One Manhattan Square Explained

252 South Street
Location:Manhattan, New York, United States
Mapframe-Wikidata:yes
Coordinates:40.7104°N -73.9914°W
Status:complete
Start Date:2014
Completion Date:2019
Opening:2019
Building Type:Residential, retail
Architectural:Glass
Roof:847feet[1]
Top Floor:PH
Floor Count:80
Cost:$250M
Floor Area:939850square feet
Architect:Adamson Associates, Dattner Architects
Main Contractor:Extell Development
Developer:Extell Development Company
Owner:Gary Barnett
Management:Extell Management Services
Topped Out Date:September 2017

One Manhattan Square (also known as 225 Cherry Street or 252 South Street) is a luxury residential skyscraper building developed by Extell Development Company in the Two Bridges neighborhood of Manhattan, New York City. Built from 2014 to 2019, the skyscraper was built on the site of a former Pathmark grocery store, which was demolished in 2014.[2] The building topped out in 2017 and stands out significantly within the context of the neighborhood, at 847feet in height, the next highest structure being the Manhattan Bridge at roughly 336feet in height.[3] A 13-story affordable housing component will be located separately on-site from the main tower.[4] The building topped out in September 2017 and was complete by August 2019.[5] [6]

Controversy

The neighborhood's residents immediately reacted to the closing of the old Pathmark supermarket, claiming that gentrification would prevent them from being able to buy affordable groceries. Once the Pathmark closed, other markets in the neighborhood became more expensive.[7]

Other residents of the area opposed the project because the tower would be out of context with the rest of the vicinity. Its design has also been compared to a cheese grater.[8] In fact, Extell Development Company initially proposed a tower of 68 stories or 800 feet at the site in 2014,[9] but later reduced the scale of the tower structure to 56 stories or 700 feet. Concerns are over the transit infrastructure not being able to support such a development. However, the building wound up topping out at 80 stories.

Additionally, several dozen area residents organized into a protest in April 2015 claiming the project made unequal the future residents of the affordable housing portion and those residing in the luxury tower. Some claimed the separation of the affordable portion, restricted to a 13-story structure, acted as a "poor door" for the overall development.[10]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: One Manhattan Square. Skyscraper Page. 24 November 2018.
  2. Web site: Litvak. Ed. May 29, 2014. Photos: Cherry Street Pathmark Demolition. The Lo-Down. 3 June 2015.
  3. Web site: Elie. Perler. April 2, 2015. Extell Planning to Reduce Height of 250 South Street Tower to 56 Stories. Bowery Boogie. 3 June 2015. dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20220518125450/http://www.boweryboogie.com/2015/04/extell-planning-to-reduce-height-of-250-south-street-tower-to-54-stories/ . May 18, 2022.
  4. Web site: Litvak. Ed. June 12, 2014. Extell Reveals Plans For 205-Unit Affordable Tower on Former Pathmark Site. The Lo-Down. 3 June 2015.
  5. News: Plitt. Amy. Extell's One Manhattan Square tops out on the Lower East Side. September 29, 2017. Curbed NY. August 13, 2018.
  6. News: Report: 121 Closings at One Manhattan Square in 2019 So Far. The Lo-Down. August 21, 2019.
  7. News: Conduah. Panyin. Clash Over Tower in Two Bridges. 3 June 2015. Straus News. February 25, 2015. https://web.archive.org/web/20150402164731/http://www.nypress.com/local-news/20150225/clash-over-tower-in-two-bridges. 2 April 2015. dead.
  8. Web site: Lampen. Claire. Where Isn't This Shiny Giant Cheese-Grater Tower?. 11 April 2019. Gothamist.
  9. Web site: Fedak. Nikolai. 28 April 2014. Permits Filed: 250 South Street. New York YIMBY. 27 May 2023.
  10. Web site: McCarthy. Hannah. Protesters Voice Outrage Over Extell's 'Building From Hell,' Coming to the LES. Bedford + Bowery. 28 April 2015. 3 June 2015.