Ontario Liberal Party leadership elections explained

This is a list of results of leadership elections for the Ontario Liberal Party, a political party in Ontario, Canada.

Note: Before 1919, the leaders of the Ontario Liberal Party were chosen by its elected Members of the Legislative Assembly. There were calls for a more open process as early as 1907.

1919 leadership convention

(Held on June 26, 1919 at the Foresters' Hall, 22 College Street, Toronto.)[1]

First ballot:

Second ballot:

Charles Martin Bowman, MPP for Bruce North; W.T.R. Preston, editor of the Port Hope Evening Guide, Rev. W. G. Charlton of Aylmer, and A. J. Young of Toronto were nominated but declined. Frederick Forsyth Pardee, Member of Parliament for Lambton West was to be nominated but sent a message to the convention declining.[2]

1922 leadership convention

(Held on March 3, 1922 at the Foresters' Hall, 22 College Street, Toronto.)[3]

(Note: The vote totals do not appear to have been announced.)

1930 leadership convention

(Held on December 16–17, 1930 at the King Edward Hotel in Toronto.)[4]

W.E.N. Sinclair and Sydney Tweed both withdrew from the race before balloting.

1943 leadership convention

(Held on April 30, 1943 at the King Edward Hotel in Toronto.)

There were 8 spoiled ballots. Premier Gordon Conant had also been a candidate but collapsed the morning of the leadership vote and withdrew.

1945 leadership election

(Held on April 2, 1945 at the King Edward Hotel in Toronto.)

Harry Nixon resigned as Liberal leader on December 10, 1944 and nominated Hepburn to succeed him as parliamentary leader until a leadership convention could be held.[5] Following the defeat of George Drew's Conservative government in a non-confidence motion, Hepburn was elected Acting Leader on April 2, 1945, at a joint meeting held at the King Edward Hotel of Ontario Liberal MPPs, federal Ontario Liberal MPs the party executive and other party officials in order to lead the party into the election. The move was to be affirmed by a party convention to be held on May 1, but this was cancelled due to the 1945 provincial election being underway.[6] [7] [8] Hepburn was defeated in the 1945 provincial election, and Farquhar Oliver was chosen as the Ontario Liberal Party's parliamentary leader on July 4, 1945.

1947 leadership convention

(Held on May 16, 1947 at the King Edward Hotel in Toronto)[9]

(Note: Complete vote totals were not reported. Oliver received 492 of 661 votes cast)[10]

1950 leadership convention

(Held on November 10, 1950 at the Royal York Hotel in Toronto.)[11]

First ballot:

Second ballot (Sullivan eliminated; Hicks, Cox and Hipel withdrew):

Third ballot (Calder eliminated):

1954 leadership convention

(Held on April 9, 1954 at the Royal York Hotel in Toronto.)[12]

1958 leadership convention

(Held on April 20, 1958 at the King Edward Hotel in Toronto.)[13]

First ballot:

Wren eliminated and endorsed Wintermeyer; Whicher and Reaume withdrew and endorsed Wintermeyer.[14]

Second ballot:

Singer eliminated.

Third ballot:

1964 leadership convention

See main article: 1964 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Held on September 19–20, 1964 at the Royal York Hotel in Toronto.)

Delegate support by ballot
Candidate1st ballot2nd ballot3rd ballot4th ballot5th ballot6th ballot
Name Votes cast % Votes cast % Votes cast % Votes cast % Votes cast % Votes cast %
Andy Thompson37927.740829.746233.652038.153939.977258.8
Charles Templeton31723.135625.939628.842230.941931.054041.2
Robert Nixon31322.835125.635625.938728.339229.0
Joe Greene23617.221115.414910.9372.7
Victor Copps614.5272.0100.7
Eddie Sargent513.7201.5
Joseph Gould130.9
Total1,370100.01,373100.01,373100.01,366100.01,350100.01,312100.0

1967 leadership convention

(Held on January 6, 1967 at the Royal York Hotel, Toronto)[15]

(Nixon was elected interim leader by the caucus on November 16, 1966 following the resignation of Andrew Thompson. Nixon had suggested that Charles Templeton may become permanent leader but members of his caucus spoke in opposition and Templeton decline to run. Nixon was acclaimed as permanent leader at the party's 1967 convention. He announced his resignation as party leader in 1972, but subsequently entered the race to succeed himself in 1973.)

