2010 Philippine House of Representatives elections explained

Election Name:2010 Philippine House of Representatives elections
Type:parliamentary
Noleader:yes
Ongoing:no
Seats For Election:All 286 seats to the House of Representatives of the Philippines
Majority Seats:144
Country:Philippines
Previous Election:2007
Next Election:2013
Module:
Embed:yes
Election Name:Congressional district elections
Noleader:yes
Party1:Lakas Kampi CMD
Last Election1:0
Percentage1:37.41
Seats1:106
Party2:Liberal Party (Philippines)
Last Election2:23
Percentage2:19.93
Seats2:47
Party3:Nationalist People's Coalition
Last Election3:28
Percentage3:15.97
Seats3:29
Party4:Nacionalista Party
Last Election4:11
Percentage4:11.35
Seats4:25
Party5:Others
Last Election5:22
Percentage5:12.78
Seats5:22
Module:
Embed:yes
Election Name:Party-list election
Noleader:yes
Party1:Ako Bicol
Last Election1:0
Percentage1:5.06
Seats1:3
Party2:Senior Citizens
Last Election2:1
Percentage2:4.31
Seats2:2
Party3:Buhay
Last Election3:3
Percentage3:4.16
Seats3:2
Party4:Akbayan
Last Election4:2
Percentage4:3.53
Seats4:2
Party5:Gabriela Women's Party
Last Election5:2
Percentage5:3.35
Seats5:2
Party6:Coop-NATCCO
Last Election6:2
Percentage6:3.14
Seats6:2
Party7:1-CARE
Last Election7:0
Percentage7:2.56
Seats7:2
Party8:Abono
Last Election8:2
Percentage8:2.55
Seats8:2
Party9:Bayan Muna
Last Election9:3
Percentage9:2.49
Seats9:2
Party10:An Waray
Last Election10:2
Percentage10:2.37
Seats10:2
Party11:CIBAC
Last Election11:2
Percentage11:2.17
Seats11:2
Party12:A TEACHER
Last Election12:2
Percentage12:2.05
Seats12:2
Party13:Others
Last Election13:20
Percentage13:30.47
Seats13:32
Map:2010PhilippineHouseElections.png
Speaker
Before Election:Prospero Nograles
Before Party:Lakas Kampi CMD
After Election:Feliciano Belmonte Jr.
After Party:Liberal Party (Philippines)

The 2010 Philippine House of Representatives elections were held on May 10, 2010, to elect members to the House of Representatives of the Philippines to serve in the 15th Congress of the Philippines from June 30, 2010, to June 30, 2013. The Philippines uses parallel voting for seats in the House of Representatives; a voter has two votes: one for a representative from one's legislative district, and another for a sectoral representative via closed lists under the party-list system, with a 2% election threshold and 3-seat cap, when the parties with 2% of the national vote or more not meeting the 20% of the total seats, parties with less than 2% of the vote will get one seat each until the 20% requirement is met.

In district elections, 229 single-member districts elect one member of the House of Representatives. The candidate with the highest number of votes wins that district's seat. In the party-list election, parties will dispute 57 seats. In all, the 15th Congress will have 286 members, with 144 votes being the majority. No party entered candidates in all districts, but only Lakas Kampi CMD entered enough candidates to win an outright majority.

By May 21, GMA News and Public Affairs, based on their partial and unofficial tally, had Lakas Kampi CMD with the party with the most seats with 109, followed by the Liberal Party with 43, the Nationalist People's Coalition had 33, and the Nacionalista Party had 25. The other parties garnered 13 seats. This includes candidates who switched parties after the campaign period has begun, while excluding party-list representatives.[1]

In the party-list election, Ako Bicol Political Party topped the election getting 5% of the national vote and won three seats, but their proclamation was delayed as a disqualification case against them was brought up; their first three nominees were subsequently seated with the dismissal of the case.[2] As much as 43 other parties qualified to win seats, and all but two were yet to be seated due to pending disqualification cases.

