Pedimental sculptures in Canada explained

Pedimental sculptures are sculptures within the frame of a pediment on the exterior of a building, some examples of which can be found in Canada. Pedimental sculpture poses special challenges to sculptors: the triangular composition limits the choices for figures or ornament at the ends, and the sculpture must be designed to be viewed both from below and from a distance.

History

As with the ancient Greeks, and the Roman architects and sculptors who followed them, North American artists had two different structural approaches creating pedimental sculpture. They are either freestanding statues that stand on the bed (the ledge or cornice that creates the bottom of the pediment), or they can be relief sculpture, attached to the back wall of the pediment.[1]

Compositionally, the restrictions imposed by both the physical triangular shape of a pediment, and the traditional themes that are usually employed for the subject matter, are, according to Ernest Arthur Gardner, "as exactly regulated as that of a sonnet or a Spenserian stanza: the artist has liberty only in certain directions and must not violate the laws of rhythm".[2]

The Golden Dog

Perhaps the most famous pedimental sculpture in Quebec is Le Chien d'Or (1688) in Quebec City. The gray limestone relief panel depicts a dog gnawing a bone,[3] a metaphor for nursing a grudge.

Timothée Roussel (1639-1700), a French immigrant and surgeon, was a Quebec City landowner in New France,[3] and Jean Normand was his neighbor.[4] The two bickered over right of passage across Normand's land, and Roussel won in court over Normand in 1682 and 1683.[4] The men eventually came to blows, and wound up in court again in 1686.[4] The court record noted that Normand's son Joseph had killed Roussel's dog.[4]

Two years later, Roussel built a house on Buade Street, and affixed the bas relief panel over his front door.[3] It featured a menacing inscription:
"I am a dog that gnaws his bone / I couch and gnaw it all alone / A time will come, which is not yet / When I'll bite him by whom I'm bit." (Translation by William Kirby, 1877.)[5]

Merchant Nicolas Jacquin, dit Philibert[6] bought the house from Roussel's heirs in 1734, and greatly expanded it. The merchant was murdered in 1748.[7] Philibert's house was later converted into a coffeehouse, was the meeting place for Freemasons from 1775 to 1800, and served as the city's post office from 1845 to 1871.[8] The house was demolished for construction of a large Second Empire post office building, completed in 1872.[9] Roussel's panel was mounted high above its side entrance.[8]

Author William Kirby made the relief panel the centerpiece of his 1877 historical novel The Golden Dog.[5] The lead character was Philibert's son, who tracks down his father's killer and avenges the murder. The novel helped to make Le Chien d'Or famous, but also popularized the urban legend that the relief panel was erected as a threat to Philibert's murderer.[4]

The post office building was expanded and remodeled in a Beaux-Arts style in 1913.[9] The then-225-year-old relief was relocated to a more prominent location, a segmental pediment over the building's new entrance porch.[10]

Manitoba Legislative Building

The 1911-1912 British-Empire-wide design competition for the Manitoba Legislative Building in Winnipeg had 67 entrants, and was won by Scottish architect Frank Worthington Simon. He chose Scottish sculptor Albert Hodge to design its sculptured main pediment.[11] Hodge died in 1918 at age 42, three years prior to the building's completion. Piccirilli Brothers of New York City carved Hodge's pedimental figures in limestone.

The pediment group which was modelled by the late Albert Hodge, of London, attracts attention first by its conspicuous situation as well as by its artistic quality. In judging such a group it must be borne in mind that the height above the eye, its peculiar confining frame and the necessities of its composition make it one of the most difficult of sculptural problems. Mr. Hodge, however, has most successfully developed his subject, filling the outer acute angles of the pediment as well as the high apex, the composition being balanced on either side and culminating at the centre. The female figure of Manitoba sits full front in the middle, and to the left there are three distinct groups, connected and related to the central figure by sentiment and gesture. In the corner Enterprise beckons the workers to the Land of Promise. Next there is a finely modelled bull led by Europa typifying the emigration from Europe, and between this group and Manitoba, there are a father, mother and child - the new family in the new world. On the opposite side of the angle are two figures clasping a jar whence issues a stream of water fertilizing the earth - the confluence of the Red and Assiniboine rivers. Next is a group of ploughmen and horses, tilling the soil, balancing the Bull-and-Europa group. Between these and Manitoba is a group of a man and a woman bringing the fruits of the soil, balancing the family group. Thus are expressions and balance complete, scale maintained, and the space well filled.
Mr. Hodge's work is also seen in the two sphinxes, representing Wisdom and Knowledge, placed on either side of the main pediment, and in the group of two figures, personifying, respectively, Peace and War, above the east and west pediments.[12]

