Phantom ballplayer explained

A phantom ballplayer is either a baseball player who is incorrectly listed in source materials as playing in a Major League Baseball (MLB) game, often the result of typographical or clerical errors, or a player who spent time on an MLB active roster without ever appearing in an MLB contest during his career. Most of the first form of phantom players date from the 19th or early 20th century, with at least one showing up as late as World War II.

A modern-day phantom ballplayer is generally caused by the player being removed from the active roster by a subsequent action (such as being optioned to a minor league team) or the team reaching the end of their season, and the player not having later opportunity to play in a major league game. Many of these phantom players were September call-ups in backup roles.

Phantoms who never were

Real players who never played

Research by the Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) has identified over 400 players who appeared on major league rosters, but did not appear in a major league game, since 1884.[3] A number of examples are presented here.

Pre-1950

1950s

1960s

1970s

1980s

1990s

2000s

2010s

2020s

denotes an active professional baseball player who could lose phantom status if he returns to the major leagues and appears in a game

Honorable mentions

Baseball-Reference.com maintains lists of players who have appeared in only a single major league game; as of April 2024, there are over 1,500 batters and over 700 pitchers listed.[160]

See main article: Cup of coffee.

Other players who had notable experiences similar to phantom ballplayers include:

Not officially on a major-league roster

Passing phantoms

Some players have gone years between first being listed on an MLB active roster without playing (thus becoming phantoms), and eventually appearing in an MLB game (thus losing phantom status). Examples include:

Rookie cards

Makers of baseball cards have issued major league rookie cards featuring some players who never actually played in MLB. Two known examples are listed below. Starting in 2005, the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA) required card manufacturers to limit rookie cards to players already added to an MLB active roster, or players who appeared in an MLB game during the prior season.[177] Note that card makers also issue cards of "future stars", "top prospects", or similar wording, which are not rookie cards and are speculative in nature.