Despite being the party leader and winning a congressional seat in Pampanga, Lakas Kampi CMD leader and sitting president Gloria Macapagal Arroyo had reportedly declined to run as Speaker and is fielding Edcel Lagman of Albay on the basis of term–sharing with Danilo Suarez of Quezon if they win the speakership.[3] Meanwhile, the Liberals will be fielding in former Speaker Feliciano Belmonte Jr. of Quezon City, who was also a former Lakas Kampi member. Incumbent Speaker Prospero Nograles is barred from seeking office in the House after serving three consecutive terms; he was defeated in the Davao City mayoralty election, although his son successfully kept his father's seat.

Notable celebrities who won include Imelda Marcos (KBL, Ilocos Norte–2nd), Lani Mercado (Lakas Kampi, Cavite–2nd), Lucy Torres (Liberal, Leyte–4th) and Manny Pacquiao (PCM, Saranggani).

With the Liberals, Nacionalistas, the NPC, a faction of Lakas-Kampi, other minor parties and most of the party-list groups voting for him, Belmonte was easily elected as Speaker, with 227 votes, as compared to 29 votes of Lagman.[4]

Redistricting

There are several new districts; most notable is the redistricting of Cavite from three legislative districts to seven. Only the old first district remained intact, except for Bacoor being separated and being named as the new second district; all other districts were redistricted anew.

Province/City14th CongressImplementing law(s)
1 2 R.A. 9508
1 2 R.A. 9725
4 5 R.A. 9716
3 7 R.A. 9727
New R.A. 9724
New R.A. 9726
New R.A. 9387
New R.A. 9387
Total new seats 10

The election in the Dinagat Islands is in limbo as the Supreme Court earlier ruled that the Dinagat Islands' creation as a province from Surigao del Norte was unconstitutional for not having met the provisions of the constitution on population and land area. However, the court's decision has yet to be final pending motions for reconsideration, and the commission allowed the elections to take place. If the Supreme Court finalizes its decision on the dissolution of the Dinagat Islands, the provincial-level and congressional elections held in both areas, and in the areas they were originally carved from will be voided and new elections will take place. (This will be for Surigao del Norte's province-level positions, and the first congressional district of the province. City and municipal-level elections and the 2nd district congressional election will not be affected.) If the decision is upheld, there will be 58 sectoral representatives.

Malolos, which was supposed to have its own congressional district from Bulacan's 1st district, but it was nullified with finality by the Supreme Court for having insufficient population. However, the ballots for both Malolos and the 1st district excluding Malolos were printed after the decision was finalized. As such, the elections for representative in Malolos and the 1st district were deferred, and voting done on May 10 was invalidated, and an election will be scheduled solely for the representative's position (all positions elected were upheld, with Malolos' first eight councilor candidates winning seats in the City Council, as opposed to the ten originally provided in the enabling law).[5]

Retiring and term-limited incumbents

See main article: Retiring and term-limited incumbents in the Philippine House of Representatives elections, 2010. As of now, there are 68 Representatives that are either term-limited or retiring from Congress.

Campaign

Campaigns in House of Representatives elections are usually conducted on a district-by-district basis; there is no nationwide campaign. The races are between local politicians in the districts, and their allegiances and parties may switch from their announcement on the intention to run, registering as a candidate, printing out of ballots, election day and from the convening of the 15th Congress. The sitting president's party usually controls the House of Representatives no matter the election result.

The Lakas-Kampi titular head, President Arroyo, became the first president to run for a seat in the House of Representatives after her term as president; the party had the most number of candidates, and was the only party that can win an outright majority as the other parties did not run in a majority of the seats. Lakas-Kampi aimed to secure enough votes to impeach (96) as leverage if their presidential candidate Gilberto Teodoro does not win.

The Liberal Party chose former Lakas-Kampi stalwart and Quezon City mayor Feliciano Belmonte Jr. as their candidate for the speakership. Belmonte, a former speaker while being a member of Lakas-CMD (one of the two parties that formed Lakas-Kampi), defected to the Liberals before the election. The Nacionalista Party would also field a candidate for the speakership. The Nationalist People's Coalition usually supports the policies of the sitting president, while the sectoral representatives, except for those leaning to the left, also support whoever is in power. The other parties that fielded candidates on the presidential election would support their own presidential candidate, but it is unknown if they would've supported the party of the winning president; these parties fielded candidates in a minority of seats.

Notable races

Ilocos Region

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in the Ilocos Region, 2010.

Cordillera Administrative Region

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in the Cordillera Administrative Region, 2010.