Pedimental sculptures

BuildingProvinceLocationImageSculptureSculptorArchitectInstalledMedium / Notes
Alberta Legislature BuildingAlbertaEdmonton
10800 97 Avenue NW
central crest incorporating provincial shieldtbdAllan Merrick Jeffers and Richard Blakey1913 Alberta Legislative Building:
Bank of Montreal, Calgary branchAlbertaCalgary
8th Avenue and 1st Street SW
version of the bank's coat of arms tbdKenneth Rea[13] 1932Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[14]
Merchants' Bank of Canada, Victoria branchBritish ColumbiaVictoria
1225 Douglas Street
Bank of Montreal coat of armstbdFrancis M. Rattenbury, architect[15]

Honeyman & Curtis,
1922 expansion[16]
1907

1922
Built by the Merchants' Bank of Canada in 1907.
Bank of Montreal purchased the building in 1922, and expanded it, adding a pedimental sculpture of the BOM coat of arms.
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[17]
Manitoba Legislative Building[18] ManitobaWinnipeg
450 Broadway
enthroned central figure of Manitoba, figures representing the Red River and the Assiniboine River at far rightAlbert Hodge, sculptor
Piccirilli Brothers (New York City), carvers[19]
Frank Worthington Simon and Septimus Warwick1920Manitoba Legislative Building:
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[20]
Winnipeg Law Courts BuildingManitobaWinnipeg; 391 Broadwayblindfolded Justice with sword and scales, flanked by two figurestbdVictor W. Horwood[21] 1916 Horwood (1878–1939) was provincial government architect
Pediment sculpture commission was won by open competition[22]
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[23]
New Brunswick Legislative BuildingNew BrunswickFredericton
706 Queen Street
central shieldunknownJames C. Dumaresq1882Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[24]
Colonial BuildingNewfoundland and LabradorSt. John's
Military Road
lion and unicorn, in a version of the Royal coat of arms of the United KingdomunknownJames Purcell1847 Colonial Building:
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[25]
Bank of Montreal, Sydney branchNova ScotiaSydney
175 Charlotte Street
central shieldtbdSir Andrew Taylor1901Twin pediments on north and west facades, carved from olive green sandstone
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[26]
Nova ScotiaHalifax
1726 Hollis Street
lion and unicorn, in a version of the Royal coat of arms of the United KingdomunknownJohn Merrick1819Province House:
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[27]
Bank of Montreal, Cambridge branchOntarioCambridge (Galt); 44 Main Street (at Water)central shield in low relieftbdHogel & Davis1919Built by the Merchants' Bank of Canada
Bank of Montreal, Hamilton branchOntarioHamilton
James and Main
Bank of Montreal coat of armstbdKenneth G. Rea1928Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[28]
Rideau Hall
(Government House)
OntarioOttawa
1 Sussex Drive
lion and unicorn, in a version of the Royal coat of arms of the United KingdomtbdDavid Ewart,
1914 expansion
1838
1865-1868
1914
Rideau Hall:
Pediments not original construction, date from 1914 construction of Mappin Hall
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[29]
St. Lawrence Hall[30] OntarioToronto
157 King Street east
depiction of former coat of arms of TorontoJohn Cochrane and brothers[31] William Thomas1851 St. Lawrence Hall:
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[32]
Ancienne Banque de MontréalQuebecGatineau; 40 promenade du PortageCurved fragmental pediment with Bank of Montreal coat of armsEdward and William Sutherland Maxwell1907Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[33]
Ancienne-Douane (old customs house)QuebecMontréal; 150, rue Saint-Paul Ouest / place RoyaleAlbion, representing Great Britain, solitary female figure with trident and shield[34] unknownJohn Ostell1836 Old Customs House:
current statue replaces wooden original;
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[35]
Bank of Montreal Head OfficeQuebecMontreal
119, rue Saint-Jacques
Bank of Montreal coat of arms: two First Nations figures flank a seal with motto Concordia salus (here with two European pioneers)[36] Sir John SteellJohn Wells[37] 1847 Bank of Montreal Main Office
