Open access citation advantage explained

Open access citation advantage (OACA), sometimes known as FUTON bias (for "full text on the net"), is a type of bias whereby scholars tend to cite academic journals with open access (OA)—that is, journals that make their full text available on the Internet without charge (not behind a paywall)—in preference to toll-access publications. The concept was introduced, under the FUTON bias name, by UK medical researcher Reinhard Wentz in a letter to The Lancet in 2002.[1] [3] [4] [5] In the context of evidence-based medicine, articles in expensive journals that do not provide open access may be "priced out of evidence", giving a greater weight to open access publications.[6] Open access citation advantage may increase the impact factor of open access journals relative to journals without open access.[7]

One study concluded that authors in medical fields "concentrate on research published in journals that are available as full text on the internet, and ignore relevant studies that are not available in full text, thus introducing an element of bias into their search result".[9] Authors of another study conclude that "the OA advantage is a quality advantage, rather than a quality bias", that authors make a "self-selection toward using and citing the more citable articles—once OA self-archiving has made them accessible", and that open access "itself will not make an unusable (hence uncitable) paper more used and cited".[10]

A similar phenomenon, termed the "no abstract available bias" or NAA bias, is a scholar's tendency to cite journal articles that have an abstract available online more readily than articles that do not—this affects articles' citation count similarly to open access citation advantage.[11]

Notes and References

  1. Murali . N. S. . Murali . H. R. . Auethavekiat . P. . Erwin . P. J. . Mandrekar . J. N. . Manek . N. J. . Ghosh . A. K. . 2004 . Impact of FUTON and NAA bias on visibility of research . . 79 . 8 . 1001–1006 . 10.4065/79.8.1001 . 15301326 . 20536645.
  2. Scholars in some fields can more easily discover and access articles whose full text is available online, which increases authors' likelihood of reading and citing these articles, an issue that was first raised and has been mainly studied in connection with medical research.[1]
  3. Ghosh . A. K. . Murali . N. S. . 2003 . Online access to nephrology journals: The FUTON bias . . 18 . 9 . 1943; author reply 1943 . 10.1093/ndt/gfg247 . 12937253 .
  4. Mueller . P. S. . Murali . N. S. . Cha . S. S. . Erwin . P. J. . Ghosh . A. K. . 2006 . The effect of online status on the impact factors of general internal medicine journals . . 64 . 2 . 39–44 . 16517987.
  5. Krieger . M. M. . Richter . R. R. . Austin . T. M. . 2008 . An exploratory analysis of PubMed's free full-text limit on citation retrieval for clinical questions . . 96 . 4 . 351–355 . 10.3163/1536-5050.96.4.010 . 2568849 . 18974812.
  6. Gilman . I. . 2009 . Opening up the Evidence: Evidence-Based Practice and Open Access . Faculty Scholarship . Pacific University Libraries . July 5, 2011 . February 21, 2011 . https://web.archive.org/web/20110221233556/http://commons.pacificu.edu/libfac/4/ . dead .
  7. Clayson . Peter E. . Baldwin . Scott A. . Larson . Michael J. . 2021-06-01 . The open access advantage for studies of human electrophysiology: Impact on citations and Altmetrics . International Journal of Psychophysiology . en . 164 . 103–111 . 10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2021.03.006 . 33774077 . 232409668 . 0167-8760. free .
  8. [7]
  9. Wentz . R. . 2002 . Visibility of research: FUTON bias . . 360 . 9341 . 1256 . 10.1016/S0140-6736(02)11264-5 . 12401287 . 5084231.
  10. Gargouri . Y. . Hajjem . C. . Larivière . V. . Gingras . Y. . Carr . L. . Brody . T. . Harnad . S. . 2010 . Self-Selected or Mandated, Open Access Increases Citation Impact for Higher Quality Research . . 5 . 10 . e13636 . 1001.0361 . 2010PLoSO...513636G . 10.1371/journal.pone.0013636 . 2956678 . 20976155 . free.

  11. See also

    Further reading

  12. [11]

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Open access citation advantage".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.