Persona non grata (Philippines) explained

Persona non grata, in the context of Philippine governance parlance, refers individuals or groups declared as unwelcome in a particular locality. This designation is merely symbolic and non-binding, and does not legally prohibit a person declared as persona non grata from stepping foot on that locality.

Definition

Persona non grata means an unwelcome person in Latin. In the context of diplomacy or international relations, a persona non grata declaration on a foreign citizen, usually a diplomat who otherwise has a privilege of immunity, is barred from entering the country which issued the declaration.[1] In the context of local governance in the Philippines, local government units (LGUs, including municipalities, cities, and provinces) could declare a person persona non grata. One such reason for a move is in response to the particular person breaking local ordinances and laws.[2]

The declaration would imply that a person is barred from entering the jurisdiction of a particular locality.[2] However, according to a Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) legal opinion, persona non grata declarations are often made through resolutions by the local legislature rather than ordinances and is merely made to express a sentiment; which effectively meant that such declarations are non-binding. In the case of the municipal council of Anahawan, Southern Leyte declaring then-newly installed Mayor Roberto Loquinte as persona non grata for their opinion of Loquinte being unfit for the position, the DILG said that the local legislature is within their right to issue the declaration but the same must be done "within the bounds of the law". It also said that it could not legally prevent Loquinte from assuming the position as Mayor and/or discharging his function, an act which the DILG finds reprehensible.[3] [4]

Notable personae non gratae

The following are notable people or groups who were declared as persona non grata by local government units (LGUs) in the Philippines. This excludes foreigners who were only barred entry and/or deported by the Philippine national government but includes foreigners who were declared as persona non grata by LGUs.

Politicians and government officials

Person/sIssuing DateBackground
Rodolfo FariñasIlocos Norte2017The Ilocos Norte Provincial Board declared Rodolfo Fariñas, incumbent 1st district representative of Ilocos Norte in the House of Representatives of the Philippines, as persona non grata after Fariñas launched an inquiry on the Ilocos Norte tobacco excise tax funds controversy. Fariñas himself is a resident of Laoag, the province's capital.
Omar MayoBaguio2021The Baguio City Council declared Omar Mayo, the appointed project supervisor of the National Electrification Administration (NEA) to help resolve the BENECO leadership dispute as persona non grata on October 25, 2021, after he led a pre-dawn takeover of the BENECO headquarters with the help of armed personnel of the Philippine National Police on October 18. BENECO's leadership is disputed between NEA-appointed general manager Ana Maria Rafael and BENECO Board backed manager engineer Melchor Licoben.[5]
Marie RafaelBenguet2021The province of Benguet declared Former PCOO Asec. Marie Rafael persona non grata after the armed forceful entry into the BENECO headquarters on Oct. 18, 2021.[6]
Walden BelloDavao City2022The Davao City council declared Former Akbayan Representative and vice presidential candidate Walden Bello persona non grata for his statements in the 2022 vice presidential debates of where he called Davao City a trading hub for illegal drugs, and called the city government corrupt. [7]
Huang XilianKalayaan, Palawan2023The municipal council of Kalayaan of the province of Palawan declares Huang Xilian, the ambassador of the China to the Philippines as persona non grata in response to the August 2023 Second Thomas Shoal standoff to condemn the Chinese presence in the area. Kalayaan covers the disputed Spratly Islands.[8]

