Mu (negative) explained

P:
J:mou4
Poj:
Kanji:
Hiragana:
Revhep:mu
Hangul:
Hanja:
Rr:mu

thumb|Chinese traditional character for Wu

In the Sinosphere, the word, realized in Japanese and Korean as and in Standard Chinese as , meaning 'to lack' or 'without', is a key term in the vocabulary of various East Asian philosophical and religious traditions, such as Buddhism and Taoism.

Etymology

The Old Chinese * () is cognate with the Proto-Tibeto-Burman *, meaning 'not'. This reconstructed root is widely represented in Tibeto-Burman languages; for instance, means 'not' in both Tibetan and Burmese.[1]

Pronunciations

The Standard Chinese pronunciation of (Chinese: ; 'not', 'nothing') historically derives from the Middle Chinese, the Late Han Chinese muɑ, and the reconstructed Old Chinese *.[2]

Other varieties of Chinese have differing pronunciations of . Compare Cantonese ; and Southern Min pronounced as /bo˧˥/ (Quanzhou) and pronounced as /bə˧˥/ (Zhangzhou).

The common Chinese word (Chinese: ) was adopted in the Sino-Japanese, Sino-Korean, and Sino-Vietnamese vocabularies. The Japanese kanji Japanese: has readings of or, and a (Japanese reading) of . It is a fourth grade kanji.[3] The Korean Korean: is read (in Revised, McCune–Reischauer, and Yale romanization systems). The Vietnamese Hán-Việt pronunciation is Vietnamese: or Vietnamese: .

Meanings

Some English translation equivalents of or are:

In modern Chinese, Japanese and Korean it is commonly used in combination words as a negative prefix to indicate the absence of something (no ..., without ..., un- prefix), e.g., // (Korean: 무-선) for "wireless".[7] In Classical Chinese, it is an impersonal existential verb meaning "not have".[8]

The same character is also used in Classical Chinese as a prohibitive particle, though in this case it is more properly written .[9]

Characters

In traditional Chinese character classification, the uncommon class of phonetic loan characters involved borrowing the character for one word to write another near-homophone. For instance, the character Chinese: [[wikt:其|其]] originally depicted a winnowing basket, and scribes used it as a graphic loan for (Chinese: , "his; her; its"), which resulted in a new character (Chinese: [[wikt:箕|箕]]) (clarified with the bamboo radical Chinese: ) to specify the basket.

The character (Chinese: [[wikt:無|無]]) originally meant "dance" and was later used as a graphic loan for, "not". The earliest graphs for Chinese: pictured a person with outstretched arms holding something (possibly sleeves, tassels, ornaments) and represented the word "dance; dancer". After meaning "dance" was borrowed as a loan for meaning "not; without", the original meaning was elucidated with the radical Chinese: , "opposite feet" at the bottom of, Chinese: [[wikt:舞|舞]] "dance".

Mu-kōan

The Gateless Gate, a 13th-century collection of Zen kōan, uses the word wu or mu in its title (Wumenguan or Mumonkan 無門關) and first kōan case ("Zhao Zhou's Dog" 趙州狗子). Chinese Chan calls the word mu 無 "the gate to enlightenment".[10] The Japanese Rinzai school classifies the Mu Kōan as hosshin 発心 "resolve to attain enlightenment", that is, appropriate for beginners seeking kenshō "to see the Buddha-nature"'.[11]

Case 1 of The Gateless Gate reads as follows:

The koan originally comes from the Zhaozhou Zhenji Chanshi Yulu, The Recorded Sayings of Zen Master Zhao Zhou, koan 132:

The Book of Serenity, also known as the Book of Equanimity or more formally the Hóngzhì Chánshī Guǎnglù, has a longer version of this koan, which adds the following to the start of the version given in the Zhaozhou Zhenji Chanshi Yulu.