1973 leadership convention

See main article: 1973 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election.

(Held on October 28, 1973 at the Royal York Hotel in Toronto.)

Delegate support by ballot
Candidate1st ballot2nd ballot3rd ballot
Name Votes cast % Votes cast % Votes cast %
Robert Nixon73042.576845.392257.7
Norman Cafik57433.461336.167542.3
Donald Deacon40223.431618.6Endorsed Nixon
Michael Houlton110.6No endorsement
Total1,717100.01,697100.01,597100.0

1976 leadership convention

See main article: 1976 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Held on January 24–25, 1976 at the Four Seasons Sheraton Hotel, Toronto)

Delegate support by ballot
Candidate1st ballot2nd ballot3rd ballot
Name Votes cast % Votes cast % Votes cast %
Stuart Smith62932.074238.599851.2
David Peterson51826.467334.995348.8
Albert Roy46923.951326.6No Endorsement
Mark MacGuigan30815.7No Endorsement
Larry Condon371.9No Endorsement
Michael Houlton40.2No endorsement
Total1,965100.01,928100.01,951100.0

1982 leadership convention

See main article: 1982 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Held on February 21, 1982 at the Sheraton Centre Toronto Hotel, Toronto).

= Eliminated from next round

= Withdrew nomination

= Winner

Delegate support by ballot
Candidate1st Ballot 2nd Ballot
NameVotes%Votes%
David Peterson966 46.3 1136 55.2
636 30.5 774 37.6
Richard Thomas 234 11.2 148 7.2
130 6.2
122 5.8
Votes cast by ballot
Total 2088 100.0 2058 100.0

1992 leadership convention

See main article: 1992 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Held February 8–9, 1992 at the Copps Coliseum in Hamilton.)

= Eliminated from next round

= Withdrew nomination

= Winner

Delegate support by ballot
Candidate1st Ballot 2nd Ballot 3rd Ballot 4th Ballot 5th Ballot
NameVotes%Votes%Votes%Votes%Votes%
740 30.2 767 31.8 865 35.6 988 41.6 1153 49.8
Lyn McLeod667 27.2 744 30.9 873 35.9 1049 44.1 1162 50.2
345 14.1 380 15.8 402 16.6 341 14.3 Released delegates
247 10.1 307 12.7 289 11.9 Released delegates
236 9.6 213 8.8 Supported McLeod
216 8.8 Released delegates
Votes cast by ballot
Total 2451 100.0 2411 100.0 2429 100.0 2378 100.0 2315 100.0

There were 21 spoiled ballots on the final count.

1996 leadership convention

See main article: 1996 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Held November 30 – December 1, 1996 at the Maple Leaf Gardens, Toronto)

2013 leadership election

See main article: 2013 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Held January 26, 2013 at the Maple Leaf Gardens, Toronto)

= Eliminated from next round

= Withdrew nomination

= Winner

Delegate support by ballot
CandidateCommitted[16] Ballot 1Ballot 2Ballot 3
NameVotesVotesVotes+/- (pp)Votes+/- (pp)
Sandra Pupatello 509
27.4%
599
28.7%
817
39.4%
+10.7 866
43.0%
+5.8%
Kathleen Wynne 468
25.2%
597
28.6%
750
36.2%
+7.6 1,150
57.0%
+20.8
Gerard Kennedy 260
14.0%
281
13.5%
285
13.7%
+0.2 Endorsed Wynne
Harinder Takhar 244
13.1%
235
11.3%
18
0.9%
-10.4 Endorsed Pupatello
Charles Sousa 204
11.0%
222
10.7%
203
9.8%
-0.9 Endorsed Wynne
Eric Hoskins 105
5.7%
150
7.2%
Endorsed Wynne
Independent 67
3.6%
Glen Murray Endorsed Wynne
Votes cast and net change by ballot
Total 1,857 2,084 2,073 -11 2,016 -57

Takhar endorsed Pupatello before the second ballot voting took place, but after the deadline to drop off the ballot.

