Proto-Celtic language explained

Proto-Celtic
Also Known As:PC, Common Celtic
Region:Central or Western Europe
Era:ca. 1300–800 BC
Familycolor:Indo-European
Ancestor:Proto-Indo-European
Target:Celtic languages

Proto-Celtic, or Common Celtic, is the hypothetical ancestral proto-language of all known Celtic languages, and a descendant of Proto-Indo-European. It is not attested in writing but has been partly reconstructed through the comparative method. Proto-Celtic is generally thought to have been spoken between 1300 and 800 BC, after which it began to split into different languages. Proto-Celtic is often associated with the Urnfield culture and particularly with the Hallstatt culture. Celtic languages share common features with Italic languages that are not found in other branches of Indo-European, suggesting the possibility of an earlier Italo-Celtic linguistic unity.

Proto-Celtic is currently being reconstructed through the comparative method by relying on later Celtic languages. Though Continental Celtic presents much substantiation for Proto-Celtic phonology, and some for its morphology, recorded material is too scanty to allow a secure reconstruction of syntax, though some complete sentences are recorded in the Continental Gaulish and Celtiberian. So the main sources for reconstruction come from Insular Celtic languages with the oldest literature found in Old Irish[1] and Middle Welsh,[2] dating back to authors flourishing in the 6th century AD.

Dating

Proto-Celtic is usually dated to the Late Bronze Age, ca. 1200–900 BC.[3] The fact that it is possible to reconstruct a Proto-Celtic word for 'iron' (traditionally reconstructed as

) has long been taken as an indication that the divergence into individual Celtic languages did not start until the Iron Age (8th century BCE to 1st century BCE); otherwise, descendant languages would have developed their own, unrelated words for their metal. However, Schumacher[4] and Schrijver[5] suggest a date for Proto-Celtic as early as the 13th century BC, the time of the Canegrate culture, in northwest Italy, and the Urnfield culture in Central Europe, implying that the divergence may have already started in the Bronze Age.

Sound changes from Proto-Indo-European

The phonological changes from Proto-Indo-European (PIE) to Proto-Celtic (PC) may be summarized as follows. The changes are roughly in chronological order, with changes that operate on the outcome of earlier ones appearing later in the list.

Late PIE

These changes are shared by several other Indo-European branches.

Italo-Celtic

The following sound changes are shared with the Italic languages in particular, and are cited in support of the Italo-Celtic hypothesis.

One change shows non-exact parallels in Italic: vocalization of syllabic resonants next to laryngeals depending on the environment. Similar developments appear in Italic, but for the syllabic nasals *m̩, *n̩, the result is Proto-Italic *əm, *ən (> Latin em ~ im, en ~ in).

Early PC

Late PC

Examples

PIEPCExample
PIEProto-CelticOld IrishWelsh
fatherathiredryddcf. home (< *ɸatrijo-)
threetrítri


sing
hundred
canaid
cét pronounced as //kʲeːd//
canu
cant
fourceth(a)irpedwar
appleuballafal
seederceyedrychsight


to glue
jaw
glen(a)id
giun, gin
(he) sticks fast
mouth
glynu
gên
adhere
jaw
womanbenO.W. ben
carryberid(he) carriesadfer
cymeryd[10]
to restore
to take
suckdenaitthey suckdynu, denu


take
sickness
ga(i)bid
galar
(he) takes
sickness
gafael
galar
hold
grief
kill, woundgonaid(he) wounds, slaysgwanustab
oldsenhen
mothermáthirmodrybcf. aunt
nephewniadnai
lickligid(he) licksllyo, llyfu
king (gen. ríg)rhi
youngóacieuanc
rulershipflaithgwladcountry
PIEPCExample
PIEPCOld IrishWelsh

  • acc. *abonen
riveraubafon
brotherbráthirbrawd
oldsenhen
between
consonants[11]
fatherathiredryddcf. home
truefírgwir
wheelrothrhod
in final syllablenephewniænai
elsewheregiftdándawn
worldbithbyd
numberrímrhif


blind
age
cáech
one-eyed
coeg
hoedl
empty, one-eyed
age
goddíaduw
oneóen oín;
áen aín
un
before
  • >
    *
youngóacieuanc
elsewherestreamsruthffrwd
mysteryrúnrhin
silenttáuesilence
(*)
taw



people
cow
túath
tud
M.W. bu, biw
before stopswidelethanllydan
before other
consonants
roostercailech
(Ogham gen. )
ceiliog
before stopsact of bearing; mindbreth, brithbryd
before other
consonants
deadmarbmarw
subdueM.Ir.
damnaid
he ties,
fastens,
binds
toothdét pronounced as //dʲeːd//dant
before obstruentslordshipflaithgwladcountry
before sonorantshandlámllaw
before obstruentsbetrayalmrathbrad
before sonorantsgraingrángrawn
(presumably with
same distribution
as above)
to tamedaimid
fodam-
daimid
-
goddefendure, suffer
  • ?
knowngnáthgnawdcustomary

Phonological reconstruction

Consonants

The following consonants have been reconstructed for Proto-Celtic (PC):

MannerVoicing Bilabial  Alveolar  Palatal  Velar 
plainlabialized
Plosivevoicelesspronounced as /t/pronounced as /k/pronounced as /kʷ/
voicedpronounced as /b/pronounced as /d/pronounced as /ɡ/pronounced as /ɡʷ/
Fricativepronounced as /ɸ/pronounced as /s/pronounced as /x/
Nasalpronounced as /m/pronounced as /n/
Approximantpronounced as /l/pronounced as /j/pronounced as /w/
Trillpronounced as /r/

Allophones of plosives

Eska has recently proposed that PC stops allophonically manifest similarly to those in English. Voiceless stop phonemes /t k/ were aspirated word-initially except when preceded by /s/, hence aspirate allophones [tʰ kʰ]. And unaspirated voiced stops /b d ɡ/ were devoiced to [p t k] word-initially.[12] [13]

This allophony may be reconstructed to PC from the following evidence:[12] [13]

Evolution of plosives

Proto-Indo-European (PIE) voiced aspirate stops *, *, *gʰ/ǵʰ, merge with *b, *d, *g/ǵ in PC. The voiced aspirate labiovelar *gʷʰ did not merge with *, though: plain * became PC *b, while aspirated *gʷʰ became *. Thus, PIE *gʷen- 'woman' became Old Irish and Old Welsh ben, but PIE *gʷʰn̥- 'to kill, wound' became Old Irish gonaid and Welsh gwanu.