Special circumstances

See also

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Book: The Official Encyclopedia of Baseball . Hy . Turkin . Hy Turkin . S. C. . Thompson . S. C. Thompson . . . 1956 . 56-5560.
  2. Book: This Great Game . Doris Townsend . Prentice-Hall . 1971 . 0139190767 . 242 . registration .
  3. Web site: Near Major Leaguers . Bill . Hickman . . . October 8, 2017 . July 4, 2018.
  4. News: Kid Gleason Promises Chicago Fans the Pennant . . 12 . April 17, 1919 . June 3, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  5. News: Bill Stewart to Join White Sox . . . 6 . December 14, 1918 . June 3, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  6. Web site: Wezen-Ball: Bill Stewart, MLB Umpire & NHL Referee (and coach!) . Larry . Granillo . baseballprospectus.com . April 28, 2011 . June 12, 2022.
  7. Web site: Umpire Card for Bill Stewart . . . June 3, 2018.
  8. News: Harvard First Sacker Will Join Athletics . . 15 . June 28, 1920 . June 12, 2022 . newspapers.com.
  9. News: Harvard Twirler Goes to Hanover in Trade . Harrisburg Telegraph . . 13 . July 8, 1920 . June 12, 2022 . newspapers.com.
  10. News: Connie Mack Recalls Jones . The Evening Sun . . 3 . July 24, 1920 . June 12, 2022 . newspapers.com.
  11. News: (untitled) . . . 11 . August 2, 1920 . June 12, 2022 . newspapers.com.
  12. Web site: Lou Almada Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  13. Web site: Giants 'Farm' Almada . Newspapers.com . May 18, 1927 . January 2, 2022.
  14. News: Baseball career info. Arizona Daily Star. April 24, 1968. 22.
  15. Web site: Jake Levy Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  16. News: May Fill Bill . . . 12 . September 13, 1927 . June 1, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  17. Book: The Big Book of Jewish Baseball: An Illustrated Encyclopedia & Anecdotal History . Peter S. . Horvitz . Joachim . Horvitz . S.P.I. Books . 2001 . 1561719730 .
  18. Web site: Al Olsen Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  19. News: Brown to Quit Baseball After Boston Failure . Harrisburg Telegraph . . . 18 . April 23, 1943 . May 31, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  20. Web site: Al Olsen Minor League Statistics & History . . May 31, 2018.
  21. News: Sports of the Times; The Ghost Who Batted For Boston. The New York Times . January 31, 1990 . October 5, 2011 . Ira . Berkow.
  22. Web site: Chicago White Sox 4, Boston Red Sox 2 (1) . . May 16, 1943 . May 31, 2018.
  23. Web site: Boston Red Sox 4, Chicago White Sox 2 (2) . . May 16, 1943 . May 31, 2018.
  24. News: Brooklyn Recalls Bill Sharman, Lembo . Elmira Advertiser . . . 8 . September 19, 1951 . June 1, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  25. News: This Caused Rhubarb . . 18 . September 28, 1951 . June 1, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  26. https://vault.si.com/vault/1971/04/12/best-damn-team-in-baseball Deford, Frank. "Best Damn Team in Baseball," Sports Illustrated, April 12, 1971.
  27. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/richards-influence-on-baseball-philosophy-still-resonates-today Wood, Phil. "Richards' influence on baseball philosophy still resonates today," Washington Examiner, Saturday, September 12, 2009.
  28. https://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.fcgi?id=swango001joh Bruce Swango  - Baseball Reference.
  29. News: Series Lineups . . . 37 . October 7, 1964 . June 29, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  30. News: Frick Announces Series Eligibles . . . . 39 . September 25, 1964 . July 6, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  31. Web site: Ike Futch Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  32. News: Sports (column) . . 17 . June 27, 1966 . June 6, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  33. Web site: Maurice Ogier Minor & Winter Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  34. News: Twins Reactivate Kaat; Send Ogier To Farm System . . . . 15 . May 2, 1968 . June 1, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  35. Web site: Lee Robinson Minor & Mexican Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  36. News: Dukes, LA swap men . . . D-2 . May 12, 1974 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  37. News: Rick Rhoden Answers Call . . . E-8 . July 4, 1974 . March 16, 2017 . newspapers.com.
