Nurhaci Explained

Nurhaci
Khan of Great Jin
Succession:Khan of the Later Jin dynasty
Reign:17 February 1616 – 30 September 1626
Successor:Hong Taiji
Birth Date:14 May 1559
(嘉靖三十八年 四月 初八日)
Birth Place:Hetu Ala, Manchuria, Ming
Death Date:
(天命十一年 八月 十一日)
Death Place:Aijipu, Later Jin
Burial Place:Fu Mausoleum
Spouse:
    Spouse-Type:Consorts
    Issue:
    Full Name:Aisin-Gioro Nurhaci (愛新覺羅·努爾哈齊)
    Manchu: Nurgaci
    Mongolian: Нурхач
    Era Dates:Tianming (天命): 14 May 1616 – 15 February 1627
    Manchu: Abkai fulingga
    Mongolian: Тэнгэрийн сүлдэт
    Regnal Name:Emperor Fuyu Lieguo Yingming (覆育列國英明皇帝)
    Posthumous Name:Emperor Chengtian Guangyun Shengde Shengong Zhaoji Liji Renxiao Ruiwu Duanyi Qin'an Hongwen Dingye Gao (承天廣運聖德神功肇紀立極仁孝睿武端毅欽安弘文定業高皇帝)
    Manchu: Dergi hūwangdi
    Temple Name:Taizu (太祖)
    Manchu: Taidzu
    House:Aisin-Gioro
    Dynasty:Later Jin
    Father:Taksi
    Mother:Empress Xuan

    Nurhaci (14 May 1559 – 30 September 1626), also known by his temple name as the Emperor Taizu of Qing, was the founding khan of the Jurchen-led Later Jin dynasty.[1]

    As the leader of the House of Aisin-Gioro, Nurhaci reorganized and united various Jurchen tribes (the later "Manchu"), consolidated the Eight Banners military system, and eventually launched attacks on both the Ming and Joseon dynasties. His conquest of Ming dynasty's northeastern Liaodong region laid the groundwork for the Qing conquest of the Ming by his descendants, who proclaimed the Qing dynasty in 1636. He is also generally credited with ordering the creation of a new written script for the Manchu language based on the Mongolian vertical script.

    Name and titles

    Nurhaci is written as in Manchu language. Some suggest that the meaning of the name in the Manchu language is "the skin of a wild boar".[2] Another explanation is "brave person like wild boar".[3] Regarded as the founding father of the Qing dynasty, he is given the customary temple name of Taizu, which is traditionally assigned to founders of dynasties. His name is also alternatively spelled Nurgaci, Nurhachi, or Nu-er-ha-chi (the last of these simply the transcription of the Chinese characters used to write his name).

    Nurhaci was the last chieftain of the Jianzhou Jurchens and first khan of the Later Jin dynasty. His title in Manchu as khan was Geren gurun-be ujire genggiyen han ("brilliant khan who benefits all nations"). His era name was Tianming (; Manchu:Abkai Fulingga), in Mongolian "Mongolian: Тэнгэрийн сүлдэт" (Tengri-yin Süldetü). It means "Heaven's Mandate." He was given a posthumous name in 1736 (see infobox), the shortened form of which was "Emperor Gao", Manchu:Dergi Hūwangdi)

    Early life

    Nurhaci was born in 1559. Being a member of the Gioro clan of the Suksuhu River tribe, Nurhaci also claimed descent from Mentemu, a Jurchen headman who lived some two centuries earlier. The young man grew up as a soldier in the household of the Ming dynasty general Li Chengliang in Fushun, where he learned Mandarin Chinese, the official language of the courts. Nurhaci read the Chinese novels Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Water Margin learning all he knew about Chinese military and political strategies from them.[4] [5] [6] He named his clan Aisin Gioro around 1612, when he formally ascended the throne as the Khan of the Later Jin dynasty.