Bonsecours MarketQuebecMontreal; 350, Rue Saint-Paulabstract designtbdWilliam Footner1847Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[38]
Le Chien d'Or
The Golden Dog
QuebecQuebec City; Louis S. St.-Laurents Building, 3, Rue De Buadegold-painted limestone relief panel of a dog gnawing a boneunknownPierre Gauvreau, builder1688 (sculpture)
1872 (building)
1913 (expansion)
North facade (relief panel is center, below the entrance porch's flag):
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[39]
London and Lancashire Life BuildingQuebecMontreal; 244, rue Saint-Jacquesseveral minor ornate pediments on main and flanking facadesunknownEdward Maxwell1898 London and Lancashire Life Building, 1895:
Maisonneuve Municipal Library
(Bibliothèque Maisonneuve)
QuebecMontreal; 4120 Ontario Street Eastcentral seal with inscriptiontbdCajetan Dufort[40] 1910-1912 Formerly, Maisonneuve City Hall:
(l'Hôtel de Ville de Maisonneuve)
Maisonneuve Public Bath and Gymnasium QuebecMontreal; 1875–1877, Morgan boulevard, Borough Mercier-Hochelaga-Maisonneuveblind pediment, with figural acroteriaArthur Dubord[41] Marius Dufresne[42] 1916 Later called "Bain Morgan"
Montreal Masonic Memorial TempleQuebecMontreal; 2295 Saint-Marc Street and 1805 Sherbrooke Street Westtwo caped male athletes flank a coat of arms with signs of the Four EvangeliststbdJohn Smith Archibald1929Montreal Memorial Masonic Temple:
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[43]
Ravenscrag, Hugh Allan Residence QuebecMontreal; 835-1025 Avenue des Pins Ouestcoat of arms (motto Spero), scrollwork and foliation carved in deep open-bed pedimentunknownVictor Roy and John W. Hopkins1863Segmental pediment dormer:
QuebecMontreal; 5723, avenue du Parca pair of segmental pediments with escutcheonsunknownJoseph-Raoul Gariépy1924 Rialto Theatre:
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[44]
Saint-Joseph du Mont-RoyalQuebecMontréal; 3800, chenin Queen Maryescutcheon flanked by palm branchesPaul Bellot1937-1941Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[45]
SaskatchewanRegina; Scarth Street and 11th Avenueminor segmental pediments over 3rd story, and triangular pediments over 4th story, contain abstract carvingunknownDavid Ewart1907aka Old Post Office
Saskatchewan Legislative BuildingSaskatchewanRegina
2405 Legislative Drive
Center: Enthroned figure of Canada
Left: Seated Aboriginal, his wife and infant, tools and handicrafts
Right: Seated settler, his wife and 2 children, cow, sheep and plow[46]
Canadian members of the Bromsgrove Guild of Applied Arts[47] Edward and William Sutherland Maxwell1912 Saskatchewan Legislative Building:
Listed on the Canadian Register of Historic Places[48]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Webb, Pamela A., Hellenistic Architectural Sculpture: Figural Motifs in Western Anatolia and the Aegean Islands, The University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, Wisconsin, 1996 pp.23-25
  2. Price, Matlack, "The Problem of the Pediment," The Architectural Forum, July 1925, Volume XLIII, Number 1, pp. 1.
  3. http://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/roussel_timothee_1E.html Timothée Roussel
  4. Jean-Francois Caron, "The Golden Dog," Encyclopedia of French Cultural Heritage in North America.http://www.ameriquefrancaise.org/en/article-590/The_Golden_Dog.html
  5. William Kirby, The Chien d'Or: The Golden Dog; A Legend of Quebec (New York: R. Worthington, 1878).
  6. http://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/jacquin_nicolas_3E.html Nicholas Jacquin, dit Philibert
  7. http://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/legardeur_de_repentigny_pierre_jean_baptiste_francois_xavier_4E.html Legardeur de Repentigny
  8. James MacPherson Le Moine, "Le Chien d'Or: The History of an Old House," Maple Leaves (Quebec: Augustin Cote & Co., 1873), pp. 89-97.https://archive.org/details/cihm_08621/page/n105/mode/2up?q=Chien
  9. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=14966 Old Post Office
  10. David Mendel, "Old Post Office: An Imposing Edifice," Quebec: Birthplace of New France (Quebec: Sylvain Harvey and Commission de la capitale nationale de Quebec, 2012), pp. 18-23.
  11. Web site: Wiens . Gavin . Manitoba History: Carrying the Torch: Optimistic Themes in the Classical Vocabulary of the Manitoba Legislative Building . Manitoba Historical Society . 27 September 2021.