  38. News: Dukes Collect Some World Series Cash . . . D-11 . November 21, 1974 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  39. Web site: Ed Kurpiel Minor & Mexican Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  40. News: Cards Recall Trio from Tulsa Team . . . 16 . September 12, 1974 . June 6, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  41. Web site: Davis May Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  42. News: Transactions . The Town Talk . . B-3 . April 26, 1977 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  43. News: Moves mean 'wasted year' for pitcher May . M. Howard . Gelfand . . 1D . May 19, 1977 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  44. Web site: Tom McGough Minor & Mexican Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  45. Web site: Pat Cristelli Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  46. Web site: Ed Ricks Minor & Mexican Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  47. Web site: Harry Saferight Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  48. News: Pirates call up 8 . . . 4 . September 1, 1979 . June 6, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  49. Web site: Duane Dewey Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  50. Web site: Russ Stephans Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  51. Web site: Mark Leonette Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  52. News: Transactions . . . B2 . July 3, 1987 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  53. News: Sanderson back . Journal Gazette . . B-1 . July 7, 1987 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  54. Web site: Bill Merrifield Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  55. News: Merrifield assigned to instructional camp . . . 9 . September 12, 1987 . June 1, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  56. News: Dodd. Rustin. Royals' Whit Merrifield is taking his family along on big-league journey. September 2, 2017. Kansas City Star. June 4, 2016.
  57. News: Perrotto. John. Rumors and Rumblings – Merrifield fulfills father's dream. September 2, 2017. Fanrag. September 1, 2017.
  58. Web site: Joe Law Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  59. News: Frequent flier . . 2-D . July 12, 1988 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  60. News: Transactions . . 34 . August 9, 1988 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  61. News: Transactions . . 58 . August 11, 1988 . June 14, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  62. Web site: Law follows, eclipses father's baseball career . Walter . Villa . MLB.com . August 16, 2016 . August 7, 2022.
  63. Web site: Armando Moreno Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  64. News: Transactions . . D-4 . August 4, 1990 . July 4, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  65. News: Transactions . . B-4 . August 6, 1990 . July 4, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  66. Web site: Terrel Hansen Minor, Mexican & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  67. News: Flashes . . 36 . May 2, 1992 . July 4, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  68. Web site: Bruce Dostal Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  69. News: Transactions . . 3–7 . June 11, 1994 . July 4, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  70. News: Notes . . 4–7 . June 15, 1994 . July 4, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  71. Web site: Dark Side of the Moonlight . The Church of Baseball . June 21, 2010 . July 4, 2018.
  72. News: Chimelis leaves Giants as a pariah . Michael . Martinez . . . . 3C . June 7, 1995 . July 4, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  73. Web site: Jesus Martinez Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  74. News: Transactions . . 6C . September 3, 1996 . July 4, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  75. Web site: Remembering the Dodgers who didn't play. SB Nation. Eric. Stephen. December 29, 2016. June 3, 2018.
  76. Web site: Luke Wilcox Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  77. News: St. Johns native gets call up to Yankees . Geoff . Kimmerly . . . C1 . July 15, 2000 . June 29, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  78. News: Yankees recall Bellinger, send Wilcox to Columbus . . . C5 . July 17, 2000 . June 29, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  79. Web site: Cesar King Minor & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  80. News: Game Notes . . D9 . May 20, 2001 . June 29, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  81. News: Transactions . . D7 . May 24, 2001 . June 29, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  82. Web site: Jeff Urban Minor & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  83. Web site: Dave Parrish Minor, Fall & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  84. Web site: Cory Morris Minor, Fall & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  85. Web site: Tim Gradoville Minor Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  86. Web site: Luis Munoz Minor, Winter & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  87. http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/local/breaking/pirates-promote-munoz-cleveland-claims-bullington-401714/ "Pirates promote Munoz; Cleveland claims Bulllington."
  88. Web site: Tom Cochran Minor, Independent & Winter Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  89. Web site: Major League Spinners . MiLB.com . Lowell Spinners . https://web.archive.org/web/20180720095823/http://www.milb.com/content/page.jsp?ymd=20111017&content_id=25693786&sid=t558&vkey=roster . July 20, 2018 . Wayback Machine.