PIE *p is lost in PC, apparently going through the stages *ɸ (possibly a stage *[pʰ])[12] and *h (perhaps seen in the name Hercynia if this is of Celtic origin) before being completely lost word-initially and between vowels. Next to consonants, PC *ɸ underwent different changes: the clusters *ɸs and *ɸt became *xs and *xt respectively already in PC. PIE *sp- became Old Irish s (f- when lenited, exactly as for PIE *sw-) and Brythonic f; while argues there was an intermediate stage *sɸ- (in which *ɸ remained an independent phoneme until after Proto-Insular Celtic had diverged into Goidelic and Brythonic), finds it more economical to believe that *sp- remained unchanged in PC, that is, the change *p to *ɸ did not happen when *s preceded. (Similarly, Grimm's law did not apply to *p, t, k after *s in Germanic, and the same exception occurred again in the High German consonant shift.)

Proto-CelticOld IrishWelsh
  • > * 'shine'
las-aidllach-ar
  • > * 'seven'
sechtsaith
  • or * 'heel'
seirffêr

In Gaulish and the Brittonic languages, the Proto-Indo-European * phoneme becomes a new * sound. Thus, Gaulish petuar[ios], Welsh pedwar "four", but Old Irish cethair and Latin quattuor. Insofar as this new pronounced as //p// fills the gap in the phoneme inventory which was left by the disappearance of the equivalent stop in PIE, we may think of this as a chain shift.

The terms P-Celtic and Q-Celtic are useful for grouping Celtic languages based on the way they handle this one phoneme. But a simple division into P- / Q-Celtic may be untenable, as it does not do justice to the evidence of the ancient Continental Celtic languages. The many unusual shared innovations among the Insular Celtic languages are often also presented as evidence against a P- vs Q-Celtic division, but they may instead reflect a common substratum influence from the pre-Celtic languages of Britain and Ireland,http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/288/5469/1158, or simply continuing contact between the insular languages; in either case they would be irrelevant to the genetic classification of Celtic languages.

Q-Celtic languages may also have pronounced as //p// in loan words, though in early borrowings from Welsh into Primitive Irish, pronounced as //kʷ// was used by sound substitution due to a lack of a pronounced as //p// phoneme at the time:

Gaelic póg "kiss" was a later borrowing (from the second word of the Latin phrase osculum pacis "kiss of peace") at a stage where p was borrowed directly as p, without substituting c.

Vowels

The PC vowel system is highly comparable to that reconstructed for PIE by Antoine Meillet. The following monophthongs are reconstructed:

TypeFrontCentralBack
 long  short  long  short  long  short 
Closepronounced as /iː/pronounced as /i/ pronounced as /uː/pronounced as /u/
Midpronounced as /eː/pronounced as /e/ pronounced as /o/
Open pronounced as /aː/pronounced as /a/ 

The following diphthongs have also been reconstructed:

+TypeWith -iWith -u
With a- pronounced as /ai/ pronounced as /au/
With o- pronounced as /oi/ pronounced as /ou/

Morphology

Nouns

The morphological (structure) of nouns and adjectives demonstrates no arresting alterations from the parent language. Proto-Celtic is believed to have had nouns in three genders, three numbers and five to eight cases. The genders were masculine, feminine and neuter; the numbers were singular, plural and dual. The number of cases is a subject of contention:[14] while Old Irish may have only five, the evidence from Continental Celtic is considered rather unambiguous despite appeals to archaic retentions or morphological leveling. These cases were nominative, vocative, accusative, dative, genitive, ablative, locative and instrumental.

Nouns fall into nine or so declensions, depending on stem. There are *o-stems, *ā-stems, *i-stems, *u-stems, dental stems, velar stems, nasal stems, *r-stems and *s-stems.

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • makkʷos
  • makkʷou
  • makkʷoi
Vocative
  • makkʷe
  • makkʷou
  • makkʷūs
Accusative
  • makkʷom
  • makkʷou
  • makkʷūs
Genitive
  • makkʷī
  • makkʷūs
  • makkʷom
Dative
  • makkʷūi
  • makkʷobom
  • makkʷobos
Ablative
  • makkʷū
  • makkʷobim
  • makkʷobis
Instrumental
  • makkʷū
  • makkʷobim
  • makkʷūs
Locative
  • makkʷei
  • makkʷou
  • makkʷobis

However, Celtiberian shows -o- stem genitives ending in -o rather than : aualo "[son] of Avalos".[15]

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • dūnom
  • dūnou
  • dūnā
Vocative
  • dūnom
  • dūnou
  • dūnā
Accusative
  • dūnom
  • dūnou
  • dūnā
Genitive
  • dūnī
  • dūnūs
  • dūnom
Dative
  • dūnūi
  • dūnobom
  • dūnobos
Ablative
  • dūnū
  • dūnobim
  • dūnobis
Instrumental
  • dūnū
  • dūnobim
  • dūnūs
Locative
  • dūnei
  • dūnou
  • dūnobis

E.g. *ɸlāmā 'hand' (feminine) (Old Irish lám; Welsh llaw, Cornish leuv, Old Breton lom)

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • ɸlāmā
  • ɸlāmai
  • ɸlāmās
Vocative
  • ɸlāmā
  • ɸlāmai
  • ɸlāmās
Accusative
  • ɸlāmām
  • ɸlāmai
  • ɸlāmās
Genitive
  • ɸlāmās
  • ɸlāmajous
  • ɸlāmom
Dative
  • ɸlāmāi
  • ɸlāmābom
  • ɸlāmābos
Ablative
  • ɸlāmī
  • ɸlāmābim
  • ɸlāmābis
Instrumental
  • ɸlāmī
  • ɸlāmābim
  • ɸlāmābis
Locative
  • ɸlāmāi
  • ɸlāmābim
  • ɸlāmābis

E.g. *sūlis 'sight, view, eye' (feminine) (Brittonic sulis ~ Old Irish súil)

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • sūlis
  • sūlī
  • sūlīs
Vocative
  • sūli
  • sūlī
  • sūlīs
Accusative
  • sūlim
  • sūlī
  • sūlīs
Genitive
  • sūleis
  • sūljous
  • sūljom
Dative
  • sūlei
  • sūlibom
  • sūlibos
Ablative
  • sūlī
  • sūlibim
  • sūlibis
Instrumental
  • sūlī
  • sūlibim
  • sūlibis
Locative
  • sūlī
  • sūlibim
  • sūlibis

E.g. *mori 'body of water, sea' (neuter) (Gaulish Mori- ~ Old Irish muir ~ Welsh môr)

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • mori
  • morī
  • moryā
Vocative
  • mori
  • morī
  • moryā
Accusative
  • mori
  • morī
  • moryā
Genitive
  • moreis
  • moryous
  • moryom
Dative
  • morei
  • moribom
  • moribos
Ablative
  • morī
  • moribim
  • moribis
Instrumental
  • morī
  • moribim
  • moribis
Locative
  • morī
  • moribim
  • moribis

E.g. *bitus 'world, existence' (masculine) (Gaulish Bitu- ~ Old Irish bith ~ Welsh byd ~ Breton bed)