    Nurhaci's grandfather Giocangga was a chieftain of the Jurchens in Hetu Ala who enjoyed the patronage of Li. He frequented the Fushun market as official delegation leader, and accompanied Li to Beijing at least once. In 1582, Nikan Wailan, a rival Jurchen chief, led Ming forces to attack the Fort Gure (古勒城, now in Xinbin County). Giocangga feared for his granddaughter who was married to Atai, the town's chief. He rushed into the city, taking Nurhaci's father Taksi with him. During the ensuing battle, both Giocangga and Taksi were killed.

    Nurhaci sought revenge against Nikan Wailan for the deaths of his father and grandfather. The Ming returned his father's remains, grant him trade patents, and recognized him as the successor of Giocangga. However, Nurhaci's demand that they hand over Nikan Wailan was refused. Nurhaci therefore started to expand his own power, starting only from thirteen sets of armor inherited from his father. In 1584, he attacked Nikan Wailan at Turun. Nikan Wailan fled away to Erhun, which Nurhaci attacked again in 1587. Nikan Wailan this time fled to Li Chengliang's territory. Li relented and gave Nikan Wailan over to Nurhaci, who beheaded Nikan Wailan immediately.

    Nurhaci gradually grew his strength in the following years and subdued the core Jianzhou Jurchen tribes and towns from 1583 to 1588. At the same time, Nurhaci still considered himself a guardian of the Ming border and a local representative of imperial Ming power. He received the title of assistant commissioner-in chief in 1589 and the honor of "dragon-tiger general" in 1595. He consolidated his relationship with the Ming by personally leading multiple tributary missions to Beijing from 1590 onward, and was seen in by the Ming a loyal subject. His aggressive tactics against other Jurchen tribes were fueled by the high status that the Ming had given him.

    Unifying the Jurchen tribes

    See main article: Jurchen unification.

    See also: Timeline of the Jurchens. In 1593, the Yehe called upon a coalition of nine tribes: the Hada, Ula, Hoifa, Khorchin Mongols, Sibe, Guwalca, Jušeri, Neyen, and the Yehe themselves to attack the Jianzhou Jurchens. The coalition was defeated at the Battle of Gure and Nurhaci emerged victorious.

    From 1599 to 1618, Nurhaci set out on a campaign against the four Hulun tribes. He began by attacking the Hada in 1599 and conquering them in 1603. Then in 1607, Hoifa was also conquered with the death of its beile Baindari, followed by an expedition against Ula and its beile Bujantai in 1613, and finally the Yehe and its beile Gintaisi at the Battle of Sarhu in 1619. As Nurhaci's power expanded, the relationship with the Ming also became increasingly strained. In 1608, Ming subjects were prohibited from cultivating the land or gathering ginseng, one of the main Jurchen export products, within Nurhaci's boundary.

    In 1599, Nurhaci gave two of his translators, Erdeni Baksi ('Jewel Teacher' in Mongolian) and Dahai Jargūci,[7] the task of creating a Manchu alphabet by adapting the Mongolian script. Dahai was described with his origin from the Liao valley and his ethnicity as Han Chinese in the Korean book "Nanjung chamnok; Sok chamnok" (亂中雜錄) by Cho Kyŏng-nam (趙慶南) (1570-1641) a Korean official and scholar, contradicting Qing texts which says his clan is Giolca. The Qing texts said Dahau's family lived near Fushun in the Giolca region.[8]

    In 1606, he was granted the title of Kundulun Khan by the Mongols.

    In 1616, Nurhaci declared himself Khan and founded the Jin dynasty (aisin gurun), often called the Later Jin in reference to the legacy of the earlier Jurchen Jin dynasty of the 12th century. The "Later Jin" was renamed to "Qing" by his son Hong Taiji after his death in 1626, however Nurhaci is usually referred to as the founder of the Qing dynasty.

    In order to help with the newly organized administration, five of his trusted companions were appointed as his chief councilors, Anfiyanggū, Eidu, Hūrhan, Fiongdon, and Hohori.

    Only after he became Khan did he finally unify the Ula (clan of his consort Lady Abahai, mentioned below) and the Yehe, the clan of his consort Monggo Jerjer.

