Novocherkassk massacre explained

Novocherkassk massacre
Location:Novocherkassk, Rostov Oblast, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union
Motive:Quelling protests
Type:Shooting
Fatalities:26 (officially)
Perps:Soviet Army, KGB
Weapons:Sniper rifles, machine guns, APCs, cars, tanks

The Novocherkassk massacre (Russian: Новочеркасский расстрел|Novocherkasskiy rasstrel) was a massacre carried out by the Soviet army and KGB against unarmed civilians who were rallying on 2 June 1962 in the Soviet city of Novocherkassk.[1] A few weeks prior to the massacre, workers at the Electro Locomotive Novocherkassk plant (NEVZ) had organized a peaceful labor strike. The security forces killed 26 people, according to the official account, in the massacre.[2]

On January 1, 1962, the wages at the NEVZ were lowered by 30–35%. At the same time, the production quotas which were set up for workers as a part of the Soviet Union's planned economy were raised. These events also coincided with a sharp nationwide increase in the prices of dairy and meat products (up to 35% according to one account), raising them above the budget of many workers.[3] Protesters gathered near the city's central administrative building did not disperse when ordered by the surrounding Soviet troops, who then opened fire,[4] killing 26 and wounding 87, including children.[5]

Arrests, show trials and cover-ups ensued: about 240 were arrested, seven people were convicted of various crimes such as "mass disorder" and sentenced to death and hundreds of others were imprisoned for up to 15 years (though the prison terms of some were later reduced).[6] News of the events never appeared in the state-controlled press and the Soviet government continued to conceal it until April 27, 1991; however, it was described in a few underground samizdat publications.[7] [8] The 26 dead were secretly buried by KGB operatives in graves which were not disclosed to relatives and friends until June 2, 1994, when almost all bodies were discovered and reburied at the official memorial.

In 1992, shortly after the dissolution of the Soviet Union, the events were investigated by the Chief Military Prosecutor's Office. The major suspects among the highest-ranking Soviet officials such as Nikita Khrushchev, Anastas Mikoyan, Frol Kozlov and several others who were deemed responsible for the massacre had died by the time of the investigation.[9] [10] Each year, the massacre is commemorated on its anniversary by a group of surviving participants. Some of the victims of the massacre were symbolically compensated for their illegal imprisonment and deaths. In 1990, a museum was dedicated to the victims of the massacre next to the square where it took place.

History

See also: Monetary reform in the Soviet Union, 1961 and Khrushchev Thaw. The riots were a direct result of shortages of food and provisions, as well as the poor working conditions in the factory. The protest began on June 1 in the Budyonny Electric Locomotive Factory, when workers from the foundry and forge shops stopped work after factory management refused to hear their complaints. The strike and attendant discussions had spread throughout the whole factory by noon.

The unrest began when Nikita Khrushchev announced an increase in the prices of meat and butter throughout the Soviet Union on June 1. On the same day, as required by a separate economic plan, the minimum production quotas for each worker at the factory were increased,[11] thereby effectively reducing pay rates;[12] some protestors called Khrushchev a "False Leninist" and compared his policies unfavorably with the annual price-reduction regime of Joseph Stalin.[13] These tensions culminated in a march on the town hall and police headquarters, and the strike spread to other enterprises after police arrested thirty workers.

According to documents declassified in the 1990s, motorised infantry units were called to suppress the protesters, but they fired in the air; the lethal fire came from a unit of Internal troops from Rostov-on-Don, composed of 10 snipers and 2 machine guns, firing from the "Don" hotel. Orders to kill were passed through the whole chain of command from Khrushchev via the ministry of defense.[14]

The First Deputy Commanding General of the North-Caucasian Troops, general Matvey Kuzmich Shapochnikov, refused to execute an order to attack peaceful demonstrators with tanks (he reportedly said, "I don't see any enemy that we could turn our weapons against"), for which he was later degraded, brutally beaten and arrested by the secret state security police.[15]