Central Luzon

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in Central Luzon, 2010.

Metro Manila

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in Metro Manila, 2010.

Calabarzon

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in Calabarzon, 2010.

Central Visayas

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in Central Visayas, 2010.

Eastern Visayas

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in Eastern Visayas, 2010.

Davao Region

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in the Davao Region, 2010.

Soccsksargen

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives elections in Soccsksargen, 2010.

Party-list

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives party-list election, 2010. Several party-list organizations were delisted, added to the list, disqualified and re-listed in the run-up to the election, most notably LGBT party Ang Ladlad which secured a Supreme Court injunction preventing COMELEC from disqualifying them. Mikey Arroyo's nomination by Ang Galing Pinoy, a party representing tricycle drivers and security guards, and other personalities of the Arroyo administration that were nominated by supposedly underrepresented sectors had also been questioned.

Defeated incumbents

District Party Incumbent Winner Party
AbraJoy Bernos-Valera
Albay–3rdFernando Gonzalez
BatanesDina Abad
BiliranRogelio Espina
Bukidnon–2ndJesus Emmanuel Paras
Camarines Norte–2ndElmer Panotes
Cotabato–1stNancy Catamco
Eastern SamarBen Evardone
Iloilo CityJerry Treñas
Maguindanao–1stBai Sandra Sema
Manila–6thRosenda Ocampo
PasayImelda Calixto-Rubiano
Quezon City–3rdJorge Banal Jr.
Sultan Kudarat–1stRaden Sakaluran
Sulu–1stTupay Loong
Taguig–2ndSigfrido Tinga

Open seat gains

  1. Antipolo's 2nd legislative district (Independent gain)
  2. Bacolod's legislative district (NPC gain)
  3. Basilan's legislative district (Independent gain)
  4. Batangas's 1st legislative district (Liberal gain)
  5. Batangas's 3rd legislative district (PMP gain)
  6. Benguet's legislative district (Liberal gain)
  7. Bohol's 1st legislative district (LDP gain)
  8. Bohol's 2nd legislative district (Nacionalista gain)
  9. Bukidnon's 2nd legislative district (Lakas Kampi CMD gain)
  10. Bulacan's 3rd legislative district (Liberal gain)
  11. Bulacan's 4th legislative district (Liberal gain)
  12. Cagayan's 3rd legislative district (Lakas Kampi CMD gain)
  13. Cagayan de Oro's 1st legislative district (PMP gain)
  14. Cebu City's 2nd legislative district (Liberal gain)
  15. Ilocos Norte's 1st legislative district (Nacionalista gain)
  16. Ilocos Norte's 2nd legislative district (KBL gain)
  17. Lanao del Norte's 1st legislative district (Lakas Kampi CMD gain)
  18. Leyte's 4th legislative district (Liberal gain)
  19. Marinduque's legislative district (Lakas Kampi CMD gain)
  20. Misamis Oriental's legislative district (PMP gain)
  21. North Cotabato's 2nd legislative district (Lakas Kampi CMD gain)
  22. Pangasinan's 4th legislative district (NPC gain)
  23. Parañaque's 1st legislative district (Liberal gain)
  24. Pateros/Taguig's legislative district (Liberal gain)
  25. Quezon City's 1st legislative district (Liberal gain)
  26. San Juan's legislative district (PMP gain)
  27. Sarangani's legislative district (Nacionalista gain)
  28. Sorsogon's 2nd legislative district (Liberal gain)
  29. South Cotabato's 2nd legislative district (NPC gain)
  30. Tarlac's 1st legislative district (NPC gain)

Results

District elections

In district elections, the candidate with the highest number of votes in the district wins that district's seat.Even prior to the election when Lakas Kampi CMD members switched parties to either the Liberals or the Nacionalistas, they still suffered the biggest seat losses, although they still retained the plurality of seats in the House. The Liberals and Nacionalistas all gained seats but will not surpass the number of Lakas Kampi's seats. Lakas Kampi also tallied the most votes, but had a disproportionate number of seats won (38% of the vote as compared to 45% of the district seats).

A total of seven independents won in the House.

Party-list election

See main article: Philippine House of Representatives party-list election, 2010. In party-list elections, parties nominate three persons to be their candidates, ranked in order of which they will be seated if elected.