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • bitus
  • bitou
  • bitowes
Vocative
  • bitu
  • bitou
  • bitowes
Accusative
  • bitum
  • bitou
  • bitūs
Genitive
  • bitous
  • bitowou
  • bitowom
Dative
  • bitou
  • bitubom
  • bitubos
Ablative
  • bitū
  • bitubim
  • bitubis
Instrumental
  • bitū
  • bitubim
  • bitubis
Locative
  • bitū
  • bitubim
  • bitubis

E.g. Celtic languages: *beru "rotisserie spit" (neuter)

CaseSingularDualPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *beruCeltic languages: *berouCeltic languages: *berwā
VocativeCeltic languages: *beruCeltic languages: *berouCeltic languages: *berwā
AccusativeCeltic languages: *beruCeltic languages: *berouCeltic languages: *berwā
GenitiveCeltic languages: *berousCeltic languages: *berowouCeltic languages: *berowom
DativeCeltic languages: *berouCeltic languages: *berubomCeltic languages: *berubos
AblativeCeltic languages: *berūCeltic languages: *berubimCeltic languages: *berubis
InstrumentalCeltic languages: *berūCeltic languages: *berubimCeltic languages: *berubis
LocativeCeltic languages: *berūCeltic languages: *berubimCeltic languages: *berubis

Velar and dental stems

Before the *-s of the nominative singular, a velar consonant was fricated to *-x : Celtic languages: *rīg- "king" > Celtic languages: *rīxs. Likewise, final *-d devoiced to *-t-: Celtic languages: *druwid- "druid" > Celtic languages: *druwits.[16]

E.g. "king" (masculine)

CaseSingularDualPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *rīxsCeltic languages: *rīgeCeltic languages: *rīges
VocativeCeltic languages: *rīxs Celtic languages: *rīgeCeltic languages: *rīges
AccusativeCeltic languages: *rīgamCeltic languages: *rīgeCeltic languages: *rīgās
GenitiveCeltic languages: *rīgosCeltic languages: *rīgouCeltic languages: *rīgom
DativeCeltic languages: *rīgeiCeltic languages: *rīgobomCeltic languages: *rīgobos
AblativeCeltic languages: *rīgīCeltic languages: *rīgobimCeltic languages: *rīgobis
InstrumentalCeltic languages: *rīgeCeltic languages: *rīgobimCeltic languages: *rīgobis
LocativeCeltic languages: *rīgiCeltic languages: *rīgobimCeltic languages: *rīgobis

E.g. "druid" (masculine)

CaseSingularDualPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *druwitsCeltic languages: *druwideCeltic languages: *druwides
VocativeCeltic languages: *druwitsCeltic languages: *druwideCeltic languages: *druwides
AccusativeCeltic languages: *druwidemCeltic languages: *druwideCeltic languages: *druwidās
GenitiveCeltic languages: *druwidosCeltic languages: *druwidouCeltic languages: *druwidom
DativeCeltic languages: *druwideiCeltic languages: *druwidobomCeltic languages: *druwidobos
AblativeCeltic languages: *druwidīCeltic languages: *druwidobimCeltic languages: *druwidobis
InstrumentalCeltic languages: *druwideCeltic languages: *druwidobimCeltic languages: *druwidobis
LocativeCeltic languages: *druwidiCeltic languages: *druwidobimCeltic languages: *druwidobis

E.g. "friend" (masculine)

CaseSingularDualPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *karantsCeltic languages: *karanteCeltic languages: *karantes
VocativeCeltic languages: *karantsCeltic languages: *karanteCeltic languages: *karantes
AccusativeCeltic languages: *karantamCeltic languages: *karanteCeltic languages: *karantās
GenitiveCeltic languages: *karantosCeltic languages: *karantouCeltic languages: *karantom
DativeCeltic languages: *karanteiCeltic languages: *karantobomCeltic languages: *karantobos
AblativeCeltic languages: *karantīCeltic languages: *karantobimCeltic languages: *karantobis
InstrumentalCeltic languages: *karanteCeltic languages: *karantobimCeltic languages: *karantobis
LocativeCeltic languages: *karantiCeltic languages: *karantobimCeltic languages: *karantobis

Nasal stems

Generally, nasal stems end in *-on-; this becomes *-ū in the nominative singular: *abon- "river" > *abū.

E.g. "river" (feminine)

CaseSingularDualPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *abūCeltic languages: *aboneCeltic languages: *abones
VocativeCeltic languages: *abūCeltic languages: *aboneCeltic languages: *abones
AccusativeCeltic languages: *abonamCeltic languages: *aboneCeltic languages: *abonās
GenitiveCeltic languages: *abonosCeltic languages: *abonouCeltic languages: *abonom
DativeCeltic languages: *aboneiCeltic languages: *abnobomCeltic languages: *abnobos
AblativeCeltic languages: *abonīCeltic languages: *abnobimCeltic languages: *abnobis
InstrumentalCeltic languages: *aboneCeltic languages: *abnobimCeltic languages: *abnobis
LocativeCeltic languages: *aboniCeltic languages: *abnobimCeltic languages: *abnobis

E.g. "name" (neuter)

CaseSingularDualPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *anmanCeltic languages: *anmanīCeltic languages: *anmanā
VocativeCeltic languages: *anmanCeltic languages: *anmanīCeltic languages: *anmanā
AccusativeCeltic languages: *anmanCeltic languages: *anmanīCeltic languages: *anmanā
GenitiveCeltic languages: *anmēsCeltic languages: *anmanouCeltic languages: *anmanom
DativeCeltic languages: *anmaneiCeltic languages: *anmambomCeltic languages: *anmambos
AblativeCeltic languages: *anmanīCeltic languages: *anmambimCeltic languages: *anmambis
InstrumentalCeltic languages: *anmaneCeltic languages: *anmambimCeltic languages: *anmambis
LocativeCeltic languages: *anmaniCeltic languages: *anmambimCeltic languages: *anmambis

Generally,Celtic languages: *s-stems contain an *-es-, which becomes *-os in the nominative singular: Celtic languages: *teges- 'house' > Celtic languages: *tegos.

