On the Independence of Ukraine explained

"On the Independence of Ukraine" (Russian: На независимость Украины) is a controversial Ukrainophobic poem by Joseph Brodsky written in the early 1990s, on the occasion of the 1991 Declaration of Independence of Ukraine and the subsequent dissolution of the Soviet Union.

In the poem, Brodsky, in angry and insulting words expressed his feelings about the breach between the Ukrainian and Russian peoples. He refers to Ukrainians as, among other things, khokhly (a Russian ethnic slur for Ukrainians), vertukhais (prison guards) and Cossacks. In the poem's final lines, he states that independence-minded Ukrainians will, on their deathbed, abandon their love of poet Taras Shevchenko (considered the father of Ukrainian literature), and instead embrace poet Alexander Pushkin (considered the father of Russian literature):

The poem was never officially published. Brodsky himself is known to have read the poem in public only a few times, including at the Palo Alto Jewish community center on October 30, 1992.[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] Known only from private manuscripts, it began to receive publicity after it was published in 1994 by Ukrainian nationalists as a demonstration of Brodsky's Russian nationalist views.[4]

For some time, the authorship of the poem was disputed due to striking differences in style, e.g., by human rights activist Alexander Daniel who pointed out "surprisingly poor style" of the poem, but later retracted from his analysis, when presented with "statements from reliable witnesses" who saw Brodsky's reading of the poem.[6] In 2015, a video of Brodsky's 1992 public reading of the poem was posted on Facebook by a user named Boris Vladimirsky. This constituted sufficient proof for Daniel and others that the poem was indeed Brodsky's.[7]

In 2015, on the peak of the war in Donbass, Russian media further popularized the poem.[8]

Notes and References

  1. Book: Grudzińska-Gross, Irena . Czeslaw Milosz and Joseph Brodsky: Fellowship of Poets . New Haven. Yale University Press. 2009 . 159–160 . 978-0300149371.
  2. Book: Loseff, Lev . Joseph Brodsky: A Literary Life. Miller. Jane Ann. New Haven. Yale University Press . 2012 . 241–242 . 978-0300181609.
  3. Web site: If we have all this here, why do we need Europe?. Haven . Cynthia . 23 May 2011 . The Book Haven. . 10 May 2018.
  4. Gessen . Keith . 21 August 2011 . A Note on Brodsky and Ukraine . https://web.archive.org/web/20180317210123/https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/a-note-on-brodsky-and-ukraine . dead . 17 March 2018 . . 10 May 2018.
  5. Bertelsen . Olga . 2015 . Joseph Brodsky's Imperial Consciousness. https://web.archive.org/web/20180331213451/https://ssh.apsl.edu.pl/baza/wydawn/ssh021/263-292.pdf . dead . 2018-03-31 . Scripta Historica. . 21 . 263–289.
  6. Web site: Тщета гуманитарного знания . Daniel . Alexander. 11 February 2005 . Polit. 10 May 2018 . ru . The Vanity of the Knowledge of the Humanites.
  7. Web site: Впервые доказано авторство "На независимость Украины" Бродского . 9 April 2015 . Colta. 10 May 2018 . ru . The authorship of Brodsky's "On the Independence of Ukraine" is proven for the first time.
  8. Web site: Buch . Hans Christoph . 2022-05-31 . Ein hässlicher Fleck auf der sonst weissen politischen Weste – wie Joseph Brodsky dazu kam, in einem Gedicht die Ukraine zu schmähen . NZZ.