Candidates from the district elections are not allowed to be nominated by the parties participating in the party-list election, nor are parties who have candidates in the district elections may be allowed to join the party-list election; the parties in the party-list election must represent a distinct "sector" in the society such as women, laborers and the like.

In the election, the voter elects the party, not the nominees of the party (closed list). If the party surpasses 2% of the national vote, the person first nominated by the party will be seated. Additional seats can be won depending on the number of votes the party garnered in the election (see the formula), although a party can only win up to three seats. If there are still empty seats, parties with less than 2% of the vote will be ranked in descending order, then will have one seat each until all of the seats have been filled up.

On May 31, the leading parties in the party-list election were declared by the commission as winners; deferred are the parties (not nominees) that have pending disqualification cases against them. According to Ang Galing Pinoy's proclamation, the party of incumbent Pampanga 2nd district representative Mikey Arroyo was recalled as Arroyo has a pending disqualification notice against him, and he is their No. 1 nominee.[14]

Details

Shading refers to the party that won a plurality of seats:

DetailsSeats won per party Total seats
Others & ind.
IElections
IIElections
IIIElections
IV–AElections
IV–BElections
VElections
VIElections
VIIElections
VIIIElections
IXElections
XElections
XIElections
XIIElections
CaragaElections
ARMMElections
CARElections
NCRElections
Party-listElection
Total

Aftermath

See main article: 15th Congress of the Philippines. Several congressmen-elect have already defected to the Liberal Party as response to Noynoy Aquino's victory in the presidential election.[15] This comes as Negros Occidental representative Iggy Arroyo said that Lakas Kampi CMD has the number to elect his sister-in-law and representative-elect President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo as speaker as she is pushed by to run for the speakership.[16] Congressman-elect and former speaker Feliciano Belmonte Jr. (formerly of Lakas Kampi) has emerged to be the Liberal Party's leading candidate for speaker.[17] The anti-Arroyo representatives have formed the Conscience and Reform (CORE) coalition to strengthen their ranks.[18]

However, Arroyo had repeatedly declined Lakas Kampi's prodding to run for speaker. Three Lakas Kampi congressmen instead made themselves available to run for speaker: Edcel Lagman (Albay), Danilo Suarez (Quezon) and Elpidio Barzaga Jr. (Dasmariñas) in a party caucus.[19] It was agreed upon that while Arroyo "will still call the shots," Lagman will run for the speakership, and if elected, will serve for the first 18 months, then Suarez will serve the remainder.[3]

On June 25, the Liberal Party swore in congressmen as new members, mostly defecting from Lakas-Kampi. Most Lakas-Kampi congressmen jumpred ship after Arroyo declined being their party's candidate for speaker.[20] With the House "tradition" in which congressmen align themselves with the party of the president, Belmonte now has at least 150 congressmen pledging support for him, including 75 from the Liberal Party, members of the Nationalist People's Coalition (NPC), Nacionalistas, PDP–Laban, party-list groups, and "some 55" members of the Lakas-Kampi independent bloc.[21]

The House of Representatives convened on July 26, with Joseph Emilio Abaya (Cavite) nominating Belmonte for Speaker; Rodolfo Albano (Isabela), Danilo Suarez (Quezon) and Augusto Syjuco (Iloilo) nominated Lagman. Belmonte was elected Speaker with 227 votes, while Lagman got 29 votes.[4]

Speakership election
Party width=15%Belmonte !width=15%Lagman !width=15% rowspan=2Total
19* 26 45
21 1 22
bgcolor=whiteOther district representatives 161 1* 162
bgcolor=blackParty-list representatives 26 1 27
Totals 227 29 256