E.g. "house" (neuter)

CaseSingularDualPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *tegosCeltic languages: *tegeseCeltic languages: *tegesa
VocativeCeltic languages: *tegosCeltic languages: *tegeseCeltic languages: *tegesa
AccusativeCeltic languages: *tegosCeltic languages: *tegeseCeltic languages: *tegesa
GenitiveCeltic languages: *tegesosCeltic languages: *tegesouCeltic languages: *tegesom
DativeCeltic languages: *tegesiCeltic languages: *tegesobomCeltic languages: *tegesobos
AblativeCeltic languages: *tegesīCeltic languages: *tegesobimCeltic languages: *tegesobis
InstrumentalCeltic languages: *tegeseCeltic languages: *tegesobimCeltic languages: *tegesobis
LocativeCeltic languages: *tegesiCeltic languages: *tegesobimCeltic languages: *tegesobis

E.g. *ɸatīr 'father' (masculine)

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • ɸatīr
  • ɸatere
  • ɸateres
Vocative
  • ɸatīr
  • ɸatere
  • ɸateres
Accusative
  • ɸateram
  • ɸatere
  • ɸaterās
Genitive
  • ɸatros
  • ɸatrou
  • ɸatrom
Dative
  • ɸatrei
  • ɸatrebom
  • ɸatrebos
Ablative
  • ɸatrī
  • ɸatrebim
  • ɸatrebis
Instrumental
  • ɸatre
  • ɸatrebim
  • ɸatrebis
Locative
  • ɸatri
  • ɸatrebim
  • ɸatrebis

E.g. *mātīr 'mother' (feminine)

CaseSingularDualPlural
Nominative
  • mātīr
  • mātere
  • māteres
Vocative
  • mātīr
  • mātere
  • māteres
Accusative
  • māteram
  • mātere
  • māterās
Genitive
  • mātros
  • mātrou
  • mātrom
Dative
  • mātrei
  • mātrebom
  • mātrebos
Ablative
  • mātrī
  • mātrebim
  • mātrebis
Instrumental
  • mātre
  • mātrebim
  • mātrebis
Locative
  • mātri
  • mātrebim
  • mātrebis

Pronouns

The following personal pronouns in Celtic can be reconstructed as follows:[17] [18]

CaseFirst-personSecond-person
SingularPluralSingularPlural
NominativeCeltic languages: *mīCeltic languages: *snīCeltic languages: *tūCeltic languages: *swī
AccusativeCeltic languages: *me[19] Celtic languages: *snosCeltic languages: *tuCeltic languages: *swes
GenitiveCeltic languages: *mene[20] ?Celtic languages: *towe?

The following third-person pronouns in Proto-Celtic may also be reconstructed.[21] [17]

CaseSingularPlural
MasculineFeminineNeuter
NominativeCeltic languages: *es, Celtic languages: *ēsCeltic languages: *sīCeltic languages: *edCeltic languages: *eyes
AccusativeCeltic languages: *emCeltic languages: *seyam? Celtic languages: *sīm?Celtic languages: *sūs
GenitiveCeltic languages: *esyoCeltic languages: *esyāsCeltic languages: *esyoCeltic languages: *ēsom? Celtic languages: *esom?
Dative
Instrumental
Locative
Celtic languages: *e(s)yōiCeltic languages: *esyāiCeltic languages: *e(s)yōiCeltic languages: *ēbis

Forms of the masculine singular relative pronoun *yo- can be found in the first Botorrita plaque: The form io-s in line 10 is the nominative singular masculine of the relative pronoun from Proto-Indo-European *yo- (Sanskrit ya-, Greek hos), which shows up in Old Irish only as the aspiration for leniting relative verb forms. Line 7 has the accusative singular io-m and the dative singular io-mui of the same root.[22]

Adjectives

Adjectives in Proto-Celtic had positive, comparative, superlative and equative degrees of comparison.

Positive-degree inflection classes

Four inflection classes for positive-degree adjectives are known. Most adjectives belonged to the o-ā class, in which the adjectives inflected like masculine o-stems, neuter o-stems and feminine ā-stems when agreeing with nouns of their respective genders. A much smaller minority of adjectives were i- and u-stems.

Consonant-stem adjectives also existed but were vanishingly rare, with only relics in Old Irish like Irish, Old (to 900);: "hot" < Celtic languages: *teɸents.

Comparative degree

The comparative degree was formed on most adjectives by attaching Celtic languages: *-yūs to the adjective stem. For instance, Celtic languages: *senos "old" would have a comparative Celtic languages: *senyūs "older". However, some Caland system adjectives instead had a comparative ending in Celtic languages: *-is, which was then extended to Celtic languages: *-ais. For example, Celtic languages: *ɸlitanos "wide" had a comparative Celtic languages: *ɸletais.[23]

Superlative degree

The superlative was formed by simply attaching Celtic languages: *-isamos to the adjective stem. In some adjectives where the stem ends in *s, the suffix is truncated to Celtic languages: *-(s)amos by haplology.[23] Thus, Celtic languages: *senos "old" would have a superlative Celtic languages: *senisamos "oldest" but Celtic languages: *trexsnos (stem Celtic languages: *trexs-) would have a superlative Celtic languages: *trexsamos.

Verbs

From comparison between early Old Irish and Gaulish forms it seems that Continental and Insular Celtic verbs developed differently and so the study of Irish and Welsh may have unduly weighted past opinion of Proto-Celtic verb morphology. It can be inferred from Gaulish and Celtiberian as well as Insular Celtic that the Proto-Celtic verb had at least three moods:

and four tenses:

A probable optative mood also features in Gaulish (tixsintor) and an infinitive (with a characteristic ending -unei) in Celtiberian.[24] [25]

Verbs were formed by adding suffixes to a verbal stem. The stem might be thematic or athematic, an open or a closed syllable.

Primary endings

The primary endings in Proto-Celtic were as follows. They were used to form the present, future, and subjunctive conjugations.[17]

Proto-Celtic primary endings
Person and numberBasic endingsThematic present
Active Mediopassive Active Mediopassive
1st Celtic languages: *-ū (thematic)
Celtic languages: -mi (athematic)
Celtic languages: *-ūrCeltic languages: *-ūCeltic languages: *-ūr
2nd Celtic languages: *-siCeltic languages: *-tarCeltic languages: *-esiCeltic languages: *-etar
3rd Celtic languages: *-tiCeltic languages: *-torCeltic languages: *-etiCeltic languages: *-etor
1st Celtic languages: *-mosiCeltic languages: *-morCeltic languages: *-omosiCeltic languages: *-omor
2nd Celtic languages: *-tesiCeltic languages: *-dweCeltic languages: *-etesiCeltic languages: *-edwe
3rd Celtic languages: *-ntiCeltic languages: *-ntorCeltic languages: *-ontiCeltic languages: *-ontor

Present-stem formations

Proto-Celtic possessed a diverse set of ways to form present stems. They can be roughly be divided into two broad categories of athematic and thematic.

These two inflectional categories can themselves be subdivided based on the means of derivation from a verb root via a combination of root ablaut grades and suffixes. These derivational classes include:

Derivational classes of Proto-Celtic verbs! Inflectional class! Root ablaut! Affix! Class! KPV designation
Thematice-grade(none)Simple thematicA-1
  • -ye-
e-grade *-ye-A-5
  • -de-
e-grade *-de-A-6
o-gradeCeltic languages: -ī-
Celtic languages: -eyo-
  • -eye- causative/iterative
(none)
zero grade(none)Thematized root athematicA-2
tudáti-type thematic
  • -ske-
  • -ske- inchoative
A-3
  • -ye-
zero-grade *-ye-A-4
Nasal infixAniṭ-root nasal-infixA-8
i-reduplicationi-reduplicated presentA-15
(varied)
  • -āye-
Denominative(none)
Athematice-grade(none)CeRH-root presentA-13
zero grade
  • -na- (when levelled)
seṭ-root nasal-infixA-8
  • -nu-
  • -new- present
A-10
  • -ī-
essiveA-7
(varied)
  • -ā-
factitive(none)

Nasal-infix presents

In Proto-Celtic, the Indo-European nasal infix presents split into two categories: ones originally derived from laryngeal-final roots (i.e. seṭ roots in Sanskrit), and ones that were not (i.e. from aniṭ roots). In seṭ verbs, the nasal appears at the end of the present stem, while in aniṭ-derived verbs the nasal was followed by a root-final stop (generally -g- in Old Irish).