Victims

According to now available official sources, 26 protesters were machine-gunned and killed by Soviet troops.[16] [17] An additional 87 protesters were wounded, three of them mortally. Due to Soviet propaganda at that time the protesters trusted the goodwill of the Soviet army, and many did not expect them to fire live ammunition at unarmed citizens. After the initial demonstrations, a curfew was imposed on the city and the dead were secretly buried in cemeteries scattered across the Rostov Oblast. However, a group of several hundred demonstrators gathered in the square again the following morning. 116 of them were arrested, and fourteen were convicted in show trials. Seven of those convicted received a death sentence, and the others were sentenced to prison terms ranging from ten to fifteen years.

Following the incident, the Soviet government directed extra food supplies to the region and began an investigation. Additional workers were arrested, and several military officials involved in the incident were court martialed.

The story was hushed-up by Soviet media and remained an official secret until 1992, a year after the fall of the Soviet Union. At that time the remains of 20 protesters were recovered, identified, and buried in the Novoshakhtinsk cemetery.

Aftermath

On August 19, 1962, the trials began.[18] About 110 people were charged with breaking Article 77 and 79 of the RSFSR Penal Code. The defendants, identified using photos taken by KGB agents, were charged with banditry, mass disorder, and attempt to overthrow the Soviet State. Soviet Militia officers were used as "eyewitnesses" to fabricate cases despite being directly involved in attempts to disperse the strike. Many defendants were sentenced to 5 to 12 years in prison. The Supreme Court of the RSFSR, chaired by L.N. Smirnov with help of prosecutor A.A. Kruglov, sentenced 7 people (out of 14 charged) to death:[19] [20]

The trials continued until September 1962.

Investigation

Siuda report

In the mid-1960s, an early investigation was started by (1937 - May 5, 1990), an anarcho-syndicalist activist and participant in the rallies, by whose account most of the events became first known to the Russian public. Himself the son of a Bolshevik killed in 1937 during the Great Purge, Siuda was sentenced to 12 years imprisonment in September 1962, but was freed in the spring of 1965.[21] In prison, with help from his mother, he gathered information on the victims and events of the rally, and compiled a list of 104 convicts.[22] [23] His information was first published in the 1980s in underground publications known as samizdat, . After being freed from prison, he was constantly harassed by the KGB for his dissenting behavior and publications. In an interview in the early 90s, he reported that the 1980s Soviet militia (civil police) used semi-legal groups of ex-convicts (similar to titushky) to harass dissenters such as himself.

He notes that the Novocherkassk massacre did not become widely known because the victims and observers were terrorized into silence by the KGB and the Communist Party. In 1979, he publicly condemned the Soviet Invasion of Afghanistan. Piotr died under suspicious circumstances, which his spouse Emma called a political murder and attributed to his reporting on Novocherkassk.[24] He died days after reporting a discovery of an eyewitness, an excavator operator, who told him where the massacre victims were buried; he had also received a phone call in which someone had told him that he would not survive the 28th anniversary of the massacre.

Official investigation

With the first signs of the Soviet Union's disintegration in 1989, the freshly elected Soviet Supreme Council initiated an investigation into the massacre. A group of activists, journalists, and a few local volunteers established a Novocherkassk Massacre Foundation to find, help, and compensate the victims, and conduct further investigation into the crime.

On May 18, 1992, the newly created Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the RSFSR officially condemned the massacre and instructed the General Prosecutor's office to review all fabricated criminal cases against the victims.[25] It also offered the Government to pay restitution of 25,000 rubles to the victims. At that time, this amount was worth one-twelfth of a Lada car[26] or 12,789 litres (3378 gallons) of milk.[27]

Timeline

May

June

July

October

Legacy

In the early 1990s a museum was opened in the building next to a square where demonstrants were killed. It showed at least 36 photos of people taken by KGB that were used during fake trials as "evidence" of protesters identities. In 2009 the museum, that was maintained by efforts of a few victims and volunteers, was handed over to the Museum of the History of the Don Cossacks. The museum has a stand with photos of victims and events copied from photos taken in 1962 by KGB that were declassified in early 90s.