Special elections

External links

Results

Media websites

Notes and References

  1. News: Fight for Speakership could bring Arroyo down to earth . GMANews.TV Staff . GMANews.TV . 2010-05-21 . 2010-06-01.
  2. News: Comelec dismisses petition vs AKO Bicol Party-list . . 2010-07-28 . 2011-12-26.
  3. News: Lakas-Kampi leaders agree to term sharing for Speakership . . 2010-06-04 . 2010-06-04 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100607024322/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/nation/view/20100604-273792/Lakas-Kampi-leaders-agree-to-term-sharing-for-Speakership . 2010-06-07 .
  4. News: Belmonte is new House Speaker . Lira . Dalangin-Fernandez . INQUIRER.net . 2010-07-26 . 2010-07-26 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100727200249/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/nation/view/20100726-283237/Belmonte-is-new-House-Speaker . 2010-07-27 .
  5. News: Bulacan to have special election after May 10 . Kimberly Jane . Tan . GMANews.tv . 2010-04-19 . 2010-05-31.
  6. News: Pangasinan's six districts field women candidates . Eva Visperas and Jaime Laude . https://archive.today/20130131074342/http://www.philstar.com/article.aspx?articleid=529753 . dead . 2013-01-31 . . 2009-12-06 . 2010-01-08 .
  7. News: New Malabon-Navotas lawmaker sworn in . https://archive.today/20120908214230/http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=524040&publicationSubCategoryId=65 . dead . 2012-09-08 . Jerry . Botial . . 2009-11-17 . 2010-01-31 .
  8. News: Appeals court: Lucio Tan's daughter can't run . Rey . Requejo . . 2010-04-22 . 2010-04-28.
  9. News: Reyes' son is new Taguig congressman . Gil . Cabacungan . . 2010-03-01 . 2010-03-01 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100302231156/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/inquirerheadlines/metro/view/20100301-255979/Reyes-son-is-new-Taguig-congressman . 2010-03-02 .
  10. News: Arthur Yap runs unopposed in Bohol. 2009-12-03. Philippine Daily Inquirer. 2010-02-18. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20091206042204/http://globalnation.inquirer.net/cebudailynews/community/view/20091203-239895/Arthur-Yap-runs-unopposed-in-Bohol. 2009-12-06.
  11. News: Nograles hit for stalling on solon's oath . Leila . Salaverria . . 2010-01-28 . 2010-01-28 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100130051910/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/nation/view/20100128-249879/Nograles-hit-for-stalling-on-solons-oath . 2010-01-30 .
  12. http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=551916&publicationSubCategoryId=107 Cuenco gets top post in ASEAN assembly - Philstar.com
  13. News: Pacquiao vs Chiongbian . . 2009-10-25 . 2010-01-29.
  14. News: Mikey Arroyo leads 35 party-list solons . Jerome Aning, Tarra Quismundo . . 2010-06-01 . 2010-06-21 . https://web.archive.org/web/20100603025133/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/inquirerheadlines/nation/view/20100601-273152/Mikey-Arroyo-leads-35-party-list-solons . 2010-06-03 . dead .
  15. http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=587790&publicationSubCategoryId=63{{Dead link|date=November 2018 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}
  16. News: Arroyo to run for speaker, says brother-in-law . Carla . Gomez . . 2010-05-12 . 2010-05-21 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100516040004/http://politics.inquirer.net/politics/view/20100512-269604/Arroyo-to-run-for-speaker-says-brother-in-law . 2010-05-16 .
  17. News: LP to pit Belmonte vs Arroyo for Speaker . . 2010-05-14 . 2010-05-18 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100516033912/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/inquirerheadlines/nation/view/20100514-269835/LP-to-pit-Belmonte-vs-Arroyo-for-Speaker . 2010-05-16 .
  18. News: Gil Jr . Cabacungan . Aquino House forces forming 'CORE' to stop Arroyo bid for Speaker . . 2010-05-14 . 2010-06-21 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100516033917/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/inquirerheadlines/nation/view/20100514-269836/Aquino-House-forces-forming-CORE-to-stop-Arroyo-bid-for-Speaker . 2010-05-16 .
  19. News: Arroyo not running for Speaker as 3 Lakas step up to plate . . 2010-05-19 . 2010-05-21 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100521135557/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/nation/view/20100519-270965/Arroyo-not-running-for-Speaker-as-3-Lakas-step-up-to-plate . 2010-05-21 .
  20. News: Vicente . Labro . Arroyo allies jumping to LP as political realignment starts . . 2010-06-28 . 2010-07-20 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100701074839/http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/inquirerheadlines/regions/view/20100628-278070/Arroyo-allies-jumping-to-LP-as-political-realignment-starts . 2010-07-01 .
  21. News: RG . Cruz . House reorganization just a formality . ABS-CBN News . 2010-07-06 . 2010-07-20.