To aniṭ roots

Aniṭ nasal infix verbs conjugated exactly like basic thematic verbs in the present tense.

However, the origin of the invariant root vowel in -o- in *CewC- roots in Old Irish is unclear. Usually, it is held that the consonantism in these verbs was generalized in favour of the plural stem *CunC- in Old Irish. One would expect alternation between o in the 1st- and 3rd- person plural and -u- elsewhere in the present; but for both contexts Old Irish only attests -o-.

The following verbs can be reconstructed in this class:

To seṭ roots

On the other hand, the seṭ presents originally had a long vowel after the nasal in the singular and -a- after the nasal in the plural, but the attested Celtic languages levelled this alternation away. Gaulish shows traces of the singular long-vowel vocalism while Old Irish generalized the plural -a- to the singular.[26]

The seṭ nasal-infix presents were further subdivided into subcategories based on the root-final laryngeal. Traditionally two subclasses have long been accepted, the Indo-European languages: *h₁ subclass (cited with a -ni- suffix) and Indo-European languages: *h₂ (cited with a -na- suffix). Indo-European languages: *h₃ nasal-infixed verbs were often leveled to act like Indo-European languages: *h₂ verbs, being also cited with a -na- suffix; the only original difference between the two would have been the 3rd-person plural ending in *-nonti instead of *-nanti.

The nasal-infix seṭ verbs in Proto-Celtic underwent multiple levelings. First, the suffixal vowel in the plural forms was harmonized so that they would all be the short counterpart to the vowel in the singular forms. Then all the long vowels in the singular were shortened to make the suffix vowel identical in quality and length across all person-number combinations.

Evolution of Proto-Celtic ablaut in the nasal infix for seṭ roots
Person and numberPre-levelingLeveling of vowel qualityLeveling of vowel length
Indo-European languages: *h₁ verbsIndo-European languages: *h₂ verbsIndo-European languages: *h₃ verbsIndo-European languages: *h₁ verbsIndo-European languages: *h₂ and Indo-European languages: *h₃ verbsIndo-European languages: *h₁ verbsIndo-European languages: *h₂ and Indo-European languages: *h₃ verbs
1st Celtic languages: *-nīmiCeltic languages: *-nāmiCeltic languages: *-nāmiCeltic languages: *-nīmiCeltic languages: *-nāmiCeltic languages: *-nimiCeltic languages: *-nami
2nd Celtic languages: *-nīsiCeltic languages: *-nāsiCeltic languages: *-nāsiCeltic languages: *-nīsiCeltic languages: *-nāsiCeltic languages: *-nisiCeltic languages: *-nasi
3rd Celtic languages: *-nītiCeltic languages: *-nātiCeltic languages: *-nātiCeltic languages: *-nītiCeltic languages: *-nātiCeltic languages: *-nitiCeltic languages: *-nati
1st Celtic languages: *-namosiCeltic languages: *-namosiCeltic languages: *-namosiCeltic languages: *-nimosiCeltic languages: *-namosiCeltic languages: *-nimosiCeltic languages: *-namosi
2nd Celtic languages: *-natesiCeltic languages: *-natesiCeltic languages: *-natesiCeltic languages: *-nitesiCeltic languages: *-natesiCeltic languages: *-nitesiCeltic languages: *-natesi
3rd Celtic languages: *-nentiCeltic languages: *-nantiCeltic languages: *-nontiCeltic languages: *-nintiCeltic languages: *-nantiCeltic languages: *-nintiCeltic languages: *-nanti

The following seṭ-root nasal presents are reconstructible for Proto-Celtic:

Preterite formations

There were two or three major preterite formations in Proto-Celtic, plus another moribund type.

The s-, t-, and root aorist preterites take Indo-European secondary endings, while the reduplicated suffix preterite took stative endings. These endings are:[27]

Proto-Celtic preterite endings
Person and numberEnding type
Secondary endingsStative endings
1st Celtic languages: *-amCeltic languages: *-a
2nd Celtic languages: *-sCeltic languages: *-as
3rd Celtic languages: *-tCeltic languages: *-e
1st Celtic languages: *-mo(s)Celtic languages: *-mo
2nd Celtic languages: *-te(s)Celtic languages: *-te
3rd Celtic languages: *-antCeltic languages: *-ar
t-preterite

The Old Irish t-preterite was traditionally assumed to be a divergent evolution from the s-preterite, but that derivation was challenged by Jay Jasanoff, who alleges that they were instead imperfects of Narten presents. Either derivation requires Narten ablaut anyway, leading to a stem vowel i in the singular and e in the plural. The stem vowel in the t-preterite was leveled to *e if the next consonant was either velar or *m, and *i in front of *r or *l.[28]

Suffixless preterites

Many suffixless preterite formations featured reduplication. The nature of the reduplication depends on the structure of the root.[27]

Proto-Celtic suffixless preterites
RootMeaningShapePreterite stemNotes
Celtic languages: *keng-"to step"Other root typesCeltic languages: *ke-kong-Classic Indo-European reduplication, where the root is put in the o-grade and the prefixed reduplicant is formed with the first consonant followed by *e.
Celtic languages: *nigʷ- "to wash"
  • C(R)eiT-
Celtic languages: *ni-noig-In Proto-Celtic, roots with a semivowel (PIE Indo-European languages: *-y- or *-w-) before a non-laryngeal consonant have the reduplicant formed not with the first consonant of the root followed by *e, but instead the first consonant of the root followed by the semivowel. The root itself remains in the o-grade.
Celtic languages: *duk- "to lead, carry"
  • C(R)euT-
Celtic languages: *du-douk-
Celtic languages: *gʷed- "to pray"
  • CeT-
Celtic languages: *gʷād-Roots ending in only a single stop as their coda generally merely change the stem vowel to Celtic languages: to form their preterite, without apparent reduplication. It originally spread from Celtic languages: ād- (from Indo-European languages: h₁e-h₁od-), the preterite stem for Celtic languages: *ed- "to eat".
Celtic languages: *kerd- "to throw, put"
  • CeRT-
Celtic languages: *kard-A few roots in *CeRT- also had the *CeT- preterite formation applied to them but the long Celtic languages: was shortened due to Osthoff's law.
Celtic languages: *dā-"to give"
  • C(C)eH-
Celtic languages: *de-dū (singular)
Celtic languages: *ded(a)- (plural)
Laryngeal-final roots produced long vowels in the root syllable in the singular, but not in the plural (where the root was in the zero-grade instead). Usually the singular stem was generalized in Celtic, but in these cases the plural stem was generalized.
Celtic languages: *kʷri- "to buy"
  • C(R)eiH-
Celtic languages: *kʷi-kʷr-The treatment for *CeH- roots was also extended to *C(R)eiH- roots. Due to the roots' semivowel, the reduplicant also contains the semivowel.