    Nurhaci chose to variously emphasize either differences or similarities in lifestyles with other peoples like the Mongols for political reasons.[9] Nurhaci said to the Mongols that "The languages of the Chinese and Koreans are different, but their clothing and way of life is the same. It is the same with us Manchus (Jurchen) and Mongols. Our languages are different, but our clothing and way of life is the same." Later Nurhaci indicated that the bond with the Mongols was not based in any real shared culture, rather it was for pragmatic reasons of "mutual opportunism", when he said to the Mongols: "You Mongols raise livestock, eat meat and wear pelts. My people till the fields and live on grain. We two are not one country and we have different languages."[10]

    When the Jurchens were reorganized by Nurhaci into the Eight Banners, many Manchu clans were artificially created as a group of unrelated people founded a new Manchu clan (mukun) using a geographic origin name such as a toponym for their hala (clan name).[11] The irregularities over Jurchen and Manchu clan origin led to the Qing trying to document and systematize the creation of histories for Manchu clans, including manufacturing an entire legend around the origin of the Aisin Gioro clan by taking mythology from the northeast.[12]

    Invasion of Ming dynasty

    See also: Transition from Ming to Qing.

    In 1618, Nurhaci commissioned a document titled the Seven Grievances in which he enumerated seven problems with Ming rule and began to rebel against the domination of the Ming dynasty. A majority of the grievances dealt with conflicts against Yehe, and Ming favouritism of Yehe.

    Nurhaci led many successful engagements against the Ming dynasty, the Northern Yuan dynasty, the Joseon dynasty, and other Jurchen clans, greatly enlarging the territory under his control.

    The first capitals of the Later Jin dynasty established by Nurhaci were Fe Ala and Hetu Ala.[13] [14] [15] [16] Many ethnic Han participated in the construction of Hetu Ala.[17]

    Defectors from the Ming side played a massive role in the Qing conquest of the Ming. Ming generals who defected to the Manchus were often married to women from the Aisin Gioro clan while lower-ranked defectors were given non-imperial Manchu women as wives. Nurhaci arranged for a marriage between one of his granddaughters and the Ming general Li Yongfang (李永芳) after Li surrendered Fushun in Liaoning to the Manchus in 1618 as the result of the Battle of Fushun.[18] [19] [20] [21] [22] His son Abatai's daughter was married to Li Yongfang.[23] [24] [25] [26] The offspring of Li received the "Third Class Viscount" title.[27] Li Yongfang was the great-great-great-grandfather of Li Shiyao (李侍堯).[28] [29]

    The Han prisoner of war Gong Zhenglu (Onoi) was appointed to instruct Nurhaci's sons and received gifts of slaves, wives, and a domicile from Nurhaci after Nurhaci rejected offers of payment to release him back to his relatives.[30]

    Nurhaci had treated Han in Liaodong differently according to how much grain they had, those with less than 5 to 7 sin were treated poorly while those with more than that amount were rewarded with property. Due to a revolt by Han in Liaodong in 1623, Nurhachi, who previously gave concessions to conquered Han subjects in Liaodong, turned against them and ordered that they no longer be trusted and enacted discriminatory policies and killings against them, while ordering that Han who assimilated to the Jurchen (in Jilin) before 1619 be treated equally as Jurchens were and not like the conquered Han in Liaodong.

    By May 1621, Nurhaci had conquered the cities of Liaoyang and Shenyang. In April 1625, he designated Shenyang the new capital city, which would hold that status until the Qing conquest of the Ming in 1644.[31]

    Death and legacy

    In 1626, Nurhaci was defeated by Ming general Yuan Chonghuan at the Battle of Ningyuan, in what was the first serious military defeat of his life. During this battle, Nurhaci was wounded by Portuguese gunners using Macau s manufactured cannons placed in Yuan's army.[32] Unable to recover either physically or mentally, Nurhaci died of his wounds two days later in Aijipu (靉雞堡; present-day Da'aijinpu Village, Dijia Township, Yuhong District, Shenyang) on 30 September 1626, at the age of 67. His tomb, Fu Mausoleum, is located east of Shenyang.