Origins

In the original text, the question is used as a conventional beginning to a question-and-answer exchange (mondo). The reference is to the Mahāyāna Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra[15] which says for example:

Koan 363 in the Zhaozhou Zhenji Chanshi Yulu shares the same beginning question.[16]

Interpretations

This koan is one of several traditionally used by Rinzai school to initiate students into Zen study,[4] and interpretations of it vary widely. Hakuun Yasutani of the Sanbo Kyodan maintained that

This koan is discussed in Part 1 of Hau Hoo's The Sound of the One Hand: 281 Zen Koans with Answers. In it, the answer of "negative", mu, is clarified as although all beings have potential Buddha-nature, beings who do not have the capacity to see it and develop it essentially do not have it. The purpose of this primary koan to a student is to free the mind from analytic thinking and into intuitive knowing. A student who understands the nature of his question would understand the importance of awareness of potential to begin developing it.[17]

Yoshitaka and Heine

The Japanese scholar made the following comment on the two versions of the koan:

A similar critique has been given by Steven Heine:

Non-dualistic meaning

In Robert M. Pirsig's 1974 novel Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, mu is translated as "no thing", saying that it meant "unask the question". He offered the example of a computer circuit using the binary numeral system, in effect using mu to represent high impedance:

The word features prominently with a similar meaning in Douglas Hofstadter's 1979 book, Gödel, Escher, Bach. It is used fancifully in discussions of symbolic logic, particularly Gödel's incompleteness theorems, to indicate a question whose "answer" is to either un-ask the question, indicate the question is fundamentally flawed, or reject the premise that a dualistic answer can be given.[18]

"Mu" may be used similarly to "N/A" or "not applicable," a term often used to indicate that the question cannot be answered because the conditions of the question do not match the reality. An example of this concept could be with the loaded question "Have you stopped beating your wife?", where "mu" would be considered the only respectable response.[18] [19]

The programming language Raku uses "Mu" for the root of its type hierarchy.[20]

See also

References

Works cited

External links

Notes and References

  1. Schuesler, p. 519.
  2. Book: Schuessler, Axel. ABC Etymological Dictionary of Old Chinese. 2007. University of Hawaii Press. 978-0-8248-2975-9. 518.
  3. Web site: The Kyoiku Kanji (教育漢字) - Kanshudo . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220324010221/https://www.kanshudo.com/collections/kyoiku_kanji . March 24, 2022 . 2023-05-06 . www.kanshudo.com.
  4. Baroni, Helen Josephine. The illustrated encyclopedia of Zen Buddhism, p. 228.
  5. Fischer-Schreiber, I., Ehrhard, R. K. & Diener, M. S. (1991). The Shambhala dictionary of Buddhism and Zen (M. H. Kohn, Trans.). Boston: Shambhala. P. 147.
  6. http://www.buddhism-dict.net/cgi-bin/xpr-ddb.pl?71.xml+id('b7121') Muller, A. Charles, ed. Digital Dictionary of Buddhism (Edition of 2010 July 31) page: "non-existent"
  7. [WWWJDIC]
  8. Book: Pulleyblank, E.G. . Outline of classical Chinese grammar . Edwin G. Pulleyblank . 1995 . UBC Press . Vancouver . 978-0-7748-0541-4 . 30 .
  9. Book: Pulleyblank, E.G. . Outline of classical Chinese grammar . Edwin G. Pulleyblank . 1995 . UBC Press . Vancouver . 978-0-7748-0541-4 . 107 .
  10. Muller.
  11. Baroni, p. 228.
  12. Book: Aitken, Robert, ed. and trans. . Robert Baker Aitken . The Gateless Barrier: The Wu-men Kuan (Mumonkan) . San Francisco. North Point Press . 1991 . 978-0-86547-442-0 .
  13. Book: Green, James, ed. and trans. . The Recorded Sayings of Zen Master Zhao Zhou . Lanham, Maryland . Rowman Altamira . 1998 . 978-0-7619-8985-1 . 53 .
  14. Book: Wick, G.S. . The Book of Equanimity: illuminating classic Zen koans . Gerry Shishin Wick . 2005 . Wisdom Publications . Somerville, MA . 978-0-86171-387-5 . 57 .
  15. Book: Loori, J.D. . Sitting with Koans: essential writings on Zen Koan introspection . John Daido Loori . 2005 . Wisdom Publications . Somerville, MA . 978-0-86171-369-1 . 266 .
  16. Book: Green, James, ed. and trans. . The Recorded Sayings of Zen Master Joshu . Lanham, Maryland . Rowman Altamira . 1998 . 978-0-7619-8985-1 . 116.
  17. Hau, "The Sound of the One Hand: 281 Zen Koans with Answers", 1975
  18. Book: Hofstadter . Douglas R. . Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid . Basic Books . 1999 . 1979 . 978-0-465-02656-2 . .
  19. Web site: mu . The New Hackers' Dictionary (Jargon File) . Raymond . Eric S. . Eric S. Raymond.
  20. Web site: class Mu. docs.raku.org.