  12. A. A. Stoughton, "The New Manitoba Parliament Building," Construction: A Journal for the Architectural, Engineering and Contracting Interests of Canada, vol. 16, no. 3 (March, 1921), H. Gagnier, Limited, Publishers, Toronto, Canada, p. 74.https://books.google.com/books?id=OVgxAQAAMAAJ&dq=Albert+Hodge+sculpture&pg=PA74
  13. Web site: 1923 (sic) - Bank of Montreal Building, Calgary, Alberta . Archiseek . 6 September 2021.
  14. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=8354&pid=0 Bank of Montreal, Calgary
  15. Barrett, Anthony A. & Rhodri Windsor Liscombe, Francis Rattenbury and British Columbia, Architecture and Challenge in the Imperial Age, University of British Columbia PressVancouver, 1983
  16. Web site: 1907 - Merchant's Bank of Canada, Victoria, British Columbia . Archiseek . 7 September 2021.
  17. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=1485&pid=0 Merchant's Bank of British Columbia
  18. Baker, Marilyn, Manitoba's Third Legislative Building, Symbols in Stone: The Art and Politics of a Public Building, Hyperion Press Limited, Winnipeg, 1986
  19. "Statues/Sculpture", 100 Facts, 100 Years, the Legislative Building of Manitoba, p. 16.
  20. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=15362&pid=0 Manitoba Legislative Building
  21. Web site: Historic Sites of Manitoba: Winnipeg Law Courts Building (391 Broadway, Winnipeg) . Manitoba Historical Society . 7 September 2021.
  22. News: Veiled Justice: the Bath Rubber and the Potato Peeler . 7 September 2021 . Manitoba Free Press . 27 August 1915.
  23. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=12789&pid=0 Winnipeg Law Courts
  24. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=1268&pid=0 Legislative Assembly Block, New Brunswick
  25. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=3063&pid=0 Colonial Building
  26. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=9325&pid=0 Bank of Montreal, Sydney
  27. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=1682&pid=0 Province House, Nova Scotia
  28. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=8330&pid=0 Bank of Montreal, Hamilton
  29. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=7692&pid=0 Rideau Hall
  30. McKelvey, Margaret and Merilyn McKelvey, Toronto: Carved in Stone, Fitzhenry & Whiteside, Toronto 1984, p20 and more
  31. McKelvey, Margaret and Merilyn McKelvey, Toronto: Carved in Stone, Fitzhenry & Whiteside, Toronto 1984, p. 20
  32. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=7527&pid=0 St. Lawrence Hall
  33. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=7081&pid=0 Ancienne Banque de Montréal, Gatineau
  34. Web site: Propriétés municipales c'intérêt patrimonial (fr) . Ville de Montréal . 16 September 2021.
  35. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=7828&pid=0 Former Montreal Custom House
  36. Web site: Bank of Montreal Coat of Arms . Bank of Montreal . 6 September 2021.
  37. http://dictionaryofarchitectsincanada.org/node/1275 Wells' Canadian Commissions (1831–1859)
  38. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=7560&pid=0 Bonsecours Market
  39. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=14966 Old Post Office, Quebec City
  40. Dick Nieuwendyk, "Maisonneuve City Hall," Montreal Times, n.d.https://mtltimes.ca/life/maisonneuve-city-hall/
  41. News: To Start Work in Maisonneuve Park . 7 September 2021 . Montreal Gazette . 4 November 1914.
  42. Web site: Public bath and gymnasium, Morgan Boulevard, Montreal, QC, 1916 . McCord Museum . 7 September 2021.
  43. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=12542&pid=0 Masonic Memorial Temple, Montreal
  44. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=1198&pid=0 Rialto Theatre
  45. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=11855&pid=0 Oratoire Saint-Joseph
  46. Gordon Barnart, Sentinel of the Prairies: The Saskatchewan Legislative Building (Regina, Saskatchewan: 1987), p. 37.
  47. Web site: Goodspeed . Rhona . Saskatchewan Legislative Building and Grounds . 7 September 2021.
  48. https://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=13054&pid=0 Saskatchewan Legislative Building