    Among the most lasting contributions Nurhaci left his descendants was the establishment of the Eight Banners, which would eventually form the backbone of the military that dominated the Qing Empire. The status of Banners did not change much over the course of Nurhaci's lifetime, nor in subsequent reigns, remaining mostly under the control of the royal family. The two elite Yellow Banners were consistently under Nurhaci's control. The two Blue Banners were controlled by Nurhaci's brother Šurhaci until he died, at which point the Blue Banners were given to Šurhaci's two sons, Chiurhala and Amin. Nurhaci's eldest son, Cuyen, controlled the White Banner for most of his father's reign until he rebelled. Then the Bordered White Banner was given to Nurhaci's grandson and the Plain White was given to his eighth son and heir, Hong Taiji. However, by the end of Nurhaci's reign, Hong Taiji controlled both White Banners. Finally, the Red Banner was run by Nurhaci's second son Daišan. Later in Nurhaci's reign, the Bordered Red Banner was handed down to his son. Daišan and his son would continue holding the two Red Banners well into the end of Hong Taiji's reign.

    The details of Hong Taiji's succession as the Khan of the Later Jin dynasty are unclear.[33] When he died in late 1626, Nurhaci did not designate an heir; instead he encouraged his sons to rule collegially. Three of his sons and a nephew were the "four senior beiles": Daišan (43 years old), Amin (son of Nurhaci's brother Šurhaci; 40 or 41), Manggūltai (38 or 39), and Hong Taiji himself (33). On the day after Nurhaci's death, they coerced his primary consort Lady Abahai (1590 - 1626)  - who had borne him three sons: Ajige, Dorgon, and Dodo  - to commit suicide to accompany him in death.[34] This gesture has made some historians suspect that Nurhaci had in fact named the fifteen-year-old Dorgon as a successor, with Daišan as regent.[35] By forcing Dorgon's mother to kill herself, the princes removed a strong base of support for Dorgon. The reason such intrigue was necessary is that Nurhaci had left the two elite Yellow Banners to Dorgon and Dodo, who were the sons of Lady Abahai. Hong Taiji exchanged control of his two White Banners for that of the two Yellow Banners, shifting their influence and power from his young brothers onto himself.

    According to Hong Taiji's later recollections, Amin and the other beile were willing to accept Hong Taiji as Khan, but Amin then would have wanted to leave with his Bordered Blue Banner, threatening to dissolve Nurhaci's unification of the Jurchens. Eventually the older Daišan worked out a compromise that allowed Hong Taiji as the Khan, but almost equal to the other three senior beiles. Hong Taiji would eventually find ways to become the undisputed leader.

    The change of the name from Jurchen to Manchu by Hong Taiji was made to hide the fact that the ancestors of the Manchus, the Jianzhou Jurchens, were ruled by the Chinese.[36] [37] [38] The Qing dynasty carefully hid the two original editions of the books of "Qing Taizu Wu Huangdi Shilu" and the "Manzhou Shilu Tu" (Taizu Shihlu Tu) in the Qing palace, forbidden from public view because they showed that the Manchu Aisin Gioro family had been ruled by the Ming dynasty.[39] In the Ming period, the Koreans of Joseon referred to the Jurchen-inhabited lands north of the Korean peninsula, above the rivers Yalu and Tumen, as part of Ming China, which they called the "superior country" (sangguk).[40]

    Translations of Chinese texts

    The first Manchu translations of Chinese works were the Six Secret Teachings (Chinese: 六韜), Sushu 素書, and Three Strategies of Huang Shigong (Chinese: 三略), all Chinese military texts dedicated to the arts of war due to the Manchu interests in the topic, like Sun-Tzu's work The Art of War.[41] [42] The military related texts which were translated into Manchu from Chinese were translated by Dahai.[43]

    Manchu translations of Chinese texts included the Ming penal code and military texts were performed by Dahai.[44] These translations were requested of Dahai by Nurhaci. The military text Wuzi was translated into Manchu along with The Art of War.[45]

    Chinese history, Chinese law, and Chinese military theory classical texts were translated into Manchu during the rule of Hong Taiji in Mukden (now Shenyang), with the Manchus placing significance upon military and governance related Chinese texts.[46] A Manchu translation was made of the military-themed novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms.[47] [48] Chinese literature, military theory and legal texts were translated into Manchu by Dahai and Erdeni.[49] The translations were ordered in 1629.