Future formations

One major formation of the future in Celtic, the s-future. It is a descendant of the Proto-Indo-European (h₁)se-desiderative, with i-reduplication in many verbs. The Old Irish a- and s-future come from here.

Another future formation, attested only in Gaulish, is the -sye-desiderative.

Subjunctive formations

Most verbs took one subjunctive suffix in Proto-Celtic, -(a)s-, followed by the thematic primary endings. It was a descendant of the subjunctive of an Indo-European sigmatic thematic formation

. The -ase- variant originated in roots that ended in a laryngeal in Proto-Indo-European; when the *-se- suffix was attached right after a laryngeal, the laryngeal regularly vocalized into *-a-. It would then analogically spread to other Celtic strong verb roots ending in sonorants in addition to the weak verbs, even if the root did not originally end in a laryngeal.[29]

There were also three verbs that did not use -(a)se-, instead straight-out taking thematised primary endings. Two of these verbs are Celtic languages: *bwiyeti "to be, exist" (subjunctive Celtic languages: *bweti) and Celtic languages: *klinutor "to hear" (subjunctive Celtic languages: *klowetor).[30]

Primary subjunctive formations in Proto-Celtic generally use the e-grade of the verb root, even if the present stem uses the zero-grade.

Imperative formation

Imperative endings in Proto-Celtic were as follows:[17] [31]

Imperative endings in Proto-Celtic
Person and numberActive endings
Basic endingsWith thematic vowels
2nd -∅, Celtic languages: *-siCeltic languages: *-e
3rd Celtic languages: *-tou, Celtic languages: *-tūd, Celtic languages: *-tuCeltic languages: *-etou, Celtic languages: *-etūd, Celtic languages: *-etu
1st Celtic languages: *-mo(s)Celtic languages: *-omo(s)
2nd Celtic languages: *-te(s)Celtic languages: *-ete(s)
3rd Celtic languages: *-ntou, Celtic languages: *-ntuCeltic languages: *-ontou, Celtic languages: *-ontu
Second-person singular imperative

The second-person singular imperative was generally endingless in the active; no ending was generally added to athematic verbs. On thematic -e/o- verbs, the imperative ended in thematic vowel *-e. However, there is also another second-person singular active imperative ending, -si, which was attached to the verb root athematically even with thematic strong verbs.[32]

The thematic deponent second-person singular imperative ending was *-eso. The -the in Old Irish is secondary.[33] [17]

Third-person imperative

The third-person imperative endings in Insular Celtic, Gaulish and Celtiberian have completely separate origins from each other. The Insular Celtic endings are derived from Celtic languages: *-tou, *-ntou, Gaulish endings from Celtic languages: *-tu, *-ntu, and the Celtiberian third-person imperative singular ending stems from Celtic languages: *-tūd.[31]

Example conjugations

See also: Grammatical conjugation. Scholarly reconstructions [34] [35] [36] may be summarised in tabular format.

!rowspan="2"
PersonPresentImperfectFuturePast
Medio-
passive
Indicative1st
  • berū
  • berūr
  • beremam
  • bibrāsū
  • bibrāsūr
  • bīram
2nd
  • beresi
  • beretar
  • beretās
  • bibrāsesi
  • bibrāsetar
  • birs
3rd
  • bereti
  • beretor
  • bereto
  • bibrāseti
  • bibrāsetor
  • birt
?
1st
  • beromosi
  • beromor
  • beremo
  • bibrāsomosi
  • bibrāsomor
  • berme
2nd
  • beretesi
  • beredwe
?
  • bibrāsete
  • bibrāsedwe
  • berte
3rd
  • beronti
  • berontor
  • berento
  • bibrāsonti
  • bibrāsontor
  • berant
?
Subjunctive1st
  • berasū
  • berasūr
2nd
  • berasesi
  • berasetar
3rd
  • beraseti
  • berasetor
1st
  • berasomosi
  • berasomor
2nd
  • berasetesi
  • berasedwe
3rd
  • berasonti
  • berasontor
Imperative2nd
  • bere
  • bereso
3rd
  • beretou
?
1st
  • beromos
?
2nd
  • berete
?
3rd
  • berontou
?
Participle
  • beronts
  • beromnos
  • bertyos
  • britos

Copula

The copula *esti was irregular. It had both athematic and thematic conjugations in the present tense. Schrijver supposes that its athematic present was used clause-initially and the thematic conjugation was used when that was not the case.[37]

Conjugation of *esti in Proto-Celtic
PersonPresent
AthematicThematic
1st sg.Celtic languages: *esmiCeltic languages: *esū
2nd sg.Celtic languages: *esiCeltic languages: *esesi
3rd sg.Celtic languages: *estiCeltic languages: *eseti
1st pl.Celtic languages: *esmosiCeltic languages: *esomosi
2nd pl.Celtic languages: {{asteriskCeltic languages: *esetes
3rd pl.Celtic languages: *sentiCeltic languages: {{asterisk

Numerals

!Numeral!PIE!PC
One (1)
  • h₁óynos
  • oinos
Two (2)
  • dwóh₁
  • duwo
Three (3)
  • tréyes
  • trīs
Four (4)
  • kʷetwóres
  • kʷetwores
Five (5)
  • pénkʷe
  • kʷenkʷe
Six (6)
  • swéḱs
  • swexs
Seven (7)
  • septḿ̥
  • seɸtam > *sextam
Eight (8)
  • oḱtṓw
  • oxtū
Nine (9)
  • h₁néwn̥
  • nowan
Ten (10)
  • déḱm̥
  • dekam

Vocabulary

The vast majority of reliably reconstructible lexical items in Proto-Celtic have good Indo-European etymologies, unlike what is found in, for example, the Greek language—at least 90% according to Matasovic.[38] These include most of the items on the Swadesh list of basic vocabulary. But a few words that do not have Indo-European cognates, so may be borrowings from substrate or adstrate Pre-Indo-European languages, are also from basic vocabulary, including *bodyo- ‘yellow’ (though this has possible cognates in Italic), *kani "good," and *klukka "stone."[39] It is notable that fully 32 items have been reconstructed for Proto-Celtic with the meaning "fight."[40]