Movies

During a Politburo scene in The Devil's Alternative by Frederick Forsyth, the KGB chief, asked if he could suppress riots during famine, responds that the KGB could suppress ten, even twenty Novocherkassks, but not fifty; intentionally using the example to highlight the seriousness of the threat in the novel.

The massacre is dramatised in Francis Spufford's 2010 novel Red Plenty.

The films Once upon a time in Rostov (2012) and Dear Comrades (2020) offer depictions of the massacre.

See also

External links

47.47°N 40.06°W

Notes and References

  1. http://soviethistory.org/index.php?page=subject&SubjectID=1961novocherkassk&Year=1961 1961: Novocherkassk Massacre
  2. Book: Grant, Ted . Russia : from revolution to counter-revolution. . 2017 . 978-1-900007-72-6 . 2 . The Novocherkassk uprising . Wellred Books . 1014425658.
  3. Web site: Novocherkassk Massacre. 2015-06-19. Seventeen Moments in Soviet History. en-US. 2019-06-02.
  4. Web site: Siegelbaum. Lewis. 19 June 2015. Novocherkassk Massacre. Seventeen Moments in Soviet History. en-US. Failing to heed a warning from the general in charge of troops stationed in and around the building, the crowd was dispersed by gunfire..
  5. Web site: Не хватает денег на мясо и колбасу, ешьте пирожки с ливером. Бессмертный барак. 2 June 2016 . 2016-06-02.
  6. [Taubman, William]
  7. News: Massacre in Workers Paradise . 1990-12-18. Washington Post. 2019-06-02. en-US. 0190-8286.
  8. Web site: 2013 . "Приехали, расстреляли, и все": семейные фотографии, память места и опыт государственного насилия в Новочеркасске » ИНТЕЛРОС . «They arrived and killed, and that's all»: The family photos, memorial places and experience of state committed violence in Novocherkassks . 2022-06-02 . www.intelros.ru.
  9. Web site: Бойня в Новочеркасске: "Но был один, который не стрелял". Би-би-си. Артем Кречетников. Москва. BBC News Русская служба. 25 May 2012 . ru. 2019-06-02. В 1992 году Главная военная прокуратура возбудила по факту новочеркасского расстрела уголовное дело против Хрущева, Козлова, Микояна и еще восьми человек, которое было прекращено в связи с их смертью..
  10. Web site: Новочеркасский расстрел: герои, палачи и жертвы трагедии 1962 года. Ростов. АиФ-. 2017-06-02. www.rostov.aif.ru. 2019-06-02.
  11. Vladislav Zubok and Constantine Pleshkov, Inside the Kremlin's Cold War: from Stalin to Khrushchev, Harvard University Press, p. 262
  12. Hosking, Geoffrey. A History of the Soviet Union, Fontana Press, London. 1992.
  13. Book: Kozlov, V.A.. Mass Uprisings in the USSR: Protest and Rebellion in the Post-Stalin Years. Routledge. 2002. 9781315702506. 250.
  14. News: Не хватает денег на мясо и колбасу, ешьте пирожки с ливером. Бессмертный барак. 2018-06-04.
  15. News: Шапошников Матвей Кузьмич – История на сайте Бессмертный барак. Шапошников Матвей Кузьмич :: Бессмертный барак. 2018-06-04.
  16. http://www.vesti.ru/doc.html?id=124198&cid=1&date=02.06.2007 (in Russian) Новочеркасск вспоминает жертв трагедии, Vest, 2007
  17. https://web.archive.org/web/20101014055355/http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,827865,00.html And Then the Police Fired
