.
  49. Web site: WATCH: Whitehorse Covers New Pornographers' 'Bones Of An Idol' . polarismusicprize.ca . September 3, 2014 . April 24, 2018.
  50. Web site: WATCH: Great Lake Swimmers Cover Sarah Harmer's 'I'm A Mountain' . polarismusicprize.ca . August 27, 2014 . April 24, 2018.
  51. Web site: Arkells Cover Owen Pallett's 'I Am Not Afraid' For Polaris Cover Sessions #4 . polarismusicprize.ca . October 8, 2015 . April 24, 2018.
  52. Web site: Zaki Ibrahim Covers Leonard Cohen's 'Show Me The Place' For Polaris Cover Sessions #6 . polarismusicprize.ca . July 11, 2016 . April 24, 2018.
  53. Web site: Joel Plaskett Covers Feist's 'Bittersweet Melodies' For Polaris Cover Sessions #5 . polarismusicprize.ca . April 25, 2016 . April 24, 2018.
  54. Web site: Little Scream Does Mary Margaret O'Hara's "Anew Day" For SiriusXM Polaris Cover Session . polarismusicprize.ca . July 25, 2017 . April 24, 2018.
  55. Web site: Hannah Georgas Does Arcade Fire's "Crown Of Love" For Latest SiriusXM Polaris Cover Session . polarismusicprize.ca . May 24, 2017 . April 24, 2018.
  56. News: Les soeurs Boulay Do Kate & Anna McGarrigle To Launch 2017 SiriusXM Polaris Cover Sessions . Polaris Music Prize . March 27, 2017 . April 24, 2018 . Brophy . Aaron .
  57. Web site: Jean-Michel Blais Covers Feist's "Mushaboom" For SiriusXM Polaris Cover Sessions . polarismusicprize.ca . August 7, 2018 . December 10, 2019.
  58. Web site: Weaves Do Arcade Fire's "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" For SiriusXM Polaris Cover Session . polarismusicprize.ca . May 8, 2018 . December 10, 2019.
  59. Web site: Lindi Ortega Covers Leonard Cohen's "Suzanne" For SiriusXM Polaris Cover Sessions . polarismusicprize.ca . June 13, 2018 . December 10, 2019.
  60. Web site: Faith Healer Covers The Band's "When You Awake" For SiriusXM Polaris Cover Sessions . polarismusicprize.ca . July 3, 2019 . December 10, 2019.
  61. Web site: Partner Covers Rush's "Limelight" For SiriusXM Polaris Cover Sessions . polarismusicprize.ca . August 28, 2019 . December 10, 2019.
  62. Web site: Pierre Kwenders Covers Jean-Pierre Ferland's "It Ain't Fair" For SiriusXM Polaris Cover Sessions . polarismusicprize.ca . June 12, 2019 . December 10, 2019.
  63. Web site: Shad and Holy Fuck (Holy Shad) 7-inch Collaboration (Behind-the-Scenes). AUX. September 8, 2014. September 25, 2016. YouTube.
  64. Web site: Buffy Sainte-Marie And Tanya Tagaq Team Up For Polaris Collaboration Session . polarismusicprize.ca . February 21, 2017 . April 24, 2018.
  65. Web site: The Weather Station & Jennifer Castle Polaris-Stingray Seven-Inch Available Free For Record Store Day Canada . polarismusicprize.ca . April 3, 2019 . December 10, 2019.