Other individuals

Person/sIssuing DateBackground
Claire DanesManila1998The Manila City Council declared American actress Claire Danes after the shooting for the film Brokedown Palace as persona non grata and her movies were prohibited after derogatory comments she made about Manila and Filipinos in an interview with Vogue[9] and Premiere magazine.[10] In response to the declaration, then-President Joseph Estrada remarked that Danes should not be allowed to enter the Philippines. Danes later apologized for those remarks, but they refused to lift the ban.[11] [12] [13]
2008 Members Church of God International (MCGI) leader, Daniel Razon was declared as persona non grata by the Municipal Council of Apalit when Razon criticized the local government's decision to order and effect the closure of the buildings erected inside the compound of the Ang Dating Daan (ADD) Convention Center in his program Good Morning Kuya. Razon claimed the Apalit government was influenced by other religious organizations criticial to the MCGI which the municipal council says is "untrue and baseless". [14]
Candy PangilinanBaguio2009At the Mother's Day event at SM Baguio, Pangilinan for a joke implying that the audience mistaken her as an Igorot with the punchline that she is a human being. Pangilinan has apologized after the show and said she misdelivered the line and intended to say "Igorot statue". The Baguio City Council passed a resolution declaring her as persona non grata. [15]
Ramon BautistaDavao City2014The Davao City Council declared comedian Ramon Bautista as persona non grata for his remarks that there are many hipon in the city during a rave party which is part of the Kadayawan Festival. Hipon, which literally translates to shrimp, is a colloquial term for a person with an attractive body but an unappealing face. Bautista has apologized for his remarks.[16]
Leah NavarroGeneral Santos2019The city council of General Santos declared Leah Navarro a persona non grata after she indicated that the recent Mindanao earthquakes were a form of "retribution" in her reply to Former Supreme Court spokesperson Theodore Te's tweet, "What’s with all the earthquakes in Mindanao?" Navarro has deleted the tweet.[17]
Ai-Ai delas Alas
Darryl Yap
Quezon City2022The Quezon City Council declared the actress Ai-Ai delas Alas as persona non grata for "disrespecting city's official seal", this is due to the motion filed by the QC District IV Councilor Ivy Lagman accusing Ai-ai delas Alas and Darryl Yap of defacing the city's triangle seal in a two-minute and 21-second video uploaded on Yap's Vincentiments Facebook Page. A member of the city council said that this resolution is not aimed at barring Ai-Ai from the locality but only for expressing the official sentiment towards the artist.[18] Ai-Ai delas Alas's camp condemned the resolution.[19] [20] [21]
Pura Luka VegaVarious2023The drag artist was declared persona non grata by various local government units for their drag performance bar in a traditional Jesus Christ-inspired outfit singing to a rock rendition of Ama Namin (Lord's Prayer). Local-level officials condemned the act as disrespectful to the country's predominant Catholic faith.
Rendon Labador
Rosmar Tan
Marki Tan
(Team Malakas)
Palawan2024The local government of Palawan declared Rosmar Tan persona non grata, along with Rendon Labador and Marki Tan,[22] [23] [24] due to their disrespectful behavior, negative publicity, incitement to conflict, and alleged violations of Republic Act No. 10951 (the 'Property and Damage Penalty Adjustment Act'), Article 153 of the Revised Penal Code, and Republic Act No. 11313 (the 'Safe Spaces Act').[25] [26]

Groups

GroupIssuing DateBackground
Communist Party of the Philippines
New People's Army
National Democratic Front
VariousThe Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) says that around 1,546 local government units in the Philippines (64 provinces, 110 cities and 1,372 municipalities) has declared the communist rebel groups as persona non grata as of December 11, 2020.[27] [28]
Panday SiningManila2019The Manila City Council declared the militant art group Panday Sining, the cultural unit of left-leaning organization Anakbayan, persona non grata for spray-painting on walls on United Nations Avenue and the Lagusnilad underpass with messages calling for the end of political repression.[29]

Usage by non-governmental entities

Aside from usage under the context of international diplomacy, persona non grata has been devised by non-governmental bodies in the Philippines. Such organization include the Philippine Olympic Committee (POC), a private entity. The POC in 2011 declared former Philippine Karatedo Federation (PKF) president Go Teng Kok as persona non grata for violating the Olympic body's constitution and by-laws by taking legal action to prevent the recognition of then-newly installed PKF Enrico Vasquez.[30] In 2021, it did the same to Philippine Athletics Track and Field Association (PATAFA) Philip Juico for his "malicious" public statements against Ernest John Obiena related to his federation's dispute on Obiena's accountability for the coaching fees of his coach.[31]