    The translation of the military texts Sushu and Three Strategies of Huang Shigong, and the Da Ming Huidian (Chinese: 大明會典) done by Dahai was ordered by Nurhaci.[50] While it was mainly administrative and ethical guidance which made up most of the Three Strategies of Huang Shigong and the Sushu, military science was indeed found in the Six Secret Teachings and Chinese military manuals were eagerly translated by the Manchus. They were also attracted to the military content in Romance of the Three Kingdoms, which is why it was translated.[51] The Art of War was translated into Manchu as Abkai: qoohai baita be gisurengge, Möllendorff: coohai baita be gisurengge, Discourse on the art of War.[52] Another later Manchu translation was made by Aisin Gioro Qiying.[53]

    Primary sources

    Information concerning Nurhaci can be found in later, propagandistic works such as the Manchu Veritable Records (; Manchu:, Möllendorff: manju-i yargiyan kooli). Good contemporary sources are also available. For instance, much material concerning Nurhaci's rise is preserved within Korean sources such as the Veritable Records of the Joseon Dynasty, especially the Seonjo Sillok and the Gwanghaegun Ilgi. Indeed, the record of Sin Chung-il's trip to Jianzhou is preserved in the Seonjo Sillok.

    The Jiu Manzhou Dang from Nurhaci's reign also survives. A revised transcription of these records (with the dots and circles added to the script) was commissioned by the Qianlong Emperor. This has been translated into Japanese under the title Manbun roto, and Chinese, under the title Manwen Laodang . A project is or was (as of 2006[54]) under way at Harvard University to translate them into English, as The Old Manchu Chronicles.[55]

    Physical appearance

    According to the account of Korean ambassadors, Nurhaci was a physically strong man with a long and stern-looking face and a big, straight nose. Like most of the other Manchu men, he shaved most of his facial hair and kept only his moustache.

    Family

    Primary Consort

    Secondary Consort

    Concubine

    In popular culture

    Science

    The genus Nurhachius, a pterodactyloid pterosaur, is named after Nurhaci.