Examples of morphology derivation from PIE

Two examples of verbs

(The following examples lack the dual plural and are conjugated in the present tense)

"To bear/carry"!Pronoun!PIE!PC
I
  • bʰéroh₂
  • berū
You
  • bʰéresi
  • beresi
He, she, it
  • bʰéreti
  • bereti
We
  • bʰéromos
  • beromosi
You (all)
  • bʰérete
  • beretesi
They
  • bʰéronti
  • beronti
"To be" (athematic version)!Pronoun!PIE!PC
I
  • h₁ésmi
  • esmi
You
  • h₁ési
  • esi
He, she, it
  • h₁ésti
  • esti
We
  • h₁smós
  • esmosi
You (all)
  • h₁sté
  • estes
They
  • h₁sénti
  • senti

Examples of noun declension

(The following examples lack the dual number)

Masculine noun

"Bear"!Case!Singular!Plural
Nom.PIE *h₂ŕ̥tḱos > PC *artosPIE *h₂ŕ̥tḱoes > PC *artoi
Gen.
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱosyo > *artī
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱoHom > *artom
Dat.
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱoey > *artūi
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱomos > *artobos
Acc.
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱom > *artom
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱoms > *artoms
Voc.
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱe > *arte
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱoes > *artūs
Loc.
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱey > *artei
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱoysu > ?
Instr.
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱoh₁ > *artū
  • h₂ŕ̥tḱōys > *artūis

Feminine noun

"Open land"!Case!Singular!Plural
Nom.PIE *ln̥dʰéh₂ > PC *landāPIE *ln̥dʰéh₂es > PC *landās
Gen.
  • ln̥dʰéh₂s > *landās
  • ln̥dʰéh₂oHom > *landom
Dat.
  • ln̥dʰéh₂ey > *landāi
  • ln̥dʰéh₂mos > *landābos
Acc.
  • ln̥dʰā́m > *landam
  • ln̥dʰéh₂m̥s > *landāms
Voc.
  • ln̥dʰéh₂ > *landā
  • ln̥dʰéh₂es > *landās
Loc.
  • ln̥dʰéh₂i > *landai
  • ln̥dʰéh₂su > ?
Instr.
  • ln̥dʰéh₂h₁ > ?
  • ln̥dʰéh₂mis > *landābis

Neuter noun

"Yoke"!Case!Singular!Plural
Nom.PIE *yugóm > PC *yugomPIE *yugéh₂ > PC *yugā
Gen.
  • yugósyo > *yugī
  • yugóHom > *yugom
Dat.
  • yugóey > *yugūi
  • yugómos > *yugobos
Acc.
  • yugóm > *yugom
  • yugéh₂ > *yugā
Voc.
  • yugóm > *yugom
  • yugéh₂ > *yugā
Loc.
  • yugéy > *yugei
  • yugóysu > ?
Instr.
  • yugóh₁ > *yugū
  • yugṓys > *yugūis

An example of adjectival declension

(The following example lacks the dual number)

"High"!Case!Masculine(singular)!Feminine(singular)!Neuter(singular)
Nom.PIE *h₂ḱrós > PC *akrosPIE *h₂ḱréh₂ > PC *akrāPIE *h₂ḱróm > PC *akrom
Gen.
  • h₂ḱrósyo > *akrī
  • h₂ḱréh₂s > *akrās
  • h₂ḱrósyo > *akrī
Dat.
  • h₂ḱróey > *akrūi
  • h₂ḱréh₂ey > *akrai
  • h₂ḱróey > *akrūi
Acc.
  • h₂ḱróm > *akrom
  • h₂ḱrā́m > *akram
  • h₂ḱróm > *akrom
Voc.
  • h₂ḱré > *akre
  • h₂ḱréh₂ > *akrā
  • h₂ḱróm > *akrom
Instr.
  • h₂ḱróh₁ > *akrū
  • h₂ḱréh₂h₁ > ?
  • h₂ḱróh₁ > *akrū
!Case!Masculine(plural)!Feminine(plural)!Neuter(plural)
Nom.PIE *h₂ḱróes > PC *akroiPIE *h₂ḱréh₂es > PC *akrāsPIE *h₂ḱréh₂ > PC *akrā
Gen.
  • h₂ḱróHom > *akrom
  • h₂ḱréh₂oHom > *akrom
  • h₂ḱróHom > *akrom
Dat.
  • h₂ḱrómos > *akrobos
  • h₂ḱréh₂mos > *akrābos
  • h₂ḱrómos > *akrobis
Acc.
  • h₂ḱróms > *akroms
  • h₂ḱréh₂m̥s > *akrams
  • h₂ḱréh₂ > *akrā
Voc.
  • h₂ḱróes > *akroi
  • h₂ḱréh₂es > *akrās
  • h₂ḱréh₂ > *akrā
Instr.
  • h₂ḱrṓys > *akrobis
  • h₂ḱréh₂mis > *akrābis
  • h₂ḱrṓys > *akrobis

Derivation of personal pronouns (nominative case) from PIE

!Pronoun!PIE!PC
I
  • éǵ > *me [acc.]
You
  • túh₂
He
  • ís
  • se
She
  • [m.] > *séh₂ [f.] > variant *sih₂
It
  • íd
  • ed
We
  • wéy > *nos [acc.] > variant *nēs
  • snīs; *snīsnīs
You (all)
  • yū́ > *wos [acc.] > variant *wēs
  • swīs; *swīswīs
They
  • éyes
  • eyes