  90. Web site: Jose Yepez Minor, Independent & Winter Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  91. Web site: Mariners Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions . . June 2011 . June 1, 2018.
  92. Web site: Mariners Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions . . July 2011 . June 1, 2018.
  93. News: Jeroloman out to shed 'phantom ballplayer' label . Jordan . Bastian . . March 19, 2013.
  94. Web site: Jason Rice Minor, Winter & Fall Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  95. Web site: Athletics Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions . . September 2011 . June 1, 2018.
  96. Web site: Dodgers Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions . . April 2012 . June 1, 2018.
  97. Web site: Dodgers Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions . . May 2012 . June 1, 2018.
  98. Web site: Frank De Los Santos Minor, Winter & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  99. Web site: White Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions . . May 2014 . June 1, 2018.
  100. Web site: Tim Berry Minor & Fall Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  101. Web site: Orioles Roster & Staff – Transactions . . June 2014 . December 16, 2019.
  102. Web site: LOCAL SPORTS: Caleb Clay cracks Angels' roster, earns 1st MLB callup. August 6, 2024. cullmantimes.com. en.
  103. Web site: LOCAL SPORTS: Clay optioned back to Salt Lake 2 days after 1st MLB callup. August 6, 2024. cullmantimes.com. en.
  104. Web site: Caleb Clay clears outright waivers. August 6, 2024. cbssports.com. en.
  105. Web site: LOCAL SPORTS: Cullman products Clay, Mallard settling into lives away from baseball. August 6, 2024. cullmantimes.com. en.
  106. Web site: Yankees Roster & Staff – Transactions . . July 2015 . June 1, 2018.
  107. Web site: Chris Jones Minor, Fall & Winter Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  108. Web site: Angels Roster & Staff – Transactions . . May 2016 . July 4, 2018.
  109. Web site: Angels Roster & Staff – Transactions . . June 2016 . July 4, 2018.
  110. Web site: Braves Roster & Staff – Transactions . . July 2016 . July 4, 2018.
  111. News: Braves, Marlins get extra body for Sunday night game . Steve . Hummer . . July 3, 2016 . July 4, 2018.
  112. Web site: Dodgers Roster & Staff – Transactions . . August 2016 . June 1, 2018.
  113. Web site: Germany, Australia ... now Yanks for Bollinger: Wide-traveling left-hander joins club vs. Rangers at Globe Life Park. Bryan. Hoch. MLB.com. May 23, 2018. May 23, 2018.
  114. Web site: Ryan Bollinger still relishing unexpected call to Yankees. The Trentonian. Kyle. Franko. May 29, 2018. June 3, 2018.
  115. Web site: Mark Polishuk. Minor MLB Transactions: 7/18/19. MLB Trade Rumors. July 18, 2019. July 18, 2019.
  116. Web site: Transactions . MLB.com . MLB Advanced Media . October 12, 2022.
  117. Web site: Transactions . MLB.com . MLB Advanced Media . October 12, 2022.
  118. Web site: Bo Takahashi Stats, Fantasy & News. MLB.com. November 25, 2021.
  119. Web site: Jeison Guzmán Stats, Fantasy & News. MLB.com. November 25, 2021.
  120. News: Jeison Guzmán Stats, Fantasy & News . MiLB.com . August 7, 2022.
  121. Web site: Transactions. May 21, 2024. baseball.pointstreak.com. en.
  122. Web site: Trey Supak Stats, Fantasy & News. MLB.com. November 25, 2021.
  123. Web site: Jasseel De La Cruz Stats, Fantasy & News. MLB.com. November 25, 2021.
  124. Web site: Steven Fuentes Stats, Fantasy & News. MLB.com. November 25, 2021.
  125. Web site: Nationals Outright Three Players. MLB Trade Rumors. October 13, 2021 . November 25, 2021.
  126. Web site: Corey Bird "DFA'D" hours before playing Yankees. Jim. Treacy. Wsaz.com. July 31, 2021 . November 25, 2021.
  127. Web site: Dirty Birds sign former Marshall star Corey Bird . June 22, 2022 .
  128. Web site: Gianpaul Gonzalez. MLB.com.
  129. Web site: Indians Activate Aaron Civale From Injured List. MLB Trade Rumors. September 7, 2021 . November 25, 2021.
  130. Web site: Athletics' Miguel Romero: Recalled by Oakland. CBSSports.com. September 8, 2021 . November 25, 2021.
  131. Web site: Steve Adams. Phillies Designate Phillies Select Jeff Singer. MLB Trade Rumors. April 13, 2022. April 14, 2022.
  132. Web site: Steve Adams. Phillies Designate Jeff Singer For Assignment. MLB Trade Rumors. April 14, 2022. April 14, 2022.
  133. Web site: Nationals' Donovan Casey: Officially recalled by Nationals . April 15, 2022 .
  134. Web site: Nationals' Donovan Casey: Sent down Wednesday . April 20, 2022 .
  135. News: Could Boston Red Sox's future at catcher be on display in next few days with Connor Wong, Ronaldo Hernández in majors? . Chris . Cotillo . masslive.com . MSN.com . April 19, 2022 . April 19, 2022.