2020 leadership election

See main article: 2020 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Held March 6–7, 2020 at the International Centre, Mississauga)

2023 leadership election

See main article: 2023 Ontario Liberal Party leadership election. (Results announced December 2, 2023 at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre)

A leadership election was held December 2, 2023 due to the June 2, 2022 resignation of Steven Del Duca as party leader following his party's poor result in the 2022 Ontario general election.

= Winner

Results by round
Candidate1st round2nd round3rd round
Votes cast%Points allocated%Votes cast%Points allocated%Votes cast%Points allocated%
5,55942.96%6,047 46.73%6,91153.40%
Nathaniel Erskine-Smith3,32025.66%3,79229.30%6,02946.59%
Yasir Naqvi2,76021.33%3,10123.96% Eliminated
Ted Hsu1,30010.05%Eliminated
Total100%12,939 100%100%12,940100%100%12,940 100%

According to the party, 22,827 party members cast ballots[17] out of a total membership of over 100,000.[18]

Notes and References

  1. News: ONTARIO LIBERALS TO SELECT NEW LEADER AT ELEVEN TO-DAY: Four Now in Field, and Name of F. F. Pardee, M. P., May Also Be in Nomination ADVANCED POLICY TALK IS HEARD IN CONVENTION Likely to be Important Stand Taken on Labor Question-- To-day Momentous One for Party. The Globe. 26 June 1919.
  2. News: H. HARTLEY DEWART NEW LEADER; ELECTED ON THE SECOND BALLOT BY ONTARIO LIBERAL CONVENTION: Major Tolmie of Windsor Runs Second, and Mr. Elliott Third Progressive Policies for Party Are Determined Upon OVER THREE HUNDRED BALLOTS ARE MARKED Mr. Proudfoot Expostulates With Some Heat That No Man Who Voted Union Has Chance at Any Liberal Convention. The Globe. 27 June 1919.
  3. News: ONTARIO LIBERALISM KNOWS NO COALITION UNDER U.F.O. BANNER: Convention Today Will Demonstrate That "Class Political Movement" Has No Friends in Historic Party--All Farmers By No Means "Morrisonites" RECENT ELECTION STRENGTHENS CAUSE. The Globe. 1 March 1922.
  4. News: Race for Leadership, A People's Platform, To Enthuse Liberals: Three, Maybe Four, Aspire to High Office-- Sinclair's Intentions Not Definitely Known, But His Friends Say He Is "No Quitter" 1,200 DELEGATES AT GREAT RALLY Hon. Peter Heenan Said to Be Preparing a "Bill of Rights" for Labor-Tory Strongholds in Cities to Be Assailed. The Globe. 15 December 1930.
  5. News: Nixon Quits as Leader Of Ontario Liberals. Globe and Mail. 11 December 1944.
  6. News: A Sign of Party Bankruptcy. Globe and Mail. 4 April 1945.
  7. News: Hepburn Named Ontario Leader; Is Given Backing. Globe and Mail. 3 April 1945.
  8. News: Ontario Liberal Convention MAY I. Globe and Mail. 4 April 1945.
  9. "Liberal Leadership Race Won By Oliver", Ottawa Citizen, May 17, 1947
  10. News: Name Oliver Leader By Almost 7 to 1 Margin. Toronto Daily Star. 17 May 1947.
  11. News: Brown Strongly Backed In Race Among Eight For Liberal Leadership. Globe and Mail. 10 November 1950.
  12. News: Only Half of Delegates Hear 3 Liberals Speak for Leadership: Call Rally Colorless. Globe and Mail. 9 April 1954.
  13. News: By-election Fight Wintermeyer Plan In Liberal Rebirth. Toronto Daily Star. 21 April 1958.
  14. News: Albert Wren: MRP for 10 Years In Northern Riding. Globe and Mail. 2 November 1961.
  15. News: Nixon pledges home owners tax relief. Toronto Daily Star. 7 January 1967.
  16. http://pantone201.ca/olp/2013LeadershipElectionMeetingsResults.pdf Leadership Election Meeting Results 2013
  17. News: Ontario Liberal Leadership Second Ballot Results . December 2, 2023 . Liberal Party of Ontario . December 2, 2023.
  18. News: Ontario Liberal Leadership First Round Results . December 2, 2023 . Liber . December 2, 2023.