    See also

    Sources

    |-

    Notes and References

    1. Book: _博、任吉_ . 大清盛世 . 飛翔時代 . zh.
    2. Tak-sing, Kam. The Romanization of Early Manchu Regnal Names. Studia Orientalia. 87. 1999. 133–148.
    3. Web site: What does Nurhachi's name mean in Chinese . 8 July 2020 . 满族文化网 Manchu Culture Network.
    4. Book: Parker . Geoffrey . Global Crisis: War, Climate and Catastrophe in the Seventeenth Century . 2013 . Yale University Press . 978-0300189193 . illustrated .
    5. Book: Swope . Kenneth M. . The Military Collapse of China's Ming Dynasty, 1618-44 . 2014 . Routledge . 978-1134462094 . 16 . illustrated .
    6. Book: Mair . Victor H. . Chen . Sanping . Wood . Frances . Chinese Lives: The People Who Made a Civilization . 2013 . Thames & Hudson . 978-0500771471 . illustrated .
    7. Matsumura Jun, p.131 A Re-examinations of the Story of the Founding of the Ch'ing Dynasty 『清朝開国説話再考』(in Japanese)
    8. Huang . Pei . New Light on The Origins of The Manchus . Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies . 1990 . 50 . 1 . 269 . 10.2307/2719229 . 2719229 . https://web.archive.org/web/20200807074339/https://www.jstor.org/stable/2719229 . 2020-08-07 . 2020-11-05 . bot: unknown .
    9. Book: Perdue, Peter C. China Marches West: The Qing Conquest of Central Eurasia. 2009. Harvard University Press. 978-0-674-04202-5. 127.
    10. Book: The Cambridge History of China: Pt. 1; The Ch'ing Empire to 1800. 2002. Cambridge University Press. 978-0-521-24334-6. 31.
    11. Book: Sneath . David . The Headless State: Aristocratic Orders, Kinship Society, and Misrepresentations of Nomadic Inner Asia . 2007 . Columbia University Press . 978-0231511674 . 99–100 . illustrated .
    12. Book: Crossley . Pamela Kyle . Orphan Warriors: Three Manchu Generations and the End of the Qing World . 1991 . Princeton University Press . 0691008779 . 33 . illustrated, reprint .
    13. Book: Frederic E. Wakeman. The Great Enterprise: The Manchu Reconstruction of Imperial Order in Seventeenth-century China. 1985. University of California Press. 978-0-520-04804-1. 45–.
    14. Book: Gertraude Roth Li. Manchu: A Textbook for Reading Documents. 2010. Natl Foreign Lg Resource Ctr. 978-0-9800459-5-6 . 285–.
    15. Book: Jonathan D. Spence. John E. Wills, Jr.. From Ming to Ch'ing: Conquest, Region, and Continuity in Seventeenth-century China . 1979. Yale University Press. 978-0-300-02672-6. 35–.
    16. Book: Mark C. Elliott . The Manchu Way: The Eight Banners and Ethnic Identity in Late Imperial China. 2001. Stanford University Press. 978-0-8047-4684-7. 54–.
    17. Book: Frederic E. Wakeman. The Great Enterprise: The Manchu Reconstruction of Imperial Order in Seventeenth-century China. 1985. University of California Press. 978-0-520-04804-1. 47–.
    18. Book: Anne Walthall. Servants of the Dynasty: Palace Women in World History. 978-0-520-25444-2. 2008. University of California Press . 148–.
    19. Book: Wakeman, Frederic. Fall of Imperial China. 1977. Simon and Schuster. 978-0-02-933680-9 . 79–.
    20. Book: Kenneth M. Swope. The Military Collapse of China's Ming Dynasty, 1618-44 . 2014 . Routledge. 978-1-134-46209-4. 13–.
    21. Book: Frederic E. Wakeman. The Great Enterprise: The Manchu Reconstruction of Imperial Order in Seventeenth-century China. University of California Press. 1985. 978-0-520-04804-1 . 61–.
    22. Book: Mark C. Elliott. The Manchu Way: The Eight Banners and Ethnic Identity in Late Imperial China. Stanford University Press . 2001. 978-0-8047-4684-7. 76–.
    23. Web site: 李永芳将军的简介 李永芳的后代 . zh . Introduction of General Li Yongfang Li Yongfang's Descendants . 2015-12-28. www.lishiquwen.com . 2016-06-30 . https://web.archive.org/web/20171203055230/http://www.lishiquwen.com/news/7356.html . 2017-12-03 . dead.
    24. Web site: 首个投降后金的明将李永芳 . 曹德全 . zh . The first surrender of gold after the Ming Dynasty Li Yongfang . 2014-03-22 . 2016-06-30 . dead . 2016-10-07 . https://web.archive.org/web/20161007063611/http://www.fs7000.com/wap/?9179.html.