  136. News: Christian Vázquez activated by Boston Red Sox after one day on COVID list; Ronaldo Hernández sent back to WooSox . Chris . Cotillo . masslive.com . MSN.com . April 20, 2022 . April 19, 2022.
  137. Web site: Red Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions . Boston Red Sox . MLB.com . August 2022 . August 2, 2022.
  138. News: For High-A catcher Alex Hall, a g'day . Adam . McCalvy . MLB.com . June 2, 2022 . June 3, 2022.
  139. News: Tweet . Twitter.com . June 3, 2022 . June 3, 2022.
  140. Web site: Phillies add 2 new players for final game in Toronto . July 13, 2022 .
  141. Web site: Phillies Activate Brogdon, Romero; Toffey Outrighted . July 15, 2022 .
  142. Web site: Yankees' Carlos Espinal: Outrighted to minors. May 13, 2023. cbssports.com. August 8, 2022 . en.
  143. Web site: Parker Bugg receives MLB call-up to the Miami Marlins. Aileen. Hnatiuk. WGNO.com. August 14, 2022 .
  144. Web site: Marlins' Parker Bugg: Dropped from 40-man roster. CBSSports.com. August 16, 2022 .
  145. Web site: Mets designate Connor Grey for assignment . September 2022 .
  146. Web site: Rays' Chris Muller: Sent back to Triple-A. May 17, 2023. cbssports.com. May 15, 2023 . en.
  147. Web site: Chris Muller: In search of new organization. May 29, 2023. cbssports.com. en.
  148. Web site: Norwith Gudiño Stats, Fantasy & News. July 25, 2023. milb.com. en.
  149. Web site: Red Sox Reinstate John Schreiber. July 25, 2023. mlbtraderumors.com. July 25, 2023 . en.
  150. Web site: Norwith Gudiño: Released by Boston. August 1, 2023. cbssports.com. August 2023 . en.
  151. Web site: Marlins' Josh Simpson: Back to minors. September 17, 2023. cbssports.com. en.
  152. Web site: Cardinals' Nick Raposo: Sent down to minors. June 26, 2024. cbssports.com. en.
  153. Web site: Cardinals' Jacob Bosiokovic: Sent back to minors. July 5, 2024. cbssports.com. en.
  154. Web site: White Sox's Jake Eder: Serving as 27th man Wednesday. July 10, 2024. cbssports.com. en.
  155. Web site: White Sox's Jake Eder: Sent to Charlotte. July 11, 2024. cbssports.com. en.
  156. Web site: Yankees Promote Jorbit Vivas. July 17, 2024. mlbtraderumors.com. en.
  157. Web site: Yankees' Jorbit Vivas: Sent back to minors. July 17, 2024. cbssports.com. en.
  158. Web site: Orioles Designate Cole Irvin For Assignment. July 30, 2024. mlbtraderumors.com. en.
  159. Web site: Orioles' Blake Hunt: Demoted, but with taxi squad . CBS Sports . July 31, 2024. August 1, 2024.
  160. Web site: Cup of Coffee Players . . April 4, 2024.
  161. Web site: Jimmy Whalen Minor & Independent Leagues Statistics & History. Baseball-Reference.com. November 25, 2021.
  162. Web site: CONTENTdm. Digital.la84.org. November 25, 2021.
  163. Web site: Jimmy Whalen Minor & Independent Leagues Statistics & History . . June 1, 2018.
  164. Web site: REPLACEMENT TEAM IN COBB'S DAY LACKED SOMETHING: QUALITY . Jerome Holtzman . January 24, 1995 . Chicago Tribune . February 5, 2020.
  165. News: Rain washes out Mazone's shot . Stephen . Miller . . . C1 . September 6, 2006 . May 31, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  166. Web site: Brian Mazone Minor, Independent & Winter League Statistics & History . . May 31, 2018.
  167. http://losangeles.dodgers.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20090320&content_id=4040698&vkey=n
  168. Web site: Jorge Comellas . . March 14, 2022.
  169. Web site: Blue Jays recall Wagner, demote Walden . . April 9, 2014 . May 27, 2019.
  170. News: Surprise! Poyner and Walden make Red Sox pitching staff . Evan . Drellich . . March 26, 2018 . May 28, 2019.
  171. Web site: Mariners promote righty Harper, option Whalen . . May 28, 2019.
  172. Web site: Daniel Camarena Stats, Fantasy & News. MLB.com. November 25, 2021.
  173. Web site: Padres' Daniel Camarena: Unsteady in big-league debut. CBS Sports. June 20, 2021 .
  174. Web site: Domingo Acevedo . . June 12, 2022.
  175. Web site: Twins make roster moves. MLB.com. November 25, 2021.
  176. Web site: After 1,154 games in the minor leagues, Drew Maggi makes his MLB debut . en-US . Sullivan . Becky . April 27, 2023 . April 27, 2023 . NPR.
  177. Web site: Ten Baseball Card Blunders . Dacardworld.com . January 3, 2008 . June 13, 2021.
  178. Web site: 1973 Topps: Rookie Catchers . Psacard.com . June 13, 2021.
  179. Web site: George Pena Minor, Mexican & Winter Leagues Statistics & History . . June 13, 2021.
  180. Web site: 1975 Topps: Rookie Pitchers . Psacard.com . June 12, 2021.
  181. Web site: Juan Veintidos Minor & Mexican Leagues Statistics & History . . June 13, 2021.
  182. Web site: Cincinnati Reds 3, Chicago Cubs 2 . . September 2, 1956 . April 4, 2024.
  183. https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/CIN/CIN195609020.shtml Box score for Oldham's MLB appearance
  184. News: Astros' Rookie in 'Brief' Stint . . . . 1-B . September 16, 1971 . May 31, 2018 . newspapers.com.
  185. Web site: Atlanta Braves 4, Houston Astros 2 . . September 15, 1971 . May 31, 2018.
  186. Web site: Mark Kiger . . July 6, 2018.