See also

References

Notes

Bibliography

External links

Notes and References

  1. https://www.britannica.com/art/Celtic-literature#ref42288 Celtic literature
  2. Rhys. John. Evans. E. Vincent. The Origin of the Welsh Englyn and Kindred Metres. Y Cymmrodor. 1905. XVIII. Honourable Society of Cymmrodorion. London.
  3. Koch, John T. (2020). Celto-Germanic Later Prehistory and Post-Proto-Indo-European vocabulary in the North and West, pp. 45–48.
  4. Book: Schumacher . Stefan . Die keltischen Primärverben. Ein vergleichendes, etymologisches und morphologisches Lexikon . 2004 . Institut für Sprachen und Literaturen der Universität Innsbruck . Innsbruck, Austria . 3-85124-692-6 . 85 . de.
  5. Book: Schrijver . Peter . Peter Schrijver . Koch . John T. . Cunliffe . Barry . John T. Koch . Barry Cunliffe . Celtic from the West 3: Atlantic Europe in the Metal Ages – Questions of Shared Language . 2016 . . Oxford, UK . 978-1-78570-227-3 . 489–502 . 17. Ancillary study: Sound Change, the Italo-Celtic Linguistic Unity, and the Italian Homeland of Celtic . https://books.google.com/books?id=HP4sDwAAQBAJ&q=%22peter+schrijver%22+%22celtic+from+the+west+3%22&pg=PA9 . May 12, 2019 .
  6. Matasovic, R. (2009) Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic. Brill. p.7
  7. Salmon, Joseph (1992) Accentual Change and Language Contact Stanford UP
  8. Matasovic, R. (2009) Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic. Brill. pp.11–12
  9. Cólera, Carlos Jordán (2007) "Celtiberian," e-Keltoi: Journal of Interdisciplinary Celtic Studies: Vol. 6, Article 17. p.759. Available at: https://dc.uwm.edu/ekeltoi/vol6/iss1/17 accessed June 21, 2023
  10. Welsh adfer 'to restore' < *ate-ber-, cymeryd < obsolete cymer < M.W. cymeraf < *kom-ber- (with -yd taken from the verbal noun cymryd < *kom-britu).
  11. However, according to Hackstein (2002) *CH.CC > Ø in unstressed medial syllables. Thus, H can disappear in weak cases while being retained in strong cases, e.g. IE nom.sg. *dʰugh₂tḗr vs. gen.sg. *dʰugtr-os 'daughter' > early PC *dugater- ~ dugtr-. This then led to a paradigmatic split, resulting in Celtiberian gen.sg. tuateros, nom.pl. tuateres vs. Gaulish duxtir (< *dugtīr). (Zair 2012: 161, 163).
  12. Eska . Joseph F. . Laryngeal Realism and the Prehistory of Celtic . Transactions of the Philological Society . Wiley . 116 . 3 . March 12, 2018 . 0079-1636 . 10.1111/1467-968x.12122 . 320–331.
  13. Eska . Joseph . Laryngeal Realism and early Insular Celtic orthography . North American Journal of Celtic Studies . 3 . 1 . January 26, 2021 . 2472-7490 . 1–17 . November 24, 2021.
  14. Book: Pedersen, Holger . Vergleichende Grammatik der keltischen Sprachen, 2. Band, Bedeutungslehre (Wortlehre) . Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht . Göttingen . 1913 . 978-3-525-26119-4 .
  15. Untermann, J. (1967). "Die Endung des Genitiv singularis der o-Stämme im Keltiberischen." In W. Meid (ed.), Beiträge zur Indogermanistik und Keltologie, Julius Pokorny zum 80. Geburtstag gewidmet, pp. 281–288. Innsbruck: Sprachwissenschaftliches Institut der Universität Innsbruck.
  16. Whitley. Stokes. Celtic Declension. Transactions of the Philological Society. 20. 1. 97–201. November 1887.
  17. Book: McCone, Kim . The Origins and Development of the Insular Celtic Verbal Complex . Department of Old Irish, National University of Ireland . Maynooth studies in Celtic linguistics . 2006 . 978-0-901519-46-7.
  18. Book: Thurneysen, Rudolf. Rudolf Thurneysen. Binchy. D. A. Osborn. Bergin. A Grammar of Old Irish. Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies. 1940. 1-85500-161-6.
  19. Remade as Celtic languages: *mu in the prehistory of Irish by analogy to Celtic languages: *tu.
  20. Remade as Celtic languages: *mowe in the prehistory of Irish by analogy to Celtic languages: *towe.
  21. Book: Schrijver, Peter. Studies in the History of Celtic Pronouns and Particles . Department of Old Irish, National University of Ireland . Maynooth studies in Celtic linguistics . 1997 . 978-0-901519-59-7.
  22. Matasovic, R. Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic. Leiden: Brill. 2006. p. 436
  23. The origin of the Celtic comparative type OIr. tressa, MW trech 'stronger'. 1991. Die Sprache. 34. 171–189. Jay. Jasanoff.
  24. Stefan Schumacher, Die keltischen Primärverben: Ein vergleichendes, etymologisches und morphologisches Lexikon (Innsbruck: Institut für Sprachen und Literaturen der Universität, 2004).
  25. Pierre-Yves Lambert, La langue gauloise: Description linguistique, commentaire d'inscriptions choisies (Paris: Errance, revised ed. 2003).
  26. Lambert . Pierre-Yves . Stifter . David . Le plomb gaulois de Rezé . Études Celtiques . 38 . 1 . 2012 . 0373-1928 . 10.3406/ecelt.2012.2351 . 139–164 . fr, en.
  27. Book: Schumacher. Stefan. Schulze-Thulin. Britta. aan de Wiel. Caroline. Die keltischen Primärverben. Ein vergleichendes, etymologisches und morphologisches Lexikon. 2004. Institut für Sprachen und Kulturen der Universität Innsbruck. Innsbruck. 3-85124-692-6. de.
  28. Book: Jasanoff, Jay. Long-vowel preterites in Indo-European. Melchert. Craig. The Indo-European Verb. Wiesbaden . Reichert Verlag. 2012 . 127–135.
  29. Book: McCone, Kim. The Indo-European Origins of the Old Irish Nasal Presents, Subjunctives and Futures . IBS-Vertrieb . Innsbrucker Beiträge zur Sprachwissenschaft . 1991 . 978-3-85124-617-9.
  30. Darling . Mark . The Subjunctive in Celtic: Studies in Historical Phonology and Morphology . 2020 . University of Cambridge . 10.17863/CAM.57857 . September 1, 2022. Thesis .
  31. Book: Stüber, Karin. The morphology of Celtic. Handbook of Comparative and Historical Indo-European Linguistics. 2. De Gruyter Mouton. Jared Klein. Brian Joseph. Matthias Fritz. 1203–1217.
  32. Jasanoff . Jay. Old Irish tair 'come!' . Transactions of the Philological Society . Wiley . 84 . 1 . 1986 . 0079-1636 . 10.1111/j.1467-968x.1986.tb01050.x . 132–141.
  33. Barnes . Timothy. Old Irish cuire, its congeners, and the ending of the 2nd sg. middle imperative . Ériu . 65 . 1 . 2015 . 2009-0056 . 49–56 . 10.3318/eriu.2015.65.3. September 2, 2022.
  34. Alexander MacBain, 1911, xxxvi–xxxvii; An etymological dictionary of the Gaelic language; Stirling: Eneas MacKay
  35. Alan Ward, A Checklist of Proto-Celtic Lexical Items (1982, revised 1996), 7–14.
  36. Examples of attested Gaulish verbs at https://www.angelfire.com/me/ik/gaulish.html
  37. Book: Schrijver, Peter. Dispersals and Diversification . Italo-Celtic and the Inflection of *es- ‘be’ . Brill. December 6, 2019 . 10.1163/9789004416192_012 . 209–235. 9789004414501 . 213806505 . Serangeli. Matilde. Olander. Thomas.
  38. Matasovic, R. (2009)Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic Leiden: Brill. p. 443
  39. Matasovic, R. (2009)Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic Leiden: Brill. p. 443-444
  40. English to Proto-Celtic Wordlist p. 44-45 https://www.wales.ac.uk/Resources/Documents/Research/CelticLanguages/EnglishProtoCelticWordList.pdf