Notes and References

  1. News: Persona non grata for beginners . December 13, 2020 . The Filipino Times . April 29, 2018.
  2. News: Dumlao . Artemio . Fariñas declared persona non grata by his home province . December 13, 2020 . The Philippine Star . June 28, 2017.
  3. News: DILG Opinion No. 30 S. 2020 . December 13, 2020 . Department of the Interior and Local Government . February 7, 2020.
  4. News: League of Municipalities backs Tawi-tawi judge . December 13, 2020 . The Mindanao Examiner . November 27, 2020.
  5. News: Baguio City Council declares NEA Beneco supervisor as persona non grata . 25 October 2021 . Rappler . en.
  6. News: Benguet also declares NEA Beneco supervisor unwelcome . 9 November 2021 . Rappler . 4 November 2021 . en.
  7. Web site: 2022-03-22 . Davao City declares Walden Bello persona non grata . 2022-04-20 . RAPPLER . en-US.
  8. News: Formoso . Celeste Anna . Kalayaan declares Chinese envoy persona non grata . 19 August 2023 . Daily Tribune . 16 August 2023.
  9. Van Meter . Jonathan . July 1998 . Perfectly Claire . . 118 . Danes's first film without her mother was shot in the Philippines this past winter. It was, she says, "utter hell to make. Manila is such a ghastly place.".
  10. Spines . Christine . October 1998 . Claire and Present Danger . . 66 . The shoot was plagued with malaria and hepatitis outbreaks, and had to be shut down for several sick days. "It was just so hard," Danes says, now comfortably ensconced at a Beverly Hills lunch joint, where she's gobbling up a plate of extra-rare ahi. "The place just fucking smelled of cockroaches. There's no sewage system in Manila, and people have nothing there. [We saw] people with, like, no arms, no legs, no eyes, no teeth. We shot in a real [psychiatric] hospital, so takes would be interrupted by wailing women--like, 'Cut! Screaming person.' Rats were everywhere.".
  11. News: CBS News. October 10, 1998. December 16, 2020. Manila Is Mad At Claire Danes. October 24, 2012. http://web-old.archive.org/web/20121024204719/http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/1998/10/01/entertainment/main18857.shtml.
  12. News: Ghosts, liberated women and Morgan Freeman: the films banned for odd reasons. June 2, 2017. The Guardian. refused to lift the ban – which as far as we can tell, remains in place.
  13. Web site: Associated Press . Brown hounded for calling Manila 'gates of hell' . timesnews.net . 2013-05-24 . Kingsport Tgimes-News. then-President Joseph Estrada banned Hollywood actress Claire Danes, who shot the movie “Brokedown Palace” in Manila, from entering the country.
  14. News: Garcia . Raymond . May 8, 2008 . ADD leader declared 'persona non grata' . February 8, 2024 . Sun Star Pampanga. https://web.archive.org/web/20080610034537/http://www.sunstar.com.ph/static/pam/2008/05/08/news/add.leader.declared.persona.non.grata..html . June 10, 2008 .
  15. News: Catajan . Maria Elena . Candy Pangilinan declared 'persona non grata' in Baguio . 19 August 2023 . GMA News . 16 May 2009 . en.
  16. News: Hegina . Aries Joseph . Davao City declares Ramon Bautista as 'persona non grata' –report . December 16, 2020 . Philippine Daily Inquirer . August 19, 2014 . en.
  17. News: ORNEDO . JULIA MARI . GenSan declares Leah Navarro persona non grata over retribution tweet. GMA Network. November 5, 2019. en.
  18. Web site: Malasig . Jeline . 2022-06-08 . Explained: Ai-Ai delas Alas, Darryl Yap as 'personae non gratae' in Quezon City . 2022-06-09 . Interaksyon . en-US.
  19. Web site: AiAi delas Alas camp condemns persona non grata QC resolution: It 'endangers protection granted by freedom of expression' . GMA News Online . 2022-06-08 .
  20. Web site: Sarao . Zacarian . 2022-06-07 . QC council declares Ai-Ai delas Alas, Darryl Yap 'persona non grata' . 2022-06-07 . INQUIRER.net . en.
  21. News: Purnell . Kristofer . Ai-Ai Delas Alas, Darryl Yap declared persona non grata by Quezon City Council . 6 August 2023 . The Philippine Star . 8 June 2022.
  22. Web site: Pasajol . Anne . 2024-06-18 . Rendon Labador, Rosmar Tan say sorry for Coron commotion . 2024-07-13 . INQUIRER.net . en.
  23. Web site: 2024-06-18 . Rosmar Tan, Rendon Labador, Team Malakas declared persona non-grata in entire Palawan province . 2024-07-13 . GMA News Online . en.
  24. Web site: 2024-06-17 . Vloggers Rosmar Tan and Rendon Labador face possible persona non grata in Coron, Palawan . 2024-07-13 . news.tv5.com.ph.
  25. Web site: 2024-06-17 . Coron considers persona non-grata status for vloggers Rosmar Tan, Rendon Labador . 2024-07-13 . GMA News Online . en.
  26. Web site: Laqui . Ian . Coron municipal council mulls 'persona non-grata' tag vs vloggers Rosmar, Rendon . 2024-07-13 . Philstar.com.
  27. News: Hallare . Katrina . CPP-NPA-NDF members declared persona non grata in 1,546 LGUS — DILG . 15 December 2020 . Philippine Daily Inquirer . 11 December 2020 . en . https://web.archive.org/web/20201212164024/https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1370609/cpp-npa-ndf-members-declared-persona-non-grata-in-1546-lgus-dilg . 12 December 2020.
  28. News: Arcilla . Gigie . CPP-NPA-NDF not welcome in Mandaluyong City, 1,545 LGUs . 28 January 2021 . Philippine News Agency . 28 January 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210128194313/https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1128860 . 28 January 2021 . en.
  29. News: Manila city council declares Panday Sining 'persona non grata' . December 15, 2020 . Rappler . December 6, 2019 . en.
  30. News: POC board declares Go Teng Kok persona non grata . 27 January 2022 . Philippine Daily Inquirer . 17 June 2021.
  31. News: Satumbaga-Villar . Kristel . POC declares athletics chief Philip Juico 'persona non grata' . 25 January 2022 . Manila Bulletin . 28 December 2021.