  18. Book: Ю. Спицын, Евгений . Новочеркасский бунт 1962 года. Хрущёвская слякоть. Советская держава в 1953-1964 годах . 2019 . 978-5-907172-63-0 . Moskva . 1137830162.
  19. News: Волков О.. Новочеркасск, 2 июня 1962 года. ru. Komsomolskaya Pravda». April 27, 1991.
  20. Сиуда . Пётр . October 22, 1992 . Новочеркасская трагедия . КАРТА . ru . Moscow . 1 . https://web.archive.org/web/20071021085641/http://hro.org/editions/karta/nr1/siuda.php?printv=1 . October 21, 2007.
  21. Web site: yigal . 2021-06-01 . Рабочий активист Пётр Петрович Сиуда: жизнь и судьба . 2022-06-03 . AKRATEIA . ru-RU.
  22. Siuda . Piotr . Новочеркасская трагедия 1-3 Июня 1962 года . https://web.archive.org/web/20131217221352/http://www.praxiscenter.ru/files/=D0=98=D1=81=D1=81=D0=BB=D0=B5=D0=B4=D0=BE=D0=B2=D0=B0=D0=BD=D0=B8=D1=8F/istoriya/_editor_novocherkasskaya=20tragediya.pdf . December 17, 2013.
  23. Siuda . Piotr . Новочеркасская трагедия 1-3 Июня 1962 года .
  24. ПАМЯТИ ТОВАРИЩА . Сиуда . Эмма . 1990 . ru.
  25. Web site: Право.ru: законодательство, судебная система, новости и аналитика. Все о юридическом рынке. . 2022-06-02 . ПРАВО.Ru . ru.
  26. News: 1990-07-23 . Puzzle of Moscow Milk: Price Soars; Still Scarce . en-US . New York Times . 2023-12-26 . 0362-4331 . The average selling price of a Vaz car in Russia, whatever the model, is 300,000 rubles, or $2,300.
  27. News: 1990-02-07 . Puzzle of Moscow Milk: Price Soars; Still Scarce . en-US . New York Times . 2023-12-26 . 0362-4331 . [...] the retail price of milk is still controlled, held to 7.4 rubles a gallon, the equivalent of 8 American cents at the unofficial rate [...].
  28. Book: Kozlov, Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Неизвестный СССР: противостояние народа и власти, 1953–1985. 2005 . Olma Press. 5224053579. Moskva. 65428522.
  29. Web site: СОВЕТ МИНИСТРОВ СССР ПОСТАНОВЛЕНИЕ от 17 мая 1962 г. N 456 О ПОВЫШЕНИИ ЗАКУПОЧНЫХ (СДАТОЧНЫХ) ЦЕН НА КРУПНЫЙ РОГАТЫЙ СКОТ, СВИНЕЙ, ОВЕЦ, ПТИЦУ, МАСЛО ЖИВОТНОЕ И СЛИВКИ И РОЗНИЧНЫХ ЦЕН НА МЯСО, МЯСНЫЕ ПРОДУКТЫ И МАСЛО ЖИВОТНОЕ .
  30. Web site: События в г. Новочеркасске 1 мая 1962 . 2019-06-02 . histrf.ru . ru.
  31. Web site: Узел . Кавказский . Главные факты о расстреле мятежа в Новочеркасске . 2022-06-03 . Кавказский Узел.
  32. Book: Baron, Samuel H. . Bloody Saturday in the Soviet Union: Novocherkassk, 1962 . Stanford University Press . 2001 . 9780804740937 . Stanford, California . 46.
  33. News: 1990-12-18 . Massacre in Workers Paradise . en-US . Washington Post . 2019-06-02 . 0190-8286 . On the morning of June 2 at around 11.00, 7,000 workers and other demonstrators began a protest march from the plant to the centre of Novocherkassk, simply ignoring troops and tanks that surrounded the plant. As they marched, some workers tried to block the railway line leading into town as a further show of protest..
  34. Web site: V. A. . Kozlov . 2006 . В.А.Козлов Неизвестный СССР. Противостояние народа и власти 1953-1985 гг., М.: Олма-пресс, 2006. 448 с. . 2022-06-03 . krotov.info . Олма-пресс.
  35. 1962-10-19 . Russia: And Then the Police Fired . en-US . Time . 2019-06-02 . 0040-781X.