    25. Web site: 第一个投降满清的明朝将领李寻仙jg用什么战宠永芳结局如何?. zh . What did Li Xunxian, the first general of the Ming Dynasty to surrender to the Qing Dynasty, used to favor Yongfang? . 中国历史网 . 2016-06-30 . https://web.archive.org/web/20161007091128/http://www.75800.com.cn/lx2/pAjRqK/9N6KahmKbgWLa1mRb1iyc_.html . 2016-10-07 . dead.
    26. Web site: 第一個投降滿清的明朝將領結局如何?.
    27. Book: Evelyn S. Rawski . The Last Emperors: A Social History of Qing Imperial Institutions . registration. 1998 . University of California Press. 978-0-520-92679-0. 72–.
    28. Li Shih-yao.
    29. Web site: 李奉尧(?–1789)汉军镶黄旗人,二等伯李永芳四世孙也,清朝大臣。父元亮,官户部尚书,谥勤恪,李侍尧之弟。自官 . https://web.archive.org/web/20161007061435/http://12103081.wenhua.danyy.com/library1210shtml30810106630060.html . 2016-10-07 . dead.
    30. Book: Pamela Kyle Crossley. A Translucent Mirror: History and Identity in Qing Imperial Ideology. 2000. University of California Press. 978-0-520-92884-8. 101–.
    31. Nurhaci.
    32. Book: Boxer, C. R. (Charles Ralph) . Expedições Militares Portuguêsas em Auxílio Mings Contra os Manchus, 1621-1647 . 1937 . Macau, China, Escola tipográfica salesiana . Duke University Libraries.
    33. .
    34. .
    35. , note 127, citing .
    36. Abahai.
    37. Book: Grossnick . Roy A. . Early Manchu Recruitment of Chinese Scholar-officials . 1972 . University of Wisconsin--Madison . 10 .
    38. Book: Till . Barry . The Manchu era (1644-1912): arts of China's last imperial dynasty . 2004 . Art Gallery of Greater Victoria . 5 . 9780888852168 .
    39. Book: The Augustan, Volumes 17-20 . 1975 . Augustan Society . 34 .
    40. Book: Kim . Sun Joo . The Northern Region of Korea: History, Identity, and Culture . 2011 . University of Washington Press . 978-0295802176 . 19 .
    41. Book: Early China . Society for the Study of Early China . 1975 . 53.
    42. Durrant . Stephen . 1977 . Manchu Translations of Chou Dynasty Texts . Early China . 3 . 53 . 10.1017/S0362502800006623 . 23351361 . 191822020.
    43. Book: Chan, Sin-wai . A Chronology of Translation in China and the West: From the Legendary Period to 2004 . Chinese University Press . 2009 . 978-962-996-355-2 . 60.
    44. Book: Perdue, Peter C . China Marches West: The Qing Conquest of Central Eurasia . Harvard University Press . 2009 . 978-0-674-04202-5 . 122.
    45. Book: Early China . Society for the Study of Early China . 1977 . 53.
    46. Book: Salmon, Claudine . Literary Migrations: Traditional Chinese Fiction in Asia (17th–20th Centuries) . Institute of Southeast Asian Studies . 2013 . 978-981-4414-32-6 . 94 . Claudine Salmon.
    47. Book: Chiu, Elena Suet-Ying . Bannermen Tales (Zidishu): Manchu Storytelling and Cultural Hybridity in the Qing Dynasty . Harvard University, Asia Center . 2017 . 978-0-674-97519-4 . 25 . Elena Suet-Ying Chiu.
    48. Web site: West . Andrew . Andrew West (linguist) . The Textual History of Sanguo Yanyi: The Manchu Translation . 11 October 2016.
    49. Book: Hummel, Arthur W. Sr. . Eminent Chinese of the Ch'ing period: 1644-1912 . SMC publ. . 1991 . 978-957-638-066-2 . vi . Arthur W. Hummel Sr..
    50. Dahai.
    51. Durrant . Stephen . October 1979 . Sino-Manchu Translations at the Mukden Court . Journal of the American Oriental Society . 99 . 4 . 653–661 . 10.2307/601450 . 601450.
    52. Book: Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland. North China Branch, Shanghai . Journal of the North China Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society . Kelly & Walsh. . 1890 . 40.
    53. Web site: Victor H. Mair . February 2008 . Soldierly Methods: Vade Mecum for an Iconoclastic Translation of Sun Zi bingfa . Dino–Platonic Papers . 82 . Number 178.
    54. Web site: 2012-11-08 . The Old Manchu Chronicles . 2024-06-18 . Manchu Studies Group . en-US.
    55. Web site: Manchu Studies at Harvard. sites.fas.harvard.edu. 2017-09-27. 2016-10-13. https://web.archive.org/web/20161013013251/http://sites.fas.harvard.edu/~mnch210a/index.cgi?t=TOMCIndex. dead.